来源 / 访谈

原始对话

皮特·莱维尔斯谈自举式创业、AI图像模型与独立开发者之路

Lex Fridman Podcast · · 3:53:16

Lex Fridman 采访独立开发者皮特·莱维尔斯(Pieter Levels),探讨如何在不依赖风险投资的情况下构建盈利型初创企业。他们讨论了快速验证方法、极简技术栈、微调AI图像模型的实际挑战、使用大语言模型进行内容审核、招聘平台的变现策略,以及欧洲监管政策对独立创始人的影响。

Pieter Levels on Bootstrapping Startups, AI Image Models, and Indie Development

翻译仅用于阅读理解;原始摘录仍为 source evidence。

一目了然

关键时刻8

精选观点,附带原文摘录及上下文。请在下方阅读完整文字稿。

AI产品

逼真风格AI模型仍保留NSFW训练偏差

原始摘录

if you look at the photorealistic models that people use now, there’s still core of porn there, of naked people. So I need to prompt out, and everybody needs to do this with AI startups, with imaging, you need to prompt out the naked stuff.

翻译 · 非原文措辞

如果你观察当下人们使用的照片级真实感模型,其底层核心仍包含色情内容——即裸体人物。所以我必须在提示词中明确排除这类内容;所有从事AI图像方向的初创企业构建者都必须这么做,你得在提示词中把裸体相关内容剔除掉。

上下文

创办公司

通过快速上线并收费来验证想法

原始摘录

I have an idea in my mind and I build it like a mini startup, and I launch it very quickly, within two weeks or something, of building it. And I check if there’s demand and if people actually sign up and not just sign up, but if people actually pay money.

翻译 · 非原文措辞

我脑中有一个想法,就把它当作一个微型初创项目来构建,并非常迅速地上线——大约两周左右。然后我检查是否存在真实需求,人们是否真的注册,而且不只是注册,而是是否真的付钱。

上下文

创办公司

规模化常迫使创始人陷入不情愿的管理角色

原始摘录

I have a lot of founder friends and they tell me secretly, with hundreds of millions of dollars in funding and stuff, and they tell me, “Next time, if I’m going to do it, I’m going to do it like you, because it’s more fun, it’s more indie, it’s more chill, it’s more creative.”

翻译 · 非原文措辞

我有很多创始人朋友,他们私下告诉我:‘手握数亿美元融资之类的大钱,但下次如果还要创业,我一定照你的路子来——因为那样更有趣、更独立、更轻松、也更具创造性。’

上下文

创办公司

初创企业快速增长时仍坚持使用熟悉工具

原始摘录

I think it’s accidental, because that’s the thing I knew. I knew PHP, I knew HTML, CSS, because you make websites, and when my startups started taking off, I didn’t have time to… I remember putting on my to-do list like, “Learn Node.js,” because it’s important to switch, because this obviously is much better language than PHP, and I never learned it.

翻译 · 非原文措辞

我觉得这纯属偶然,因为这是我原本就会的东西。我会 PHP,会 HTML、CSS——毕竟做网站嘛。而当我那些初创项目开始起飞时,我根本没时间……我还记得曾把‘学习 Node.js’写进待办清单里,因为大家说切换过去很重要,毕竟这显然比 PHP 好得多;但我最终从未学成。

上下文

AI产品

由用户驱动的参数优化

原始摘录

on like 10% of the users, I would randomly test parameters and then I would see if they would, because you can favor the photo or you can download it, I would measure if they favor it or like the photo. And then I would A/B test

翻译 · 非原文措辞

我会在约10%的用户中随机测试不同参数,然后观察他们的反应——因为用户可以给图片点赞(favorite)或下载图片;我就通过统计点赞或喜欢该图片的次数来衡量效果。然后我再进行A/B测试。

上下文

创办公司

用已掌握的工具启动产品

原始摘录

Nomad List, which is like this website I made to figure out the best cities to live and work as digital nomads, it wasn’t a website. It launched as a Google spreadsheet. So, it was a public Google spreadsheet anybody could edit.

翻译 · 非原文措辞

Nomad List 是我创建的一个网站,用于帮助数字游民判断最适合居住和工作的城市;但它最初根本不是网站,而是一份 Google 表格——一份任何人都可以编辑的公开 Google 表格。

上下文

创办公司

B2B招聘平台可通过增值功能支撑高价

原始摘录

You start with 2.99, but at the peak, when the feds started printing money like 2021, I was making 140K a month with Remote OK with just job posts. And I started adding crazy upsells, like rainbow-colored job posts. You can add your background image. It’s just upsells, man. And you charge a thousand dollars for an upsell.

翻译 · 非原文措辞

你起步价是2.99美元,但在巅峰期——也就是美联储于2021年开始疯狂印钞那会儿——仅靠发布职位信息,Remote OK 就为我带来每月14万美元的收入。随后我开始加入各种疯狂的增值功能,比如彩虹色职位帖、你可以添加自己的背景图。全是增值功能啊,兄弟!而某个增值功能你就能收一千美元。

上下文

AI安全

欧盟AI监管有利于既有巨头而非初创企业

原始摘录

regulation is very good for big companies because they can follow it. I can’t follow it, right? If I want to start an AI startup in Europe now, I cannot because there’s an AI regulation that makes it very complicated for me. I probably need to get notaries involved.

翻译 · 非原文措辞

监管对大公司极为有利,因为它们有能力遵守;而我做不到,对吧?如果我现在想在欧洲启动一家AI初创企业,我根本无法做到——因为存在一项AI监管法规,让我寸步难行。我甚至可能需要公证人介入。

上下文

收听采访录音

原始出版方音频。文字稿的时间戳可能基于不同版本的视频。

参与者

Lex Fridman主持人Pieter Levels嘉宾

章节导航

出版方时间戳;播放对齐功能正在开发中。

  1. 0:00引言
  2. 2:03创业哲学
  3. 9:34低谷期
  4. 13:0212个月内创办12家初创公司
  5. 19:53旅行与抑郁
  6. 32:33独立黑客
  7. 36:38照片AI
  8. 1:12:54如何学习AI
  9. 1:21:30机器人
  10. 1:29:20Hoodmaps
  11. 1:53:52学习新的编程语言
  12. 2:03:24为网站变现
  13. 2:10:01对抗垃圾信息(SPAM)
  14. 2:13:33自动化
  15. 2:24:54何时出售初创公司
  16. 2:27:52单人编码
  17. 2:33:54快速交付
  18. 2:42:39最佳编程IDE
  19. 2:52:09安德烈·卡帕西(Andrej Karpathy)
  20. 3:01:35生产力
  21. 3:15:22极简主义
  22. 3:24:07电子邮件
  23. 3:31:20咖啡
  24. 3:39:06E/acc(加速主义)
  25. 3:41:19给年轻人的建议

完整文字记录

AI 翻译为中文,英文原文将一并保留。

AI 已审阅;尚待人工独立核查及回放验证。

Pieter Levels0:00

所以我当时在琢磨怎么生成照片级真实的AI图像,结果发现……单靠Stable Diffusion本身效果并不好。人脸全都扭曲变形,分辨率也不够高,或者存在其他问题,导致效果不佳。但我开始看到一些基础模型、微调后的模型,有人用色情内容来训练这些模型,我试了试,发现它们生成的图像确实非常逼真,人体结构也合理、符合解剖学。但如果你观察如今人们使用的那些照片级真实感模型,其底层核心依然残留着色情内容——也就是裸体人物。因此,我必须通过提示词把这类内容‘剔除’;所有从事AI初创公司、尤其是图像生成领域的人,都得这么做:必须用提示词主动排除裸体内容。

英文原文

So I was trying to figure out how to do photorealistic AI photos, and it was … Stable Diffusion by itself is not doing that well. The faces look all mangled, and it doesn’t have enough resolution or something to do that well. But I started seeing these base models, these fine-tuned models, and people would train on porn, and I would try them and they would be very photorealistic. They would have bodies that actually made sense, body anatomy. But if you look at the photorealistic models that people use now, there’s still core of porn there, of naked people. So I need to prompt out, and everybody needs to do this with AI startups, with imaging, you need to prompt out the naked stuff.

Lex Fridman0:36

你得不断提醒模型:‘你得给它穿上衣服。’

英文原文

You have to keep reminding the model, “You need to put clothes on the thing.”

Pieter Levels0:39

没错。‘别生成裸体’,因为这风险极高。我用Google Vision在每张图片展示给用户前进行审核,检测是否含NSFW(不适宜工作场合)内容。

英文原文

Yeah. “Don’t put naked,” because it’s very risky. I have Google Vision that checks every photo before it’s shown to the user to check for NSFW.

Lex Fridman0:45

就像乳头检测器?哦,是NSFW检测器。

英文原文

Like a nipple detector? Oh, an NSFW detector.

Pieter Levels0:48

因为记者会非常生气。

英文原文

Because the journalist gets very angry.

Lex Fridman0:52

以下是一段与皮特·莱维尔斯(Pieter Levels)的对话,他在X平台上的昵称是levelsio。他是一位自学成才的开发者兼创业者,独立设计、编程、上线并运营了四十多家初创公司,其中许多取得了巨大成功。大多数情况下,他独自完成全部工作,以数字游民身份旅居全球四十余国、一百五十多座城市,常常窝在沙发上,仅凭一台笔记本电脑,使用原生HTML、jQuery、PHP和SQLite进行开发。他快速构建并上线产品,并在运行中持续迭代优化,全程公开透明,以一名真正独立黑客所特有的坦率与真诚,如实记录自己的成功与失败。

英文原文

The following is a conversation with Pieter Levels, also known on X as levelsio. He is a self-taught developer and entrepreneur who designed, programed shipped and ran over 40 startups, many of which are hugely successful. In most cases, he did it all by himself while living the digital nomad life in over 40 countries and over 150 cities, programming on a laptop while chilling on a couch, using vanilla HTML, jQuery, PHP and SQLight. He builds and ships quickly, and improves on the fly, all in the open, documenting his work, both his successes and failures, with a raw honesty of a true indie hacker.

Lex Fridman1:40

皮特激励了大量开发者与创业者,他们热爱创造有趣且(希望)对人们有用的东西。能采访他,于我而言既是一种荣幸,也是一种享受。这是Lex Fridman播客。如欲支持本节目,请查看简介中的赞助商信息。现在,亲爱的朋友们,让我们欢迎皮特·莱维尔斯。

英文原文

Pieter is an inspiration to a huge number of developers and entrepreneurs who love creating cool things in the world that are hopefully useful for people. This was an honor and a pleasure for me. This is the Lex Friedman Podcast. To support it, please check out our sponsors in the description. And now, dear friends, here’s Pieter Levels.

Lex Fridman2:03

你已创办了许多公司,也打造了大量产品。正如你自己所说,其中多数失败了,但也有一些取得了成功。你创办这些初创公司的哲学理念是什么?

英文原文

You’ve launched a lot of companies and built a lot of products. As you say, most failed, but some succeeded. What’s your philosophy behind building the startups that you did?

Pieter Levels2:14

我认为我的理念与大多数初创从业者截然不同,因为多数人创办公司后会融资、雇人,再开发产品,最后寻找盈利模式。而我几乎从不融资,不接受风险投资,所有事情都由我自己完成:我是设计师,也是开发者,负责全部工作,连Logo都是自己做的。因此,我的风格更偏向‘草根式’。正因为我没有外部资金,所以必须快速行动——必须迅速做出东西,才能验证某个想法是否可行。我脑中一旦产生一个想法,就会把它当作一个微型初创项目来构建,并在两周左右甚至更短时间内就将其上线。接着我会检验是否存在真实需求:人们是否真的注册?而且不只是注册,更要看他们是否愿意实际付费——必须掏出信用卡付钱给我,这样我才能确认这个想法是否被市场验证。而正如你所说,大多数想法都不行,大多数项目都会失败。

英文原文

I think my philosophy is very different than most people in startups, because most people in startups, they build a company and they raise money and they hire people and then they build a product and they find something that makes money. And I don’t really raise money. I don’t use VC funding, I do everything myself. I’m a designer, I’m the developer, I make everything, I make the logo. So for me, I’m much more scrappy. And because I don’t have funding, I need to go fast. I need to make things fast to see if an idea works. I have an idea in my mind and I build it like a mini startup, and I launch it very quickly, within two weeks or something, of building it. And I check if there’s demand and if people actually sign up and not just sign up, but if people actually pay money. They need to take out their credit cards, pay me money, and then I can see if the idea is validated. And most ideas don’t work, as you say, most fail.

Lex Fridman3:05

所以这就进入了一个快速迭代阶段:你先快速构建一个能运行的原型,立即上线,观察用户反馈,再极快地改进它,看看用户是否更喜欢一点、是否喜欢到愿意付费……整套快速流程,就是你思考问题的方式——

英文原文

So there’s this rapid iterative phase where you just build a prototype that works, launch it, see if people like it, improving it really, really quickly to see if people like it a little bit more enough to pay and all that. That whole rapid process is how you think of-

Pieter Levels3:22

没错。我觉得这速度真的很快。如果拿它跟谷歌或大型科技公司对比,尤其是谷歌——目前谷歌正深陷困境。他们发明了Transformer架构,早在多年前就开创了全部AI技术,却始终未能真正推出产品。据说早在2019年,他们本就可以推出类似ChatGPT的产品,却因困于官僚体系而从未发布。其实他们拥有全部条件:数据、技术、工程师,却偏偏没做成。原因就在于这种大型组织会严重拖慢你的节奏。而当我独自一人,穿着内裤坐在酒店房间里,只有一台笔记本电脑时,我就能飞速上线产品,完全无需向法务部门请示:‘嘿,这个能行吗?你能背书吗?’我可以直接上线。

英文原文

Yeah. I think it’s very rapid. If I compare it to, for example, Google or big tech companies, especially Google right now is struggling. They made transformers, they invented all the AI stuff years ago and they never really shipped. They could have shipped ChatGPT for example, I heard, in 2019. And they never shipped it because they were so stuck in bureaucracy. But they had everything. They had the data, they had the tech, they had the engineers and they didn’t do it. And it’s because these big organizations, it can make you very slow. So being alone by myself on my laptop, in my underwear in a hotel room or something, I can ship very fast and I don’t need to ask legal for, “Oh, can you vouch for this?” I can just go and ship.

Lex Fridman4:02

你总是穿着内裤写代码吗?你的个人头像里,你正瘫在沙发上、穿着内裤,悠闲地敲着笔记本。

英文原文

Do you always code in your underwear? Your profile picture, you’re slouching on a couch in your underwear, chilling on a laptop.

Pieter Levels4:10

不,不过我确实常穿短裤,通常就只穿短裤、不穿T恤,因为我老是觉得热,总是过热。

英文原文

No, but I do wear shorts a lot and I usually just wear shorts and no T-shirt, because I’m always too hot. I’m always overheating.

Lex Fridman4:16

谢谢你今天不仅没穿内裤,还特意穿了短裤来。

英文原文

Thank you for showing up not just in your underwear but wearing shorts.

Pieter Levels4:20

我今天确实是为你特意这么穿的,不过……

英文原文

I still wearing this for you, but …

Lex Fridman4:21

谢谢,谢谢你特意打扮一下。

英文原文

Thank you. Thank you for dressing up.

Pieter Levels4:23

我想是因为我常去健身房,所以总感觉热。

英文原文

I think it’s because since I go to the gym, I’m always too hot.

Lex Fridman4:26

你在健身房最喜欢的锻炼动作是什么?

英文原文

What’s your favorite exercise in the gym?

Pieter Levels4:28

哎呀,是推举(overhead press)。

英文原文

Man, overhead press.

Lex Fridman4:29

推举,就是肩部推举?

英文原文

Overhead press, like shoulder press?

Pieter Levels4:30

对。但做起来特别爽,因为你是在……赢!赢的感觉是什么?我推60公斤,也就是大约120磅。这是我在健身房唯一能做得很好的动作。你站直身体,做完之后摆个姿势,心里想:‘我做到了!’就像胜利者的姿态。

英文原文

Yeah. But it feels good because you’re doing … You win. Because what is it? I do 60 kilos, so it’s 120 pounds or something. It’s my only thing I can do well in the gym. And you stand like this and you’re like, “I did it.” Like a winner pose.

Lex Fridman4:44

这是一种胜利仪式。

英文原文

It’s a victory thing.

Pieter Levels4:45

胜利姿态。我还练卧推、深蹲、硬拉。

英文原文

A victory pose. I do bench press, squats, dead lifts.

Lex Fridman4:49

所以你那个马克杯上印着‘正在和我的治疗师聊天’,图案却是硬拉动作。

英文原文

Hence the mug, “Talking to my therapist,” and it’s a deadlift.

Pieter Levels4:53

对,因为硬拉对我来说就像一种心理治疗。

英文原文

Yeah. Because it acts like therapy for me.

Lex Fridman4:55

是啊,确实是。

英文原文

Yeah, yeah, it is.

Pieter Levels4:55

这话要是发到推特上,还挺有争议的,大家会生气。

英文原文

Which is controversial to say. If I say this on Twitter, people get angry.

Lex Fridman4:59

身体上的艰辛本身就是一种疗法。我最近重看了赫尔佐格执导的纪录片《一年四季的快乐人生》(Happy People: A Year in the Taiga),片中记录了西伯利亚泰加林地区一群靠捕猎为生的人,他们全年都在荒野中为生存而劳作。他们的生活方式蕴含着一种深层的幸福,因为他们始终沉浸于自然之中,忙个不停。那种身体上的辛劳,自有其独特意义。

英文原文

Physical hardship is a kind of therapy. I just rewatched Happy People a Year in the Taiga, that Warner Herzog film where they document people that are doing trapping, they’re essentially just working for survival in the wilderness year round. And there’s a deep happiness to their way of life because they’re so busy in it, in nature. There’s something about that physical toil.

Pieter Levels5:25

没错,这是我父亲教给我的。我父亲一直……家里总有建筑工程。他常年翻修房子:打通一间房,又去下一间,四十年来就这样围着房子一圈圈转。所以,他一直在家里搞建筑,这成了他的爱好。他教我:‘当你因某事抑郁时,就去工地弄一大堆沙子之类的东西,拿把铁锹,把沙子从这边铲到那边,纯粹做体力活、干重活,做点什么——设定一个目标,动手去做。’我也把这套方法用在创业上。

英文原文

Yeah, my dad taught me that. My dad always did … there was construction in the house. He was always renovating the house. He breaks through one room and then he goes to the next room and he’s just going in a circle around the house for the last 40 years. But so he’s always doing construction in the house and it’s his hobby. And he taught me, when I’m depressed for something, he says, “Get a big mountain of sand or something from construction, and just get a shovel and bring it to the other side and just do physical labor, do hard work, and do something, Set a goal, do something.” And I did that with startups too.

Lex Fridman6:02

是啊,搞建筑根本不是为了抵达终点,伙计。它本身就是一段旅程。有时我在想,那些总在翻新自家房子的人,他们真正在意的是翻新这件事本身,还是——

英文原文

Yeah, construction is not about the destination, man. It’s about the journey. Sometimes I wonder, people who are always remodeling their house, is it really about the remodeling or is it-

Pieter Levels6:03

不,不,不是。

英文原文

No, no. It’s not.

Lex Fridman6:12

是在意项目本身——

英文原文

Is it about the project-

Pieter Levels6:13

它就是一段旅程。

英文原文

It’s a journey.

Lex Fridman6:13

是其中的解谜过程。

英文原文

The puzzle of it.

Pieter Levels6:14

不,他根本不在乎最终成果。嗯,他倒也会给我看,说:‘太棒了!’我说:‘是啊,太棒了!’可他马上就想冲进下一个房间。但我觉得,这非常隐喻化地映射了工作本身——我自己也一样……我从不停止工作。我做完一个网站,立刻投入下一个;或者再做一个新网站,再启动一家新公司。所以我永远有事可做:早上醒来,喝杯咖啡,亲吻女友,然后就有一个明确目标:‘今天我要修复这个功能’,或‘今天我要解决这个Bug’,诸如此类。‘我要做点什么。’你总有件事等着你醒来去完成。我想,或许尤其对男性而言——当然女性也一样——你需要艰苦的工作,需要一份事业。

英文原文

No, he doesn’t care about the results. Well, he shows me, he’s like, “It’s amazing.” I’m like, “Yeah, it’s amazing.” But then he wants to go to the next room. But I think it’s very metaphorical for work, because I also … I never stop work. I go to the next website or I make a new one or I make a new startup. So I’m always … It gives you something to wake up in the morning and have coffee and kiss your girlfriend and then you have a goal, “Today I’m going to fix this feature,” or “Today I’m going to fix this bug,” or something. “I’m going to do something.” You have something to wake up to. And I think maybe especially as a man, also women, but you need a hard work. You need an endeavor, I think.

Lex Fridman6:52

你所做的这些构建工作,有多少是为了赚钱?又有多少纯粹源于内心深处的幸福感?

英文原文

How much of the building that you do is about money? How much is it about just a deep internal happiness?

Pieter Levels6:59

其实主要是为了乐趣,因为我早年还没赚到钱时就在做了。这才是关键所在。我一直都在写代码,也在做音乐。二十年前我就制作电子音乐,比如鼓打贝斯(drum and bass);我一直都在创作各种东西。所以我认为,创造性表达是一种有意义的工作,极其重要,也极其有趣。每天面对一个挑战,努力去解决问题,这种乐趣是无与伦比的。

英文原文

It’s really about fun, because I was doing it when I didn’t make money. That’s the point. So I was always coding, I was making music. I made electronic music, drum and bass music 20 years ago, and I was always making stuff. So I think creative expression is a meaningful work that’s so important, it’s so fun. It’s so fun to have a daily challenge where you try to figure stuff out.

Lex Fridman7:20

但有意思的是,你打造了许多成功的产品,却从未真正想过将它们推向大规模扩张、出售给大公司之类的层面。

英文原文

But the interesting thing is you built a lot of successful products and you never really wanted to take it to that level where you scale real big and sell it to a company or something like this.

Pieter Levels7:32

是的。问题在于,我并不能决定这件事。如果更多人开始使用,如果突然有数百万人开始用它,它变得很火,我也不会说:‘哦,别再注册我的网站、别再给我付钱了。’但我从未为它融过资。我想,这是因为我不喜欢随之而来的那种高压生活。我有很多创始人朋友,他们私下里告诉我,尽管他们已拿到数亿美元的融资之类的东西,但他们却对我说:‘下次如果我再创业,我就照你的路子来,因为那样更有趣、更独立、更轻松、更有创造性。’他们不喜欢那样——不喜欢变成管理者,变成CEO,变成经理。我觉得很多初创者在成为CEO之后,其实并不喜欢这份工作,但又很难从中抽身;他们真正喜欢的是打基础的工作,是写代码。所以,我认为做些有创造性的事,才能让你保持快乐。

英文原文

Yeah. The problem is I don’t dictate that. If more people start using, if millions of people suddenly start using it and it becomes big, I’m not going to say, “Oh, stop signing up to my website and paying me money.” But I never raised funding for it. And I think because I don’t like the stressful life that comes with it. I have a lot of founder friends and they tell me secretly, with hundreds of millions of dollars in funding and stuff, and they tell me, “Next time, if I’m going to do it, I’m going to do it like you, because it’s more fun, it’s more indie, it’s more chill, it’s more creative.” They don’t like this. They don’t like to be manager, where you become a CEO, you become a manager. And I think a lot of people that start startups, when they become a CEO, they don’t like that job actually, but they can’t really exit it, but they like to do the groundwork, the coding. So I think that keeps you happy, doing something creative.

Lex Fridman8:24

是的。但有意思的是,人们为何总被那种‘扩张规模’‘做到极大’的路径所吸引,却很少诚实地反问自己:到底什么才真正让我快乐?因为对许多优秀的工程师而言,让他们快乐的是‘建造’本身,是作为‘个人贡献者’——你仍在写代码,仍在亲手搭建东西;可一旦他们放弃这个角色,就会变得不快乐。但其中一部分牺牲,确实是实现规模化影响所必需的——前提是你真心相信自己正在做的事。

英文原文

Yeah. But it’s interesting how people are pulled towards that, to scale, to go really big. And you don’t have that honest reflection with yourself, what actually makes you happy? Because for a lot of great engineers, what makes them happy is the building, the “individual contributor,” where you’re actually still coding or you’re actually still building, and they let go of that and then they become unhappy. But some of that is the sacrifice needed to have a impact at scale, if you truly believe in a thing you’re doing.

Pieter Levels8:55

看看埃隆(Elon),他做的事比我大上百万倍,而我是否想那样做?我不知道。这类事其实并非你能自主选择的,但我确实非常敬佩他。我觉得埃隆跟风投(VC)支持的创始人非常不同。风投支持的初创……是软件……这世上存在大量虚假浮夸的东西,我觉得。那里有不少可疑的金融操作,我觉得。我虽从未掌握确凿证据,但直觉告诉我,有些事情正在发生:比如公司被卖给朋友或风投,然后彼此互惠,背后存在见不得光的财务交易。而埃隆身上没有这些。他只是从投资者那里募集资金,然后实实在在地造东西——他需要钱来制造硬件类的产品。这一点,我真的很敬佩。

英文原文

Look at Elon, he’s doing things million times bigger than me, and would I want to do that? I don’t know, you cannot really choose these things, but I really respect that. I think Elon’s very different from VC founders. VC start … it’s software … There’s a lot of bullshit in this world, I think. There’s a lot of dodgy finance stuff happening there, I think. And I never have concrete evidence about it, but your gut tells you something’s going on with companies getting sold to friends and VCs and then they do reciprocity, and there’s shady financial dealings. With Elon, there’s not. He’s just raising money from investors and he’s actually building stuff. He needs the money to build stuff, hardware stuff. And that I really respect.

Lex Fridman9:34

你说过,你人生中经历过几次低谷期,曾陷入抑郁,而‘建造’正是帮你走出低谷的方式之一。但你能具体谈谈吗?能带我回到那个时刻吗?就是你处于人生低点的那段时光?

英文原文

You said that there’s been a few low points in your life, you’ve been depressed and building is one of the ways you get out of that. But can you talk to that? Can you take me to that place? That time when you were at a low point?

Pieter Levels9:47

那时我在荷兰,刚大学毕业,不想找一份普通工作。我靠YouTube赚了些钱,因为我有一段音乐生涯,把我的音乐上传到YouTube后,YouTube开始通过AdSense向我付款,每月两千美元,每月两千美元。而我所有朋友都找了普通工作,我们渐渐不再一起玩了——大学时大家常聚在一起,在彼此家里放松、去派对;但一旦工作了,就只在周末聚会,平时不再走动,因为你得待在办公室。我当时就想:‘这不适合我,我想做点别的。’接着,我开始经历某种状态,我想那叫‘土星回归’——当你年满27岁时,土星会运行回你出生时它所在轨道上的同一位置。

英文原文

So I was in Holland and I graduated university and I didn’t want to get a normal job and I was making some money with YouTube because I had this music career and I uploaded my music to YouTube and YouTube started paying me with AdSense, $2,000 a month, $2,000 a month. And all my friends got normal jobs and we stopped hanging out because people in university hang out, you chill at each other’s houses, you go party. But when people get jobs, they only party in the weekend and they don’t hang anymore in the week because you need to be at the office. And I was like, “This is not for me. I want to do something else.” And I was started getting this, I think it’s Saturn return. When you turn 27, it’s some concept where Saturn returns to the same place in the orbit that it was when you’re born.

Lex Fridman10:28

我学到了太多东西。

英文原文

I’m learning so many things.

Pieter Levels10:29

这是一种占星术概念。

英文原文

It’s some astrology thing.

Lex Fridman10:31

许多真正非凡的艺术家,都在27岁那年去世。

英文原文

So many truly special artists died when they were 27.

Pieter Levels10:35

没错。27岁确实有点玄乎,伙计。对我而言也是如此。我开始发疯,因为我实在看不到自己在荷兰的未来——买房、住郊区之类的生活。于是我飞出国,去了亚洲,开始数字游民生活,持续了一年。结果这反而让我感觉更糟:我独自一人待在酒店房间里,盯着天花板想:‘我这辈子到底在干什么?这……’我那时在搞初创项目,也在经营YouTube频道,但心里却在想:‘这条路的未来在哪里?这真的……’而我在荷兰的朋友们过得都很顺利,过着普通却安稳的生活,所以我越来越抑郁,感觉自己像个局外人。

英文原文

Exactly. There’s something with 27, man. And it was for me. I started going crazy, because I didn’t really see my future in Holland, buying a house, going living in the suburbs and stuff. So I flew out. I went to Asia, started digital nomading, and did that for a year. And then that made me feel even worse because I was alone in hotel rooms looking at the ceiling, “What am I doing with my life? This is …” I was working on startups and stuff, and YouTube, but I was like, “What is the future here? Is this something …” while my friends in Holland were doing really well and with a normal life, so it was getting very depressed and I’m a outcast.

Pieter Levels11:12

我的钱在不断缩水,收入大幅减少,每月只剩五百美元左右。我盯着天花板想:‘现在我27岁了,我是个失败者。’就在那一刻,我开始创建初创项目。起因是我父亲对我说:‘如果你抑郁了,就得弄点沙子,拿把铲子,开始铲起来,去做点事。你不能干坐着不动。’这是一种很有意思的应对抑郁的方式——不是说‘哦,咱们聊聊吧’,而是‘咱们动手干点什么’。于是,我启动了一个名为‘12个月建12个初创项目’的计划:每个月我都做一个项目,并用Stripe上线发布,让别人可以付费购买。

英文原文

My money was shrinking, I wasn’t making money anymore, a lot. I was making $500 a month or something. And I was looking at the ceiling thinking, “Now I’m 27, I’m a loser.” And that’s the moment when I started building startups. And it was because my dad said, “If you’re depressed, you need to get sand, get a shovel, start shoveling, doing something. You can’t just sit still.” Which is an interesting way to deal with depression. It’s not, “Oh, let’s talk about it,” it’s more, “Let’s go do something.” And I started doing a project called 12 Startups in 12 months where every month I would make something like a project and I would launch it with Stripe so people could pay for it.

Lex Fridman11:49

所以基本模式就是:试着做出一个东西,把它放到网上,并加上Stripe支付入口,让人能为它付款。

英文原文

So the basic format is, try to build a thing, put it online, and put Stripe to where you can pay money for it.

Pieter Levels11:55

是的。我并未获得Stripe的赞助,但加一个Stripe结账按钮。

英文原文

Yeah. I’m not sponsored by Stripe, but add a Stripe Checkout button.

Lex Fridman11:58

Stripe至今仍是收款最简单的方式吗?

英文原文

Is that still the easiest way to just pay for stuff, stripe?

Pieter Levels12:02

百分之百,我觉得是。

英文原文

100%. I think so.

Lex Fridman12:03

这是一家很棒的公司,他们把事情做得如此简单,你只需点击一下……

英文原文

It’s a cool company. They just made it so easy, you can just click and …

Pieter Levels12:06

是的。而且他们人特别好。CEO帕特里克(Patrick)人特别好。

英文原文

Yeah. And they’re really nice. The CEO, Patrick, is really nice.

Lex Fridman12:09

幕后实际实现这一切,一定非常困难。因为过去这曾是个巨大难题——

英文原文

Behind the scenes, it must be difficult to actually make that happen. Because that used to be a huge problem-

Pieter Levels12:15

商户……

英文原文

Merchant …

Lex Fridman12:16

只是加一个按钮,让人能为某个东西付款。

英文原文

Just adding a thing, a button where you can pay for a thing.

Pieter Levels12:20

老兄,老兄,我知道这事,因为当年我——

英文原文

Dude. Dude, I know this because when I was-

Lex Fridman12:22

值得信赖。

英文原文

Trustworthy.

Pieter Levels12:23

……九岁时,我也在做网站,还尝试开通商户账户。那是在Stripe出现之前,当时用的是……我想叫Worldpay。所以我得填一堆表格,再用我爸的传真机从荷兰把文件传到美国。账户是以我爸名义开的,他签了字。但他开始读那些条款和条件,发现他要对高达一亿美元的损失承担法律责任。他就说:‘我不想签这个。’我说:‘爸,拜托了,我需要一个商户账户,我得靠互联网赚钱啊。’最后他还是签了,我们把文件传到美国,我拿到了商户账户;但问题是,根本没人付款。不过现在容易多了,你注册一下,加几行代码就……

英文原文

… nine years old, I was making websites also and I tried to open a merchant account. It was before Stripe, you would have … I think it was called Worldpay. So I had to fill out all these forms and then I had to fax them to America from Holland with my dad’s fax. And my dad, it was in my dad’s name, and he just signed for this. And he started reading these terms and conditions, which is, he’s liable for $100 million in damages. And he was like, “I don’t want to sign this.” I’m like, “Dad, come on. I need a merchant account. I need to make money on the internet.” And he signed it and we faxed it to America, and I had merchant account, but then nobody paid for anything, so that was the problem. But it’s much easier now. You can sign up, you add some codes and…

Lex Fridman13:02

所以‘12个月建12个初创项目’——第一个项目启动时,你是什么感受?你当时……坐在电脑前,对‘如何构建东西’到底了解多少?

英文原文

So 12 startups in 12 months. Startup number one, what were you feeling? What were you … Sitting behind the computer, how much do you actually know about building stuff at that point?

Pieter Levels13:18

我会一点点编程,因为我运营YouTube频道,还为那个频道建过网站,叫‘熊猫混音秀’(Panda Mix Show)。内容是电子音乐混音,比如Dubstep、Drum and Bass、Techno、House等。

英文原文

I could code a little bit because I did the YouTube channel and I would make websites for the YouTube channel, it was called Panda Mix Show. And it was these electronic music mixes like dubstep or drum and bass or techno, house.

Lex Fridman13:29

我看到其中一个用了Flash,你当时用的是Flash吗?

英文原文

I saw one of them had Flash. Were you using Flash?

Pieter Levels13:32

是的,我的CD专辑就用了Flash,我还卖过这张CD。

英文原文

Yeah, my CD album was using Flash. I sold my CD.

Lex Fridman13:36

年轻人,Flash是一种——

英文原文

Kids, Flash was a-

Pieter Levels13:38

Flash很酷。

英文原文

Flash was cool.

Lex Fridman13:38

……软件。这就是断层,即——

英文原文

… software. This is the break, that-

Pieter Levels13:41

就像爷爷辈的东西,但Flash确实很酷。

英文原文

Like grandpa, but Flash was cool.

Lex Fridman13:42

是的。还有……叫什么来着?天啊,我本该记得的,ActionScript(动作脚本)。那是一种编程语言。

英文原文

Yeah. And there was … what was it called? Boy, I should remember this, ActionScript. There’s some kind of programming language.

Pieter Levels13:48

对,对,ActionScript,嵌在Flash里。那时候,它就是JavaScript。

英文原文

Yeah, yeah. ActionScript. It was in Flash. Back then, that was the JavaScript.

Lex Fridman13:51

就是JavaScript,没错。我当时以为它会成为接管互联网的动态技术,为此投入了无数小时学习——

英文原文

The JavaScript, yeah. And I thought that’s supposed to be the dynamic thing that takes over the internet. I invested so many hours in learning that-

Pieter Levels13:51

而史蒂夫·乔布斯(Steve Jobs)把它干掉了。

英文原文

And Steve Jobs killed it.

Lex Fridman13:58

史蒂夫·乔布斯把它干掉了。

英文原文

Steve Jobs killed it.

Pieter Levels13:58

史蒂夫·乔布斯说:‘Flash太烂了,别再用了。’大家就都回:‘好嘞。’

英文原文

Steve Jobs said, ” Flash Sucks, stop using it,” and everyone’s like, “Okay.”

Lex Fridman14:03

不过这家伙当时说得倒也没错,对吧?

英文原文

That guy was right though, right?

Pieter Levels14:04

嗯,我不知道。它应该是个封闭平台吧,我觉得——

英文原文

Yeah, I don’t know. Well, it was a closed platform, I think, and-

Lex Fridman14:08

封闭?你明明就能……

英文原文

Closed? You could just …

Pieter Levels14:09

但这挺讽刺的,因为苹果公司本身并不怎么开放,但当年乔布斯却说:‘这是个封闭平台,我们不该用它,而且它还有安全问题。’听起来像借口,好像他只是想这么说,让它显得糟糕。但Flash确实很酷。

英文原文

But this is ironic, because Apple, they’re not very open, but back then Steve was like, “This is closed, we should not use it, and it has security problems,” I think, which sounded like a cop-out, like he just wanted to say that to make it look bad. But Flash was cool.

Lex Fridman14:22

是的,它一度确实很酷。听着,动画GIF也曾经很酷,后来以梗图(meme)形式换了一种方式回归。我记得GIF刚流行时,真挺酷的,不是反讽意义上的酷——网上会放一只跳舞的兔子之类的东西,那会儿真的让人兴奋。

英文原文

Yeah, it was cool for a time. Listen, animated GIFs were cool for a time too. They came back in a different way, as a meme, though. I remember when GIFs were actually cool, not ironically cool. On the internet you would have a dancing rabbit or something like this, and that was really exciting.

Pieter Levels14:42

你有Lex主页,所有内容居中显示;还有皮特(Pieter)的主页,以及那个‘建设中’的GIF——一个戴头盔、头顶灯光的人,简直绝了。

英文原文

You had the Lex homepage, everything was centered and you had Pieter’s homepage and the under construction GIF, which was a guy with a helmet and the lights, it was amazing.

Lex Fridman14:56

还有横幅广告。那就是……在Google AdSense出现之前,人们用横幅来做广告。

英文原文

And the banners. That’s how … Before Google AdSense you would have banners for advertising.

Pieter Levels15:00

简直绝了。

英文原文

It was amazing.

Lex Fridman15:01

而且还有很多指向色情内容的链接,或者类似色情的链接。

英文原文

And a lot of links to porn, I think. Or porny-type links.

Pieter Levels15:04

我想,当时商户账户……很多人就是用来干这个的。那时互联网上赚的钱,很大一部分来自色情内容,或者说,主要就靠这个。

英文原文

I think that was where the merchant accounts … people would use for. People would make money a lot. The only money made on internet then was porn, or a lot of it.

Lex Fridman15:12

是啊,那是个黑暗的地方。如今它依然是个黑暗的地方,但黑暗之中也有美。好了,言归正传,你当时做了些基础HTML……

英文原文

Yeah, it was a dark place. It’s still a dark place, but there’s beauty in the darkness. Anyway, so you did some basic HTML …

Pieter Levels15:20

是的。但我得真正学编码,所以这挺好的。每月启动一家初创公司这个主意不错,这样我就能学编程、学基础知识。但整个过程依然非常简陋——这是有意为之的,因为我没时间花太多精力……我只有一个月时间做点什么,所以绝不能超过一个月,而且我对这点执行得相当严格。最后我把成果以博客文章形式发布出来。我记得还发到了 Hacker News 上,大家会去查看:“哦,你真做了吗……?”因为我是公开发布的,所以有种责任感,逼着自己必须真的把它做出来。

英文原文

Yeah. But I had to learn the actual coding, so this was good. It was a good idea to … every month launch a startup, so I could learn to code, learn basic stuff. But it was still very scrappy, which is on purpose, because I didn’t have time to spend a lot of … I had a month to do something, so I couldn’t spend more than a month and I was pretty strict about that. And I published it as a blog post. I think I put it on Hacker News and people would check, “Oh, did you actually …” I felt accountability because I put it public, that I actually had to do it.

Lex Fridman15:50

你还记得你做的第一个项目吗?

英文原文

Do you remember the first one you did?

Pieter Levels15:52

我想第一个是 Play My Inbox。那时候我朋友们会互相发送一些很酷的东西……那会儿还没出现 Spotify,我觉得大概是 2013 年吧,我们会通过 YouTube 链接互发音乐,“这首歌超棒”“这首歌也超棒”。结果 Gmail 里全是这种巨型邮件线程,根本没法浏览。于是我就开发了一个应用:它能登录你的 Gmail 账户,抓取邮件并找出含 YouTube 链接的那些,再为你生成一个歌曲图库——本质上就是个简易版 Spotify。我朋友们特别喜欢。

英文原文

I think it was Play My Inbox, because back then my friends, we would send cool … It was before Spotify, I think. 2013, we would send music to each other, YouTube links. “This is a cool song, this is a cool song.” And it was these giant email threads on Gmail and they were unnavigable. So I made an app that would log into your Gmail, get the emails and find ones with YouTube links, and then make a gallery of your songs, essentially Spotify. And my friends loved it.

Lex Fridman16:21

它是靠网页抓取(scraping)实现的吗?还是用了 API?

英文原文

Was it scraping it? What was it, an API?

Pieter Levels16:23

不,它用的是 POP 协议,或者 IMAP 协议。它实际上会直接检查你的邮箱。因此存在隐私隐患——它会获取你全部邮件来查找 YouTube 链接,不过我并不会保存任何数据。但这个过程挺有趣的。而这个首个产品刚一上线就获得了媒体报道,登上了某些科技媒体,我当时就想:“这太酷了。” 它没赚钱,压根儿没设置付款按钮,但确实有人在用。我记得有数万人使用过。

英文原文

No, it uses POP. POP or IMAP. It would actually check your email. So it had privacy concerns, because it would get all your emails to find YouTube links, but then I wouldn’t save anything. But that was fun. And that first product already would get press, it went on, I think, some tech media and stuff, and I was like, “This is cool.” It didn’t make money, there was no payment button, but it was actually people using it. I think tens of thousands of people used it.

Lex Fridman16:51

这主意真棒。我好奇为什么我们至今没有这类工具?为什么没有能接入 Gmail 并提取出某些有用聚合信息的产品?

英文原文

That’s a great idea. I wonder why don’t we have that? Why don’t we have things that access Gmail and extract some useful aggregate information?

Pieter Levels17:01

是啊,你可以告诉 Gmail:“别把所有邮件都给我,只把带 YouTube 链接的邮件给我,或者类似的东西。”

英文原文

Yeah. You could tell Gmail, “Don’t give me all the emails, just give me the ones with YouTube links or something like that.”

Lex Fridman17:06

围绕 Google 其实有一整套可构建的应用生态,但人们其实并不……

英文原文

There is a whole ecosystem of apps you can build on top of the Google, but people don’t really-

Pieter Levels17:12

从不这么做。我几乎没见过……

英文原文

Never do this. I never see them-

Lex Fridman17:13

他们倒是建了一些……我见过几个像 Boomerang 这样的应用,还有几款不错的,但我好奇……也许是因为很难靠它们赚钱。

英文原文

They build … I’ve seen a few like Boomerang, there’s a few apps that are good, but I wonder what … Maybe it’s not easy to make money.

Pieter Levels17:22

我觉得难点在于,人们不愿为这些扩展程序和插件付费。因为它不是真正的独立应用,所以……人们不觉得它值钱。人们会觉得:“哦,插件就该免费。我要在 Google Sheets 之类软件里用个插件,才不会掏钱买呢,它就该是免费的。”这……但如果你访问一个网站,实实在在地……“好吧,我需要这个产品,我愿意为它付费,因为它是真正的产品。”所以哪怕后台代码完全一样,它只是个插件而已。

英文原文

I think it’s hard to get people to pay for these extensions and plugins. Because it’s not a real app, so it’s not … people don’t value it. People value it, “Oh, a plugin should be free. When I want to use a plugin in Google Sheets or something, I’m not going to pay for it. It should be free,” which is … But if you go to a website and you actually … “Okay, I need this product, I’m going to pay for this because it’s a real product.” So even though it’s the same code in the back, it’s a plugin.

Lex Fridman17:44

是啊,你可以通过浏览器端的 Chrome 扩展来实现。

英文原文

Yeah. You could do it through extensions, Chrome extensions from the browser side.

Pieter Levels17:49

是啊,但谁会为 Chrome 扩展付费?几乎没人。

英文原文

Yeah, but who pays for Chrome extensions? Barely anybody.

Lex Fridman17:52

没人。

英文原文

Nobody.

Pieter Levels17:52

所以这大概真不是个适合赚钱的地方。

英文原文

So that’s not a good place to make money, probably.

Lex Fridman17:54

是啊,这真糟糕。

英文原文

Yeah, that sucks.

Pieter Levels17:55

Chrome 扩展应该只是你初创公司的附属功能。你有个主产品,然后说:“哦,我们还提供 Chrome 扩展。”

英文原文

Chrome extension should be a extension for your startup. You have a product, “Oh, we also have a Chrome extension.”

Lex Fridman18:01

我希望 Chrome 扩展本身就能成为产品。我希望 Chrome 能支持这一点,让用户能轻松为其付费……我能想象出很多产品完全可以只以扩展形式存在,比如社交媒体的增强工具。

英文原文

I wish the Chrome extension would be the product. I wish Chrome would support that, where you could pay for it easily … I can imagine a lot of products that would just live as extensions, like improvements for social media.

Pieter Levels18:15

就像 GPTs。

英文原文

Like GPTs.

Lex Fridman18:17

对,GPTs。

英文原文

GPTs, yeah.

Pieter Levels18:18

这些 ChatGPT 的 GPTs,现在要开始收费了,目前你好像还能从 OpenAI 那里获得分成收入,我自己也做了不少。

英文原文

These ChatGPTs, they’re going to charge money for it, now you get a rev share, I think, from Open AI, I made a lot of them also.

Lex Fridman18:24

为什么?我们稍后再聊这个。咱们先倒回前面——一年内做 12 家初创公司,这主意相当酷。那么,30 天内打造一个产品,到底需要什么?当时你觉得难在哪?

英文原文

Why? We’ll talk about it. So let’s rewind back. It’s a pretty cool idea to do 12 startups in 12 months. What’s it take to build a thing in 30 days? At that time, how hard was that?

Pieter Levels18:37

我觉得最难的是搞清楚哪些东西不该加、不该做,因为你根本没时间。所以你需要建一个落地页。嗯,你其实得做出产品本身,因为得有东西让人付费。你得建登录系统吗?也许不用。也许你可以搭个简陋的登录系统。比如做照片 AI 时,用户注册、用 Stripe Checkout 支付后,就会收到一个登录链接。我刚开始时,登录链接只带一个哈希值,就是一个静态链接,所以登录非常简单。但它安全性不高——万一链接泄露了怎么办?现在我已换成真正的 Google 登录,但这花了整整一年。所以保持极度简陋非常重要……因为你没时间。你必须专注于能快速做出来的东西。

英文原文

I think the hard part is figuring out what you shouldn’t add, what you shouldn’t build, because you don’t have time. So you need to build a landing page. Well, you need to build the product, actually, because there needs to be something they pay for. Do you need to build a login system? Maybe no. Maybe you can build some scrappy login system. For photo AI, you sign up, you pay with Stripe Checkout and you get a login link. And when I started out, there was only a login link with a hash, and that’s just a static link, so it’s very easy to log in. It’s not so safe, what if you leak the link? And now I have real Google login, but that took a year. So keeping it very scrappy is very important to … because you don’t have time. You need to focus on what you can build fast.

Pieter Levels19:17

所以涉及资金、Stripe、产品开发、落地页搭建。你还得考虑:“人们怎么找到它?” 你是打算发到 Reddit 上吗?可你怎么发到 Reddit 上又不被当成垃圾信息发送者?如果你说:“嘿,这是我新创的公司,快试试吧!”——不行,没人理你……帖子会被删掉。也许你可以先在某个 subreddit 里发现大量用户正面临某个问题,然后解决它,再发帖说:“大家好,我做了个东西,或许能解决你们的问题”,甚至加上一句:“目前免费。”这样可能行得通。但你必须非常……聚焦,明确你究竟在做什么。

英文原文

So money, Stripe, build a product, build a landing page. You need to think about, “How are people going to find this?” So are you going to put it on Reddit or something? How are you going to put it on Reddit without being looked at as a spammer? If you say, “Hey, it is my new startup, you should use it,” no, nobody … It gets deleted. Maybe if you find a problem that a lot of people on Reddit already have, on a subreddit and you solve that problem, say, “What’s up, people. I made this thing that might solve your problem,” and maybe, “It’s free for now.” That could work. But you need to be very … Narrow it down, what you’re building.

Lex Fridman19:53

时间有限。其实,咱们能不能回到你当初躺在房间里、觉得自己是个失败者的那个时刻?我现在有时也会有这种感觉。你能谈谈那种感受吗?谈谈那种纯粹觉得自己是个失败者的心境?因为我觉得,此刻世界上有很多人正躺在房间里听这段话,也正感到自己是个失败者。

英文原文

Time is limited. Actually, can we go back to the you laying in a room feeling like a loser, I still feel like a loser sometimes. Can you speak to that feeling, to that place of just feeling like a loser? Because I think a lot of people in this world are laying in a room right now listening to this and feeling like a loser.

Pieter Levels20:18

好的。首先,我觉得年轻人觉得自己是失败者,这很正常。

英文原文

Okay. So I think it’s normal if you’re young that you feel like a loser, first of all.

Lex Fridman20:21

尤其是 27 岁的时候。

英文原文

Especially when you’re 27.

Pieter Levels20:23

对,对。

英文原文

Yes, yes.

Lex Fridman20:24

人生有个巅峰期。

英文原文

There’s a peak.

Pieter Levels20:26

是啊,是啊。我觉得 27 岁就是巅峰。所以千万别伤害自己,这点极其重要。只要熬过去就行。但因为你一无所有——很可能身无分文,没有生意,也没有工作。乔丹·彼得森说过这话,我在某处看到过:“人之所以抑郁,是因为他们一无所有。没有女朋友,也没有男朋友,没有……”你需要拥有某些东西,或组建家庭。你需要身边有些东西。你需要为自己构建一种生活。如果你不为自己构建生活,你就会抑郁。所以,如果你独自一人住在亚洲的青年旅舍里,盯着天花板,没有收入进账,没有女朋友,没有……那你当然会抑郁。这合乎逻辑。但当你身处其中时,你会想:“这不合逻辑,我肯定哪里出了问题。”

英文原文

Yeah. Yeah. I think 27 is the peak. And so I would not kill yourselves, it’s very important. Just get through it. But because you have nothing, you have probably no money, you have no business, you have no job. Jordan Peterson said this. I saw it somewhere, “The reason people are depressed is because they have nothing. They don’t have a girlfriend, they don’t have or boyfriend, they don’t have …” You need stuff, or a family. You need things around you. You need to build a life for yourself. If you don’t build a life for yourself, you’ll be depressed. So if you’re alone in Asia in a hostel looking at the ceiling and you don’t have any money coming in, you don’t have a girlfriend, you don’t … of course you’re depressed. It’s logic. But back then, if you’re in the moment you think, “This is not logic, there’s something wrong with me.”

Pieter Levels21:04

另外,我觉得我当时开始出现焦虑,甚至有点精神失常——我觉得旅行真能把人逼疯。我知道这一点,因为我了解有些数字游民……甚至自杀了。我还没查过与普通人群自杀率的对比数据,但我有种直觉:尤其在十年前刚兴起这股风潮时,这种生活方式心理压力极大,而且你常常独处。那时你独自旅行,周围几乎没有其他数字游民。所以你身处陌生文化中,看起来跟所有人都不一样。我在亚洲,泰国人确实都很友善,但你终究不属于当地文化。你四处旅行,从一座城市跳到另一座城市,不再有家可归,你会感到自己失去了根基。

英文原文

And also I think I started getting anxiety and I think I started going a little bit crazy where I think travel can make you insane. And I know this because I know that there’s digital nomads that … they kill themselves. And I haven’t checked the comparison with baseline people suicide rate, but I have a hunch, especially in the beginning when it was a very new thing 10 years ago, that it can be very psychologically taxing, and you’re alone a lot. Back then when you travel alone, there was no other digital moments back then, a lot. So you’re in a strange culture, you look different than everybody. I was in Asia, everybody’s really nice in Thailand, but you’re not part of the culture. You’re traveling around, you’re hopping from city to city. You don’t have a home anymore. You feel disrooted.

Lex Fridman21:51

而且你始终像个局外人,因为你跟所有人就是不一样。

英文原文

And you’re constantly an outcast in that you’re different from everybody else.

Pieter Levels21:55

没错,正是如此。但人们待你……比如在泰国,人们都非常友善,可你仍会感到自己是个局外人。然后我觉得,我当时遇到的那些数字游民全……干的都是些见不得光的勾当。他们像一群义警,因为这玩意儿当时才刚冒头。有个美国人,竟通过 UPS 向美国客户销售违禁药品;还有不少代发货商在干各种灰色勾当。那里充斥着大量见不得光的事。他们看起来也不太心理平衡,不像我想结交的人。所以我甚至感觉自己被泰国的其他外国人、其他数字游民排斥在外。我当时就想:“天啊,我犯了个大错。”接着我回到荷兰,结果抑郁得更厉害了。

英文原文

Yes, exactly. But people treat you … Like Thailand, people are so nice, but you still feel like a outcast. And then I think the digital nomads I met then were all … it was shady business. They were vigilantes, because it was a new thing. And one guy was selling illegal drugs. It was an American guy, was selling illegal drugs via UPS to Americans on this website, there were a lot of drop shippers doing shady stuff. There was a lot of shady things going on there. And they didn’t look like very balanced people. They didn’t look like people I wanted to hang with. So I also felt outcast from other foreigners in Thailand, other digital nomads. And I was like, “Man, I made a big mistake.” And then I went back to Holland and then I got even more depressed.

Lex Fridman22:32

你刚才提到了“数字游民”。什么是数字游民?这种生活方式是什么?它的哲学理念又是什么?这场运动的历史又是怎样的?

英文原文

You said digital nomad. What is digital nomad? What is that way of life? What is the philosophy there? And the history of the movement?

Pieter Levels22:38

我完全是偶然发现这一点的,因为当时我想:‘我马上要大学毕业了,然后得赶紧离开这里。我要飞去亚洲’——毕竟我之前去过亚洲。2009年我在韩国做过交换生。所以我就想:‘亚洲挺容易的,泰国也挺容易的,我就直接过去,边走边看吧。’而且那里生活成本很低,非常低。在清迈,我租一间私人房间,每月房租只要150美元,条件还挺不错。所以我完全是偶然撞上这条路的。我当时想:‘哦,原来还有其他人在用笔记本电脑创业,或者远程工作。’那时候几乎没人远程办公,但他们确实在经营自己的生意,住在哥伦比亚、泰国、越南或巴厘岛等地,选择居住在生活成本更低的地方。

英文原文

I struck upon it on accident, because I was like, “I’m going to graduate university and then I need to get out of here. I’ll fly to Asia,” because I’d been before in Asia. I studied in Korea in 2009, study exchange. So I was like, “Asia is easy, Thailand’s easy. I’ll just go there, figure things out.” And it’s cheap. It’s very cheap. Chiang Mai, I would live for $150 per month rent for private room, pretty good. So I struck upon this on accident. I was like, “Okay, there’s other people on laptops working on their startup or working remotely.” Back then nobody worked remotely, but they worked on their businesses, and they would live in Columbia or Thailand or Vietnam or Bali. They would live in more cheap places.

Pieter Levels23:16

这看起来是一种非常冒险的生活方式:你四处旅行,同时打造自己的事业,又不必承受家乡社会的压力。你是美国人,所以会受到美国社会的压力,告诉你该做什么——比如‘你得买房’,或者‘你得干这干那’。我在荷兰时也有这种压力。你可以摆脱这种压力,从而感到自己是自由的,没人指手画脚告诉你该怎么做。但恰恰也是因为这种自由,你反而开始觉得自己快要发疯了——因为你太自由了,与一切、与所有人彻底脱钩:你脱离了自己的文化,也脱离了所处地的文化,因为你待的时间实在太短了。

英文原文

And it looked like a very adventurous life. You travel around, you build your business, there’s no pressure from your home society. You’re American, so you get pressure from American society telling you what to do, “You need to buy a house,” or “You need to do this stuff.” I had this in Holland too. And you can get away from this pressure, and you can feel like you’re free. There’s nobody telling you what to do. But that’s also why you start feeling like you go crazy, because you are free, you’re disattached from anything and anybody. You’re disattached from your culture, you’re disattached from the culture you’re probably in because you’re staying very short.

Lex Fridman23:49

我觉得弗朗茨·卡夫卡说过:‘我自由,因此我迷失。’

英文原文

I think Franz Kafka said, “I’m free, therefore I’m lost.”

Pieter Levels23:53

天啊,这话太对了,简直一针见血。而所谓自由,定义就是毫无约束——一切皆有可能,你可以去往任何地方。所有人都会说:‘哦,那一定特别棒!自由,你肯定特别幸福。’可事实恰恰相反。我认为自由并不会让你幸福,反而是约束可能让你幸福。这是我当时学到的重要一课。

英文原文

Man, that’s so true. That’s exactly the point. And freedom, it’s the definition of no constraints. Anything is possible, you can go anywhere. And everybody’s like, “Oh, that must be super nice. Freedom, you must be very happy.” And it’s the opposite. I don’t think that makes you happy. I think constraints probably make you happy. And that’s a big lesson I learned then.

Lex Fridman24:14

但他们靠什么赚钱呢?所以你的意思是,他们当时在干一些见不得光的事?

英文原文

But what were they making for money? So you’re saying they were doing shady stuff at that time?

Pieter Levels24:19

对我而言,因为我更偏向开发者,所以我想做的是真正的初创公司;而当时有人正把药物运往美国,比如减肥药之类未经美国食品药品监督管理局(FDA)批准的东西。我们会一边喝啤酒,一边笑着聊起他们正在干的各种擦边球勾当。

英文原文

For me, because I was more like a developer, I wanted to make startups and there was drugs being shipped to America, diet pills and stuff. Non FDA-approved stuff. We would sit with beers and they would laugh about all the dodgy shit they’re doing.

Lex Fridman24:37

啊,这部分……好吧,我明白了。

英文原文

Ah, that part of … Okay, I see.

Pieter Levels24:38

就是那种有点油腻的电商氛围。我不是说所有电商都油腻,但你懂这种调调。

英文原文

That kind of vibe, sleazy e-com vibe. I’m not saying all e-com is sleazy, but you know this vibe.

Lex Fridman24:44

这确实算一种氛围。而你的氛围则更偏向——

英文原文

It could be a vibe. And your vibe was more-

Pieter Levels24:47

做出酷炫的东西。

英文原文

Make cool stuff.

Lex Fridman24:48

‘打造既酷炫又合乎伦理的产品。’

英文原文

“Build cool shit that’s ethical.”

Pieter Levels24:50

没错。你知道那些在迪拜开跑车的人,那些搞电商的家伙,动不动就喊:‘兄弟,你得做代发货,一个月就能赚一亿美元!’真有这种人,而我当时就想:‘这些人不是我的同类。’

英文原文

Yeah. You know the guys with sports cars in Dubai, these people, e-com, “Bro, you got to drop ship and you’ll make $100 million a month,” there was people with this shit, and I was like, “This is not my people.”

Lex Fridman25:01

是啊,这些单个要素本身都没什么问题——

英文原文

Yeah. There’s nothing wrong with any of those individual components-

Pieter Levels25:04

不,不评判。

英文原文

No, no judgment.

Lex Fridman25:05

……但其根基却不太合乎伦理。那到底是什么?我不知道具体是什么,但我明白你的意思。

英文原文

… but there’s a foundation that’s not quite ethical. What is that? I don’t know what that is, but I get you.

Pieter Levels25:12

不,我不想评判。我知道,那不是我的世界,也不是我的亚文化圈。我想做酷炫的东西,但他们也觉得自己的酷炫东西很酷,所以……不过我想做的是真正的初创公司,这才是我的追求。我会浏览Hacker News、Y Combinator这类网站,看到他们在做酷炫的东西,所以我也想做酷炫的东西。

英文原文

No, I don’t want to judge. I know that for me it wasn’t my world, it wasn’t my subculture. I wanted to make cool shit, but they also think their cool shit is cool, so … But I wanted to make real startups and that was my thing. I would read Hacker News, Y Combinator, and they were making cool stuff, so I wanted to make cool stuff.

Lex Fridman25:30

如果暂且浪漫化一下,这种生活方式其实相当酷。

英文原文

That’s a pretty cool way of life, just if you romanticize it for a moment.

Pieter Levels25:34

确实非常浪漫,伙计。如果回想那些记忆,画面是五彩斑斓的。

英文原文

It’s very romantic, man. It’s colorful, if I think about the memories.

Lex Fridman25:39

有哪些开心的回忆?比如在咖啡馆工作,或在……那种生活方式所包裹着的自由感。因为一切皆有可能,你随时可以——

英文原文

What are some happy memories? Just working cafes or working in … Just the freedom that envelops you with that way of life. Because anything is possible. You can just get off of the-

Pieter Levels25:53

哦,我觉得那简直太棒了!比如在巴厘岛,我会和我最好的朋友安德烈(他至今仍是我的挚友)以及另一位朋友一起工作,经常熬到凌晨六点。因为夜里联合办公空间一片寂静,再没别人了。我会在下午五点或六点醒来,骑摩托去联合办公空间,顺路从一家咖啡馆买三十杯热拿铁……

英文原文

Oh, I think it was amazing. I would make friends and we would work until 6:00 AM in Bali, for example, with Andre, my best friend who is still my best friend, and another friend. And we would work until the morning when the sun came up, because at night the coworking space was silent. There was nobody else. And I would wake up 6:00 PM or 5:00 PM, I would drive to the coworking space on a motorbike. I would buy 30 hot lattes from a cafe …

Lex Fridman26:24

多少杯?

英文原文

How many?

Pieter Levels26:24

三十杯。因为大概会有六个人来,或者我们也不确定——有时会有人临时加入。

英文原文

30. Because there was like six people coming, or we didn’t know. Sometimes people would come in.

Lex Fridman26:30

你刚才是说三零,三十杯?

英文原文

Did you say three, zero, 30?

Pieter Levels26:32

对。

英文原文

Yeah.

Lex Fridman26:33

厉害。

英文原文

Nice.

Pieter Levels26:34

然后我们每人喝四杯左右。伙计,在巴厘岛,我不确定那些拿铁劲儿有多大,但确实是拿铁。我们会把它们装进塑料袋,然后我骑摩托过去,结果咖啡一路洒得到处都是。接着我们走进联合办公空间,把咖啡放这儿,通宵工作。我们会放科技舞曲(techno),大家就在里面专注干活。这……真的就是一群商务人士,在那儿开发自己的初创项目,我们也都努力想做出点东西。等太阳升起,晨练的人——那些练瑜伽的女孩和男孩们——会在早上六点瑜伽课结束后进来,跟我们打招呼:‘嘿,早安!’而我们当时的样子嘛……我们互相问好:‘哟,早啊,最近咋样?’我们根本不知道自己看起来有多狼狈,但事实上真的惨不忍睹。之后我们就回青旅或酒店睡觉,第二天再重复一遍,一遍又一遍。就这样进入了一种‘锁定模式’,全身心投入工作。那段时间特别有趣。

英文原文

And we would drink four per person or something. Man, it’s Bali, I don’t know if they were powerful lattes, but they were lattes. And we’d put them in plastic bag and then I would drive there and all the coffee was falling everywhere. And then we’d go into the coworking station and have these coffees here and we’d work all night. We’d play techno music and everybody would just work in there. This would … Literally business people, they would work in their startup and we’d all try and make something. And then the sun would come up and the morning people, the yoga girls and yoga guys would come in after the yoga class at 6:00 and they say, “Hey, good morning.” We looked like this, and we’re like, “What up? How are you doing?” And we didn’t know how bad we looked, but it was very bad. And then we would go home, sleep in a hostel or a hotel, and do the same thing, and again and again and again. And it was this lock-in mode, working. And that was very fun.

Lex Fridman27:26

所以就是你们一群人,整晚都在震耳欲聋的科技舞曲中工作?

英文原文

So it’s just a bunch of you, techno music blasting all through the night?

Pieter Levels27:31

更像是(哼唱)。

英文原文

More like (singing).

Lex Fridman27:33

哦,节奏很快。

英文原文

Oh, so rapid pace.

Pieter Levels27:33

像工业风那种,不是那种俗气的……

英文原文

Like industrial, not like this cheesy-

Lex Fridman27:36

你看,对我来说,节拍速度直接影响我对事物的感受。节奏越快,我越焦虑;但这种焦虑会被转化为生产力。可一旦节奏过快,焦虑就会压倒一切。

英文原文

See, for me, it’s such an interesting thing because the speed of the beat affects how I feel about a thing. So the faster it is, the more anxiety I feel, but that anxiety is channeled into productivity. But if it’s a little too fast, I start … the anxiety overpowers.

Pieter Levels27:51

所以你不喜欢鼓打贝斯(drum and bass)音乐?

英文原文

So you don’t like drum and bass music?

Lex Fridman27:52

大概率不喜欢。

英文原文

Probably not.

Pieter Levels27:53

对,太快了。

英文原文

No, it’s too fast.

Lex Fridman27:55

至少对工作来说是这样。我得反复调试。实际上……我能调节自己的焦虑程度。‘焦虑’这个词可能不够准确,或许该叫‘富有生产力的紧张感’——反正就是这种我喜欢的状态。

英文原文

For working. I have to play with it. You can actually … I can adjust my level of anxiety. There must be a better word than anxiety. It’s like a productive anxiety that I like, whatever that is.

Pieter Levels28:07

这也取决于你做的工作类型。如果你在写作,大概率不想听鼓打贝斯音乐。但写代码时,工业风、科技舞曲这类快节奏音乐效果很好,因为能让你迅速进入心流状态;再加上咖啡因加持,你会沉浸得更深。我觉得你是在焦虑边缘走钢丝——咖啡因也在推高你的焦虑值,而科技舞曲又进一步把你推向这个临界点。有时它会过头,你就忍不住喊:‘停掉科技舞曲!关掉音乐!’但这些确实是美好的回忆。还有旅行的回忆:你从一座城市辗转到另一座城市,感觉就像过着空中飞人般的生活,非常美妙。你见识了许多酷炫的城市,而且——

英文原文

It also depends, what kind of work you do. If you’re writing, you probably don’t want drum and bass music. I think for code, industrial, techno, this kind of stuff, fast, it works well because you really get locked in and combined with caffeine, you go deep. And I think you balance on this edge of anxiety, because this caffeine is also hitting your anxiety and you want to be on the edge of anxiety with this techno running. Sometimes it gets too much, it’s like, “Stop the techno, stop the music.” But those are good memories. And also travel memories. You go from city to city and it feels like it’s jet set life. It feels very beautiful. You’re seeing a lot of cool cities, and-

Lex Fridman28:46

你记得去过的最喜欢的地方是哪儿?

英文原文

What was your favorite place that you remember you visited?

Pieter Levels28:50

我觉得至今仍是曼谷最棒。曼谷和清迈,我觉得泰国特别独特。我也去过别的地方,比如越南、南美洲等等,但还是觉得泰国胜出——当地人特别友善,生活也格外轻松惬意。

英文原文

I think still Bangkok is the best place. Bangkok and Chiang Mai. I think Thailand is very special. I’ve been to the other place, I’ve been to Vietnam and I’ve been to South America and stuff. I still think Thailand wins in how nice people are, how easy of a life people have there.

Lex Fridman29:08

什么都便宜,而且品质不错。

英文原文

Everything’s cheap and good.

Pieter Levels29:10

嗯,曼谷现在确实越来越贵了,但清迈依然很便宜。我觉得初来乍到时,那里是个绝佳起点。伙计,那里的空气质量很差,这是个大问题;而且天气也很热。但那确实是个非常酷的地方。

英文原文

Well, Bangkok is getting expensive now, but Chiang Mai is still cheap. I think when you’re starting out, it’s a great place. Man, the air quality sucks, it’s a big problem. And it’s quite hot. But that’s a very cool place.

Lex Fridman29:22

有优点也有缺点。

英文原文

Pros and cons.

Pieter Levels29:23

我也超爱巴西。我女朋友是巴西人,但我喜欢巴西并不仅仅因为这个,我是真心喜欢。唯一的问题还是安全。就像在美国一样,安全状况是局部化的。欧洲人很难理解这点:安全与否取决于具体区域。如果你去了对的地方,那简直太棒了;巴西真的很棒。但如果你去了错的地方,说不定小命就没了。

英文原文

I love Brazil also. My girlfriend is Brazilian, but I do love not just because of that, but I like Brazil. The problem still is the safety issue. It’s like in America, it’s localized. It’s hard for Europeans to understand, safety is localized to specific areas. So if you go to the right areas, it’s amazing. Brazil’s amazing. If you go to the wrong areas, maybe you die.

Lex Fridman29:44

是啊,这倒是真的。

英文原文

Yeah. That’s true.

Pieter Levels29:45

但在欧洲可不是这样,欧洲的安全状况整体更平均。

英文原文

But it’s not true in Europe. Europe’s much more average.

Lex Fridman29:48

没错,没错,你说得对,说得对,说得对。整体更均衡。我喜欢那种街区特征鲜明的城市,比如你一跨过某条街,就进入了镇上的危险区域。我就喜欢这种感觉。美国有些城市就是这样,我很喜欢。你说欧洲更……[听不清 00:30:07]

英文原文

That’s true. That’s true. You’re right. You’re right. You’re right. It’s more averaged out. I like it when there’s strong neighborhoods. When you’re like, “You cross a certain street and you’re in the dangerous part of town.” I like it. There’s certain cities in the United States like that, I like that. And you’re saying Europe is more [inaudible 00:30:07]

Pieter Levels30:06

但你不会害怕?

英文原文

But you don’t feel scared?

Lex Fridman30:06

嗯,我不会。我喜欢危险。

英文原文

Well, I don’t. I like danger.

Pieter Levels30:07

哦,你练巴西柔术(BJJ)嘛。

英文原文

Well, you do BJJ.

Lex Fridman30:08

嗯,不光是这个。我觉得危险本身很有意思……危险能揭示你自身、揭示他人的一些东西。另外,我喜欢人性的全部光谱,所以我不喜欢那种被稀释、被柔化的人性。

英文原文

Well, no. Not even just that. I think danger is interesting, so … Danger reveals something about yourself, about others. Also, I like the full range of humanity. So I don’t like the mellowed out aspects of humanity.

Pieter Levels30:23

我也有这样的朋友,我身边就有一群完全这样的人。他们会主动去那些破败的区域,喜欢这种真实感,更看重真实性,不喜欢奢华,不喜欢——

英文原文

I have friends like these, I’m with friends that are exactly like this. They go to the broken areas. They like this reality. They like authenticity more. They don’t like luxury, they don’t like-

Lex Fridman30:34

哦,对,我讨厌奢华。

英文原文

Oh yeah, I hate luxury.

Pieter Levels30:35

对,这真是很欧洲范儿。

英文原文

Yeah, it’s very European of you.

Lex Fridman30:38

等等,那是什么?这完全是另一个话题了。所以你引用了弗蕾亚·斯塔克的话:‘独自一人在陌生的小镇醒来,是世上最愉悦的感觉之一。’ 你还记得自己曾在某个陌生小镇醒来并有过这种感觉吗?我们说的是小城镇还是大城市?还是……

英文原文

Wait, what was that? That’s a whole nother conversation. So you quoted Freya Stark, “To awaken quite alone in a strange town is one of the most pleasant sensations in the world.” Do you remember a time you awoken in a strange town and felt like that? We’re talking about small towns or big towns? Or …

Pieter Levels31:00

天啊,随便哪儿都行。我想我曾在某篇博客文章里写过这句话,而当时人们醒来时普遍会有这种感受……因为我自己建了一个关于数字游民的网站,叫nomadlist.com,它是个社区,有三万名其他数字游民,因为我当时感到孤独。所以我建了这个网站,之后就不再觉得孤独了。我还开始组织线下聚会、结交朋友。当时很常见的一种情况是,人们醒来后头半分钟会忘记自己身在何处,得往窗外一看才反应过来:‘我在哪儿?这是哪个国家?’ 听起来确实挺‘特权阶级’的,但其实更多是种幽默感——你真的不知道自己在哪儿,因为你实在太‘失根’了?但其中又确有某种……天啊,就像安东尼·波登那样。这种流浪式旅行本身有种纯粹感。不过现在这已成过去式了,我想。如今我都是和女友一起旅行,感觉完全不同。但那段流浪的、个体化的独行生活,仍是我浪漫的回忆。可问题是,它并没让我快乐,只是觉得很酷。但它并没让我快乐,反而让我焦虑。

英文原文

Man, anywhere. I think I wrote it in some blog post and it was a common thing when you would wake up, and this was … Because I have this website, I started a website about this digital nomads called nomadlist.com, and it was a community, so it was 30,000 other digital nomads, because I was feeling lonely. So I built this website and I stopped feeling lonely. I started organizing meetups and making friends. And it was very common that people would say they would wake up and they would forget where they are for the first half minute. And they had to look outside, ” Where am I? Which country?” Which sounds really like privileged, but it was more funny. You literally don’t know where you are because you’re so disrooted? But there’s something … Man, it’s like Anthony Bourdain. There’s something pure about this vagabond travel thing. It’s behind me, I think. Now I travel with my girlfriend, it’s very different. But it is romantic memories of this vagabond, individualistic solo life. But the thing is it didn’t make me happy, but it was very cool. But it didn’t make me happy, it made me anxious.

Lex Fridman32:03

这其中确有某种……

英文原文

There’s something about-

Pieter Levels32:00

很酷,但它并没让我快乐,对吧?它让我焦虑。

英文原文

Very cool, but it didn’t make me happy, right? It made me anxious.

Lex Fridman32:03

这其中确有某种让你焦虑的因素。我不知道,我至今仍有这种感觉。这是一种很酷的感觉,起初有点吓人,但接着你意识到自己身在何处,然后我就说不清了,那种感觉就像是当你处于这种状态时,突然被唤醒,意识到这个地方所蕴含的无限可能。

英文原文

There’s something about it that made you anxious. I don’t know, I still feel like that. It’s a cool feeling. It’s scary at first, but then you realize where you are, and I don’t know, it’s like you awaken to the possibilities of this place when you feel like that.

Pieter Levels32:03

就是这种感觉。

英文原文

That’s it.

Lex Fridman32:18

这种感觉很棒,哪怕你只是进行基础旅行,比如去旧金山之类的地方。

英文原文

It’s great, and it’s even when you’re doing basic travel, like go to San Francisco or something else.

Pieter Levels32:23

对,这就是所谓的新奇效应——你身处一个新地方,仿佛一切皆有可能。你还没感到厌倦,而这正是人们沉迷旅行的原因。

英文原文

Yeah, you have the novelty effect, like you’re in a new place, like here things are possible. You don’t get bored yet, and that’s why people get addicted to travel.

Lex Fridman32:33

回到创业话题,你写过一本关于如何创业的书,还就此做过一场精彩的演讲,这本书名叫《MAKE:自力更生创业者手册》。

英文原文

Back to startups, you wrote a book on how to do this thing, and gave a great talk on it, how to do startups, the book’s called MAKE: Bootstrapper’s Handbook.

Pieter Levels32:44

对。

英文原文

Yeah.

Lex Fridman32:44

我想问问,你能否大致讲讲其中几个步骤?即构想、构建、发布、增长、变现、自动化与退出。每个阶段都包含大量引人入胜的想法。先从构想阶段说起:你怎么找到一个好点子?

英文原文

I was wondering if you could go through some of the steps. It’s idea, build, launch, grow, monetize, automate, and exit. There’s a lot of fascinating ideas in each one, so idea stage, how do you find a good idea?

Pieter Levels32:56

我觉得,你得具备识别问题的能力。举个例子,你可以观察自己的日常生活:比如早上醒来时,想想‘日常生活中有哪些事情真让我烦心?哪些东西运转得特别不顺畅?’ 这些就是你能看到的问题,你可能会想:‘也许我能写段代码来解决它,让我的生活更轻松些。’ 所以,我建议你把所有这类问题列出来,再为每个问题构思一个解决方案,看看哪个方案切实可行、你能真正付诸实践,然后就开始动手构建。

英文原文

So, I think you need to be able to spot problems. So for example, you can go in your daily life, like when you wake up and you’re like, “What is stuff that I’m really annoyed with that’s like in my daily life that doesn’t function well?” And that’s a problem that you can see, okay, maybe that’s something I can write code for, and it will make my life easier. So, I would say make a list of all these problems you have, and an idea to solve it, and see which one is viable, you can actually do something, and then start building it.

Lex Fridman33:25

这的确是个极佳的起点:对生活中所有问题保持开放心态,真正开始留意它们。我认为,意识到自己生活的某些方面本可以大大改善,其实并非一件轻而易举的事,因为我们往往很快就会习惯那些不适感。

英文原文

So, that’s a really good place to start. Become open to all the problems in your life, like actually start noticing them. I think that’s actually not a trivial thing to do, to realize that some aspects of your life could be done way, way better, because we kind of very quickly get accustomed to discomforts.

Pieter Levels33:44

完全正确。

英文原文

Exactly.

Lex Fridman33:45

比如门把手,或者某些物品的设计。

英文原文

Like for example, doorknobs, like design of certain things.

Pieter Levels33:50

新款莱克斯·弗里德曼门把手,[听不清 00:33:53]——

英文原文

The new Lex Fridman doorknob, [inaudible 00:33:53]-

Lex Fridman33:53

我知道那个门把手背后投入了多少惊人的设计工作。门和门把手,乃至日常用品的设计——叉子、勺子——都特别有意思。要设计出比现有叉子更优的叉子,难度极大;另一方面,你也提到,要想产生有趣的想法,就得努力过一种更有趣的生活。

英文原文

That one I know how much incredible design work has gone into. It’s really interesting, doors and doorknobs, just the design of everyday things, forks and spoons. It’s going to be hard to come up with a fork that’s better than the current fork designs, and the other aspect of it is you’re saying in order to come up with interesting ideas, you got to try to live a more interesting life.

Pieter Levels34:15

没错,而旅行恰恰能帮上忙。因为当我开始旅行后,我便注意到其他国家存在一些欧洲甚至美国都没有的东西。比如去亚洲,尤其是十年前,几乎没人知道这些。微信等各类应用,它们早已拥有我们后来才有的‘全能型应用’。如今埃隆正试图将X打造成类似微信的‘全能型应用’,道理一样。在印尼或泰国,你只需一个App就能点餐、买菜、预约按摩、叫修车师傅——任何你能想到的服务,全都能在这个App里搞定。这类现象,例如,就叫‘套利’。

英文原文

Yeah, but that’s where travel comes in, because when I started traveling, I started seeing stuff in other countries that you didn’t have in Europe for example, or America even. If you go to Asia, dude, especially 10 years ago, nobody knew about this. The WeChats, all these apps that they already had before we had them, these everything apps. Right now Elon’s trying to make X this everything app like WeChat, same thing. Indonesia or Thailand, you have one app that you can order food, or if you can order groceries, you can order massage, you can order car mechanic, anything you can think of is in the app, and that stuff, for example, that’s called arbitrage.

Pieter Levels34:53

你可以回到自己的国家,为本国开发同样的App。因此,你开始发现各种问题,也开始看到世界其他地方的人们早已提出的解决方案;此外,旅行本身也会带给你更多问题,因为旅行本身就是件令人不适的事——机场糟糕透顶,飞机也谈不上舒适。你只要一踏出家门,就会遇到一大堆问题。

英文原文

You can go back to your country and build that same app for your country for example. So, you start seeing problems, you start seeing solutions that other people already did in the rest of the world, and also traveling in general just gives you more problems, because travel is uncomfortable. Airports are horrible, airplanes are not comfortable either. There’s a lot of problems you start seeing, just getting out of your house.

Lex Fridman35:20

我的意思是,在数字世界里,你完全可以进入不同社群,看看其中有哪些方面可以改进——

英文原文

I mean, in a digital world, you can just go into different communities, and see what can be improved by-

Pieter Levels35:25

对。

英文原文

Yes.

Lex Fridman35:25

——在那些社群里。

英文原文

… in that.

Pieter Levels35:27

对,对,对,对。

英文原文

Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.

Lex Fridman35:28

你具体是怎么生成创意的?你会做创意速记吗?你是否有一个文档,专门用来持续记录各种想法?

英文原文

What specifically is your process of generating ideas? Do you do idea dumps? Do you have a document where you just keep writing stuff?

Pieter Levels35:35

对,我以前确实有……因为那时我还没赚到钱,正努力列出一份创意清单,琢磨着‘我得建这些东西……’ 我当时是从统计学角度思考的:‘好吧,我得把所有这些项目都做一遍,其中总该有一个能成功。所以,我需要准备大量备选方案来尝试。’ 我就这么干了。如今,我觉得自己已有一定经济基础,便能更多地基于技术开展工作。比如,当我了解到Stable Diffusion或ChatGPT等技术时,所有这些新技术都让我……我并未立刻着手使用它们,因为我当时没有实际问题要解决,但我对技术本身充满好奇,于是就玩了起来,边玩边摸索——先是纯属玩耍,接着慢慢发现:‘哦,Stable Diffusion生成的房屋外观和室内设计非常精美。’

英文原文

Yeah, I used to have… Because when I wasn’t making money, I was trying to make this list of ideas to see… So I need to build… I was thinking statistically, “All right, I need to build all these things and one of these will work out probably. So, I need to have a lot of things to try,” and I did that. Right now, I think because I already have money, I can do more things based on technology. So for example, AI, when I found out about… When Stable Diffusion came or ChatGPT and stuff, all these things were like… I didn’t start working with them, because I had a problem. I had no problems, but I was very curious about technology, and I was playing with it, and figuring out… First, just playing with it, and then you find something like, “Okay, Stable Diffusion generates houses very beautiful and interiors.”

Lex Fridman36:21

所以,这已不单是解决问题,而更多是探索你能用新技术创造的新可能性。

英文原文

So, it’s less about problem solving, it’s more about the possibilities of new things you can create.

Pieter Levels36:25

对,但这风险极高,因为这是典型的‘先有解决方案,再找问题’,通常行不通;而且我认为,这在创业漏斗中极为常见——他们手握技术,但用户其实并不需要这项技术,对吧?

英文原文

Yeah, but that’s very risky, because that’s the famous solution trying to find a problem, and usually it doesn’t work, and that’s very common with startup funnels, I think. They have tech, but actually people don’t need to tech, right?

Lex Fridman36:38

你能具体解释一下吗?聊聊你创作的一些作品会很有意思。能讲讲photoai.com吗?

英文原文

Can you actually explain? It’d be cool to talk about some of the stuff you’ve created. Can you explain the photoai.com?

Pieter Levels36:46

对,对。它的理念是‘解雇你的摄影师’。核心想法是:你再也不需要摄影师了。你可以把自己训练成一个AI模型,然后随时随地、穿着任意服装、摆出各种表情(如开心、悲伤)和姿势,随心所欲地拍摄无数张照片。

英文原文

Yeah, yeah. So, it’s like fire your photographer. The idea is that you don’t need a photographer anymore. You can train yourself as an AI model, and you can take as many photos as you want anywhere, in any clothes, with facial expressions, like happy, or sad, or poses, all this stuff.

Lex Fridman37:02

那么它是怎么运作的?你给我发了一个图库链接,里面全是用我做的示例图,这……

英文原文

So, how does it work? You sent me a link to a gallery of ones done on me, which is-

Pieter Levels37:10

对,左边是提示词输入框。你可以在这里输入……模型就是你的模型,也就是莱克斯·弗里德曼。所以你可以写‘模型是某某某’,随意发挥,然后点击按钮,它就开始生成照片,耗时约一分钟。

英文原文

Yeah, so on the left you have the prompts, the box. Yeah, so you can write… So, model is your model, this is Lex Fridman. So, you can write model as a blah, blah, blah, whatever you want, then press the button, and it will take photos. It will take like one minute.

Lex Fridman37:21

生成60张照片。你用的是哪家服务商来托管和提供算力?

英文原文

60 photos. What are you using for the hosting, for the compute?

Pieter Levels37:24

Replicate。

英文原文

Replicate.

Lex Fridman37:25

好的。

英文原文

Okay.

Pieter Levels37:25

replicate.com。他们做得非常非常棒。

英文原文

Replicate.com. They’re very, very good.

Lex Fridman37:29

从界面设计来看,显示预计耗时这点很酷。太棒了,它已经……我猜你只是从网上加载了几张图片。

英文原文

Interface-wise, it’s cool that you’re showing how long it’s going to take. This is amazing, so it’s taken a… I’m presuming you just loaded in a few pictures from the internet.

Pieter Levels37:37

对,我去了Google图片,搜索‘莱克斯·弗里德曼’,添加了大约十到二十张图片。你可以把它们打开成图库,再用鼠标光标……有些图片看起来不像你。所以命中率嘛,我也不清楚,大概五五开之类的。

英文原文

Yeah, so I went to Google Images, typed in Lex Fridman, I added like 10 or 20 images. You can open them in a gallery, and you can use your cursor to… So, some don’t look like you. So, the hit-and-miss rate is, I don’t know, say like 50/50 or something.

Lex Fridman37:53

但刚才我看的时候[听不清 00:37:55],效果正变得越来越好,越来越好。

英文原文

But when I was watching it [inaudible 00:37:55], it’s been getting better and better and better.

Pieter Levels37:56

一开始效果非常差,差到难以置信,但即便如此,仍有人注册使用。

英文原文

It was very bad in the beginning. It was so bad, but still people signed up to it.

Lex Fridman38:03

出现了两个莱克斯。太棒了。它变得越来越色情化,让我感到极度不适。

英文原文

There’s two Lexes. It’s great. It’s getting more and more sexual. It’s making me very uncomfortable.

Pieter Levels38:08

老兄,但这就是这些模型的问题所在。不,我们得谈谈这个,因为这些模型在……

英文原文

Man, but that’s the problem with these models. No, we need to talk about this, because the models in-

Lex Fridman38:12

当然。

英文原文

Sure.

Pieter Levels38:12

……Stable Diffusion,所以那些经过微调的逼真图像模型,最初全部是在色情内容上训练出来的,当时是一个叫哈桑(Hassan)的人做的。我当时正试图搞清楚如何生成逼真的AI照片,而仅靠Stable Diffusion本身效果并不好——人脸全都扭曲变形,分辨率也不够高,或者存在其他问题,导致效果不佳。但我开始看到一些基础模型、一些微调后的模型,人们用色情内容来训练它们,我试用了这些模型,发现它们生成的图像非常逼真,人体结构也基本合理,比如解剖学上是说得通的。但如果你观察如今大家使用的这些逼真图像模型,其底层核心里依然残留着色情内容,比如裸体人物。因此,我必须在提示词中主动排除这类内容;所有从事AI初创公司、尤其是图像相关业务的人,都必须这么做:必须在提示词中明确排除裸体内容。你得写‘裸体[听不清 00:39:00]’……

英文原文

… Stable Diffusion, so the photorealistic models that are fine-tuned, they were all trained on porn in the beginning, and it was a guy called Hassan. So, I was trying to figure out how to do photorealistic AI photos and it was… Stable Diffusion by itself is not doing that well. The faces look all mangled, and it doesn’t have enough resolution or something to do that well, but I started seeing these base models, these fine-tuned models, and people would train on porn, and I would try them, and they would be very photorealistic. They would have bodies that actually made sense, like body anatomy, but if you look at the photorealistic models that people use now, there’s still core of porn there, like of naked people. So, I need to prompt out, and everybody needs to do this with AI startups, with imaging, you need to prompt out the naked stuff. You need to put a naked [inaudible 00:39:00]-

Lex Fridman38:59

你得不断提醒模型:‘你得给这个东西穿上衣服。’

英文原文

You have to keep reminding the model, “You need to put clothes on the thing.”

Pieter Levels39:02

对,别写‘裸体’,因为这风险极高。我用Google Vision在每张图片展示给用户前都做一次检测,以筛查[听不清 00:39:09]……

英文原文

Yeah, don’t put naked, because it’s very risky. I have Google Vision that checks every photo before it’s shown to the user to check for [inaudible 00:39:09]-

Lex Fridman39:08

比如乳头检测器?

英文原文

Like a nipple detector?

Pieter Levels39:09

是的。

英文原文

Yes.

Lex Fridman39:11

[听不清 00:39:11]检测器。

英文原文

[inaudible 00:39:11] detector.

Pieter Levels39:11

因为记者们一旦发现就会非常愤怒……

英文原文

Because the journalists get very angry if they-

Lex Fridman39:13

如果你把内容性化了……

英文原文

If you sexualize-

Pieter Levels39:14

曾有位记者,我想应该是他,因使用该系统而发怒,抱怨说:‘哦,它居然显示出了乳头!’因为Google Vision没能检测出来。所以,这类问题就是你需要应对的——我指的就是这种问题。这是关于猫的图,但你看这猫的脸,同样有点扭曲变形。

英文原文

There was a journalist, I think ,that got angry that used this and it was like, “Oh, it showed a nipple,” because Google Vision didn’t detect it. So, that’s like these kind of problems you need to deal with. That’s what I’m talking about. This is with cats, but look at the cat face. It’s also kind of mangled.

Lex Fridman39:34

我有点不安。

英文原文

I’m a little bit disturbed.

Pieter Levels39:36

如果你想的话,可以放大看这只猫。这是一只非常悲伤的猫,它根本没有鼻子。

英文原文

You can zoom in on the cat if you want. This is a very sad cat. It doesn’t have a nose.

Lex Fridman39:42

它没有鼻子,哇哦。

英文原文

It doesn’t have a nose, wow.

Pieter Levels39:44

天哪,但这正是AI初创公司面临的问题:它们全都装作自己的技术完美无缺,仿佛这是突破性的成果,但实际上它并不完美,有一半时间效果真的很差。

英文原文

Man, but this is the problem with AI startups, because they all act like it’s perfect, like this is groundbreaking, but it’s not perfect. It’s really bad half the time.

Lex Fridman39:53

所以,如果我想更新模型……

英文原文

So, if I wanted to sort of update model as-

Pieter Levels39:55

对,你就把这些东西去掉,然后按需写入你想要的内容,比如写‘在泰国’之类,或‘在东京’。

英文原文

Yeah, so you remove this stuff, and you write whatever you want, like in Thailand or something, or in Tokyo.

Lex Fridman40:03

在东京?

英文原文

In Tokyo?

Pieter Levels40:04

对。

英文原文

Yeah.

Lex Fridman40:06

而且……

英文原文

And-

Pieter Levels40:07

你可以说‘夜晚霓虹灯下’,还可以为[听不清 00:40:11]添加更多细节。

英文原文

You could say like at night with neon lights. You can add more detail to [inaudible 00:40:11]-

Lex Fridman40:11

我去奥斯汀吧。你觉得它会知道……

英文原文

I’ll go in Austin. Do you think it’ll know-

Pieter Levels40:13

对,奥斯汀……

英文原文

Yeah, Austin-

Lex Fridman40:13

……在德克萨斯州?奥斯汀,德克萨斯州?

英文原文

… in Texas? In Austin, Texas?

Pieter Levels40:14

戴牛仔帽?

英文原文

With cowboy hat?

Lex Fridman40:15

在德克萨斯州,对。

英文原文

In Texas, yeah.

Pieter Levels40:17

扮成牛仔。

英文原文

As a cowboy.

Lex Fridman40:21

扮成牛仔。结果它会严重偏向色情方向。它[听不清 00:40:25]……

英文原文

As a cowboy. It’s going to go so towards the porn direction. It’s [inaudible 00:40:25]-

Pieter Levels40:25

天哪,希望不会这样。那可就等于我的职业生涯终结了。

英文原文

Man, I hope not. It’s the end of my career.

Lex Fridman40:28

或者恰恰是刚刚开始,这取决于你怎么看。‘当您的照片处理完成时,我们将向您发送推送通知。’好的,不错。

英文原文

Or the beginning, it depends. ” We can send you a push notification when your photos are done.” All right, cool.

Pieter Levels40:34

对,咱们看看。

英文原文

Yeah, let’s see.

Lex Fridman40:35

哦,哇,整个这个界面都是你开发的?

英文原文

Oh, wow, so this whole interface you’ve built?

Pieter Levels40:37

对。

英文原文

Yeah.

Lex Fridman40:38

做得真不错。

英文原文

This is really well done.

Pieter Levels40:40

全都是用jQuery写的。所以我现在还在用jQuery?

英文原文

It’s all jQuery. So, I still use jQuery?

Lex Fridman40:41

对……

英文原文

Yes-

Pieter Levels40:42

就只用这一个?

英文原文

The only one?

Lex Fridman40:42

……至今仍……

英文原文

… still-

Pieter Levels40:43

都十年了?

英文原文

After 10 years?

Lex Fridman40:43

……直到今天。你可不是唯一一个。网页开发栈就是PHP,整个技术栈……

英文原文

… to this day. You’re not the only one. The web is PHP, the stack-

Pieter Levels40:43

就是PHP加jQuery,没错,还有SQLite。

英文原文

It’s PHP and jQuery, yes, and SQLite.

Lex Fridman40:50

你只是目前仍公开谈论这套技术栈的顶尖程序员之一而已,但其实所有人都在用PHP。你只要去看一看,目前互联网上大部分网站很可能仍在使用PHP和jQuery。

英文原文

You’re just one of the top performers from a programming perspective that are still openly talking about it, but everyone’s using PHP. If you look, most of the web is still probably PHP and jQuery.

Pieter Levels41:01

我觉得占比约70%。这是因为WordPress,对吧?因为博客……

英文原文

I think 70%. It’s because of WordPress, right? Because the blogs are-

Lex Fridman41:04

对,确实如此。

英文原文

Yeah, that’s true.

Pieter Levels41:05

对……

英文原文

Yeah-

Lex Fridman41:06

确实如此。

英文原文

That’s true.

Pieter Levels41:06

我现在正看到一种复兴趋势。人们已经厌倦了各种框架。所有JavaScript框架都太……该怎么形容呢,比如‘繁重冗杂’。仅仅维护这些代码就得耗费大量精力,而且一旦框架升级到新版本,你又得把所有东西都改一遍。PHP却始终如一,一直稳定运行。

英文原文

I’m seeing a revival now. People are getting sick of frameworks. All the JavaScript frameworks are so… What do you call it, like wieldy. It takes so much work to just maintain this code, and then it updates to a new version, you need to change everything. PHP just stays the same and works.

Lex Fridman41:23

对。你能具体谈谈这套技术栈吗?你所有的网站、应用、初创项目、各类工程,基本上全都是用纯HTML、带jQuery的JavaScript、PHP和SQLite构建的。这确实是一套极其简洁的技术栈,用它能极快地交付成果。你能谈谈你采用这套技术栈背后的哲学理念吗?

英文原文

Yeah. Can you actually just speak to that stack? You build all your websites, apps, startups, projects, all of that with mostly vanilla HTML, JavaScript with jQuery, PHP, and SQLite. So, that’s a really simple stack, and you get stuff done really fast with that. Can you just speak to the philosophy behind that?

Pieter Levels41:47

我觉得这纯属偶然,因为这是我唯一熟悉的工具。我懂PHP,懂HTML、CSS,毕竟做网站就得会这些。而当我创办的初创公司开始腾飞时,我根本没时间……我还记得曾在待办事项清单上写着:‘学习Node.js’,因为我知道必须转用它,毕竟它显然比PHP强得多,但我始终没学。我从未真正去学,因为我实在抽不出时间。这些项目发展势头迅猛,我又接连启动更多新项目,始终腾不出空来。就像总想着‘总有一天我会开始认真编码’,结果这一天却始终没到来。

英文原文

I think it’s accidental, because that’s the thing I knew. I knew PHP, I knew HTML, CSS, because you make websites, and when my startups started taking off, I didn’t have time to… I remember putting on my to-do list like, “Learn Node.js,” because it’s important to switch, because this obviously is much better language than PHP, and I never learned it. I never did it, because I didn’t have time. These things were growing like this, and I was launching more projects, and I never had time. It’s like, “One day I’ll start coding properly,” and I never got to it.

Lex Fridman42:19

我有时也在想自己是否真该学这些东西。掌握Node.js或Flask这类技术,至今仍是我的待办事项之一……

英文原文

I sometimes wonder if I need to learn that stuff. It’s still a to-do item for me to really learn Node.js or Flask or these kind of-

Pieter Levels42:27

React[听不清 00:42:28]……

英文原文

React [inaudible 00:42:28]-

Lex Fridman42:28

对,React。感觉一名负责任的软件工程师理应掌握这些技术,但用纯原生版本的东西,你反而能快得多地交付成果。

英文原文

Yeah, React, and it feels like a responsible software engineer should know how to use these, but you can get stuff done so fast with vanilla versions of stuff.

Pieter Levels42:44

对,这就像是:如果你想找份工作,那作为软件开发者,你当然需要掌握这些;但如果你是想创业、想当企业家,那或许压根就不该花时间学这些,对吧?

英文原文

Yeah, it’s like software developers if you want to get a job, and there’s people making stuff, like startups, and if you want to be entrepreneur, probably you maybe shouldn’t, right?

Lex Fridman42:55

我真的很想衡量性能与速度。我认为这其中蕴含着深刻的智慧。我确实觉得,各种框架以及持续追逐新技术的这种复杂软件工程方式,反而成了障碍。至于这一点我也不知该如何评价,因为显然你不能所有东西都用纯原生JavaScript或纯C语言(比如C++)从零构建——例如在系统工程领域,指针安全性等特性就带来大量优势。所以我也说不准,但我的确感觉:只要你不太在意实现方式,就能完成多得多的工作。

英文原文

I really want to measure performance and speed. I think there’s a deep wisdom in that. I do think that frameworks and just constantly wanting to learn the new thing, this complicated way of software engineering gets in the way. I’m not sure what to say about that, because definitely you shouldn’t build everything from just vanilla JavaScript or vanilla C for example, C++ when you’re building systems engineering is like… There’s a lot of benefits for a pointer safety, and all that kind of stuff. So I don’t know, but it just feels like you can get so much more stuff done if you don’t care about how you do it.

Pieter Levels43:33

天哪,这大概是我最具争议的观点了,也许我错了,但我感觉:如今这些融资成功的框架,动辄募集五千万、一亿美元甚至两亿美元资金。其核心逻辑在于:必须吸引开发者,尤其是十八九岁、二十出头的新手开发者采用该框架,并在其之上构建一个平台——虽然框架本身开源,但你最好使用其配套的付费平台;而该平台的托管成本,比直接托管在AWS服务器或DigitalOcean的VPS上高出一千倍。因此,这里显然存在金钱动机:我们想让大量开发者采用这项技术,然后向他们收费,因为他们会在初创公司中使用它,而初创公司则会为此买单。

英文原文

Man, this is my most controversial take, I think, and maybe I’m wrong, but I feel like this frameworks now that raise money, they raise a lot of money. They raise 50 million, 100 million, $200 million, and the idea is that you need to make the developers, and new developers, like when you’re 18 or 20 years old, get them to use this framework, and add a platform to it where the framework can… It’s open source, but you probably should use the platform, which is paid to use it, and the cost of the platforms to host it are 1,000 times higher than just hosting it on a simple AWS server or VPS on DigitalOcean. So, there’s obviously a monetary incentive here. We want to get a lot of developers to use this technology, and then we need to charge them money, because they’re going to use it in startups, and then the startups can pay for the bills.

Pieter Levels44:25

这某种程度上破坏了外界关于编程学习的信息生态,因为他们会向YouTube博主、向开发者领域的影响者大笔付费……这跟营养健康或健身领域的情况一模一样,在开发领域也是如此:他们付费请影响者推广这些技术,用它做演示、开发示例产品,于是很多人便惊叹:‘哇,快用这个!’我开始注意到这种现象,是因为当我发布自己的产品时,常有人问我:‘你用的是什么技术?’我回答:‘就PHP、jQuery。这有什么关系?’

英文原文

It kind of destroys the information out there about learning to code, because they pay YouTubers, they pay developer influencers a big thing to… And same thing what happens with nutrition and fitness or something, same thing happens in developing. They pay this influencer to promote this stuff, use it, make stuff with it, make demo products with it, and then a lot of people are like, “Wow, use this.” And I started noticing this, because when I would ship my stuff, people would ask me, “What are you using?” I would say, “Just PHP, jQuery. Why does it matter?”

Pieter Levels44:56

结果人们就开始攻击我:‘你为啥不用这个新技术、这个新框架、这个新玩意儿?’我就说:‘我不知道,因为PHP这套东西管用啊,我也没刻意优化什么,它就是管用。’我一直不理解为什么……我明白新技术确实更好,理应代表进步,但我对金钱极度警惕,就像警惕游说一样。开发者框架领域里充斥着金钱——数亿美元被投入广告或影响者营销等渠道。这笔钱不可能全流向开发者。一个框架用不了那么多开发者,而它又是开源的,目的就是为了在初创公司身上赚取更多利润。

英文原文

And people would start attacking me like, “Why are you not using this new technology, this new framework, this new thing?” And I say, “I don’t know, because this PHP thing works, and I don’t really optimizing for anything. It just works.” And I never understood why… I understand there’s new technologies that are better and it should be improvement, but I’m very suspicious of money, just like lobbying. There’s money in this developer framework scene. There’s hundreds of millions that goes to ads or influencer or whatever. It can’t all go to developers. You don’t need so many developers for a framework, and it’s open source to make a lot of more money on these startups.

Lex Fridman45:32

这个视角确实很有价值,但除此之外,当你说到‘更好’时,我们能否拿出些数据来佐证‘更好’?因为我想从个体开发者角度了解,还想考察五人团队、十人团队、二十人团队的实际表现:他们交付功能的速度如何?引入多少缺陷?造成多少安全漏洞……

英文原文

So, that’s a really good perspective, but in addition to that is when you say better, it’s like, can we get some data on the better? Because I want to know from the individual developer perspective, and then from a team of five, team of 10, team of 20 developers measure how productive they are in shipping features, how many bugs they create, how many security holes result-

Pieter Levels46:00

PHP过去在安全性方面确实表现不佳,但现在已[听不清 00:46:03]……

英文原文

PHP was not good with security for a while, but now it’s [inaudible 00:46:03]-

Lex Fridman46:03

理论上真是如此吗?

英文原文

In theory, is it though?

Pieter Levels46:05

现在已很好了。

英文原文

Now it’s good.

Lex Fridman46:06

不,现在听你这么说,我想确认这是否属实,因为PHP曾长期占据互联网绝大多数网站。

英文原文

No, now as you’re saying it, I want to know if that’s true, because PHP was just the majority of websites on the internet.

Pieter Levels46:15

这可能是真的。

英文原文

It could be true.

Lex Fridman46:16

还是说它只是占比过高?WordPress也是类似情况。

英文原文

Is it just overrepresented? Same with WordPress.

Pieter Levels46:19

对。

英文原文

Yeah.

Lex Fridman46:19

是的,WordPress 一直有‘存在海量安全漏洞’的名声。我不知道这是否属实。我知道它确实经常遭到攻击,因为它太流行了。它的确存在安全漏洞,但也许许多其他系统也存在安全漏洞。总之,我只是在质疑那种陈旧的共识——这种共识总是一味地推动软件工程师去采用各种框架、采用复杂得离谱的软件工程方法,结果反而拉长了真正把东西做出来的耗时。

英文原文

Yes, there’s a reputation that WordPress has a gigantic number of security holes. I don’t know if that’s true. I know it gets attacked a lot, because it’s so popular. It definitely does have security holes, but maybe a lot of other systems have security holes as well. Anyway, I just sort of questioning the conventional wisdom that keeps wanting to push software engineers towards frameworks, towards complex, like super complicated software engineering approaches that stretch out the time it takes to actually build a thing.

Pieter Levels46:50

天啊,完全同意!大公司也一样……80% 的人其实什么都没干。这效率极低;而如果你的衡量标准是‘人们是否真能做出实际落地的东西’,那么对整个社会而言,若想节省时间,我们大概就该采用那些简单、务实、管用、不过度复杂的技术——它不该把你的生活变成一场活地狱。

英文原文

Man, 100%, and it’s the same thing with big corporations… 80% of the people don’t do anything. It’s not efficient, and if your benchmark is people building stuff that actually gets done. And for society, if we want to save time, we should probably use the technology that’s simple, that’s pragmatic, that works, that’s not overly complicated, it doesn’t make your life like a living hell.

Lex Fridman47:18

而且,只有当某个框架明显解决了你面临的直接问题时,才去用它……

英文原文

And use a framework when it obviously solves a direct problem that you-

Pieter Levels47:23

对,当然如此。我并不是说你就该不用框架来写代码。你想用什么就用什么,但我觉得这事挺可疑的。而且我觉得[听不清 00:47:32],当我发推特聊这事时,立刻就冒出一支‘大军’——这些‘框架军团’。老兄,我直觉上就感觉……

英文原文

Yeah, of course. I’m not saying you should code without a framework. You should use whatever you want, but yeah, I think it’s suspicious. And I think [inaudible 00:47:32], when I talk about it on Twitter, there’s this army comes out, there’s these framework armies. Man, something my gut tells me-

Lex Fridman47:40

我想问问这些‘框架军团’:你们这周造出了什么?这就是埃隆式提问——‘你这周干了啥?’

英文原文

I want to ask the framework army, what have they built this week? It’s the Elon question, “What did you do this week?”

Pieter Levels47:45

对,你们靠它赚到钱了吗?向用户收费了吗?它是个真正的生意吗?没错。

英文原文

Yeah, did you make money with it? Did you charge users? Is it a real business? And yeah.

Lex Fridman47:52

所以,回到‘牛仔’这个说法——首先……

英文原文

So going back to the cowboy, first of all-

Pieter Levels47:54

有些人长得可不像你,对吧?但有些人确实像。

英文原文

Some don’t look like you, right? But some do.

Lex Fridman47:56

这件事的方方面面都相当惊人。我还在看它的界面,做得真的非常棒。所以,这整个都是用 jQuery 写的,而且完成度极高。那么,请带我走一遍 Photo AI 的发展历程吧。世界上大多数人对 Stable Diffusion 或任何生成式 AI 技术都不太了解。所以你当时想的是:‘好,我怎么用这个技术做出酷炫的东西?’Photo AI 最初是怎么诞生的?

英文原文

Every aspect of this is pretty incredible. I’m also just looking at the interface. It’s really well done. So, this is all just jQuery, and this is really well done. So, take me through the journey of Photo AI. Most of the world doesn’t know much about Stable Diffusion or any of the generative AI stuff. So you’re thinking, “Okay, how can I build cool stuff with this?” What was the origin story of Photo AI?

Pieter Levels48:21

我觉得起点是 Stable Diffusion 的发布。Stable Diffusion 就是这样……它是第一款生成式图像 AI 模型。我开始动手玩它:你可以在 Mac 上安装……有人把它 fork 之后,适配到了 MacBook 上。于是我就下载下来,克隆了代码仓库,开始用它生成图像,效果令人惊叹。我在 Twitter 上发现它的,因为新东西往往最先在 Twitter 上冒头;我自己做的东西也同步发到 Twitter 上,你可以生成任意图像。

英文原文

I think it started, because Stable Diffusion came out. So Stable Diffusion like this… The first generative image AI model, and I started playing with it. You could install on your Mac… Somebody forked it and made it work for MacBooks. So, I downloaded it and cloned the repo, and started using it to generate images, and it was amazing. I found it on Twitter, because you see things happen on Twitter, and I would post what I was making on Twitter as well, and you could make any image.

Pieter Levels48:50

本质上,你只需写一段提示词(prompt),它就能生成对应主题的照片或图像,且风格任选。比如,人们会输入艺术家名字,让它生成类似毕加索风格的作品等等。我当时就在尝试摸索:它最擅长什么?擅长画人吗?不,它画人特别差;但它很擅长画房子,比如建筑类图像,我就专门生成各种建筑房屋。于是我建了个网站叫 thishousedoesnotexist.org,它生成……当时大家管这叫‘房屋色情图’(house porn)。‘Houseporn’本就是一个 Reddit 子版块,而这个网站用的就是 Stable Diffusion 的初版。所以画面看起来相当……你可以点一下换张图。它生成的全是现实中并不存在的房子。

英文原文

So, essentially you write a prompt, and then it generates a photo of that or image of that in any style. They would use artist names to make like a Picasso kind of style and stuff, and I was trying to see, what is it good at? Is it good at people? No, it’s really bad at people, but it was good at houses, so architecture for example, I would generate architecture houses. So, I made a website called thishousedoesnotexist.org, and it generated… They called like house porn at that one. Houseporn is like a subreddit, and this was Stable Diffusion, like the first version. So it looks really… You can click for another photo. So, it generates all these non-existing houses.

Lex Fridman49:34

这确实是‘房屋色情图’。

英文原文

It is house porn.

Pieter Levels49:35

但当时看起来还挺不错,尤其在那个年代。

英文原文

But it looked kind of good, especially back then.

Lex Fridman49:37

看起来真的很棒。

英文原文

It looks really good.

Pieter Levels49:38

现在的东西看起来好多了。

英文原文

Now, things look much better.

Lex Fridman49:42

这真的做得太棒了,哇哦。

英文原文

That’s really, really well done, wow.

Pieter Levels49:46

而且它还会自动生成描述文字。

英文原文

And it also generates a description.

Lex Fridman49:50

你还能点赞……好看吗?那就点赞吧。

英文原文

And you can upvote… Is it nice? Upvote it.

Pieter Levels49:52

对。

英文原文

Yeah.

Lex Fridman49:52

天啊,有太多东西想跟你聊了。这里的选项设计得真棒。

英文原文

Man, there’s so much to talk to you about. The choices here is really well done.

Pieter Levels49:57

这非常草根化。页面底部有个按最高点赞数排序的房屋排行榜。这些都是获赞最多的房子;如果你切换到‘全时段’榜单,能看到不少非常漂亮的设计。对,这一张是我最喜欢的,排在第一位。它有点像……

英文原文

This is very scrappy. In the bottom, there’s like a ranking of the most upvoted houses. So, these are the top voted, and if you go to all time, you see quite beautiful ones. Yeah. So this one is my favorite, the number one. It’s kind of like a…

Lex Fridman50:10

怎么没更火一点?

英文原文

How is this not more popular?

Pieter Levels50:12

它一度确实很火,但后来大家很快就腻了。我想,连我自己都腻了——持续不断的‘房屋色情图’,看多了全都一个样。但后来我发现它特别擅长室内设计,于是就转向 interiorai.com,先尝试上传图片、再生成室内设计方案;接着我又尝试……当时出现了一种新技术叫‘图生图’(image-to-image),即你可以输入一张照片,它会在此基础上进行修改。所以你看,它跟现在的 Photo AI 看起来几乎一模一样,本质上用的也是同一套代码。

英文原文

It was really popular for a while, but then people got so bored of it. I think, because I was getting bored of it, too, just continuous house porn, everything starts looking the same, but then I saw it was really good at interior, so I pivoted to interiorai.com, where I tried to upload first generate interior designs, and then I tried to do… There was a new technology called image-to-image where you can input an image, like a photo, and it would kind of modify the thing. So, you see it looks almost the same as Photo AI. It’s the same code essentially.

Lex Fridman50:46

不错。

英文原文

Nice.

Pieter Levels50:47

于是我就上传了自己住所的室内照片,然后输入指令,比如‘改成某种极致主义风格’,结果真成了,而且效果非常好。我当时就想:‘行,这是个创业项目了’——毕竟,用 AI 做室内设计,当时根本没人干。所以我上线了这个产品,很快取得成功:上线一周内月收入就达 1 万至 2 万美元,如今仍稳定维持在每月 4 万至 5 万美元,已持续两年。接着我就想:‘怎么进一步提升这个室内设计功能?我得开始学微调(fine-tuning)了。’

英文原文

So, I would upload a photo of my interior where I lived, and I would ask like, “Change this into, I don’t know, maximalist design,” and it worked and it worked really well. So I was like, “Okay, this is a startup,” because obviously interior design AI, and nobody’s doing that yet. So, I launched this and I was successful and within a week, made 10K, 20K a month, and now still makes like 40K, 50K a month, and it’s been like two years. So then I was like, “How can I improve this interior design? I need to start learning fine-tuning.”

Pieter Levels51:18

所谓微调,就是拿一个现成的 AI 模型,在你特定的目标任务上再训练优化。于是我就搜集大量精美的室内设计图,建了一个图库,再训练出一个专精于室内设计的新模型,效果很好,我也投入实际使用了。后来出于好玩,我又上传了自己的照片,就在这儿发生了转折——用来训练‘我自己’。这本来肯定不会成功的,结果居然成功了,而且模型甚至开始理解‘我’作为一个概念。我的脸能被准确识别,还能套用不同风格,比如‘我化身中世纪战士’之类,各种很俗气的效果。我当时就想:‘这又是一个创业点子。’于是我又做了 avatarai.me。可惜 .com 域名没抢到,这个域名是[听不清 00:52:01]……

英文原文

And fine-tuning is where you have this existing AI model and you fine tune it on the specific goal you wanted to do. So, I would find really beautiful interior design, make a gallery, and train a new model that was very good at interior design, and it worked, and I used that as well. And then for fun, I uploaded photos of myself, and here’s where it happened, and to train myself. And this would never work, obviously, and it worked, and actually it started understanding me as a concept. So, my face worked and you could do different styles, like me as a… Very cheesy, medieval warrior, all this stuff. So I was like, “This is another startup.” So, now I did avatarai.me. I couldn’t get the dot com, and this was [inaudible 00:52:01]-

Lex Fridman52:01

它现在还开着吗?

英文原文

Is it still up?

Pieter Levels52:03

对,avatarai.me。不过现在它会自动跳转到 Photo AI,因为业务已经转型了。

英文原文

Yeah, avatarai.me. Well, now it’s forwards to Photo AI, because it pivoted.

Lex Fridman52:06

明白了。

英文原文

Got it.

Pieter Levels52:07

但这个项目更偏向俗气趣味向,所以特别有意思——它爆红了。我记得一周内就赚了约 15 万美元,这是我赚得最多的一次。这非常有意思:一些大型风投公司,比如 Lensa,它们在 iOS 和其他方面比我强得多(我压根没做 iOS 应用),却迅速开发出一款功能相同的 iOS 应用;它们找到了相关技术,而所有技术本身都是开源的,这挺好。据我所知,它们靠这个赚了约 3000 万美元,随后跃升为 App Store 收入最高的应用之一,而且……

英文原文

But this was more like cheesy thing, so this is very interesting, because this went so viral. It made I think like 150K in a week or something, so most money I ever made. This is very interesting. The big VC companies, like Lensa, which are much better at iOS and stuff than me, I didn’t have iOS app, they quickly build an iOS app that does the same, and they found technology, and it’s all open technology, so it’s good, and I think they made like $30 million with it. They became the top grossing app after that, and-

Lex Fridman52:40

你对此有什么感受?

英文原文

How do you feel about that?

Pieter Levels52:41

老实说,我觉得这简直太棒了,而且并不像……

英文原文

I think it’s amazing, honestly, and it’s not like-

Lex Fridman52:44

你心里就没冒出一句‘哦,操![听不清 00:52:45]……’?

英文原文

You didn’t have a feeling like, “Oh, fuck. [inaudible 00:52:45]-“

Pieter Levels52:45

没有。我倒有点难过,因为之前我所有产品都顺风顺水,从未遭遇过真正激烈的竞争;而这次,我面对的是技能高超、人才济济的强劲对手。他们是一家开发者工作室之类的企业,早已拥有现成的应用。他们在 App Store 里早就有款应用,好像是用来修脸之类的,所以非常聪明。他们只是把‘AI 头像’作为一项新功能加进去,已有用户基础,还能给所有用过头像功能的用户推送通知。老兄,我觉得他们赚翻了,而且做得真棒;我自己也靠这个赚了不少钱,但我很快意识到这并非我真正想做的事——因为它太俗气了,近乎媚俗(kitsch)。就像‘我变身芭比娃娃’或者‘我变身……’,实在太俗了。

英文原文

No, I was a little bit sad, because all my products would work out, and I never had real fierce competition, and now I have fierce competition from a very skilled high talent. I was developer studio or something, and they already had an app. They had an app in the app store for I think retouching your face or something, so they were very smart. They add these avatars to there, it’s a feature. They had the users, they do a push notification to everybody who have these avatars. Man, I think they made so much money, and I think they did a really great job, and I also made a lot of money with it, but I quickly realized it wasn’t my thing, because it was so cheesy. It was like kitsch. It’s kind like me as a Barbie or me as a… It was too cheesy.

Pieter Levels53:29

我想解决的是真实存在的问题。这种‘头像热’注定只是泡沫,注定会……事实也证明它就是泡沫——这些头像风潮纯粹是场炒作。我想做的是真正的摄影:如何让人看起来极度逼真?这很难,正因如此,那些头像才容易成功——因为它们全是俗气的毕加索风格,而艺术本来就靠主观诠释……AI 在处理人脸时的所有缺陷,一旦冠以‘毕加索风格’之名,就成了艺术表达;但若要生成一张真实照片,人脸所有缺陷就会暴露无遗——你会看起来很怪。所以我开始打造 Photo AI,这是又一次转型:它就像一家虚拟摄影棚,让你无需摄影师、无需实体影棚,只要输入文字描述,就能‘拍摄’照片。过去一年,我一直在全力打磨它。

英文原文

I wanted to go for, what’s a real problem we can solve? This is going to be a hype, this going to be… And it was a hype, these avatars. It’s like, “Let’s do real photography. How can you make people look really photorealistic?” And it was difficult, and that’s why these avatars worked, because they were all in a cheesy Picasso style, and art is easy, because you interpret… All the problems that AI has with your face are artistic if you call it Picasso, but if you make a real photo, all the problems of your face, you look wrong. So, I started making Photo AI, which was a pivot of it where it was like a photo studio where you could take photos without actually needing a photographer, needing a studio. You just type it, and I’ve been working on it for the last year.

Lex Fridman54:14

对,这真的太惊人了,这段历程实在令人震撼。不过咱们还是回到 Photo AI 的起点吧,因为我记得当时看到过很多特别搞笑的照片。你当时是不是拿自己当案例研究?

英文原文

Yeah, it’s really incredible. That journey is really incredible. Let’s go to the beginning of Photo AI, though, because I remember seeing a lot of really hilarious photos. I think you were using yourself as a case study, right?

Pieter Levels54:15

对。

英文原文

Yeah.

Lex Fridman54:27

对,这儿有条推文写着:‘售出价值 10 万美元的 AI 生成头像。’

英文原文

Yeah, so there’s a tweet here, “Sold $100,000 in AI-generated avatars.”

Pieter Levels54:36

对,数额很大。对任何人来说都很大,对我更是如此——我靠这个每天能赚 1 万美元。

英文原文

Yeah, and it’s a lot. It’s a lot for anybody. It’s a lot for me making 10K a day on this.

Lex Fridman54:42

太厉害了,太厉害了。

英文原文

That’s amazing. That’s amazing.

Pieter Levels54:46

然后这条[听不清 00:54:48]推文是正式发布推文,而在此之前,还有我边折腾边发的推文。

英文原文

And then the [inaudible 00:54:48] tweet. That’s the launch tweet, and then before there is the me hacking on it.

Lex Fridman54:53

哦,我看到了。好,是 2022 年 10 月 26 日。

英文原文

Oh, I see. Okay, so October 26th, 2022.

Pieter Levels54:54

对。

英文原文

Yeah.

Lex Fridman55:00

‘我用自己脸部数据训练了一个机器学习模型……’

英文原文

” I trained an ML model on my face…”

Pieter Levels55:05

因为我的眼睛间距比较宽,我做YouTube时就发现,只要放上我的DJ照片、我的混音作品,大家就会说我长得像锤头鲨。这几乎是置顶评论,于是我意识到自己的眼睛确实间距很宽。

英文原文

Because my eyes are quite far apart, I learned when I did YouTube, I would put my DJ photo, my mixture, and people would say I look like a hammerhead shark. It was like the top comment, so then I realized my eyes are far apart.

Lex Fridman55:18

是啊,互联网能帮你搞清楚自己长什么样。

英文原文

Yeah, the internet helps you figure out what you look like.

Pieter Levels55:20

是啊,它能帮你认清自己实际的样子。

英文原文

Yeah, it helps you realize how you look.

Lex Fridman55:21

天哪,我可太爱互联网了。

英文原文

Boy, do I love the internet.

Pieter Levels55:23

这是个‘勾引流量’的陷阱。

英文原文

That’s a thirst trap.

Lex Fridman55:26

嗯……这个……等等。

英文原文

Well, what is… Is this… Wait.

Pieter Levels55:27

这是瀑布的水,但瀑布在背景里。所以到底发生了什么?

英文原文

It’s water from the waterfall, but the waterfall is in the back. So, what’s going on?

Lex Fridman55:34

这里面有多少是真实的?

英文原文

How much of this is real?

Pieter Levels55:35

全是AI生成的。

英文原文

It’s all AI.

Lex Fridman55:36

全是AI生成的?

英文原文

It’s all AI?

Pieter Levels55:38

是的。

英文原文

Yeah.

Lex Fridman55:39

不过,以早期阶段的标准来看,效果已经相当不错了。

英文原文

That’s pretty good though, for the early days.

Pieter Levels55:40

没错,但当时的效果完全是碰运气,因此你必须做大量筛选工作,因为99%的结果都很差。所以这些就是我上传的照片。

英文原文

Exactly, but this was hit or miss, so you had to do a lot of curation, because 99% of it was bad. So, these are the photos I uploaded.

Lex Fridman55:47

你用了多少张照片?‘就只用这些。之后我会尝试用更新、更合适的图片。’这些就是你上传的全部照片吗?

英文原文

How many photos did you use? “Only these. I’ll try more up-to-date pick later.” Are these the only photos you uploaded?

Pieter Levels55:55

是的。

英文原文

Yeah.

Lex Fridman55:55

哇哦。哇哦,好吧,所以你当时学得超快。你还记得当时有哪些有趣的细节,是你必须摸索出来才能让整个流程跑通的?顺便提醒一下正在收听的各位:他只上传了寥寥几张照片,而且这些照片其实并没有很好地捕捉到面部特征,但他却能[听不清 00:56:16]-

英文原文

Wow. Wow, okay, so you were learning all this super quickly. What are some interesting details you remember from that time for what you had to figure out to make it work? And for people just listening, he uploaded just a handful of photos that don’t really have a good capture of the face and he’s able to [inaudible 00:56:16]-

Pieter Levels56:16

我觉得是裁剪过的。就像按版式裁切一样,但它们是正方形照片,尺寸为512×512,因为Stable Diffusion就是用这个尺寸。

英文原文

I think it’s cropped. It’s like a crop by the layout, but they’re square photos, so they’re 512×512, because that’s Stable Diffusion.

Lex Fridman56:24

但无论如何,面部特征的捕捉效果并不理想。这可不是几百张、360度全方位拍摄的照片合集[听不清 00:56:34]-

英文原文

But nevertheless, not great capture of the face. It’s not like a collection of several hundred photos that are 360 [inaudible 00:56:34]-

Pieter Levels56:34

没错,我刚开始时也是这么想的:‘哦,这肯定是某种3D扫描技术吧?’对吧?

英文原文

Exactly, I would imagine that, too, when I started. I was like, “Oh, this must be some 3D scan technology,” right?

Lex Fridman56:39

是的。

英文原文

Yeah.

Pieter Levels56:39

所以,我觉得AI最酷的一点在于,它能训练出关于‘你’这个概念的模型。换句话说,它真的就像任何AI模型那样进行学习——学习你长什么样。我做了这件事之后,就开始收到私信,比如Telegram消息:‘我也想这么做!我也想要这些照片,我女朋友也想要这些照片。’我当时就想:‘好吧,这显然是一门生意。’但我没时间写代码、开发一整套应用。所以我做了一个HTML网页,注册了一个域名,而这个网页甚至都算不上……它只是一个Stripe支付链接,也就是说,你直接跳转到Stripe页面付款,后端根本没有任何代码。所以你唯一知道的就是:有客户付了钱。

英文原文

So, I think the cool thing with AI, it trains the concept of you. So, it’s literally learning just like any AI model learns. It learns how you look, so I did this and then I was getting DMs, like Telegram messages like, “How can I do the same thing? I want these photos, my girlfriend wants these photos.” So I was like, “Okay, this is obviously a business,” but I didn’t have time to code it, make a whole app about it. So, I made an HTML page, registered a domain name, and this not even… It was a Stripe payment link, which means you have literally a link to Stripe to pay, but there’s no code in the back. So, all you know is you have customers that paid money.

Pieter Levels57:19

然后,我又加了一个Typeform链接。Typeform是一个可以创建自定义输入表单的网站,类似Google表单。客户完成付款后,会收到一封邮件,里面附有Typeform链接;或者更准确地说,是在结账完成后直接获得一个链接。他们可以通过该链接上传自己的照片、填写邮箱地址,然后我就上线了。我当时想……看,这是第一张静态截图,时间是2022年10月。我记得上线后24小时之内……我不太确定具体数字,大概是1000位客户左右。但问题在于,我没有编写任何自动化代码,所有事情都得手动操作。所以前几百单,我真的是亲手下载他们的照片、亲手训练模型,再根据提示词(prompt)生成照片——我还专门建了一个文本文件来存提示词,所有步骤全靠手动完成。很快,工作量就变得完全无法承受了。但这也构成了另一个约束条件:我被迫开始写代码,实现自动化,而这本质上就是把它做成一个真正的网站。

英文原文

Then, I added a Typeform link. So, Typeform is a site where you can create your own input form, like Google Forms. So, they would get an email with a link to the Typeform or actually just a link after the checkout, and they could upload their photos, so enter their email, upload the photos, and I launched it, and I was like… Here, first still, so it’s October 2022, and I think within the first 24 hours was like… I’m not sure, it was like 1,000 customers or something, but the problem was I didn’t have code to automate this, so I had to do it manually. So the first few hundred, I just literally took their photos, trained them, and then I would generate the photos with the prompts, and I had this text file with the prompt, and I would do everything manually, and it quickly became way too much, but that’s another constraint. I was forced to code something up that would do that, and that was essentially making it into a real website.

Lex Fridman58:12

所以一开始是通过Typeform上传照片——

英文原文

So, at first it was the Typeform and they uploaded it through the Typeform-

Pieter Levels58:15

是Stripe结账页面加Typeform。

英文原文

It was a Stripe checkout Typeform.

Lex Fridman58:17

一张图片,然后你就说‘这张图片被下载下来了’。你有没有写脚本自动导出、比如下载[听不清 00:58:21]-

英文原文

An image, and then you were like, “That image is downloaded.” Did you write a script to export, like download [inaudible 00:58:21]-

Pieter Levels58:21

没有,是我自己手动下载图片的。下载的是一个解压后的ZIP文件。

英文原文

No, it just downloaded the images myself. It was an unzipped zip file.

Lex Fridman58:24

真的?然后你手动解压——

英文原文

Literally, and you unzipped it-

Pieter Levels58:25

是的,解压——

英文原文

Yeah, unzip-

Lex Fridman58:25

一张一张地——

英文原文

One by-

Pieter Levels58:26

对,因为保罗·格雷厄姆(Paul Graham)不是说过嘛:‘先做事,别急着扩展规模。’然后我就训练模型,再通过我的个人邮箱把生成的照片发给他们,邮件里写:‘这是你的虚拟头像。’他们都很喜欢,说:‘哇,太棒了!’

英文原文

Yes, because, “Do things, don’t scale,” Paul Graham says, right? And then I would train it and I would email them the photos, I think from my personal email, say, “Here’s your avatars,” and they liked it. They were like, “Wow, it’s amazing.”

Lex Fridman58:40

你是用自己的个人邮箱发的邮件——

英文原文

You emailed them with your personal email-

Pieter Levels58:43

因为他们在这个域名下还没有邮箱地址。

英文原文

Because they didn’t have an email address on this domain.

Lex Fridman58:45

这时候大概有100人?

英文原文

And this is like 100 people?

Pieter Levels58:47

是的。然后你知道谁注册了吗?哎呀,我不能说,但确实是超级有名的人,真正意义上的亿万富翁,知名科技界亿万富翁,他们都试了。我当时就想:‘哇,这也太疯狂了!’我还特别害怕联系他们,就只发了一句:‘非常感谢您使用我的网站。’对方回:‘是啊,超棒的应用,干得漂亮!’这种反应跟普通人的反馈明显不一样。

英文原文

Yeah, and then you know who signed up? Man, I cannot say, but really famous people, really, really like billionaires, famous tech billionaires did it. And I was like, “Wow, this is crazy,” and I was so scared to message them, so I said, “Thanks so much for using my sites.” He’s like, “Yeah, amazing app, great work.” So, it’s like this is different than normal reaction.

Lex Fridman59:07

是比尔·盖茨,对吧?

英文原文

It’s Bill Gates, isn’t it?

Pieter Levels59:08

我什么都不能说。

英文原文

I cannot say anything.

Lex Fridman59:12

就像那些不穿衬衫的照片。

英文原文

Just like shirtless pics.

Pieter Levels59:14

GDPR,涉及隐私保护。

英文原文

GDPR, like privacy.

Lex Fridman59:15

对。

英文原文

Right.

Pieter Levels59:15

这是欧洲的法规。我不能透露任何信息,但我当时确实震惊了。不过这也说明了一点:你做出一个东西,如果它迅速爆火,那就意味着它已被市场验证——‘这就是人们真正想要的东西。’但同时我也想:‘这只是炒作而已,热度很快就会消退。’结果确实如此,因为它实在太俗气了。

英文原文

European regulation. I cannot share anything, but I was like, “Wow,” but this shows, so you make something, and then if it takes off very fast, it’s validated. You’re like, “Here’s something that people really want.” But then also I thought, “This is hype. This is going to die down very fast,” and it did, because it’s too cheesy.”

Lex Fridman59:34

但你必须把整个流程自动化。你是怎么实现自动化的?其中的AI组件是什么?弄懂这部分难不难?

英文原文

But you have to automate the whole thing. How’d you automate it? So, what’s the AI component? How hard was that to figure out?

Pieter Levels59:41

好的,实际上从很多方面来说,这部分反而是最容易的,因为当时已经存在大量现成平台。那时就有专门用于微调Stable Diffusion的平台。现在我用Replicate,但当时用的是别的平台——还挺有意思,因为当这个项目突然爆火后,我经常在推特上发帖,讲这些网站赚了多少钱。于是……你们管提供GPU的平台叫‘供应商’,对吧?那个平台看到我赚了这么多钱,立刻就把训练费用从3美元涨到了20美元。结果我的利润瞬间归零——因为我卖30美元一份,而当时还在Slack群里跟他们交涉:‘这是怎么回事?能不能把价格调回3美元?’他们说:‘嗯,也许将来会考虑,我们正在评估中。’我当时就想:‘你们在说什么?你们刚把我所有的钱都拿走了!’但他们确实挺精明的。

英文原文

Okay, so that’s actually in many ways the easiest thing, because there is all these platforms already back then. There was platforms for fine tune Stable Diffusion. Now, I use Replicate, back then I used different platforms, which was funny because that platform, when this thing took off, I would tweet… Because I tweet always like how much money these websites make, and then… So, you call it vendor, right? The platform that did the GPUs, they increased their price for training from $3 to $20 after they saw that I was making so much money. So, immediately my profit is gone, because I was selling them for $30, and I was in a Slack with them saying, “What is this? Can you just put it back to $3?” They say, “Yeah, maybe in the future. We’re looking at it right now.” I’m like, “What are you talking about? You just took all my money,” and they’re smart.

Lex Fridman1:00:24

嗯,他们也没那么精明,因为你本身也是一个大平台,很多人尊重你,所以你可以直接公开说出来,但他们并没有——

英文原文

Well, they’re not that smart, because you also have a large platform, and a lot of people respect you, so you can literally come out and say that, but they’re not-

Pieter Levels1:00:33

是啊,但我觉得直接封杀一家公司之类的做法有点不太厚道。我更愿意把业务转移到别处,但当时根本没有别的选择。

英文原文

Yeah, but I think it’s kind of dirty to cancel a company or something. I prefer just bringing my business elsewhere, but there was no elsewhere back then.

Lex Fridman1:00:40

对。

英文原文

Right.

Pieter Levels1:00:41

所以我开始联系其他AI模型和机器学习平台。Replicate就是其中之一。我开始私信他们的CEO,说:‘能不能请你们在网站上加上这个功能?’这个功能叫DreamBooth,就是针对你自己进行微调。‘请务必加上,因为我正被供应商乱涨价呢!’他说:‘不行,因为运行一次要花半小时,我们没有足够的GPU资源。’我说:‘拜托拜托拜托!’结果一周后,他回复:‘我们决定做了,马上上线。’后来这家公司——原本并不出名——就因为这个功能一举成名,因为突然之间所有人都意识到:‘哦,我们可以开发类似的虚拟头像应用!’于是大家纷纷开始开发头像应用,也都开始用Replicate来实现,而这全都源于我早期跟CEO本·菲尔什(Ben Firsh)的几次私信交流——他人特别好。而且他们从未对我乱涨价,也从未给我差待遇,一直非常友好。这是一家非常酷的公司。你可以在上面运行任何机器学习模型、任何AI模型,包括大语言模型(LLM)。

英文原文

So, I started talking to other AI model, ML platforms. So, Replicate was one of those platforms, and I started DMing the CEO say, “Can you please create…” It’s called DreamBooth, this fine-tuning of yourself. “Can you add this to your site, because I need this, because I’m being price gauged?” And he said, “No, because it takes too long to run. It takes half an hour to run and we don’t have the GPUs for it.” I said, “Please, please, please.” And then after a week, he said, “We’re doing it, we’re launching this.” And then this company became… It was not very famous company, it became very famous with this stuff, because suddenly everybody was like, “Oh, we can build similar avatar apps,” and everybody started building avatar apps and everybody started using Replicate for it, and that was from these early DMs with the CEO, like Ben Firsh, very nice guy. And he was like… They never price-gauged me, they never treated me bad, they always been very nice. It’s a very cool company. So, you can run any ML model, any AI model, LLMs, you can run on here.

Lex Fridman1:01:36

而且你可以扩展规模——

英文原文

And you can scale-

Pieter Levels1:01:37

对,他们支持扩展。是的,是的,现在你甚至可以直接点击模型,立即运行,超级简单。用GitHub账号登录就行——

英文原文

Yes, they scale. Yeah, yeah, and I mean you can do now, you can click on the model and just run it already. It’s like super easy. You log on with GitHub-

Lex Fridman1:01:45

太棒了。

英文原文

That’s great.

Pieter Levels1:01:45

而且一旦你在网站上运行模型,就可以通过API实现自动化,从而搭建一个能运行该模型的网站。

英文原文

And by running it on the website, then you can automate with the API. You can make a website that runs the model.

Lex Fridman1:01:50

生成图像、生成文本、生成视频、生成音乐、生成语音——

英文原文

Generate images, generate text, generate video, generate music, generate speech-

Pieter Levels1:01:53

视频,比如[听不清 01:01:55]-

英文原文

Video, like [inaudible 01:01:55]-

Lex Fridman1:01:54

……微调模型。

英文原文

… fine tune models.

Pieter Levels1:01:55

他们什么都能做,是的。这是一家非常酷的公司。

英文原文

They do anything, yeah. It’s a very cool company.

Lex Fridman1:01:58

不错,你基本上是跟他们一起成长起来的。他们之所以壮大,正是因为你们这个大规模应用场景。

英文原文

Nice, and you’re growing with them essentially. They grew because of you, because it’s a big use case.

Pieter Levels1:02:03

是的,现在他们的网站看起来甚至有点奇怪。它最初只是一个纯机器学习平台,那种……我连它到底是干什么的都搞不懂。它太偏重机器学习了。你肯定能理解,因为你就在机器学习领域。我可完全搞不明白。

英文原文

Yeah, the website even looks weird now. It started as a machine learning platform that was like… I didn’t even understand what it did. It was just too ML. You would understand, because you’re in the ML world. I wouldn’t understand it.

Lex Fridman1:02:16

现在它对新手很友好。

英文原文

Now, it’s newb friendly.

Pieter Levels1:02:17

对,完全正确。我当初也不懂它怎么运作,但我知道他们大概率能做到,结果他们真做到了。他们构建了这些模型,现在我所有事情都用它们,而且我们已经为大约36000人完成了训练。

英文原文

Yeah, exactly, and I didn’t know how it worked, but I knew that they could probably do this and they did it. They built the models and now I use them for everything, and we trained, I think now like 36, 000 people already.

Lex Fridman1:02:32

但针对用户提供的这批照片进行微调时,是不是有一些技巧?你是怎么做的——

英文原文

But is there some tricks to fine-tuning to the collection of photos that are provided? How do you-

Pieter Levels1:02:38

是啊,兄弟,这类技巧多得是。

英文原文

Yes, man, there’s so many hacks.

Lex Fridman1:02:39

各种技巧,没错。

英文原文

The hacks, yeah.

Pieter Levels1:02:40

光是让模型正常工作,就有上百种技巧。

英文原文

It’s like 100 hacks to make it work.

Lex Fridman1:02:41

有哪些有意思的——

英文原文

What are some interesting-

Pieter Levels1:02:43

我现在可是要把我的秘密都抖出来了。

英文原文

I’m giving my secrets now.

Lex Fridman1:02:44

嗯,倒也不必说秘密,但或许可以分享一些关于人类面部和人体的更深入见解?哪些地方最容易出错?

英文原文

Well, not the secrets, but the more insights maybe about the human face and the human body. What kind of stuff gets messed up lot?

Pieter Levels1:02:53

我觉得人们……呃,老天,这又是一回事——人们根本不知道自己长什么样。所以,他们生成自己的照片,然后说:‘啊,这看起来不像我。’但你去翻看训练用的照片,其实它确实很像你,只是你自己并不知道自己的样子。因此,你对自己面容存在一种‘面部畸形恐惧症’,而你对此毫无察觉。

英文原文

I think people… Well, man, that’s another thing, people don’t know how they look. So, they generate photos of themselves and then they say, “Ah, it doesn’t look like me,” but you can check the training photos, it does look like you, but you don’t know how you look. So, there’s a face dysmorphia of yourself that you have no idea how you look.

Lex Fridman1:03:12

是啊,这太搞笑了。我是说,我这辈子最不愉快的事情之一,就是不得不听自己的声音、看自己的脸。所以我真的必须直面现实:我到底长什么样、声音又是什么样。

英文原文

Yeah, that’s hilarious. I mean, I’ve got… One of the least pleasant activities in my existence is having to listen to my voice and look at my face. So, I get to really have to come into terms with the reality of how I look and how I sound.

Pieter Levels1:03:29

所有人都这样,但是——

英文原文

Everybody, but-

Lex Fridman1:03:30

人们往往并不了解,对吧?

英文原文

People often don’t, right?

Pieter Levels1:03:32

真的吗?

英文原文

Really?

Lex Fridman1:03:32

你的视角是扭曲的。

英文原文

You have a distorted view perspective.

Pieter Levels1:03:35

我会按自己认为好看的样子自拍一张,别人却觉得不好看;可别人给我拍的照片,我又觉得‘这简直丑爆了’。但他们却说:‘不,这就是你本来的样子,而且你看起来很好看。’所以,别人眼中的你是好看的。因此,你应该请别人帮你选照片,而不是自己选——因为你根本不知道自己长什么样。

英文原文

I would make a selfie how I think I look that’s nice, other people think that’s not nice, but then they make a photo of me. I’m like, “This is super ugly.” But then they’re like, “No, that’s how you look, and you look nice.” So, how other people see you is nice. So, you need to ask other people to choose your photos. You shouldn’t choose them yourself, because you don’t know how you look.

Lex Fridman1:03:56

是啊,你根本不知道什么让你显得有趣,什么让你显得有吸引力,诸如此类的东西。

英文原文

Yeah, you don’t know what makes you interesting, what makes you attractive, or all this kind of stuff.

Pieter Levels1:04:00

是啊,[听不清 01:04:00]——

英文原文

Yeah, [inaudible 01:04:00]-

Lex Fridman1:04:00

而且我们很多人……这是心理学中一个阴暗的方面,我们会聚焦于某些——

英文原文

And a lot of us… This is a dark aspect of psychology, we focus on some-

Lex Fridman1:04:00

而且我们很多人,这是心理学中一个阴暗的方面,会聚焦于某些微小的瑕疵。这正是我讨厌整容手术的原因,例如。人们试图去除这些瑕疵,可恰恰是这些瑕疵才让你显得独特、有吸引力。

英文原文

And a lot of us, this is a dark aspect of psychology, we focus on some small flaws. This is why I hate plastic surgery, for example. People try to remove the flaws when the flaws are the thing that makes you interesting and attractive.

Pieter Levels1:04:12

我从锤头鲨的眼睛那里学到一点:那些在你看来丑陋的特征,很可能正是让你与众不同、讨人喜欢的地方,也正是别人喜欢你的地方。并不是‘天啊’那种感觉。别人注意到了,比如注意到你的锤头鲨式眼睛,但你会想:‘这就是我,这就是我的脸,所以我爱我自己。’这才是自信,而自信是有吸引力的。

英文原文

I learned from the hammerhead shark eyes, the stuff about you that looks ugly to you, and it’s probably what makes you original, makes you nice, and people like it about you. And it’s not like, “Oh, my god.” And people notice it, people notice your hammerhead eyes, but it’s like, “That’s me. That’s my face. So, I love myself.” And that’s confidence, and confidence is attractive.

Lex Fridman1:04:31

是的。

英文原文

Yes.

Pieter Levels1:04:32

对吧?

英文原文

Right?

Lex Fridman1:04:32

自信确实有吸引力。但没错,理解什么让你美丽也很重要。打破对称性让你美丽,偏离平均脸型让你美丽,诸如此类。当然,不同性别、不同年龄的人,情况也各不相同。

英文原文

Confidence is attractive. But yes, understanding what makes you beautiful. It’s the breaking of symmetry makes you beautiful, it’s the breaking of the average face makes you beautiful, all of that. And obviously different from men and women of different ages, all this kind of stuff.

Pieter Levels1:04:33

是啊,百分之百正确。

英文原文

Yeah, a hundred percent.

Lex Fridman1:04:47

但归根结底,是个性、所有这一切——当你的脸鲜活起来时,那才是让你美丽的东西。不过话说回来,你得靠AI来弄清楚所有这些。

英文原文

But underneath it all, the personality, all of that, when the face comes alive, that also is the thing that makes you beautiful. But anyway, you have to figure all that out with AI.

Pieter Levels1:04:58

是的。有一件事行之有效:人们上传自己的全身照,然后我裁剪出脸部,对吧?这样一来,模型就更清楚我们主要是在训练脸部。但后来我发现身体部分的还原度开始下降,因为有些人瘦,有些人肌肉发达,等等。所以你也希望保留这部分信息。现在,我在训练中混合使用全身照、脸部特写照和脸部裁剪图,整个过程全自动。我知道其他人也在用AI模型,自动检测训练集中哪些照片效果最好,再基于这些照片进行训练。一切核心都在于训练数据——而在AI领域,训练数据的质量,在很多方面比训练步数(比如训练几个月或用多少块GPU)更重要。这才是目标。

英文原文

Yeah. One thing that worked was, people would upload full body photos of themselves, so I would crop the face, right? Then the model knew better that we’re training mostly the face here. But then I started losing resemblance of the body ’cause some people are skinny, some people are muscular, whatever. So, you want to have that too. So, now, I mix full body photos in the training with face photos, face crops, and it’s all automatic. And I know that other people, they use, again, AI models to detect what are the best photos in this training set and then train on those. It’s all about training data, and it’s with everything in AI, how good your training data is, in many ways, more important than how many steps you train for, like how many months, or whatever, with these GPUs. The goals.

Lex Fridman1:05:43

你有没有给普通人提供一些指南,告诉他们如何获取优质数据、如何提供高质量的数据用于微调?

英文原文

Do you have any guidelines for people of how to get good data, how to give good data to fine tune on?

Pieter Levels1:05:48

照片应当多样化。例如,如果我只上传穿棕色衬衫或绿色衬衫的照片,模型就会误以为我在训练‘绿色衬衫’这个概念。每张照片里重复出现的元素,反而会被当作被训练的概念。你真正想训练的,应该是你的脸;其余一切——服装、背景、姿态等——都应尽可能多样化。

英文原文

The photos should be diverse. So, for example, if I only upload photos with a brown shirt or green shirts, the model will think that I’m training the green shirts. So, the things that are the same every photo are the concepts that are trained. What you want is your face to be the concept that’s trained and everything else to be diverse different.

Lex Fridman1:06:10

所以,光线也要多样化,方方面面都要多样化。

英文原文

So, diverse lighting as well. Diverse everything.

Pieter Levels1:06:12

是的,室外、室内都要有。但问题就在这里:目前根本没有操作手册,谁都不知道该怎么做。两年前,我们所有人全靠摸索,拼命尝试各种方法,想到什么就试什么。这非常令人沮丧——它既是AI领域最令人沮丧的事之一,也是最有趣、最具挑战性的事之一,因为AI本质上是个黑箱。卡帕西(Karpathy)好像就说过:‘我们其实并不真正了解这东西是怎么运作的,但它确实能起作用;只是没人真明白为什么。’我们无法窥探大语言模型内部,不知道里面究竟有什么。我们只知道它是一堆数字构成的矩阵,对吧?所以这特别令人沮丧:有些事你本以为明显能提升效果,结果反而让效果变差;而且可调节的参数实在太多了,你只能把所有可能性都试一遍,只为找到改进的方法。

英文原文

Yeah, outside, inside. But there’s no, this is the problem, there’s no manual for this. And nobody knew. We were all just, especially two years ago, we’re all hacking, trying to test anything, anything you can think of. And it’s frustrating. It’s one of the most frustrating and also fun and challenging things to do because with AI, because it’s a black box. And Karpathy, I think, says this, “We don’t really know how this thing works, but it does something, but nobody really knows why.” We cannot look into the model of an LLM, what is actually in there. We just know it’s a treaty matrix of numbers, right? So, it’s very frustrating because some things that would be, you think they’re obvious that they will improve things, will make them worse. And there’s so many parameters you can tweak. So, you’re testing everything to improve things.

Lex Fridman1:07:04

如今已形成一个专门的研究领域,叫‘机制可解释性’(mechanistic interpretability),致力于拆解并理解AI的工作原理。但另一方面,还有数据层面,以及面向消费者的实际产品层面——即如何让它生成美观、有趣、自然的结果,等等。而你正站在探索人类面部生成这一前沿。人类确实极其在意人的面孔。

英文原文

I mean there’s a whole field now of mechanistic interpretability that studies that tries to figure out, tries to break things apart and understand how it works. But there’s also the data side and the actual consumer-facing product side of figuring out how you get it to generate a thing that’s beautiful or interesting or naturalistic, all that kind of stuff. And you’re at the forefront of figuring that out about the human face. And humans really care about the human face.

Pieter Levels1:07:30

而且非常虚荣。就像我,就希望在你的播客里看起来帅气些,比如。当然啦,肯定的。

英文原文

In very vain. Like me, I want to look good in your podcast, for example. Yeah, for sure.

Lex Fridman1:07:36

另外,我其实很想严谨地应用照片AI技术——比如为播客缩略图拍摄人物肖像照。我对摄影一窍不通。基本上就是套用你的思路:先谷歌搜索‘怎么拍照?相机、布光’之类的问题。还有一点挺难的,也许你可以就此谈谈:摄影圈里,恕我直言,真正的艺术家、优秀摄影师当然值得尊敬,但很多人把自己看得太重了,总觉得需要一大堆设备。你以为只需要一盏灯?不,你得配五盏灯……

英文原文

And then one of the things actually would love to rigorously use photo AI, because for the thumbnails, I take portraits of people. I don’t know shit about photography. I basically used your approach for photography like Googled, “How do you take photographs? Camera, lighting.” And also it’s tough because maybe you could speak to this also, but with photography, no offense to any, they’re true artists, great photographers, but people take themselves way too seriously. Think you need a whole lot of equipment. You definitely don’t want one light, you need five lights…

Pieter Levels1:08:19

老天,我懂。

英文原文

Man, I know.

Lex Fridman1:08:19

你还得配齐各种镜头。我曾跟一位声学专家聊过,他专精于房间声场塑造,因为我当时琢磨着:‘我要建个播客录音室,总得做点吸音处理吧。’结果他上门一分析房间,就认定我之前做的全是错的。那一刻我才意识到:‘你知道吗?我生活中根本不需要专家。’

英文原文

And you have to have the lenses. I talked to a guy, an expert of shaping the sound in a room because I was thinking, “I’m going to do a podcast studio, whatever. I should probably do a sound treatment on the room.” And when he showed up and analyzed the room, he thought everything I was doing was horrible. And that’s when I realized, “You know what? I don’t need experts in my life.”

Pieter Levels1:08:50

你把他轰出家门了?

英文原文

You kicked him out of the house?

Lex Fridman1:08:52

没有,我没轰他。我只是说:‘谢谢,非常感谢。’

英文原文

No, I didn’t kick him. I said, “Thank you. Thank you very much.”

Pieter Levels1:08:54

‘谢谢,建议很棒,再见。’

英文原文

“Thank you. Great tips. Bye.”

Lex Fridman1:08:56

我当时就觉得……专注于眼前的实际问题,相信自己的判断,相信自己的直觉,别盲目听信他人;只有遇到具体问题时,才去咨询别人。而咨询的目的,并非把问题甩给别人,而是借鉴对方的视角来增长智慧——哪怕最终你并不认同对方的观点,你依然能从中获益。最后,我干脆自己搞了个PHP解决方案,一个PHP加jQuery的方案来——

英文原文

I just felt like there is… Focus on whatever the problems are, use your own judgment, use your own instincts, don’t listen to other people, and only consult other people when there’s a specific problem. And you consult them not to offload the problem onto them, but to gain wisdom from their perspective. Even if their perspective is ultimately one you don’t agree with, you’re going to gain wisdom from that. And just, I ultimately come up with a PHP solution, PHP and jQuery solution to-

Pieter Levels1:09:26

PHP工作室。

英文原文

PHP studio.

Lex Fridman1:09:27

PHP工作室。我有个小手提箱,里面全是基础消费级设备:一盏灯,效果就很好。

英文原文

The PHP studio. I have a little suitcase. I use just the basic consumer type of stuff. One light. It’s great.

Pieter Levels1:09:36

是啊。看看你,你可是全球顶级播客之一,单期播放量动辄数百万,而且效果极佳。而那些花大价钱优化音质、打造顶级录音棚的人,每期播放量可能才三百。这说明什么?正说明这一点:要么你做得特别出色,要么很多所谓‘关键要素’其实根本不重要。真正重要的,恐怕还是播客的内容本身——你请来了有趣的嘉宾。

英文原文

Yeah. And look at you, you’re one of the top podcasts in the world, and you get millions of views, and it works. And the people that spend so much money on optimizing for the best sound, for the best studio, they get 300 views. So, what is this about? This is about that. Either you do it really well or also that a lot of these things don’t matter. What matters is probably the content of the podcast. You get the interesting guest.

Lex Fridman1:09:57

专注在真正重要的事情上。

英文原文

Focus on the stuff that matters.

Pieter Levels1:09:58

是啊,我觉得这很普遍。业内管这叫‘装备购置综合症’(Gear Acquisition Syndrome,简称GAS),各行各业的人都会这样:光顾着买买买。最近网上有个梗:还没开始玩某项爱好,就先把全套装备买齐了——那人叫啥来着?营销。营销就是这么操控人的,就是要你买买买。但老兄,只要内容足够好,你拿iPhone都能拍出好莱坞大片。而且说不定还更有原创性,毕竟你用的是iPhone嘛。

英文原文

Yeah. And I think that’s very common. They call it gear acquisition syndrome, like GAS, people in any industry do this. They just buy all the stuff. There was a meme recently. What’s the name for the guy that buys all the stuff before you even started doing the hobby, right? Marketing. Marketing does that to people. They want you to buy this stuff. But man, you can make a Hollywood movie on an iPhone if the content is good enough. And it will probably be original because you would be using an iPhone for it.

Lex Fridman1:10:30

所以我刚才提到摄影,是因为其中确有值得借鉴的智慧。我意识到,也相信你同样意识到了:光线拥有惊人的力量,足以传达情绪。只需一盏灯,绕着你的脸移动位置——你坐在黑暗中,让灯光在脸上游走,不同角度竟能赋予这张脸截然不同的生命感。仅凭一张普通面孔,你就能玩转人物的情绪表达。这很有意思:你能让人显得有吸引力,也能让人显得丑陋;能让人显得可怕,也能让人显得孤独……诸如此类。你慢慢就会意识到这一点。而我绝对希望能借助AI,帮我们创作出绝佳的人物肖像。

英文原文

So, the reason I brought that up with photography, there is wisdom from people. And one of the things I realized, you probably also realized this, but how much power light has to convey emotion. Just take one light and move it around, says you sit in the darkness, move it around your face. The different positions are having a second life potentially. You can play with how a person feels just from a generic face. It’s interesting. You can make people attractive, you can make them ugly, you can make them scary, you can make them lonely, all of this. And so you start to realize this. And I would definitely love AI help in creating great portraits of people.

Pieter Levels1:11:16

嘉宾照片,没错。

英文原文

Guest photos. Yeah.

Lex Fridman1:11:17

比如宾客照片,这是一个很小的使用场景,但对我而言……我觉得它其实是个重要场景,因为我希望人们看起来好看,同时也希望真实地呈现他们本人。或许是我所理解的‘他们本人’——是什么让他们显得美,又是什么让他们的外貌在某些方面具有力量感。有时是眼睛,很多时候确实是眼睛,但面部某些特征有时也格外有表现力。而我自己拍照又总觉得别扭,所以根本没积累足够多的照片供我仅凭这些照片来开展工作。如果我能把这部分工作交给AI来承担,再开始尝试调整光线等各类参数——

英文原文

Guest photos, for example, that’s a small use case, but for me… I suppose it’s an important use case because I want people to look good, but I also want to capture who they are. Maybe my conception of who they are, what makes them beautiful, what makes their appearance powerful in some ways. Sometimes it’s the eyes, oftentimes it’s the eyes, but there’s certain features of the face can sometimes be really powerful. It’s also awkward for me to take photographs, so I’m not collecting enough photographs for myself to do it with just those photographs. If I can load that off onto AI and then start to play with lighting, all that kind of stuff-

Pieter Levels1:11:59

你应该亲自试试这个,而且很可能得你自己动手。你可以用照片类AI工具,但如果你自己动手,会更有趣。比如你可以训练模型,还可以学习ControlNet(控制网络)。所谓ControlNet,就是例如你的照片和播客素材通常都来自固定角度,对吧?那么你就可以创建一个始终维持这种姿态的ControlNet人脸姿态模板。这样一来,你生成的每个模型、每张照片都会采用这一ControlNet姿态模板。我觉得你亲自尝试这类技术会非常有趣。

英文原文

You should do this and you should probably do it yourself. You can use photo AI, but it’s even more fun if you do it yourself. So, you train the models, you can learn about control nets. Control nets is where, for example, your photos and your podcasts are usually from the angle, right? So, you can create a control net face pose that’s always like this. So, every model, every photo you generate uses this control net pose, for example. I think would be very fun for you to try out that stuff.

Lex Fridman1:12:22

你有没有尝试过调整光线?有没有试过调整……光线与姿态的配合?

英文原文

Do you play with lighting at all? Do you play with lighting pose with the…

Pieter Levels1:12:25

老天,实际上就在这周或最近,有个新模型发布了,能调整任意照片的光照效果。此外,Stable Diffusion也能实现AI图像光照调整。我想它叫Relights,效果惊人。你可以上传一张光照贴图(light map),比如红、紫、蓝等色块组成的贴图,再用这张光照贴图来改变你输入照片的光照效果。太神奇了!这方面可做的事情确实非常多。

英文原文

Man, actually this week or recently some new model came out that can adjust the light of any photo. But also AI image with Stable Diffusion. I think it’s called Relights. And it’s amazing. You can upload like a light map. So, for example, red, purple, blue and use the light map to change the light on the photo you input. It’s amazing. There’s, for sure, a lot of stuff you can do.

Lex Fridman1:12:54

对于普通人而言,您对如何学习掌握当前所有前沿AI工具有什么建议?就像您刚才提到的,新模型层出不穷。您如何关注动态?怎样才能始终紧跟最新进展?

英文原文

What’s your advice for people in general on how to learn all the state-of-the-art AI tools available, like you mentioned new model’s coming out all the time. How do you pay attention? How do you stay on top of everything?

Pieter Levels1:13:08

我觉得你得加入Twitter(现称X平台)。如今X平台简直太棒了,整个AI行业都在上面。而且大家头像清一色都是动漫风格。这挺有意思——我朋友常问我:‘该关注谁才能及时了解最新动态?’我就说:‘去X平台,看看某个人正在关注哪些AI相关的动漫头像账号,或者哪些AI动漫头像账号关注了他。’然后我把某个链接发给他们,他们一看就笑出声:‘这是什么啊?’但这些确实是真人在AI领域搞开发探索。他们会被大公司聘用,活跃在X平台上,而且其中大多数人都匿名,特别有意思——全都用动漫头像。我不用,但这些人确实在捣鼓AI,然后把自己发现的东西公之于众,甚至还会发表论文。所以,没错,一定要上X平台。

英文原文

I think you need to join Twitter, X. X is amazing now and the whole AI industry’s on X. And they’re all anime avatars. It’s funny because my friends ask me this, “Who should I follow to stay up to date?” And I say, “Go to X and follow all the AI anime models that this person is following or follows.” And I send them some URL and they all start laughing like, “What is this?” But they’re real people hacking around in AI. They get hired by big companies and they’re on X. And most of them are anonymous. It’s very funny. They use anime avatars. I don’t. But those people hack around and then they publish what they’re discovering. They took out papers, for example. So, yeah, definitely X.

Lex Fridman1:13:51

我关注的人几乎全是从事AI相关工作的人。

英文原文

Almost exclusively all the people I follow are AI people.

Pieter Levels1:13:55

是啊,现在真是个好时候。

英文原文

Yeah, it’s a good time now.

Lex Fridman1:13:57

不过,这也的确让我内心感到愉悦,毕竟推特上充斥着太多纷乱。

英文原文

Well, but also just brings happiness to my soul ’cause there’s so much turmoil on twitter.

Pieter Levels1:14:06

是啊,比如政治之类的话题。

英文原文

Yeah, like politics and stuff.

Lex Fridman1:14:07

各种争斗此起彼伏,简直像战区一样;而能进入这样一个令人愉快的空间,看到大家专心致志地创造东西,真的很好。

英文原文

There’s battles going on. It’s like a war zone, and it’s nice to just go into this happy place to where people are building stuff.

Pieter Levels1:14:14

完全同意。我最喜欢推特的一点,正是大家在造东西、看别人造东西——这会激发你也想动手创造的欲望;看到别人分享自己的新发现,你也会想:‘好,我也要做出点什么来。’这过程纯粹就是乐趣十足。所以如果你想开始用X平台,我建议你先去Replicate网站,试着玩转各种模型。当你手动输入内容、设定参数并找到一套行之有效的方案后,你就能基于它开发一个应用或搭建一个网站。

英文原文

Yeah, a hundred percent. I like Twitter for that most, building stuff, seeing other, because it inspires you to build and it’s just fun to see other people share what they’re discovering and then you’re like, “Okay, I’m going to make something too.” It’s just super fun. And so if you want to start going on X, and then I would go to replicate and start trying to play with models. And when you have something that you manually enter stuff, you set the parameters, something that works, you can make an app out of it or a website.

Lex Fridman1:14:42

您能否再稍微详细讲讲,照片类AI是如何一步步变得越来越好、越来越好的?

英文原文

Can you speak a little bit more to the process of it becoming better and better and better, photo AI?

Pieter Levels1:14:48

我之前开发了这款照片AI工具,很多用户在用,每月生成的照片数量达到百万张甚至更多。我在测试不同参数时发现,比如增加生成照片的步数(step count),或更换采样器(sampler)——也就是调度器(scheduler)。还有DPM系列工具等等,这些我其实都不太懂,但我清楚可以从中选择不同选项,而每次生成的图像结果也各不相同。只是我当时并不知道哪些参数组合效果更好。于是我先自己测试,后来就想:‘我何不直接在这些用户身上做测试呢?’反正每月已有百万张照片生成,所以我随机选取10%的用户,对他们测试不同参数组合,再观察用户反应——因为用户可以给照片点赞,也可以下载照片,我便通过统计点赞率或下载率来衡量他们是否喜欢这些照片。接着我进行A/B测试,并检验统计显著性,从而判断哪些参数更好、哪些更差。

英文原文

So, I had this photo AI and a lot of people using it. There was like a million or more photos a month being generated. And I discovered I was testing parameters, increase the step count of generating photo or changing the sampler, like a scheduler. You have DPM tools, all these things I don’t know anything about, but I know that you can choose them and you generate image and they have different resulting images. But I didn’t know which one were better. So, I would do it myself, test it, but then I was like, “Why don’t I test on these users?” ‘Cause I have a million photos generated anyway, so on like 10% of the users, I would randomly test parameters and then I would see if they would, because you can favor the photo or you can download it, I would measure if they favor it or like the photo. And then I would A/B test and you test for significance and stuff, which parameters were better and which were worse.

Lex Fridman1:15:37

所以,您开始逐步弄清楚哪些模型实际效果更好。

英文原文

So, you starting to figure out which models are actually working well.

Pieter Levels1:15:41

没错。一旦数据量足够显著,我就将全部用户切换到效果更好的参数组合。这正是让产品变强的关键突破点——利用用户自身来提升产品。我在用户注册时就明确告知:‘我们会对您的照片进行抽样,以随机参数组合开展测试。’这套方法效果极佳。如今我已不太频繁做测试了,因为已接近收益递减点——产品已足够好,但当初那个突破点确实至关重要。

英文原文

Exactly. And then if it’s significant enough data, you switch to that for all the users. And so that was the breakthrough to make it better. Just use the users to improve themselves. And I tell them when they sign up, “We do sampling, we do testing on your photos with random parameters.” And that worked really well. I don’t do a lot of testing anymore because I reached a diminishing point where it’s good, but there was a breakthrough. Yeah.

Lex Fridman1:16:03

所以,核心就在于参数、模型本身,以及让用户帮您在模型与参数构成的巨大空间中完成搜索。

英文原文

So, it’s really about the parameters, the models, and letting the users help do the search in the space of models and parameters for you.

Pieter Levels1:16:13

但事实上,Stable Diffusion方面,我用的是1.5版本;后来2.0版发布,再后来Excel版也出来了,所有这些新版本反而更差。因此,主流用户至今仍在使用Stable Diffusion 1.5,因为它不像后来那些版本那样被‘阉割’——后来的版本为了强化安全特性等,被大幅削弱了功能。所以大多数人仍停留在Stable Diffusion 1.5。与此同时,Stable Diffusion公司本身却发生了剧变:CEO离职,诸多风波接踵而至,原因在于公司始终未能盈利。他们向我们提供了这个开源模型,所有人都在用;他们融资数亿美元,却始终未从中赚到一分钱。真正受益的,反而是早期那些小型开发者,比如我这样靠该模型开发小型应用的人。如今他们开始对新模型收费,但这些新模型对用户而言并不够好,也不够开源,对吧?

英文原文

But actually, so Stable Diffusion, I used 1.5, 2.0 came out as Stable Diffusion, Excel came out, all these new versions, and they were all worse. And so the core scene of people are still using 1.5 because it’s also not like what do you call “neutered.” They neutered to make it super with safety features and stuff. So, most of the people are still on Stable Diffusion 1.5. And meanwhile Stable Diffusion, the company went, the CEO left. A lot of drama happened because they couldn’t make money. They gave us this open source model that everybody uses. They raised hundreds of millions of dollars. They didn’t make any money with. There are not lots. And they did an amazing job, and now everybody uses open source model for free and it’s amazing. It’s amazing.

Lex Fridman1:17:04

所以您说,您甚至没有采用最新版本?

英文原文

You’re not even using the latest one, you’re saying?

Pieter Levels1:17:06

没有。奇怪的是,这家公司融了数亿美元,但真正从中获益的却是我们这些早期的小型开发者——像我这样用该模型开发小型应用的人。而现在他们开始对新模型收费,可这些新模型对用户来说并不够好,也不够开源,对吧?

英文原文

No, and the strange thing is that this company raised hundreds of millions, but the people that are benefiting from it, early, small, people like me who make these small apps that are using the model. And now they’re starting to charge money for the new models, but the new models are not so good for people. They’re not so open source, right?

Lex Fridman1:17:20

是啊,这确实很有意思:开源在AI领域影响如此深远,但我们不禁要问,其背后的商业模式究竟是什么?但它确实催生了整个生态系统——大量公司正依托这些开源模型开展业务。

英文原文

Yeah. It is interesting because open source is so impactful in the AI space, but you wonder what is the business model behind that? But it’s enabling this whole ecosystem of companies that they’re using the open source models.

Pieter Levels1:17:34

这就像是那些框架,但他们既没能施加足够影响力推动大家采用,也没对平台本身收费。

英文原文

So, it’s like those frameworks, but then they didn’t bribe enough influence to use it and they didn’t charge money for the platform.

Lex Fridman1:17:42

回到您的书和其中的理念——您甚至还没迈出第一步:生成创意。当时您手上根本没有成形的书,却要从零开始填充内容。您怎么判断一个创意是否足够好?面对海量涌现的创意,您如何挑选出真正值得付诸实践的那个?

英文原文

So, back to your book and the ideas, you didn’t even get to the first step, generating ideas. So, you had no book and you’re filling it up. How do you know when an idea is a good one? You have this just flood of ideas. How do you pick the one that you actually try to build?

Pieter Levels1:18:01

老天,大多数时候您根本不知道。我通常只选那些对我而言最可行、最容易落地的创意。我现在显然没法创办一家航天公司,对吧?那挑战实在太大了;但我可以打造别的东西——

英文原文

Man, mostly you don’t know. Mostly I choose the ones that are most viable for me to build. I cannot build a space company now, right? Would be quite challenging, but I can build something-

Lex Fridman1:18:09

您真把‘航天公司’写下来过吗?

英文原文

Did you actually write down like “space company”?

Pieter Levels1:18:11

没有,我觉得小行星采矿才酷呢——飞到小行星上,采集些资源带回来卖掉。发射任务可以外包给别人来做。所以您只需研发一台能抵达小行星的机器人,而机器人技术本身就很有意思。我还想学机器人技术呢。所以也许这个方向可行——

英文原文

No, I think asteroid mining would be very cool because you go to an asteroid, you take some stuff from there, you bring it back, you sell it. And you can hire someone to launch the thing. So, all you need is the robot that goes to the asteroid and the robotics’ interesting. I want to also learn robotics. So, maybe that could be-

Lex Fridman1:18:30

我觉得小行星采矿和机器人技术这两者……

英文原文

I think both the asteroid mining and the robotics is…

Pieter Levels1:18:33

对,二者结合。

英文原文

Yeah, together.

Lex Fridman1:18:40

我感觉……[听不清,01:18:40]

英文原文

I feel like [inaudible 01:18:40].

Pieter Levels1:18:39

不,完全正确!就是这个!‘我们做这件事,不是因为它容易,而是因为我们以为它容易。’完全正确!这就是我对小行星采矿的态度。完全正确!这正是我该去做的理由。

英文原文

No, exactly. This is it. “We do this not because it’s easy, but because we thought it would be easy.” Exactly. That’s me with asteroid mining. Exactly. That’s why I should do this.

Lex Fridman1:18:51

这不是NomadList.com,这是小行星采矿。克服引力真的很难。

英文原文

It’s not nomadlist.com. It’s asteroid mining. Gravity is really hard to overcome.

Pieter Levels1:18:59

是啊。但听起来——老天,我好像显得很傻。可能其实并不傻,但听起来确实挺容易入手的,相对而言比较容易入手。您不必自己造火箭。

英文原文

Yeah. But it seems, man, I sound like idiot. Probably not. But it sounds quite approachable. Relatively approachable. You don’t have to build the rockets.

Lex Fridman1:19:06

哦,您可以借助SpaceX之类的公司把设备送入太空。

英文原文

Oh, you use something like SpaceX to get out space.

Pieter Levels1:19:07

对,您雇SpaceX把狗形机器人之类的东西送上去。

英文原文

Yeah, you hire SpaceX to send this dog robots or whatever.

Lex Fridman1:19:12

那么,您真有本现存的笔记本,上面写着‘小行星采矿’这几个字吗?

英文原文

So, is there actually existing notebook where you wrote down “asteroid mining”?

Pieter Levels1:19:15

没有。那时候我用的是Trello。

英文原文

No. Back then I used Trello.

Lex Fridman1:19:17

Trello,对。

英文原文

Trello. Yeah.

Pieter Levels1:19:17

但现在我改用Telegram了,用它的‘保存消息’功能。想到什么创意,我就随手记下来。

英文原文

But now I use Telegram. I rather than saved messages. I have an idea, I write it down.

Lex Fridman1:19:22

您是在Telegram上给自己发消息?

英文原文

You type to yourself on Telegram?

Pieter Levels1:19:24

因为您用WhatsApp,对吧?我想您应该也有‘给自己发消息’的功能。对,就相当于一个记事本。

英文原文

Because you use WhatsApp, right? I think. So, you have “message to yourself” thing also. Yeah, so like a notepad.

Lex Fridman1:19:28

所以您是在Telegram上跟自己对话?

英文原文

So, you’re talking to yourself on Telegram.

Pieter Levels1:19:30

对。就当个记事本,防止遗忘。然后我会把它置顶。

英文原文

Yeah. You use like a notepad, not forget stuff. And then I pin it.

Lex Fridman1:19:33

我喜欢你没用那些特别复杂的系统之类的东西。现在人们都用 Obsidian,还有像 Notion 这类工具,各种笔记系统五花八门。而你就是个用记事本(notepad.exe)的人。

英文原文

I love how you’re not using super complicated systems or whatever. People use Obsidian now. There’s a lot of these, Notion, where you have systems for note-taking. You’re notepad.exe guy.

Pieter Levels1:19:48

老兄,我看过一些 YouTuber 做这种事……还有很多所谓的效率大师也这么干,整套 iPad 加 Apple Pencil 的装备。我自己也买了 iPad 和 Pencil,还装了个能在屏幕上画纸、画日历的 App。学生常用这类工具涂色什么的。我当时就想:‘哥们儿,我坚持了一星期,然后突然问自己:“我这辈子到底在干啥?”其实我直接给自己发条消息写下来,就已经够用了。’

英文原文

Man, I saw some YouTubers doing this like… There’s a lot of these productivity gurus also and they do this whole iPad with a pencil. And then I also had an iPad and I also got the pencil, and I got this app where you can draw on paper, draw like a calendar. People, students use this and you do coloring and stuff. And I’m like, “Dude, I did this for a week. And then I’m like, ‘What am I doing in my life?’ I can just write it as a message to myself and it’s good enough.”

Lex Fridman1:20:14

说到创意,你曾发过一条推文,解释为什么第一个冒出来的想法有时反而是绝妙的想法。你认为原因在于:第一个想法源自潜意识,其实在你大脑后台已酝酿数周、数月,甚至数年。八小时的刻意思考,永远比不上潜意识持续不断的后台运行。所以这个观点是说:你花八小时苦思冥想一个点子,和那个瞬间蹦进你脑海的第一个点子相比,后者可能更优;而有些潜意识里的东西,你其实已经琢磨了好多年——这真的很有意思。

英文原文

Speaking of ideas, you shared a tweet explaining why the first idea sometimes might be a brilliant idea. The reason for this you think is the first idea submerges from your subconscious and was actually boiling your brain for weeks, months, sometimes years in the background. The eight hours of thinking can never compete with a perpetual subconscious background job. So, this is the idea that if you think about an idea for eight hours versus the first idea that pops into your mind. And sometimes there is subconscious stuff that you’ve been thinking about for many years. That’s really interesting.

Pieter Levels1:20:46

我的意思是‘它浮现出来’。我之前拼错了,因为我不是英语母语者,但它的的确确是从你的潜意识里‘浮现’出来的,就像水里冒泡一样。你的潜意识就在那儿,一直在沸腾。等它准备好了,就‘叮’一声——就像微波炉加热完成,点子就这么蹦出来了。

英文原文

I mean like, “It emerges.” I wrote it wrong because I’m not native English, but it emerges from your subconscious, it comes from like a water. Your subconscious is in here, it’s boiling. And then when it’s ready, it’s like ding. It’s like a microwave, it comes out. And there you have your idea.

Lex Fridman1:21:01

你觉得你自己也有过这种点子?

英文原文

You think you have ideas like that?

Pieter Levels1:21:02

有,一直都有,百分之百。

英文原文

Yeah, all the time. A hundred percent.

Lex Fridman1:21:04

就是那些早已存在于那儿的东西。

英文原文

It’s just stuff that’s been there.

Pieter Levels1:21:05

对。

英文原文

Yes.

Lex Fridman1:21:06

对。

英文原文

Yeah.

Pieter Levels1:21:06

而且它还会冒出来,我又把它扔回去,扔回厨房继续炖。

英文原文

And also it comes up and I send it back, send it back to the kitchen to boil more.

Lex Fridman1:21:12

还没熟呢,对。

英文原文

Not ready yet. Yeah.

Pieter Levels1:21:13

这就像是锅里一锅正在熬煮的创意浓汤,百分之百就是这样。这就是我大脑的工作方式,我想大多数人也一样。

英文原文

And it’s like a soup of ideas that’s cooking. It’s a hundred percent. This is how my brain works, and I think most people.

Lex Fridman1:21:18

但这也跟时机有关。有时候你得把它扔回去,并不只是因为你还没准备好,而是世界还没准备好。

英文原文

But it’s also about the timing. Sometimes you have to send it back, not just because you’re not ready, but the world is not ready.

Pieter Levels1:21:24

对,比如很多初创公司创始人,他们的点子往往太超前了,百分之百没错。

英文原文

Yeah. So, many times, like startup founders are too early with their idea. Yeah, a hundred percent.

Lex Fridman1:21:30

机器人领域就是个很典型的例子:过去有很多机器人公司失败了,因为打造一家能盈利的机器人公司实在太难——制造成本高、所有环节开销巨大,机器人的智能水平又不足以打造出足够吸引人、能赚钱的产品。一长串机器人公司曾尝试过,怀揣远大梦想,最终却纷纷失败。

英文原文

Robotics is an interesting one for that because there’s been a lot of robotics companies that failed, because it’s been very difficult to build a robotics company make money ’cause there’s the manufacturing, the cost of everything. The intelligence of the robot is not sufficient to create a compelling enough product from wish to make money. There’s this long line of robotics companies that have tried, they had big dreams, and they failed.

Pieter Levels1:21:54

对,比如波士顿动力(Boston Dynamics)。我至今仍不清楚他们到底在做什么,但他们总是在 YouTube 上上传视频,效果确实令人惊叹。但我感觉,眼下很多这类公司就像‘为解题而找题’——解决方案先行,问题还没找到。军方当然在用,但问题是:我现在家里真需要一只机器狗吗?我不知道。它挺有趣,但目前确实还没解决什么实际问题。VR 也是类似情况:真的很酷,苹果 Vision Pro 也非常酷,但它目前对我而言,也还没真正解决什么问题。这就是技术在主动寻找应用场景,不过总有一天会找到的。

英文原文

Yeah, like Boston Dynamics. I still don’t know what they’re doing, but they always upload YouTube videos and it’s amazing. But I feel like a lot of these companies don’t have, it’s like a solution looking for a problem for now. Military obviously uses. But do I need a robotic dog now for my house? I don’t know. It’s fun, but it doesn’t really solve anything yet. I feel the same with VR. It’s really cool. Apple Vision Pro is very cool. It doesn’t really solve something for me yet. And that’s the tech looking for a solution, but one day will.

Lex Fridman1:22:24

当年个人电脑出现,尤其是 Mac 问世时,发生了一场重大转变。它不知怎么就一下子抓住了所有人的想象力,杀手级应用也迅速变得清晰可见——比如,你终于可以在电脑上打字了。

英文原文

When the personal computer, when the Mac came along, there was a big switch that happened. It somehow captivated everybody’s imagination. The application, the killer apps became apparent. You can type in a computer.

Pieter Levels1:22:38

而且这些应用几乎是立刻就显现出了价值。当时也有人嚷嚷:‘我们根本不需要这些电脑,它们不过是炒作罢了。’技术发展本来就是一波一波推进的。

英文原文

But they became apparent immediately. Back then they also had this thing where like, “We don’t need these computers. They’re like a hype.” And it also went in like waves.

Lex Fridman1:22:49

对,但正是这种炒作,才让技术得以充分普及,从而慢慢打开人们的心智,让大家开始意识到它的可能性。就拿现在的机器人来说,普通人家中几乎见不到机器人。

英文原文

Yeah. But the hype is the thing that allowed the thing to proliferate sufficiently to where people’s minds would start opening up to it a little bit, the possibility of it. Right now, for example, with the robotics, there’s very few robots in the homes of people.

Pieter Levels1:23:03

没错,完全正确。

英文原文

Exactly, yeah.

Lex Fridman1:23:04

目前家里有的机器人,也就是扫地机器人 Roomba 这类吸尘器,或者亚马逊的 Alexa。

英文原文

The robots that are there are Roombas, so the vacuum cleaners, or they’re Amazon Alexa.

Pieter Levels1:23:11

或者洗碗机——说白了,它本质上也算一台机器人。

英文原文

Or dishwasher, I mean, it’s essentially a robot.

Lex Fridman1:23:13

没错,但它们的智能程度非常有限,这大概是我们能对除 Alexa 外所有这类设备的共同总结。Alexa 确实挺聪明,但在与你互动的方式上仍有局限。这只是其中一个例子。我有时会想:世上有些人,仿佛生来就是为了打造某样东西;我偶尔也会琢磨,自己究竟是被赋予了什么使命?你对自己的人生有过规划、有过梦想吗?

英文原文

Yes, but the intelligence is very limited, I guess, is one way we can summarize all of them except Alexa, which is pretty intelligent, but is limited with the kind of ways it interacts with you. That’s just one example. I sometimes think about that as if some people in this world were born in the whole existence is like, they were meant to build the thing. I sometimes wonder what I was meant to do. You have these plans for your life, you have these dreams?

Pieter Levels1:23:49

我觉得你生来就是要造机器人的。

英文原文

I think you’re meant to build robots.

Lex Fridman1:23:51

哦,就我个人而言?也许吧,也许吧。我确实有过这种感觉,但也可能是别的事。有意思的是,我这辈子最不可能被赋予的使命,反而是跟人交谈——这事儿挺怪的,因为我向来就害怕跟人说话。简直就像……

英文原文

Okay. Me personally. Maybe. Maybe. That’s a sense I’ve had, but it could be other things. Hilariously not be the thing I was meant to be is to talk to people, which is weird because I always was anxious about talking to people. It’s like a…

Pieter Levels1:24:09

真的?

英文原文

Really?

Lex Fridman1:24:10

对,我怕这个,我以前就怕,没错,就是那样。

英文原文

Yeah, I’m scared of this. I was scared. Yeah, exactly.

Pieter Levels1:24:14

我怕你。

英文原文

I’m scared of you.

Lex Fridman1:24:15

就是那种贯穿始终的焦虑感,泛指一切社交互动。我是个内向者,习惯躲着这个世界。所以,这真的挺奇怪的。

英文原文

It’s just anxiety throughout, social interaction in general. I’m an introvert that hides from the world. So, yeah, it’s really strange.

Pieter Levels1:24:23

对,但生活本身大概就是这样:你很难极度刻意地决定自己这辈子要干什么,更多时候就像冲浪——你冲进大海,随波逐流,看最后被带到哪儿。

英文原文

Yeah, but that’s also kind of life, like life brings you to, it’s very hard to super intently choose what you’re going to do with your life. It is more like surfing. You’re surfing the waves, you go in the ocean, you see where you end up.

Lex Fridman1:24:38

对,宇宙似乎自带一种幽默感。

英文原文

Yeah. And there’s universe has a kind of sense of humor.

Pieter Levels1:24:41

对。

英文原文

Yeah.

Lex Fridman1:24:42

我想,你只能任由自己被海浪裹挟而去。

英文原文

I guess you have to just allow yourself to be carried away by the waves.

Pieter Levels1:24:46

完全正确,对。

英文原文

Exactly. Yeah.

Lex Fridman1:24:48

你在自己的人生中,有过这种感受吗?

英文原文

Have you felt that way in your life?

Pieter Levels1:24:50

有,一直都有,对。我觉得这才是活出人生最好的方式。

英文原文

Yeah, all the time. Yeah. I think that’s the best way to live your life.

Lex Fridman1:24:54

所以,就任由一切自然发生。你知道自己未来几年打算做什么吗?有没有可能彻底改变?

英文原文

So, a allow of whatever to happen. Do you know what you’re doing in the next few years? Is it possible that it’ll be completely changed?

Pieter Levels1:25:00

有可能。比如人际关系,你当然想好好维系,对吧?你想牵着女友的手,盼着她成为你的妻子,诸如此类。但我觉得,你得对某些事保持开放心态,比如你将来想住在哪里——我们自己都不知道,比如这一点,就让它顺其自然吧。它自会逐渐明晰:海浪会把你送到某个地方,而那里恰好就是你想定居之处。至于你将来要做什么?我觉得这才是活出人生的好方式。我认为,人生中大多数压力,都源于试图掌控、紧抓不放——这有点像佛教思想:你需要放下控制,放手让它去。事情自然会发生。当你服用裸盖菇素(迷幻蘑菇)或其它致幻药物时,那些原本就爱掌控一切的人,往往容易经历糟糕的体验,对吧?因为你必须学会放手。其实我自己就是个控制狂。十七岁那年我第一次吃蘑菇,体验非常好;但快结束时就不那么好了,因为我试图强行控制它,心里想:‘啊,现在反应太强了,我得……赶紧停下。’兄弟,你停不了的,只能硬着头皮走下去。我觉得这真是人生的绝佳隐喻。我认为这是一种极其平和的生活方式。

英文原文

Possibly. I think relationships, you want to hold the relationships, right? You want hold your girl and you want her to become wife and all this stuff. But I think you should stay open to where, for example, where you want to live. We don’t know where we want to live, for example. That’s something that will figure itself out. It will crystallize where you will get sent by the waves to somewhere where you want to live, for example. What you’re going to do? I think that’s a really good way to live your life. I think most stress comes from trying to control, like hold things. It’s kind of Buddhist. You need to lose control, let it lose. And then things will happen. When you do mushrooms, when you do drugs, like psychedelic drugs, the people that start, that are control freaks, get bad trips, right? ‘Cause you need to let go. I’m pretty control freak actually. And when I did mushrooms when I was 17, it was very good. And then at the end it wasn’t so good ’cause I tried to control it. It was like, “Ah, now it’s going too much. Now, I need to… Let’s stop.” Bro, you can’t stop it. You need to go through with it. And I think it’s a good metaphor for life. I think that’s a very tranquil way to lead you life.

Lex Fridman1:26:05

对,其实我当初服用死藤水(ayahuasca)时,这个道理就已深深烙印在我心里:你根本无法掌控任何事。我想,我可能在巴西柔术(jiu-jitsu)中体会得最深——只要放手、放松。正因如此,我才拥有了无比震撼的体验。我的死藤水体验中,真的没有任何负面成分;我所经历过的所有致幻体验,也都毫无负面。其中一部分或许与我的生理构造、基因有关,但另一部分,纯粹是因为我没试图去掌控,只是随波逐流。

英文原文

Yeah, actually when I took ayahuasca, that lesson is deeply within me already that you can’t control anything. I think I probably learned that the most in jiu-jitsu. So, just let go and relax. And that’s why I had just an incredible experience. There’s literally no negative aspect of my ayahuasca experience, or any psychedelics I’ve ever had. Some of that could be with my biology and my genetics, whatever, but some of it was just not trying to control. Just surf the waves.

Pieter Levels1:26:34

对,千真万确。我觉得人生中绝大多数压力,都来自试图掌控。

英文原文

Yeah. For sure. I think most stress in life comes from trying to control.

Lex Fridman1:26:38

那么,一旦有了点子,第二步就是动手建造。当你有了点子之后,你如何思考‘建造’这件事?

英文原文

So, once you have the idea, step two, build. How do you think about building the thing once you have the idea?

Pieter Levels1:26:45

我觉得你应该用自己熟悉的技术去建造。比如我做的 Nomad List 网站——一个帮数字游民筛选全球最适合居住和工作城市的平台——它最初根本不是网站,而是一份公开的 Google 表格,任何人都能编辑。我当时的想法是:‘我来收集一批适合数字游民生活的城市,标注网速、生活成本等各项数据。’然后我发了条推文。那时我粉丝不多,大概就几千个。结果那条推文居然火了——按当时的‘走红标准’,就是获得了五次转发,接着很多人就开始编辑表格。很快,这份表格里就汇集了来自世界各地的数百座城市及其全部数据,完全是众包完成的。后来,我才把它做成了网站。

英文原文

I think you should build with the technology that you know. So, for example, Nomad List, which is like this website I made to figure out the best cities to live and work as digital nomads, it wasn’t a website. It launched as a Google spreadsheet. So, it was a public Google spreadsheet anybody could edit. And I was like, “I’m collecting cities where we can live as these nomads with the internet speeds, the cost of living, other stuff.” And I tweeted it. And back then, I didn’t have a lot of followers. I have a few thousand followers or something. And I went viral for my skill viral back then, which was five retweets and a lot of people started editing it. And there was hundreds of cities in this list from all over the world with all the data. It was very crowdsourced. And then I made that into a website.

Pieter Levels1:27:29

所以,先弄清楚你能用什么技术,而且是你已经掌握的技术。比如,如果你不会写代码,就可以用电子表格;如果你连电子表格都不会用,那也没关系,你总还能用一些网站生成器,比如 Wix 或者 Squarespace 之类的东西,对吧?创业根本不需要会写代码。你真正需要的只是一个产品创意,然后做一个着陆页之类的东西,在上面放一个 Stripe 支付按钮,接着把它做出来就行。如果你会写代码,那就用你已经熟悉的编程语言开始动手编码,看看能做到什么程度;之后你随时可以重写代码。初创阶段,技术栈并不是一家企业最重要的东西。最关键的是验证市场是否存在,验证是否真有用户愿意为你的产品付费。因此,尽你所能,用一切你能用上的工具。如果你不会写代码,那就用电子表格、着陆页生成器,等等。

英文原文

So, figuring out what technology you can use, that you already know. So, if you cannot code, you can use spreadsheet. If you cannot use a spreadsheet, whatever, you can always use, for example, a website generator like Wix or something, or Squarespace, right? You don’t need to code to build a startup. All you need is an idea for a product, build something like a landing page or something, put a Stripe button on there, and then make it. And if you can code, use the language that you already know and start coding with that and see how far you can get. And you can always rewrite the code later. The tech stack it’s not the most important of a business when you’re starting out a business. The important thing is that you validate that there’s a market, that there’s a product that people want to pay for. So, use whatever you can use. And if you cannot code, use spreadsheets, landing page generators, whatever.

Lex Fridman1:28:19

而众包元素非常有趣,很酷。当大量用户开始使用时,那种感觉特别棒,你也能学得飞快。我其实就试过电子表格这种方式:我把一个电子表格公开分享出去,并且设置成所有人可编辑。

英文原文

And the crowdsourcing element is fascinating. It’s cool. It’s cool when a lot of people start using it. You get to learn so fast. I’ve actually did the spreadsheet thing. You share a spreadsheet publicly, and I made it editable.

Pieter Levels1:28:37

是啊。

英文原文

Yeah.

Lex Fridman1:28:37

太酷了。

英文原文

It’s so cool.

Pieter Levels1:28:38

一些有意思的事情就开始发生了。

英文原文

Interesting things start happening.

Lex Fridman1:28:39

是啊,我当初是为健身项目做的这个,因为我每天要做大量俯卧撑和引体向上。

英文原文

Yeah, I did it for a workout thing ’cause I was doing a large amount of pushups and pull ups every day.

Pieter Levels1:28:44

是啊,我记得这个人,没错。

英文原文

Yeah, I remember this man. Yeah.

Lex Fridman1:28:47

当时就像 Google 表格那样,权限设置得相当宽松,所有单元格都允许编辑。于是人们可以在任意单元格里随便输入内容,还能新建工作表、新建标签页,结果整个表格一下子就爆炸式增长起来了。其中一件让我特别喜欢的事是:几乎没什么喷子,因为一旦出现喷子,其他用户就会主动把他们的内容删掉。这就形成了一种奇怪的‘保卫战’——大家想保护这个东西,仿佛它自带一种免疫系统。

英文原文

While it’s like Google Sheets is pretty limited in that everything’s allowed. So, people could just write anything in any cell and they can create new sheets, new tabs, and it just exploded. And one of the things that I really enjoyed is there’s very few trolls because actually other people would delete the trolls. There would be this weird war of like, they want to protect the thing. It’s an immune system that’s inherent to the thing.

Pieter Levels1:29:18

它在电子表格里自成一个社会。

英文原文

It becomes a society in a spreadsheet.

Lex Fridman1:29:20

接着还出现了被边缘化的群体,他们跑到电子表格最底部去,试图隐藏信息,还说:‘我才不想跟顶部那些酷 kids 混在一起呢,我就待在底部好了。’但这种众包元素确实非常强大。如果你能打造一款产品,把这种机制充分用起来,那就太棒了。任何投票系统、任何用于 A/B 测试的评分系统,都真的、真的、真的非常有趣。总之,Nomad List 非常出色,我很想听你聊聊它。不过,聊它的其中一个角度,就是你开发 Hood Maps 的过程。你干了一件超棒的事:一边开发这个项目,一边全程记录下来,而且只用了短短三四天、最多五天时间。所以大家一定要去看看博客文章里的那段视频。你能解释一下 Hood Maps 是什么,以及整个开发过程是怎样的吗?

英文原文

And then there’s the outcasts who go to the bottom of the spreadsheet and they would try to hide messages and they like, “I don’t want to be with the cool kids up at the top of the spreadsheet, so I’m going to at the bottom.” I mean, but that kind of crowdsourcing element is really powerful. And if you can create a product that used that to its benefit, that’s really nice. Any kind of voting system, any kind of rating system for A and B testing is really, really, really fascinating. So, anyway, so Nomad List is great. I would love for you to talk about that. But one sort of way to talk about it is through you building hood maps. You did an awesome thing, which is document yourself building the thing and doing so in just a handful of days, like 3, 4, 5 days. So, people should definitely check out the video in the blog post. Can you explain what hood maps is and what this whole process was?

Pieter Levels1:30:17

当时我正在旅行,同时也在努力寻找值得解决的问题。我渐渐发现,每个人对一座城市的体验都不一样,因为他们住在不同的区域。我来自阿姆斯特丹,虽然我没在那里长大,但大学时期曾住在那儿。我知道欧洲城市的市中心通常都是旅游区,人山人海,不够地道,体现不出真正的荷兰文化,只是‘阿姆斯特丹游客文化’而已。所以每当有人来阿姆斯特丹旅行,我都会告诉他们:‘别去市中心,去市中心东南边,比如 Jordaan 或 Pijp 这些地方。’这些更偏‘嬉皮士风’的区域,我觉得更能代表阿姆斯特丹更真实的文化。

英文原文

So, I was traveling and I was still trying to find problems, and I would discover that everybody’s experience of a city is different because they stay in different areas. So, I’m from Amsterdam and when I grew up in Amsterdam, or I didn’t grow up, but I lived there in university, I knew that center is like, in Europe, the centers are always tourist areas, so they’re super busy. They’re not very authentic, they’re not really Dutch culture, it’s Amsterdam tourist culture. So, when people would travel to Amsterdam I would say, “Don’t go to the center, go to southeast of the center, the Jordaan or the Pijp or something.” More hipster areas. I was like, “A little more authentic culture of Amsterdam.”

Pieter Levels1:30:54

我平时就住那儿,也常去那儿。我当时就想,这或许可以做成一款 App:你在 Google 地图上叠加一层彩色图层,不同区域用不同颜色标注——比如红色代表游客区,绿色代表富人区(绿色象征金钱),黄色代表嬉皮士区。这样旅行时你就能快速判断该去城市里的哪个区域。因为我当时经常旅行,就想找到那些酷炫的地方。

英文原文

That’s where I would live and where I would go. And I thought this could be an app where you can have a Google Maps and you put colors over it. You have areas that are like color-coded, like red is tourist, green is rich, green money, yellow is hipster. And you can figure out where you need to go in the city when you travel. ‘Cause I was traveling a lot, I wanted to go to the cool spots.

Lex Fridman1:31:13

所以就只用颜色。

英文原文

So, just use color.

Pieter Levels1:31:15

对,就用颜色。我当时想用 Canvas(画布)来实现。所以我就琢磨:好吧,我到底需要什么?我需要……

英文原文

Color. Yeah. And I would use a canvas. So, I thought, okay, what do I need? I need to…

Lex Fridman1:31:19

你当时就知道自己会用 Canvas 吗?

英文原文

Did you know that you would be using a canvas?

Pieter Levels1:31:22

不,我根本不知道 Canvas 还能这么用,因为之前我压根儿不了解……

英文原文

No, I didn’t know it was possible ’cause I didn’t know-

Lex Fridman1:31:24

这才是最酷的地方,大家真该好好看看。

英文原文

This is the cool thing. People should really check it out.

Pieter Levels1:31:27

这就是整个项目的起点。

英文原文

This is how it started.

Lex Fridman1:31:27

因为你极其真实、极其动人地呈现出了那种令人谦卑甚至尴尬的‘不知所措’状态——就像在问:‘这玩意儿我该怎么搞?’你还把整个过程完整记录了下来。没错,你说得对,‘哥们儿,我自己都觉得挺尴尬的。’

英文原文

Because you’re honestly capture so beautifully the humbling aspects or the embarrassing aspects of not knowing what to do. It’s like, “How do I do this?” And you document yourself. Yeah, you’re right, “Dude, I feel embarrassed about myself.”

Pieter Levels1:31:45

哦,真的吗?是啊。

英文原文

Oh, really? Yeah.

Lex Fridman1:31:45

这就叫活着嘛。不错。所以你对 Canvas 一无所知——Canvas 是 HTML5 提供的一种功能,允许你在网页上绘制图形。

英文原文

It’s called being alive. Nice. So, you don’t know anything about Canvas is HTML5 thing that allows you to draw shapes.

Pieter Levels1:31:58

它可以绘制图像,本质上就是逐像素绘图。这在当时很特别,因为在那之前,网页上只能放置各种固定元素,对吧?你想画一个像素点,就得用 Canvas。我知道自己必须逐像素绘图,因为我要绘制这些颜色。我当时的想法是:好,我先嵌入一个 Google 地图,再在地图上方覆盖一个 div 层,把颜色图层叠加上去,透明度设为 50%,让它半透可见。于是我用 Canvas 实现了这个效果,然后开始绘图。接着我又意识到,显然还得让其他人也能编辑这张图,毕竟光靠我自己可画不完所有区域。所以我再次采用了众包方式。

英文原文

Draw images, just draw pixels essentially. And that was special back then because before you could only have elements, right? So, you want to draw a pixel, use a Canvas. And I knew I needed to draw pixels ’cause I need to draw these colors. And I felt like, okay, I’ll get a Google Maps, I frame Embeds, and then I put a div on top of it with the colors. And I’ll do opacity 50, so it kind of shows. So, I did that with Canvas, and then I started drawing. And then I felt like obviously other people need to edit this ’cause I cannot draw all these things myself. So, I crowdsourced it again.

Pieter Levels1:32:31

用户直接在地图上绘制,然后将像素数据发送到服务器,存进数据库。接着我运行了一个机器人程序(类似定时任务 cron job),每天(或每周)自动计算一次:‘好,阿姆斯特丹市中心这一块,有六个人标记为游客区,但有两个人标成了嬉皮士区。那么游客区胜出,对吧?’其实就是个数组运算:统计地图上每个微小像素区域中,哪种颜色标记出现次数最多。如果多数人标记为游客区,那它就显示为红色。我会对全球所有 GPS 坐标点都做这样的处理。

英文原文

And you would draw on the map and then it would send the pixel data to the server. It would put it in the database. And then I would have a robot running like a cron job, which every week would calculate, or every day would calculate like, “Okay, so Amsterdam Center, there’s like six people say it’s tourists, this part of the center, but two people say it’s like hipster. Okay, so the tourist part wins, right?” It’s just an array. So, find the most common value in a little pixel area on a map. So, if most people say it’s tourists, it’s tourists, and it becomes red. And I would do that for all the GPS corners in the world.

Lex Fridman1:33:05

我们能不能确认一下:作为参与贡献的人类用户,你是不是必须身处在那个地点才能打标签?还是说……

英文原文

Can we just clarify, as a human that’s contributing to this, do you have to be in that location to make the label or do you-

Pieter Levels1:33:12

大家只要输入城市名,就立刻疯狂开画,到处乱涂。

英文原文

People just type in cities and go berserk and start drawing everywhere.

Lex Fridman1:33:16

他们是画形状,还是画像素点?

英文原文

Would they draw shapes or would they draw pixels?

Pieter Levels1:33:18

老天,他们画的东西简直离谱,比如各种冒犯性符号——我前面提过,有人画阴茎。

英文原文

Man, they drew crazy stuff, like offensive symbols. I mentioned they would draw penises.

Lex Fridman1:33:23

嗯,这明显是男生才会干的事。

英文原文

I mean that’s obviously a guy thing.

Pieter Levels1:33:25

我也会干同样的事,画阴茎。

英文原文

I would do the same thing, draw penises.

Lex Fridman1:33:28

等我登陆火星、周围又没摄像头的时候,我也照样在火星表面画阴茎……

英文原文

When I show up to Mars and there’s no cameras, I’m drawing a penis on the same-

Pieter Levels1:33:31

完全正确!哥们儿,我以前还在雪地上画过。但阴茎图案最终并没造成什么问题,因为我明白:不是每个人都画阴茎,更不会都画在同一个地方。大多数人还是会合理使用这个工具。所以,只要众包数据足够多,所有这些叠加在地图上的像素点就构成了一层像素图层,我们只需选出其中出现频率最高的像素颜色即可。换句话说,这就相当于一场视觉化的投票,而且它真的奏效了。一周之内,我就收集到了足够多的数据。有些城市表现特别好,比如洛杉矶,很多人开始使用它,目前大部分数据都来自洛杉矶。

英文原文

Exactly. Man, I did it in the snow. But the penises did not become a problem ’cause I knew that not everybody would draw a penis and not in the same place. So, most people would use it fairly. So, just say if I had enough crowdsource data, so you have all these pixels on top of each, it’s like a layer of pixels, and you choose the most common pixel. So, yeah, it’s just like a poll, but in visual format. And it worked. And within a week, I’d had enough data. And it was like cities that did really well, like Los Angeles, a lot of people started using it. Like most data’s in Los Angeles.

Lex Fridman1:34:02

因为洛杉矶拥有明确划分的街区,而且不只是官方定义的行政区划,更是人们普遍认知中的特色区域。你有没有预先设定好用户可用的标签分类?

英文原文

Because Los Angeles has defined neighborhoods. And not just in terms of the official labels, but what they’re known for. Did you provide the categories that they were allowed to use as labels?

Pieter Levels1:34:18

用的是颜色,对。

英文原文

Colors, yeah.

Lex Fridman1:34:19

用颜色?

英文原文

As colors?

Pieter Levels1:34:20

我设定的类别大概有:嬉皮士、游客、富人、商务。每个城市总会有商务区,也总会有住宅区——住宅区用灰色表示。我觉得这些是城市里最常见、最典型的几类区域。

英文原文

So, I use like, I think you can see there’s like hipster, tourist, rich, business. There’s always a business area and then there’s a residential. Residential is gray. So, I thought those were the most common things in the city, kind of.

Lex Fridman1:34:32

还有点网络迷因(meme)的味道,给地图贴标签这件事本身就挺好玩的。

英文原文

And a little bit meme-y, like it’s almost fun to label it.

Pieter Levels1:34:35

是啊,当然,这明显做了简化,但这类事情本来就需要简化,你不能设置太多分类。本质上这就像是用画笔作画:你在底部选中一种颜色,也就是对应一个类别,然后开始涂抹。整个过程没有任何操作说明,也没有用户手册。另外我还加了标签功能,让用户能在特定位置添加文字备注,比如‘别来这儿’,或者‘这儿有不错的咖啡馆’之类。结果由此催生的网络迷因简直绝了!我还增加了上传功能,让这些标签可以上传保存。由此产生的迷因内容真是令人惊叹:洛杉矶的用户会写下各种疯狂的文字,这些内容还会在各个城市间病毒式传播。你还可以开启定位权限,系统大概率就会把你推荐到奥斯汀。

英文原文

Yeah, I mean obviously it’s simplified, but you need to simplify this stuff. You don’t want to have too many categories. And it’s essentially like using a paintbrush, where you select the color in the bottom, you select the category and you start drawing. There’s no instruction. There’s no manual. And then I also add a tagging so people could write something on a specific location, so, “Don’t go here,” or like, “Here’s nice cafes and stuff.” And man, the memes that came from that. And I also added uploading so that the tags could be uploaded. So, the memes that came from that is amazing. People in Los Angeles would write crazy stuff. It would go viral in all these cities. You can allow your location, and then we’ll probably send you to Austin.

Lex Fridman1:35:17

好的,我们现在看到……哎哟,‘喝醉的嬉皮士’。

英文原文

Okay, so we’re looking… Oh, boy. “Drunk hipsters.”

Pieter Levels1:35:28

‘AirBroNBros’(空气兄弟)。

英文原文

“AirBroNBros.”

Lex Fridman1:35:30

‘AirBroNBros’(空气兄弟)。‘吸可卡因的嬉皮士女孩’。

英文原文

” AirBroNBros.” “Hipster Girls who do Cocaine.”

Pieter Levels1:35:33

‘我在这儿看见一个穿鱼装的男人被人打了。’

英文原文

I saw a guy in a fish costume get beaten up here.

Lex Fridman1:35:36

嗯,这看起来也挺准的。

英文原文

Yep, that seems also accurate.

Pieter Levels1:35:38

‘价格虚高,名不副实。’

英文原文

“Overpriced and underwhelming.”

Lex Fridman1:35:43

让我看看。我得确认一下这个是否准确。我们来看看。“脏乱的第六街”。熟悉奥斯汀的人知道,这个标签很重要。奥斯汀的第六街很有名。“醉醺醺的兄弟会男生扎堆的脏乱第六街”,这很准确。“喝醉了的胖哥们”也在第六街继续出没,非常有名。

英文原文

Let me see. Let me make sure this is accurate. Let’s see. “Dirty 6th.” For people who know Austin, know that that’s important to label. 6th Street is famous in Austin. “Dirty Sixth drunk frat boys,” accurate. ” Drunk fat bros,” continued on Sixth, very well known.

Pieter Levels1:36:03

“喝醉了的自恋男”。

英文原文

“Drunk douchebros.”

Lex Fridman1:36:00

醉醺醺的兄弟会男生继续在第六街出没。很好,那就这样吧。

英文原文

Drunk frat bros continued on sixth. Very well then.

Pieter Levels1:36:01

自恋男。

英文原文

Douche bros.

Lex Fridman1:36:02

第六街就是醉醺醺的自恋男扎堆的地方。

英文原文

Was Sixth drunk douche bros.

Pieter Levels1:36:06

从兄弟会男生变成自恋男。

英文原文

Go from frat to douche.

Lex Fridman1:36:07

自恋男。到目前为止,这描述非常准确。

英文原文

Douche. It’s very accurate so far.

Pieter Levels1:36:09

真的吗?

英文原文

Really?

Lex Fridman1:36:11

这里只让长得好看的人居住。我觉得这可能挺准确的。

英文原文

They only let hot people live here. I think that might be accurate.

Pieter Levels1:36:17

我觉得是那个片区。河畔的健身狂魔。对,没错。

英文原文

I think the district. Exercise freaks on the river. Yeah, that’s true.

Lex Fridman1:36:24

遛狗的人。准确。

英文原文

Dog runners. Accurate.

Pieter Levels1:36:25

对。

英文原文

Yeah.

Lex Fridman1:36:26

我在这儿见过一个穿鱼形服装的人被人打了。

英文原文

Saw a guy in the fish costume get beat up here.

Pieter Levels1:36:28

我想知道这个故事。

英文原文

I want to know that story.

Lex Fridman1:36:30

所以这些全都是用户贡献的内容。

英文原文

So that’s all user contributed.

Pieter Levels1:36:32

对。而这些内容我自己根本想不出来,因为我并不了解奥斯汀,也不了解这里的网络迷因和亚文化。

英文原文

Yeah. And this is stuff I couldn’t come up with because I don’t know Austin. I don’t know the memes here and the subcultures.

Lex Fridman1:36:37

然后作为用户,我可以给这些内容点赞或点踩。

英文原文

And then me as a user can upvote or down vote this.

Pieter Levels1:36:37

对。

英文原文

Yes.

Lex Fridman1:36:40

所以这完全是众包的。

英文原文

So this is completely crowd sourced.

Pieter Levels1:36:42

因为借鉴了Reddit的点赞、点踩机制,就从那儿起步了。

英文原文

Because of Reddit up vote, down vote. Took it From there.

Lex Fridman1:36:45

对。这真的、真的、真的非常强大。“单身养狗人士”,准确。那么,它是什么时候从单纯用颜色表示,变成实际显示文字的呢?

英文原文

Yeah. That’s really, really, really powerful. Single people with dogs. Accurate. At which point did it go from colors to actually showing the text?

Pieter Levels1:36:53

我想我是在一周后添加的文字。所以这儿就是像素点。

英文原文

I think I added the text a week after. And so here’s the pixels.

Lex Fridman1:36:59

所以这真的很酷。关于这些像素点,你是怎么处理的?那可是海量的数据啊。

英文原文

So that’s really cool. The pixels, how do you go from that? That’s a huge amount of data.

Pieter Levels1:36:59

对。

英文原文

Yeah.

Lex Fridman1:37:02

所以我们现在看到的是一幅图像,整座城市就像一片由不同颜色像素点组成的海洋。那么,你如何把这些像素点整合起来,形成某种真正有意义的东西呢?

英文原文

So we’re now looking at an image where it’s just a sea of pixels that are colored different colors in a city. So how do you combine that to be a thing that actually makes some sense?

Pieter Levels1:37:14

我觉得这里的问题在于,你虽然有这些数据,但它们并未锁定在某个具体位置上。

英文原文

I think here the problem was that you have this data but it’s not locked to one location.

Lex Fridman1:37:14

对。

英文原文

Yeah.

Pieter Levels1:37:20

所以我必须对它进行标准化处理。因此当你在地图上绘制时,它会显示具体的像素位置,而你可以将该像素位置转换为GPS坐标,比如纬度、经度。但这个数字会带有很多逗号或小数位,因为它非常精确——精确到桌子上的某一个特定位置。所以你要做的,就是取这个像素点,并通过去掉小数位来对其进行标准化处理(这是我后来发现的方法),从而让你谈论的是这个街区或这条街道。我正是这么做的:直接去掉小数位,然后以这种方式保存下来,接着数据就开始进入网格系统,最终形成一张网格化的数据图,也就是一种像素地图。

英文原文

So I had to normalize it. So when you draw on the map, it’ll show you the specific pixel location and you can convert the pixel location to a GPS coordinate like latitudes, longitudes. But the number will have a lot of commas or a lot of decimals because it’s very specific. It’s like this specific part of the table. So what you want to do is you want to take that pixel and you want to normalize it by removing decimals, which I discovered, so that you’re talking about this neighborhood or this street. So that’s what I did. I just took the decimals off and then I saved it like this and then it starts going to a grid and then you have a grid of data. You get a pixel map kind of.

Lex Fridman1:37:56

然后你说它看起来有点丑,于是你又做了平滑处理。

英文原文

And then you said it looks kind of ugly so then you smooth it.

Pieter Levels1:38:00

对,我开始加入模糊化等效果。不过现在它又不平滑了,因为我更喜欢那种原始效果。人们也喜欢像素风格。对,很多人在用,而且它一直在走红;每次我的地图服务提供商(比如Mapbox)账单飙升时,我就不得不暂停使用……我最初用的是Google Maps。它一走红,Google Maps的额度就超了,我只好……真有意思,当我上线发布时,它突然爆火,结果地图再也加载不了了,提示‘超出限额’,还让我‘联系企业销售部门’。我当时就想:‘可我现在急需一张地图,又不想联系企业销售,更不想跟人家约时间开会排日程。’

英文原文

Yeah, I started adding blurring and stuff. I think now it’s not smooth again because I liked it better. People like the pixel look. Yeah, a lot of people use it and it keeps going viral and every time my maps bill like Map Box, I had to stop using… I first used Google Maps. It went viral and Google Maps, it was out of credits and I had to… So funny, when I launched, it went viral, the map didn’t load anymore. It says over the limits. You need to contact enterprise sales. And I’m like, “But I need now a map and I don’t want to contact enterprise sales. I don’t want to go on a call schedule with some calendar.”

Pieter Levels1:38:36

于是我转投Mapbox,用了好几年;结果它又爆火了,去年我收到了一张两万美元的账单。他们帮了我一把,说可以少付点钱。现在我已切换到一个开源的地图平台。所以说,这产品成本非常高,却一分收入都没赚到;不过玩起来确实很有趣,只是实在太烧钱了。

英文原文

So I switched to Map Box and then had Map Box for years and then it went viral and I had a bill of $20,000. It was last year. So they helped me with the bill. They said you can pay less. And then I now switched to an open source kind of map platform. So it’s a very expensive product and never made any dollar money, but it’s very fun but it’s very expensive.

Lex Fridman1:38:58

你从这段经历中学到了什么?毕竟你用的是别人通过API提供的服务。

英文原文

Where do you learn from that experience? Because when you leverage somebody else’s through the API.

Pieter Levels1:39:06

对,我觉得地图托管服务本不该这么贵,但我自己也可以托管,只是……我不太会操作,不过理论上我能搞定。

英文原文

Yeah, I don’t think a map hosting service should cost this much, but I could host it myself, but that would be… I don’t know how to do that, but I could do that.

Lex Fridman1:39:17

对,这超级复杂。

英文原文

Yeah, it’s super complicated.

Pieter Levels1:39:19

我觉得关键在于,这个项目根本没法赚钱。我尝试过很多方法想靠它盈利,但全都失败了。

英文原文

I think that the thing is more about you can’t make money with this project. I try to do many things to make money with it and it hasn’t worked.

Lex Fridman1:39:26

你之前提到过,或许可以在上面投放广告,或者找人赞助。对,但让我特别惊讶的是,居然没人愿意在上面打广告。

英文原文

You talked about possibly doing advertisements on it or somehow or people sponsoring it. Yeah. But it’s really surprising to me that people don’t want to advertise on it.

Pieter Levels1:39:37

我觉得地图类应用本身就极难变现。Google Maps其实也没真正赚到多少钱。有时你确实能看到一些广告,但我认为那里面没什么油水。你当然可以放横幅广告,但那样显得很丑,而这个项目本身挺酷的。所以由我来补贴一点,倒也挺有意思。它也算是Nomad List的一部分,我也把它放在Nomad List各个城市的页面上了。不过我也意识到,并非所有产品都非得变现不可。有些产品纯粹就是很酷,而‘街区地图’的存在本身就很酷。我就是希望它存在,对吧?

英文原文

I think map apps are very hard to monetize. Google Maps also doesn’t really make money. Sometimes you see these ads, but I don’t think there’s a lot of money there. You could put a banner ad, but it’s kind of ugly and the project, it’s kind of cool. So it’s kind of fun to subsidize it. It’s a little bit part of Nomad List. I put it on Nomad List in the cities as well. But I also realized you don’t need to monetize everything. Some products are just cool and it’s cool to have hood maps exist. I want this to exist, right?

Lex Fridman1:40:08

对。你创造的很多东西,我都特别庆幸它们存在于这个世界上。的确如此。而如何靠它赚钱,又是另一道难题;我甚至惊讶于自己竟想不出办法来。我也惊讶于地图居然不赚钱,但你说得对,这确实很难——要让它真正落地,背后需要大量计算资源。

英文原文

Yeah. There’s a bunch of stuff you’ve created that I’m just glad exists in this world. That’s true. And it’s a whole nother puzzle and I’m surprised to figure out how to make money off of it. I’m surprised maps don’t make money, but you’re right. It’s hard. It’s hard to make money because there’s a lot of compute required to actually bring it to life.

Pieter Levels1:40:26

那么,广告该放在哪儿呢?如果你有个网站,你可以加个广告框,或者做产品植入之类的事。但你现在说的是一个地图应用,其界面90%都是地图。那你还能怎么办?真难想出广告该往哪儿放。

英文原文

So where do you put the ad? If you have a website, you can put a ad box or you can do a product placement or something. But you’re talking about a map app where 90% of the interface is a map. So what are you going to do? It’s hard to figure out where is this.

Lex Fridman1:40:40

对。而且人们也不想为此付费。

英文原文

Yeah. And people don’t want to pay for it.

Pieter Levels1:40:42

没错,正因如此——一旦你向用户收费,就会流失99%的用户,同时也会失去众包数据。这样一来,整个项目就不好玩了,准确性也会大打折扣。所以用户其实是通过贡献数据来‘付费’的;而这样也挺好,虽然不赚钱,但很酷。

英文原文

No, exactly because if you make people pay for it, you lose 99% of the user base and you lose the crowdsource data. So it’s not fun anymore. It stops being accurate. So they pay for it by crowdsourcing the data, but then yeah, it’s fine. It doesn’t make money, but it’s cool.

Lex Fridman1:40:59

但话说回来,Nomad List却是能赚钱的。

英文原文

But that said, Nomad List makes money.

Pieter Levels1:41:02

对。

英文原文

Yeah.

Lex Fridman1:41:03

那么,Nomad List背后的故事是怎样的?

英文原文

So what was the story behind Nomad List?

Pieter Levels1:41:05

Nomad List的诞生,源于我当时在泰国清迈——如今它已是榜单上的第二名城市。当时我正用笔记本电脑工作,在那儿遇到了其他数字游民。我心里想:‘嗯,这似乎是个很棒的生活方式——带着笔记本电脑去不同国家工作,顺便旅行。’但那时候全球各地的网络都很慢。比如荷兰或美国的网速很快,但在南美洲或亚洲的许多地方,网速却只有0.5兆比特,连YouTube视频都看不了。

英文原文

So Nomad List started because I was in Chiang Mai in Thailand, which is now the second city here. And I was working on my laptop. I met other Nomads there and I was like, “Okay, this seems like a cool thing to do, working on your laptop in a different country, kind of travel around.” But back then the internet everywhere was very slow. So the internet was fast in, for example, Holland or United States, but in a lot of parts in South America or Asia, it was very slow like 0.5 megabits. So you couldn’t watch a YouTube video.

Pieter Levels1:41:37

奇怪的是,泰国的网速还挺快,但我仍想找其他适合边工作边旅行的城市。而快速网络是刚需,所以我心想:‘不如用电子表格来众包这些信息吧。’我还得了解生活成本,因为我手头并不宽裕,每月只有500美元。所以我得找个房租每月仅200美元左右的地方,才能勉强租得起房子。于是Nomad List应运而生,至今仍在运行。我想,它现在差不多已有十年历史了。

英文原文

Thailand weirdly had quite fast internet, but I wanted to find other cities where I could go to work on my laptop, whatever and travel. But we needed fast internet, so I was like, “Let’s crowdsource this information with a spreadsheet.” And I also needed to know the cost of living because I didn’t have a lot of money. I had $500 a month. So I to find a place where the rent was $200 per month or something where I had some money that I could actually rent something and there was Nomad List and it still runs. I think it’s now almost 10 years.

Lex Fridman1:42:09

所以简单说明一下它的运作方式:我正在查看清迈的信息,它有一个总分,目前排名第二。

英文原文

So it’s just to describe how it works. I’m looking at Chiang Mai here. There’s a total score. It’s ranked number two.

Pieter Levels1:42:16

对,这就是所谓的‘数字游民评分’。

英文原文

Yeah, that’s like a Nomad score.

Lex Fridman1:42:17

4.82分(由用户打分),其中网络一项显示为‘快’。

英文原文

4.82 by members, but it’s looking at the internet. In this case it’s fast.

Pieter Levels1:42:24

对。

英文原文

Yeah.

Lex Fridman1:42:24

趣味性、气温、湿度、空气质量、安全性、食品安全、犯罪率、种族歧视(或缺乏种族歧视)、教育水平、电网稳定性、对气候变化的脆弱性、收入水平。

英文原文

Fun, temperature, humidity, air quality, safety, food safety, crime, racism or lack of crime, lack of racism, educational level, power grid, vulnerability to climate change, income level.

Pieter Levels1:42:40

项目有点太多了。

英文原文

It’s a little much.

Lex Fridman1:42:41

英语普及度。太棒了!太棒了!步行便利性。

英文原文

English. It’s awesome. It’s awesome. Walkability.

Pieter Levels1:42:44

我一直在不断增加新指标。

英文原文

I keep adding stuff.

Lex Fridman1:42:45

因为对某些人群而言,某些指标确实至关重要,而这真的非常酷。幸福感——我很想就此问问你。夜生活、免费Wi-Fi、空调、对女性友好程度、言论自由。

英文原文

Because for certain groups of people, certain things really matter and this is really cool. Happiness. I’d love to ask you about that. Night life, free wifi, AC, female friendly, freedom of speech.

Pieter Levels1:42:58

泰国在这方面不太理想。

英文原文

Not so good in Thailand.

Lex Fridman1:43:00

各项数值源自国家级统计数据。我喜欢这一项——

英文原文

Values derived from national statistics. I like how that one has-

Pieter Levels1:43:04

我之所以这么做,是因为这些数据集通常都是国家级的,而非城市级的。所以我无法得知曼谷与清迈在言论自由方面的差异,只知道泰国全国的整体情况。

英文原文

I need to do that because the data sets are usually national. They’re not on city level. So I don’t know about the freedom of speech between Bangkok or Chiang Mai. I know them in Thailand.

Lex Fridman1:43:12

这真的非常有趣。所以这是针对城市所作的评分,涵盖所有对你重要的方面,比如网络。而这一切全是众包的。

英文原文

This is really fascinating. So this is for city, is basically rating all the different things that matter to you, internet. And this is all crowdsourced.

Pieter Levels1:43:21

嗯,它最初确实是众包的,但后来我发现,可以从世界银行等公共来源下载更精准的数据集——联合国等机构也提供了大量可免费使用的公开数据。我开始遇到数据偏差问题,例如印度用户非常热爱自己的国家,会为印度所有指标提交最高分;而且不是一个人,而是很多人一起‘吹捧’印度。我当时就想:‘我也很喜欢印度,但这显然不是有效的数据。’

英文原文

Well, so it started crowdsource, but then I realized that you can download more accurate data sets from public source like World Bank. They have a lot of public data sets, United Nations and you can download a lot of data there, which you can freely use. I started getting problems across with data where for example, people from India, they really love India and they would submit the best scores for everything in India and not just one person, but a lot of people they would love to pump India. And I’m like, “I love India too, but that’s not valid data.”

Pieter Levels1:43:55

因此,你开始发现数据中出现偏差,比如人们实际来自哪里之类的信息不一致。于是我开始切换使用不同的数据集,现在主要依赖数据集,但有一项仍是众包的:用户会自行添加自己的所在地,也会在个人资料中添加自己的旅行信息;我利用这些数据来判断哪些地方即将兴起、哪些地方当前正热门。因此,你在此处看到的排名约有一半是基于真实身在当地的数字游民。你可以点击某个城市,也可以点击具体的人,从而看到那些确实身处该地的用户。目前这类用户大约有3万至4万人。所以,眼下这些人就在奥斯汀……

英文原文

So you started getting discrepancies in the data between where people were from and stuff. So I started switching to data sets and now it’s mostly data sets, but one thing that’s still crowdsourced is people add where they are, they add their travels to their profile and I use that data to see which places are upcoming and which places are popular now. So about half the ranking you see here is based on actual digital nomads who are there. You can click on a city, you can click on people and you can see the people, the users that are actually there. And it’s like 30,000, 40,000 members. So these people are in Austin now and…

Lex Fridman1:44:29

目前奥斯汀有1800名远程工作者,其中8名以上成员已签到,还有即将抵达并停留于此的成员。这太棒了。

英文原文

1,800 remote workers in Austin now, of which eight plus members checked in, members who will be here soon and go… This is amazing.

Pieter Levels1:44:36

是的,我们组织线下聚会。人们自行组织聚会,每月大概有30场左右,相当于每天一场。我本人几乎不参与组织,全由他们自主安排。整个过程就像一个‘黑箱’,自动运行,我几乎不用做什么。它从各处抓取数据,然后就自然运转起来了。

英文原文

Yeah. So we have meetups. So people organize their own meetups and we have about I think 30 per month. So it’s like one meetup a day and I don’t do anything. They organize themselves. So it’s a whole black box, it just runs and I don’t do a lot on it. It pulls data from everywhere and it just works.

Lex Fridman1:44:56

奥斯汀的缺点是生活成本太高、天气酷热、如今又特别潮湿,而且很难交到朋友。

英文原文

Cons of Austin is too expensive, very sweating, humid now, difficult to make friends.

Pieter Levels1:45:00

很难交到朋友?有意思,对吧?我之前还真不知道这一点。

英文原文

Difficult to make friends. Interesting, right? I didn’t know that.

Lex Fridman1:45:02

很难交到朋友。

英文原文

Difficult to make friends.

Pieter Levels1:45:04

在奥斯汀。

英文原文

In Austin.

Lex Fridman1:45:04

但这一切都是众包的,而且总体上优点居多。

英文原文

But this all crowd source but mostly it’s pros.

Pieter Levels1:45:07

是的,奥斯汀非常不错。

英文原文

Yeah. Austin’s very good.

Lex Fridman1:45:08

治安相当安全,网络速度很快。

英文原文

Pretty safe, fast internet.

Pieter Levels1:45:09

我不明白为什么数据显示‘对女性不安全’。请核查一下数据集。实际感受是安全的。美国这类国家的问题在于,安全性因地区而异。

英文原文

I don’t understand why it says not safe for women. Check the data set. It feels safe. The problem with a lot of places like United States is that it depends per area.

Lex Fridman1:45:18

是的。

英文原文

Yeah.

Pieter Levels1:45:18

因此,如果你只获取城市级或国家级的数据,就会像巴西那样——因为其安全与富裕程度差异极大,安全区域与不安全区域并存,所以整体数据极不可靠。你根本无法对巴西做出太多概括性判断。

英文原文

So if you get city level data or nation level data, it’s like Brazil is the worst because the range in safe and wealthy and not safe is huge. So you can’t say many things about Brazil.

Lex Fridman1:45:31

那么,当人们真正抵达某座城市后,你怎么确定具体哪个区域能获得高速网络呢?例如,对我而言,这始终是个令人头疼的难题:如何找到提供高速Wi-Fi的酒店?好吧,好吧。我抵达一座城市时,会面临大量引人入胜的难题,但我至今尚未找到切实可行的解决方案。每次抵达新城市,我都得琢磨:哪里能连上高速网络?而为播客录制考虑,我又该去哪里找一张安静、带桌子的场所?

英文原文

So once they actually show up to the city, how do you figure out what area, where to get fast internet? For example, for me it’s consistently a struggle to figure out. Hotels with fast wifi, for example. Okay, okay. I show up to a city, there’s a lot of fascinating puzzles and I haven’t figured out a way to actually solve this puzzle. When I show up to a city, figuring out where I can get fast internet connection, and for podcasting purposes, where I can find a place with a table that’s quiet.

Pieter Levels1:46:04

没错,是这样。

英文原文

Right. Yeah.

Lex Fridman1:46:05

这可不容易。

英文原文

That’s not easy.

Pieter Levels1:46:06

施工噪音。

英文原文

Construction sounds.

Lex Fridman1:46:07

各种各样的噪音。你逐渐学会辨识世界上所有类型的噪音来源,也了解房间的声学品质——房间越空旷,墙壁若没有窗帘或其他吸音材料,就越容易产生回声。总之,你还发现很多酒店根本没有桌子,也没有常规……

英文原文

All kinds of sounds. You get to learn about all the sources of sounds in the world and also the quality of the room because the more… The emptier the room, and if it’s just walls without any curtains or any of this kind of stuff, then there’s echoes in the room. Anyway, but you figure out that a lot of hotels don’t have tables. They don’t have normal…

Pieter Levels1:46:29

就是那种奇怪的写字台,对吧?

英文原文

It’s this weird desk, right?

Lex Fridman1:46:31

对。

英文原文

Yeah.

Pieter Levels1:46:31

不是那种放在房间中央的桌子。

英文原文

It’s not a center table.

Lex Fridman1:46:33

对。而如果你想入住更宽敞、更高级的酒店,它们通常配备所谓‘精品风’‘现代主义风格’的时髦桌子,但这些桌子……

英文原文

Yeah. And if you want to get a nicer hotel where it’s more spacious and so on, they usually have these boutique fancy looking like modernist tables that don’t…

Pieter Levels1:46:33

对,设计感太强了。

英文原文

Yeah. It’s too design-y.

Lex Fridman1:46:44

设计感太强了,根本算不上真正实用的桌子。

英文原文

It’s too design-y. They’re not really real tables.

Pieter Levels1:46:47

那要是买宜家(IKEA)的呢?

英文原文

What if you get IKEA?

Lex Fridman1:46:49

买宜家的?

英文原文

Buy IKEA?

Pieter Levels1:46:50

对,出发前就下单订购宜家家具。数字游民真这么干,他们会专门购置书桌。

英文原文

Yeah. Before you arrive, you order an IKEA. Nomads do this. They get desks.

Lex Fridman1:46:54

我觉得,你抵达一个地方后理应直接拥有书桌,除非你打算长期居住。整套组装流程实在太麻烦了。爱彼迎(Airbnb)极不可靠,房源质量参差不齐,落差巨大。酒店同样问题重重,优缺点并存。酒店的一大问题是:宣传图片往往根本不能真实反映房间实际情况。

英文原文

I feel like you should be able to show up to a place and have the desk unless you stay in there for a long time. Just the entire assembly, all that. Airbnb is so unreliable. The range in quality that you get is huge. Hotels have a lot of problems, pros and cons. Hotels have the problem that the pictures somehow never have good representative pictures of what’s actually going to be in the room.

Pieter Levels1:47:19

这的确是个问题。全是假照片啊,老兄。

英文原文

And that’s a problem. Fake photos, man.

Lex Fridman1:47:23

要是我能拥有Nomad List网站上那种针对酒店的详细数据就好了。

英文原文

If I could have the kind of data you have on Nomad List for hotels.

Pieter Levels1:47:26

是啊,老兄。

英文原文

Yeah, man.

Lex Fridman1:47:28

而且我觉得,靠这个也能赚大钱。

英文原文

And I feel like you can make a lot of money on that too.

Pieter Levels1:47:30

对,预订佣金、联盟营销,没错?我早想过这个点子,因为我们自己也面临同样的问题。我去住酒店时,有些特定酒店口碑极佳,我现在已熟悉某些连锁品牌等信息;但即便同属一个连锁品牌,在不同城市的表现也可能天差地别——某城市表现极差,另一城市却极好。

英文原文

Yeah, the booking fees, affiliate, right? I thought about this idea because we have the same problem. I go to hotels and there’s specific ones that are very good and I know now the chains and stuff, but even if you go to… Some chains are very bad in a specific city and very good in other cities.

Lex Fridman1:47:44

而且每家酒店内部房型种类繁多:有的价格高,有的便宜,等等。但你却无法获知房间内具体配置、真实布局,甚至看不到房间视野如何。

英文原文

And each individual hotel has a lot of kinds of rooms. Some are more expensive, some are cheaper and so on. But you can get the details of what’s in the room, what’s the actual layout of the room, what is the view of the room.

Pieter Levels1:47:58

用三维扫描。

英文原文

3D scan it.

Lex Fridman1:47:58

我觉得,对酒店而言,这是个绝佳的突破口。首先,打造一项服务,为酒店提供高分辨率的详细数据;接着,只要有一家酒店签约采用这项服务,我就百分百会用这个网站订酒店,而不是用那些毫无信息量的糟糕替代方案。届时,其他酒店将面临巨大压力,不得不纷纷加入该平台;而你则能大赚特赚,毕竟酒店行业利润丰厚。

英文原文

I feel like as a hotel you can win a lot. So first you create a service that allows you to have high resolution data about a hotel. Then one hotel signs up for that. I would 100% use that website to look for a hotel instead of the crappy alternatives that don’t give any information. And I feel like there’ll be this pressure for all the hotels to join that site and you can make a shit ton of money because hotels make a lot of money.

Pieter Levels1:48:24

我觉得这话没错,但问题在于:酒店业如此,航空业亦然。为何你在航空公司官网上订机票时,体验总是那么糟糕?这实在很奇怪。为何非得如此糟糕?显然存在市场竞争,那为何最优秀的网站没能胜出?

英文原文

I think it’s true, but the problem is with these hotels, it’s same with airline industry. Why does every airline website suck when you try book a flight? It’s very strange. Why does it have to suck? Obviously there’s competition here. Why doesn’t the best website win?

Lex Fridman1:48:35

这种现象背后的解释是什么?

英文原文

What’s the explanation for that?

Pieter Levels1:48:36

老兄,这个问题我思考多年了。我认为原因在于:我无论如何都得订机票,我知道某条航线必须经由卡塔尔航空(Qatar Airways)承运,我只能硬着头皮走完这套流程。酒店预订也是类似情况:我终究得订一间酒店。那你有时间去精挑细选最好的一家吗?其实并没有。你只是急需把住宿和航班搞定,哪怕忍受整个流程的痛苦也在所不惜。正因如此,酒店和航空公司官网的预订流程才总是如此糟糕——它们缺乏改进动力,因为只有面向超高消费人群(比如顶级奢华客户)时,用户体验才真正影响实际预订决策。

英文原文

Man, I’ve thought about this for years. So I think it’s like I have to book the flight anyway. I know there’s a route that they take and I need to book, for example, Qatar Airlines and I need to get through this process. And with hotels, similar. You need a hotel anyway. So do you have time to figure out the best one? Not really. You kind of just need to get the place booked and you need to get the flight and you’ll go through the pain of this process. And that’s why this process always sucks so much with hotels and airline websites and stuff because they don’t have an incentive to improve it because generally only for a super upper segment of the market I think like super high luxury, it affects the actual booking.

Lex Fridman1:49:17

我不确定。我觉得这是个有趣的理论,但应该另有解释。我的观点是:优秀软件工程师根本不被允许修改系统。本质上存在某种官僚体制,管理层级过多,官僚主义严重。顶尖工程师入职后,试图开展工作,却完全不被允许做出实质性贡献,最终只能离职。于是公司只剩大量平庸的软件工程师,他们对改进任何东西都毫无兴趣。

英文原文

I don’t know. I think that’s an interesting theory. I think that must be a different theory. My theory would be that great software engineers are not allowed to make changes. Basically there’s some kind of bureaucracy,. There’s way too many managers. There’s a lot of bureaucracy and great engineers show up, they try to work there and they’re not allowed to really make any contributions and then they leave. And so they have a lot of mediocre software engineers. They’re not really interested in improving any other thing.

Lex Fridman1:49:45

事实上,他们本意是想改进系统,但受制于公司的官僚体制,加上所有老板、高层管理者很可能都不是技术出身,既不懂网页开发,也不懂编程,因而根本不予尊重。你必须给予顶尖工程师充分的自由与尊重,让他们放手去做伟大的事情。这似乎才是合理解释。假如你是一位顶尖程序员,你愿意去美国航空(American Airlines)工作吗?……

英文原文

And literally they would like to improve the stuff, but the bureaucracy of the place, plus all the bosses, all the high up people are not technical people probably. They don’t know much about web development. They don’t know much about programming, so they just don’t give any respect. You have to give the freedom and the respect to great engineers as they try to do great things. That feels like an explanation. If you were a great programmer, would you want to work at America Airlines or…

Pieter Levels1:50:16

不,绝对不。

英文原文

No. No.

Lex Fridman1:50:19

我对此有点纠结,因为我本人热爱编程,反而特别想去美国航空工作,亲手把系统变好。

英文原文

I’m torn on that because I actually, as somebody who loves program, would love to work at America Airlines so I can make the thing better.

Pieter Levels1:50:27

是的,我入职也纯粹是为了自己修复它。

英文原文

Yeah. But I would work there just to fix it for myself.

Lex Fridman1:50:30

对,为了自己。然后你就清楚自己消除了多少痛苦、缓解了多少挫败感……

英文原文

Yeah, for yourself. And then you just know how much suffering you’re alleviated, how much frustration-

Pieter Levels1:50:37

为全社会。

英文原文

For all society.

Lex Fridman1:50:38

试想成千上万、甚至数以百万计的人访问那个网站,不得不反复点击无数次;网站常常失灵,操作笨拙不堪……你让他们的生活变得轻松太多了。

英文原文

You imagine all the thousands, maybe millions of people that go to that website and have to click a million times. It often doesn’t work. It’s clunky, all that kind of stuff. You’re making their life just so much better.

Pieter Levels1:50:38

轻松太多了。

英文原文

Much better.

Lex Fridman1:50:50

是的。但一定还存在另一种解释,根源在于管理层和官僚体制。

英文原文

Yeah. But there must be an explanation that has to do with managers and bureaucracies.

Pieter Levels1:50:54

我觉得根源还是钱。你知道Booking.com(缤客网)吗?

英文原文

I think it’s money. Do you know Booking.com?

Lex Fridman1:50:57

当然知道。

英文原文

Sure.

Pieter Levels1:50:58

它是全球最大的酒店预订网站,总部在荷兰。我有位朋友曾在那儿工作,据他介绍,他们按网站局部划分团队,比如专门负责一个10×10像素区域,并持续对该区域进行A/B测试。他们以此类测试闻名,例如用红色字体显示‘仅剩一间房!立即预订!’,结果因此被欧盟开罚单,挺有意思的。

英文原文

So it’s the biggest booking website in the world. It’s Dutch actually. And they have teams because my friend worked there. They have teams for a specific part of the website, like a 10 by 10 pixels area where they run tests on this. So they run tests and they’re famous for this stuff like, “Oh, there’s only one room left,” which is red letters like, “One room left. Book now.” And they got a fine from the European Union about this. Kind of interesting.

Pieter Levels1:51:21

他们拥有众多此类团队,连续24小时运行测试;团队成员睡觉,第二天醒来上班,再查看测试结果:‘哦,这个版本效果更好。’这个网站已演变成一头‘巨兽’,却是全球营收最高的酒店预订网站,稳居榜首。这说明,网站成败关键并非用户体验,而是——我不知道该怎么说——归根结底是赚钱,未必每家公司都如此,但若一家上市公司以盈利为唯一优化目标……

英文原文

So they have all these teams and they run the test for 24 hours. They go to sleep, they wake up next day, they come to the office and they see, “Okay, this performed better.” This website has become a monster, but it’s the most revenue generating hotel booking website in the world. It’s number one. So that shows that it’s not about user experience. It’s about, I don’t know, about making more money and not every company, but if they’re optimizing, it’s a public company. If they’re optimizing for money…

Lex Fridman1:51:47

但你完全可以通过颠覆式创新、大幅提升体验来实现盈利优化。

英文原文

But you can optimize for money by disrupting, making it way better.

Pieter Levels1:51:50

是啊,但这种情况总是反复出现……它们一开始都是靠颠覆起家的。Booking 最初就是一家初创公司,成立于 1997 年,后来却渐渐又变成了那种陈旧的老套路。Uber 现在也开始变得跟出租车一样了。它刚起步时非常棒,但现在在很多地方,传统出租车反而比 Uber 更好——更舒适、更友善。所以这就像是一个轮回。

英文原文

Yeah, but this always started… They start with disrupting. Booking all started as a startup, 1997, and then they become the old shit again. Uber now starts to become like a taxi again. It was very good in the beginning. Now it’s kind like taxis now in many places are better. They’re nicer than Ubers. So it’s like the circle.

Lex Fridman1:52:08

我觉得其中一部分原因也在于:要招到超一流的工程师确实很难。Stripe 看起来似乎很简单,但真正做出来却极难。为什么亚马逊连‘一键下单’这种在我看来堪称天才的想法都迟迟难以实现?它的核心就是让购买变得更简单,尽可能减少摩擦——只需点一下按钮,在一个页面内就完成购买;而当时大多数网站却需要大量点击,而且常常失败,比如订机票时就经常出问题。

英文原文

I think some of it is also just it’s hard to have ultra competent engineers. Stripe seems like a trivial thing, but it’s hard to pull off. Why was it so hard for Amazon to have buy with one click, which I think is a genius idea. Make buying easier. Make it as frictionless as possible. Just click a button, one scene, you bought the thing, as opposed to most of the web was a lot of clicking and it often doesn’t work like with the airlines.

Pieter Levels1:52:39

你还记得那些带‘删除’按钮的表单吗?你点‘下一步’或‘提交’,结果弹出 404 错误,或者你的网络直接断掉,调制解调器死机。是啊,老兄。

英文原文

You remember the forms with delete? You could click next, submit and with 404 or something or your internet would go down, your modem. Yeah, man.

Lex Fridman1:52:47

那时我甚至会陷入存在主义危机——挫败感会席卷我的全身,让我在那一瞬间真想放弃人生。是啊。

英文原文

And I would have an existential crisis. The frustration would take over my whole body and I would just want to quit life for a brief moment there. Yeah.

Pieter Levels1:52:56

现在我很开心,如果出了什么问题,Google Chrome 会自动保留表单内容。不过,得感谢谷歌的某位工程师,是他们用这个功能造福了社会,对吧?

英文原文

I’m so happy the form stays in Google Chrome now if something goes wrong. But Google somebody at Google and prove society with that, right?

Lex Fridman1:53:03

是啊。而谷歌面临的一个挑战,恰恰就是如何保有这样做的自由度。

英文原文

Yeah. And one of the challenges at Google is to have the freedom to do that.

Pieter Levels1:53:08

他们现在已经没有这种自由了。

英文原文

They don’t anymore.

Lex Fridman1:53:09

那里有一大堆官僚流程,没错。

英文原文

There’s a bunch of bureaucracy, yeah.

Pieter Levels1:53:09

在谷歌内部。

英文原文

At Google.

Lex Fridman1:53:11

那里聚集了太多太多极其聪明的人才,但整个公司运转就是很慢。

英文原文

There’s so many brilliant, brilliant people there, but it just moves slowly.

Pieter Levels1:53:16

是啊。

英文原文

Yeah.

Lex Fridman1:53:16

我在想这背后的原因是什么,也许这本就是一家公司发展到一定阶段后的自然状态;但像埃隆·马斯克这样的人一进来,就直接裁掉大部分员工,始终逼着公司保持初创企业的运作方式,哪怕公司早已规模庞大。

英文原文

I wonder why that is and maybe that’s the natural way of a company, but you have people like Elon who rolls in and just fires most of the folks and always push the company to operate as a startup even when it’s already big.

Pieter Levels1:53:29

但苹果就是这样做的。我读商学院时就了解到:苹果内部设有相互竞争的产品团队,这些团队都按初创公司模式运作——每个团队三到五人,各自开发同一类产品,最终由表现最好的团队胜出。所以我认为,要在公司内部模拟自由市场机制,才能激发创业精神;而唯有具备创业心态,公司才能持续提出新想法,并把事情做得更好。

英文原文

But Apple does this. I started in business school. Apple does competing product teams that operate as startups. So it’s three to five people, they make something, they have multiple teams make the same thing. The best team wins. So I think you need to emulate a free market inside a company to make it entrepreneurial. And you need entrepreneurial mentality in a company to come up with new ideas and do it better.

Lex Fridman1:53:52

所以,你特别擅长的一件事,就是快速学习新东西。你有了一个想法,就尝试把它做出来;为了实现它,你会去学所有必需的知识。你已有当前技能,但只学刚好够用的最少内容。因此,你正是最适合回答‘如何学习’这个问题的人——怎样才能快速、高效、精准地掌握所需知识?举个例子,你曾做过一次为期 30 天的 3D 学习计划,全程记录自己,限定自己只用 30 天时间尽可能多地掌握 3D 相关知识。

英文原文

So one of the things you do really, really well is learn a new thing. You have an idea, you try to build it, and then you learn everything you need to in order to build it. You have your current skills, but you learn just the minimal amount of stuff. So you’re a good person to ask how do you learn? How do you learn quickly and effectively and just the stuff you need? Just by way of example, you did a 30 days learning session on 3D where you documented yourself giving yourself only 30 days to learn everything you can about 3D.

Pieter Levels1:54:25

是啊,我当时想学虚拟现实,因为那和人工智能一样,是在 2016、2017 年突然兴起的——我记得是 HTC Vive 这类大型 VR 眼镜(早于苹果 Vision Pro)问世的时候。我当时就想:‘哦,这肯定要火,我得赶紧学。’但我对 3D 完全一窍不通。于是我就装了 Unity 和 Blender 之类的软件,开始自学所有相关内容,因为我认定这是一种刚刚萌芽、未来必将大放异彩的新技术;如果我能掌握相关技能,就能用它来构建产品。所以说到学习这件事,我觉得特别有意思——人们总问我:‘你怎么学编程的?我该不该学编程?’我只能回答:‘我不知道。’我每天都在学习,这话虽老套,但千真万确:我每天都在学新东西。

英文原文

Yeah, I tried to learn virtual reality because this was same as AI. It came up suddenly 2016, 2017 with I think HTC Vive, these big VR glasses before Apple Vision Pro. And I was like, “Oh, this is going to be big so I need to learn this.” And I know nothing about 3D. I installed I think Unity and Blender and stuff, and I started learning all this stuff because I thought this was a new nascent technology that was going to be big. And if I had the skills for it, I could use this to build stuff. And so I think with learning, for me, I think learning is so funny because people always ask me, “How do you learn to code? Should I learn to code?” And I’m like, “I don’t know.” Every day I’m learning. It’s kind of cliche, but every day I’m learning new stuff.

Pieter Levels1:55:08

所以我每天都会在 Google 上搜索,或者向 ChatGPT 提问:‘这个怎么弄?那个怎么搞?’每天我都在提升自己的技能水平。学习永无止境。所以所谓‘如何学习’这个问题,答案其实就是:你永远不会结束学习。那么,你想学到什么程度?只想略知一二?还是想深入掌握?抑或打算终身学习?

英文原文

So every day I’m searching on Google or asking out ChatGPT how to do this thing, how to do this thing. Every day I’m getting better at my skill. So you never stop learning. So the whole concept of how do you learn, well, you never end. So where do you want to be? Do you want know a little bit? Do you want to know a lot? Do you want to do it for your whole life?

Pieter Levels1:55:25

所以我认为,付诸行动才是学习的最佳起点——也就是动手去做。你什么都不会?那就直接开干!比如,‘怎么建一个网站?’——上网搜‘怎么建网站’,或者现在直接问 ChatGPT:‘怎么建网站?从哪儿开始?’它会为你生成代码。你复制代码,粘贴进一个文件并保存,再用 Google Chrome 或其他浏览器打开——一个网站就诞生了!接着你就可以开始调整:‘好,怎么加个按钮?现在怎么加入 AI 功能?’所以说,通过实际行动,你学东西的速度远超阅读书籍或教程。

英文原文

So I think taking action is the best step to learn. So making things. You know nothing, just start making things. Okay, so how to make a website. Search how to make a website or nowadays you ask ChatGPT, “How do I make a website? Where do I start?” It generates codes for you. Copy the code, put it in a file, save it. Open it in Google Chrome or whatever. You have a website and then you start tweaking with it and you start, “Okay, how do I add a button? How do I add AI features nowadays?” So it’s like by taking action, you can learn stuff much faster than reading books or tutorials.

Lex Fridman1:55:57

其实我一直很好奇,让我问问 Perplexity:‘怎么建一个网站?’我只是好奇它会怎么回答。我希望它给出的是最基础、最原生的方案:先明确网站用途,再选域名,然后挑一个网页托管服务商;接着选择网站构建工具或 CMS(内容管理系统),比如 Wix。

英文原文

Actually I’m always curious. Let me ask perplexity. How do I make a website? I’m just curious what it would say. I hope it goes with really basic vanilla solutions. Define your website’s purpose, choose a domain name, select a web hosting provider. Choose a website, a builder or a CMS website. Build a platform. Wix.

Pieter Levels1:56:20

它推荐的是 Wix 或 Squarespace,还说要做一个落地页。

英文原文

It tells Wix or Squarespace is what I said. Make a landing page.

Lex Fridman1:56:23

那如果我想自己编程呢?它说:先设计网站,再创建必要页面。

英文原文

How do I say if I want to program it myself? Design your website, create essential pages.

Pieter Levels1:56:29

是啊,它甚至还会告诉你上线之后该怎么做——比如开始推广。

英文原文

Yeah. Even tells you to launch it, right? Start promoting it.

Lex Fridman1:56:31

上线你的网站。嗯,这当然可以做到。

英文原文

Launch your website. Well, you could do that.

Pieter Levels1:56:34

是啊,但这就是全部了。

英文原文

Yeah, but this is literally it.

Lex Fridman1:56:34

如果你想建一个网站的话。

英文原文

If you want to make a website.

Pieter Levels1:56:35

这就像最基本的 Google Analytics(谷歌分析)一样。

英文原文

This is the basic like Google Analytics.

Lex Fridman1:56:38

但你用这种网站建不出 Nomad List(游牧者清单)。

英文原文

But you can’t make Nomad Lists with this web.

Pieter Levels1:56:38

你可以。

英文原文

You can.

Lex Fridman1:56:41

用 Wix 就行。

英文原文

With Wix.

Pieter Levels1:56:43

不,我觉得用它能做到的程度其实相当高。

英文原文

No, you can get pretty far, I think.

Lex Fridman1:56:43

确实能走得很远。

英文原文

You get pretty far.

Pieter Levels1:56:45

现在的网站构建工具已经相当先进了,你只需要做一个可点击图片的网格布局,点击后跳转到另一个页面即可。

英文原文

Website builders are pretty advanced. All you need is a grid of images that are clickable that open another page.

Lex Fridman1:56:51

是啊。

英文原文

Yeah.

Pieter Levels1:56:52

你能做到的程度其实相当高。

英文原文

You can get quite far.

Lex Fridman1:56:53

那我该怎么学编程?先选一门编程语言入门。

英文原文

How do I learn to program? Choose a programming language to start with.

Pieter Levels1:57:03

FreeCodeCamp(免费代码营)挺不错。

英文原文

FreeCodeCamp is good.

Lex Fridman1:57:07

按主题系统性地学习各类资源;坚持每天练习编码 30 到 60 分钟,持之以恒是关键;加入编程社区,比如 Reddit 上的相关板块……是啊,是啊,这些建议挺靠谱的。

英文原文

Work through resources thematically. Practice coding regularly for 30, 60 minutes a day. Consistency is key. Join programming communities like Reddit’s… Yeah. Yeah, it’s pretty good.

Pieter Levels1:57:20

是啊。

英文原文

Yeah.

Lex Fridman1:57:20

挺靠谱的。

英文原文

It’s pretty good.

Pieter Levels1:57:21

所以我觉得这是个非常好的起点——试想你对一切一无所知,却想建一个网站、想创办一家公司。正因如此,AI 在教育领域的潜力将无比惊人:世界各地的任何人都能提出这个问题,并立刻开始动手构建。

英文原文

So I think it’s a very good starting ground because imagine you know nothing and you want to make a website, you want to make a startup. That’s why, man, the power of AI for education is going to be insane. People anywhere can ask this question and start building stuff.

Lex Fridman1:57:37

是啊,它确实能把事情讲清楚。而且只要开始动手建,持续不断地建、建、建!实际上就是应用所学,无论是 AI 还是网页开发相关的编程。关键是心里要有一个具体项目,比如我特别喜欢‘一年打造 12 家初创公司’这个想法,或者几乎每天都做一个小项目——每天建一个东西,让它跑起来,再把它做完。这真是个酷炫的实验。

英文原文

Yeah, it clarifies it for sure. And just start building, keep build, build. Actually apply the thing, whether it’s AI or any of the programming for web development. Just have a project in mind, which I love the idea of 12 startups in 12 months or build a project almost every day. Just build a thing and get it to work and finish it every single day. That’s a cool experiment.

Pieter Levels1:58:05

我觉得这正是灵感来源:曾有个女孩在 160 天里做了 160 个网站——全是迷你网站,她就是这么学会编程的。所以给自己设定挑战很有意义。你可以去参加某个编程训练营,但我认为这类训练营实际效果并不理想;对我而言,更有效的方式是在完全零基础的情况下自主学习,主动设定挑战,直接上手实践。但你必须有自律性,必须坚持下去。而编程本身……门槛真的很高,入门特别难,而且特别让人烦躁——跟电脑打交道本身就特别烦人,所以很多人很难坚持下去。

英文原文

I think that was the inspiration. There was a girl who did 160 websites in 160 days or something, literally mini websites, and she learned to code that way. So I think it’s good to set yourself challenges. You can go to some coding bootcamp, but I don’t think they actually work. I think it’s better to do for me out of the dark self-learning and setting yourself challenges and just getting in. But you need discipline. You need discipline to keep doing it. And coding, coding is very… It’s a steep learning curve to get in. It’s very annoying. Working with computers is very annoying, so it can be hard for people to keep doing it.

Lex Fridman1:58:45

是啊,那种‘咬牙坚持、绝不放弃’的劲头,以及完成一件事所必需的紧迫感,正是其强大之处。所以当你把 Hood Maps(街区地图)的创作过程或一个可运行原型的开发过程全程记录下来时,那种持续不断的挫败感就格外真实——大概就是不断自问:‘这该怎么弄?’然后去查资料,恍然大悟:‘哦,原来是这样。’接着你要从各种可选方案中做出判断,然后动手尝试;最后当它真的跑通时,那种多巴胺飙升的感觉就是:‘成了!酷!’

英文原文

Yeah. That thing of just keep doing it and don’t quit, that urgency that’s required to finish a thing. That’s why it’s really powerful when you documented this, the creation of Hood Maps or a working prototype that there’s just a constant frustration, I guess. It’s like, “How do I do this?” And then you look it up and you’re like, “Okay.” You have to interpret the different options you have and then just try it. And then there’s a dopamine rush of like, “It works. Cool.”

Pieter Levels1:59:16

老天,太神奇了!我还做了直播,视频传到了 YouTube 等平台,大家都能看。当事情真的成功运行时,那种感觉简直不可思议。你看,我从不往远处想,只盯着眼前:‘下一个要解决的问题是什么?’然后是下一个……到最后,你就做出了一个完整的 App、网站,或者别的什么东西。但大多数人却总爱往太远的地方看——就像那张海报说的:你根本不知道前方有多难,所以只管关注下一步、下一个微小挑战、下一个具体步骤,然后看看最终会走到哪里。

英文原文

Man, it’s amazing. And I live streamed it. It’s on YouTube and stuff. People can watch it and it’s amazing when things work. Look, it’s just amazing that I don’t look far ahead. So I only look, okay, what’s the next problem to solve? And then the next problem. And at the end you have a whole app or website or thing. But I think most people look way too far ahead. It’s like this poster again. You don’t know hard it’s going to be so you should only look for the next thing, the next little challenge, the next step, and then see where you end up.

Lex Fridman1:59:49

并且默认它会很容易。

英文原文

And assume it’s going to be easy.

Pieter Levels1:59:52

是啊,完全正确。就得抱着这种天真心态,因为你注定会遇到极其困难的问题。而且很多大难题根本不是技术问题,而是公共关系问题——比如可能有人不喜欢你的网站,甚至就因为一个网站你就被全网抵制了。各种意外都可能发生。

英文原文

Yeah, exactly. Be naive about it because you’re going to have very difficult problems. A lot of the big problems won’t be even technology, will be public. Maybe people don’t like your website. You’ll get canceled for a website for example. A lot of things can happen.

Lex Fridman2:00:06

那么,像你这样公开地、透明地进行开发——快速迭代、实时获取用户反馈——体验究竟如何?一方面,这的确能发挥众包的力量;但另一方面,人们也能随时对你进行批评,这又带来了负面效应。

英文原文

What’s it like building in public you do openly where you’re just iterating quickly and you’re getting people’s feedback? So there’s the power of the crowdsourcing, but there’s also the negative aspects of people being able to criticize.

Pieter Levels2:00:20

所以啊,哥们儿,我觉得黑子其实挺好的,因为我觉得很多黑子讲得还挺有道理。关键在于你要从‘你这网站烂透了, blah blah blah’这种情绪化表达中抽身出来,冷静想想:‘好吧,那就把这个删掉。’——‘你这网站烂透了,因为……个人原因?’他到底说了啥?他为啥不喜欢?然后你琢磨出来:哦,他不喜欢是因为注册流程太麻烦,或者数据有问题。他们说:‘不,这些数据不准确。’那我就得提升数据质量。这个黑子说得有道理,完全无视黑子确实很傻。而且啊,哥们儿,我小时候十岁左右那会儿也干过这事——上网瞎嚷嚷些疯狂的东西,现在推特上大部分、或者说一半的用户,不就都这样嘛。所以你得带着点怀疑态度去看。对,哥们儿,你在推特(X)上真得练就一身厚脸皮。但我屏蔽了很多人。最近我查了下,发现自己已经屏蔽了整整一万五千人。所以十年下来,我屏蔽了一万五千人。这就相当于……

英文原文

So man, I think haters are actually good because I think a lot of haters have good points and it takes stepping away from the emotion of your website sucks because blah, blah, blah. And you’re like, “Okay, just remove this.” Your website sucks because personal. What did he say? Why did he not like it? And you figure out, okay, he didn’t like it because the signup was difficult or something or the data. They say, no, this data is not accurate or something. I need to improve the quality of data. This hater has a point because it’s dumb to completely ignore your haters. And also, man, I think I’ve been there when I was 10 years old or something. You’re on the internet. You’re just shouting crazy stuff. That’s like most of Twitter or half of Twitter. So you have to take it with a grain of salt. Yeah, man, you need to grow a very thick skin on Twitter, on X. But I mute a lot of people. I found out I muted already 15,000 people recently. I checked,\. So in 10 years I muted 15,000 people. So that’s like…

Lex Fridman2:01:16

是一个一个手动屏蔽的?

英文原文

That’s one by one manual?

Pieter Levels2:01:18

是的。

英文原文

Yeah.

Lex Fridman2:01:18

哇哦。

英文原文

Oh wow.

Pieter Levels2:01:19

所以平均每年屏蔽一千五百人。我不喜欢拉黑,因为拉黑会惹人生气——他们截个图到处发:‘啊,他把我拉黑了!’所以我只静音,静音之后对方就彻底消失了,效果简直棒极了。

英文原文

So 1,500 people per year. And I don’t like to block because then they get angry. They make a screenshot and they say, “Ah, you blocked me.” So I just mute and it disappear and it’s amazing.

Lex Fridman2:01:29

你刚才提到了Reddit。那么《Hood Maps》有没有登上Reddit首页?

英文原文

So you mentioned Reddit. So Hood Maps, did that make it to the front page of Reddit?

Pieter Levels2:01:34

有,有,真的登上了!真的登上了!太震撼了!我的服务器差点崩掉,我当时看Google Analytics,发现网站同时在线人数达到五千人左右,简直疯狂。而且还是在深夜,太震撼了!哥们儿,说实话,如今TikTok、YouTube Shorts、Instagram Reels这些平台,很多应用就是靠别人拍TikTok视频给带火的。比如说你自己开发了个App,完全可以自己拍个视频:‘哦,这是我做的App,它这么运作,blah blah blah,我做它的原因比如是……,以及你为啥该用它。’如果视频质量够好,它就会爆红,你就能……哥们儿,我单靠一条TikTok视频,每月多赚了两万美元左右。结果成了个‘照片 guy’(指视频里出镜的拍摄者)。

英文原文

Yeah. Yeah, it did. Yeah, yeah, yeah. It did. It was amazing. And my server almost went down and I was checking Google Analytics was like 5,000 people on the website or something crazy. And it was at night and it was amazing. Man, I think nowadays, honestly, TikTok, YouTube reels, Instagram reels, a lot of apps get very big from people making TikTok videos about it. So let’s say you make your own app, you can make a video for yourself like, “Oh, I made this app. This is how it works, blah, blah, blah, and this is why I made it, for example, and this is why you should use it.” And if it’s a good video, it will take off and you will get… Man, I got $20,000 extra per month or something from one TikTok video. It made a photo guy.

Lex Fridman2:02:18

是您自己拍的,还是别人拍的?

英文原文

By you or somebody else by somebody else?

Pieter Levels2:02:19

是某个素不相识的路人拍的。现在有一大堆AI领域的网红,他们专门测评AI应用,等视频爆火后就开口要钱——比如‘你再发一条类似视频,给我四千美元’之类的。我就回一句:‘行吧。’我就真这么干过,但确实管用。TikTok是目前用户获取和自然增长(organic growth)方面非常大的平台。我认为最好的用户获取方式就是自然增长——你不用买广告,尤其创业初期你很可能根本没钱投广告。所以要么走自然增长路线,要么发几条爆款推文(tweets),也能让App一炮而红。

英文原文

By some random guy. So there’s all these AI influencers that they write about. They show AI apps and then they ask money later when a video goes viral. All I can do, do it again and send me $4,000 or something. I’m like, ” Okay.” I did that, for example. But it works. TikTok is a very big platform for user acquisition and organic. The best user acquisition I think is organic. You don’t need to buy ads. You probably don’t have money when you start to buy ads. So use organic or write a banger tweets that can make an app take off as well.

Lex Fridman2:02:50

嗯,没错,本质上就是先做出酷炫的东西,再积累一点点粉丝基础,让这个酷炫的东西被人注意到;只要它足够酷,自然就会病毒式传播。

英文原文

Well, yeah, fundamentally create cool stuff and have just a little bit of a following enough for the cool thing to be noticed. And then it becomes viral if it’s cool enough.

Pieter Levels2:03:00

对。而且你现在在X(原Twitter)或很多其他平台上,也不需要太多粉丝了。TikTok、X,还有Instagram Reels,我觉得现在算法都差不多——不再看你有多少粉丝,而是先拿你的内容小范围测试,比如推给三百人;如果反响好,就再推给一千人,以此类推。所以只要内容本身够好,它自己就会火起来,不管你有五十万粉丝、一千粉丝,还是更多。

英文原文

Yeah. And you don’t need a lot of followers anymore on X and a lot of platforms because TikTok, X, I think it’s Instagram reels also, they have the same algorithm now. It’s not about followers anymore. It’s about they test your content on a small subset, like 300 people. If they like, it’ll get tested to a thousand people and on and on. So if the thing is good, it will rise anyway. It doesn’t matter if you have half a million followers or a thousand followers or more.

Lex Fridman2:03:24

您关于变现的哲学是什么?也就是,怎么从自己打造的产品里赚钱?

英文原文

What’s your philosophy of monetizing, how to make money from the thing you build?

Pieter Levels2:03:27

是这样的,很多新手采用免费用户模式——你可以免费注册并使用App,但这招在我这儿一直不太灵,因为我觉得免费用户基本不会转化付费。如果你有风投资金,搞免费用户倒是有道理:你可以拿融资的钱投广告,精准预测多少人会转化、能带来多少用户,再给他们免费试用期等等,最后促成注册。但你必须把这套转化流程打磨得极其成熟,才能让它真正跑通——而这非常难。

英文原文

Yeah. So a lot of starters, they do free users, so you could sign up and could use an app for free, which it never worked for me well because I think free users generally don’t convert. And I think if you have VC funding, it makes sense to get free users because you can spend your funding on ads and you can get millions of people come in predictably how much they convert and give them a free trial, whatever, and then they sign up. But you need to have that flow worked out so well for you to make it work that you need… It’s very difficult.

Pieter Levels2:03:57

我觉得最好的办法,就是一开始就直接向用户收钱。比如在落地页(landing page)上清晰展示你的App、你在做什么;做个演示,或者录个视频。然后告诉用户:‘想用?付钱吧。’十美元、二十美元、四十美元都行。我一般会定得比十美元/月高些,像Netflix那样十美元/月——但Netflix是巨头公司,它有能力把价格压得相对便宜。而如果你是个独立开发者(indie hacker),自己一个人开发App,那你每个用户至少得赚三十美元甚至更多,才值得你投入时间精力,你得靠它赚钱。

英文原文

I think it’s best to start and just start asking people for money in the beginning. So show your app, what are you doing on your landing page. Make a demo, whatever, video. And then if you want to use it, pay me money. Pay $10, $20, $40. I would ask more than $10 per month like Netflix, $10 per month. But Netflix is giant company. They can afford to make it so cheap, relatively cheap. If you’re an individual like an indie hacker, you are making your own app. You need to make at least $30 or more on a user to make it worth it for you. You need to make money.

Lex Fridman2:04:31

而且这样还能建立起一个真正关心你产品的用户社群。

英文原文

And it builds a community of people that actually really care about the product.

Pieter Levels2:04:34

对,另外,建社群现在也很普遍,比如建个Discord服务器。现在每个AI应用几乎都有自己的Discord,开发者和用户都在里面,一起提需求、一起共建,这已经非常常规了。你要意识到,刚开始创业时,哪怕只拉到一千个用户,难度都非常大;同样,哪怕只做到一千次页面浏览(page views),也很难。但如果你向这一千个用户每人收三十美元,一个月就是三万美元,这可是一大笔钱。

英文原文

Also, yeah, making a community like making a Discord is very normal now. Every AI app has a Discord and you have the developers and the users together in a Discord, and they ask for features. They build together. It’s very normal now. And you need to imagine if you’re starting out, getting a thousand users is quite difficult. Getting a thousand pages is quite difficult. And if you charge them like $30, you have 30K a month and it’s a lot of money.

Lex Fridman2:04:59

这笔钱足够……

英文原文

That’s enough to…

Pieter Levels2:05:00

过上不错的生活了。

英文原文

Live a good life.

Lex Fridman2:05:01

对,能过得相当不错。当然,托管(hosting)之类也会产生不少成本。

英文原文

Yeah, live a pretty good life. That could be a lot of costs associated with hosting.

Pieter Levels2:05:04

对,这是另一件事。我确保自己的利润率非常高,所以尽量把成本压到最低:我不雇人;我现在还试着跟AI服务商谈价,问他们:‘能不能便宜点?’我才发现原来可以这么做——直接发邮件给公司:‘能给个折扣吗?太贵了。’他们回:‘行,打五折。’我心想:‘哇,太好了!’我以前都不知道这事,原来直接开口问就行。尤其是现在经济有点衰退,你更可以直接跟公司说:‘我需要折扣。’没必要态度恶劣,可以说:‘我需要折扣,不然可能得换别家了。这里一点、那里一点,能给点优惠吗?’他们往往答应——很多公司真会给25%或50%的折扣。因为你总以为官网上标的价格就是API之类服务的最终定价,其实根本不是。

英文原文

Yeah. So that’s another thing. I make sure my profit margins are very high, so I try to keep the costs very low. I don’t hire people. I try to negotiate with AI vendors now like, “Can you make it cheaper?” Which I discovered this. You can just email companies and say, “Can you give me discount? It’s too expensive.” And they say, “Sure, 50%.” I’m like, “Wow, very good.” And I didn’t know this. You can just ask. And especially now it’s kind of recession, you can ask companies like, “I need a discount.” You don’t need to be asshole, about it. Say, “I need a discount or I need to go maybe to another company. Maybe a discount here and there?” And they say, “Sure.” A lot of them will say yes, 25% discount, 50% discount. Because you think the price on the website is the price of the API or something. It’s not.

Lex Fridman2:05:53

而且你本身是个公众人物。

英文原文

And also you’re a public facing person.

Pieter Levels2:05:56

这也帮了大忙。

英文原文

That helps also.

Lex Fridman2:05:57

你还向世界传递着爱与正能量,你确实在真心实意地打造酷炫的东西。所以很多公司可能都想跟你合作,因为你正在做的事本身就很有价值。

英文原文

And there’s love and good vibes that you put out into the world. You’re actually legitimately trying to build cool stuff. So a lot of companies probably want to associate with you because you’re trying to do.

Pieter Levels2:06:06

对,这就像个隐藏技巧。不过我觉得就算没有……

英文原文

Yeah, it’s like a secret hack. But I think even without….

Lex Fridman2:06:08

隐藏技巧就是:做个好人。

英文原文

Secret hack. Be a good person.

Pieter Levels2:06:10

至于能拿到多少折扣,还得看他们给多少——所以你得多在推特(X)上发点搞笑帖(shit post),说不定还能换来折扣呢。

英文原文

It depends how much discount they will give. They’ll maybe give more, but that’s why you should shit post on Twitter, so you get discounts maybe.

Lex Fridman2:06:19

对,对。另外,当项目是众包(crowdsourced)形式时,收费还能防止垃圾信息,或者至少有助于防止垃圾信息。

英文原文

Yeah. Yeah. And also when it’s crowdsourced, paying does prevent spam or help prevent spam.

Pieter Levels2:06:29

对,对,对。还能帮你筛选出高质量用户。

英文原文

Also. Yeah. Yeah. It gives you high quality users.

Lex Fridman2:06:30

高质量用户。

英文原文

High quality users.

Pieter Levels2:06:32

免费用户嘛——抱歉,但说实话,他们真的很糟糕。尤其是AI初创公司,动不动就涌进来几百万人,纯粹滥用你的App,各种黑、各种折腾。

英文原文

Free users are, sorry, but they’re horrible. It’s just millions of people especially with AI startups. You get a lot of abuse, so you get millions of people from anywhere just abusing your app, just hacking it and whatever.

Lex Fridman2:06:44

网上有个事儿,你之前提到过,像是4chan发现了《Hood Maps》?

英文原文

There’s something on the internet. You mentioned like 4Chan discovered Hood Maps.

Pieter Levels2:06:49

对,但我其实并不喜欢4chan。不过你知道我的意思——他们特别疯,尤其是早年,他们干的事儿还挺有意思的。

英文原文

Yeah, but I love 4Chan. I don’t love 4Chan, but you know what I mean. They’re so crazy, especially back then. It’s kind of funny what they do.

Lex Fridman2:06:58

实际上,Netflix新出的那部纪录片叫《反社交网络》(Anti-Social Network)之类的,真是让人着迷。光是4chan本身那种精神气质,就特别吸引人。

英文原文

Actually, what is it? This new documentary on Netflix, Anti-Social Network or something like that. That really was fascinating. Just 4Chan, just the spirit of the thing, 4Chan.

Pieter Levels2:06:58

大家其实误解了4chan。

英文原文

People misunderstand 4Chan.

Lex Fridman2:07:10

它承载了太多关于自由的理念,也充满了那种戏弄体制、反抗权威的幽默感。

英文原文

It’s so much about freedom and also the humor involved in fucking with the system and fucking the man.

Pieter Levels2:07:18

没错,它本质上就是反体制的。

英文原文

That’s it. It’s just anti-system.

Lex Fridman2:07:20

但出发点是为了好玩。它的阴暗面在于:你玩得开心,干着反体制的事儿,但纳粹分子总会冒出来。

英文原文

But for fun. The dark aspect of it is you’re having fun, you’re doing anti-system stuff, but the Nazis always show up.

Pieter Levels2:07:31

这种转变是从某个时候开始的。

英文原文

That shift started happening.

Lex Fridman2:07:32

它就这样慢慢偏移了方向,是的。

英文原文

It’s drifting somehow. Yeah.

Pieter Levels2:07:34

比如校园枪击案之类的事儿。所以这是个非常敏感的话题。但我确实知道,尤其是早期,比如2010年前后,我常去4chan找乐子,上面会发一些极端冒犯性的内容——那纯粹是为了吓退普通人。我们会拿给其他人看,说:‘嘿,你知道这个叫4chan的网站吗?快去看看!’对方一看就惊了:‘哥们儿,这都是啥玩意儿?!’我就说:‘不不不,你没懂。这就是故意吓你的。但你真往下翻翻,会发现底下全是深度讨论。’而他们往往……这就像一道‘普通用户过滤器’,专门用来劝退外行。所以还挺酷的。但话说回来……

英文原文

Like school shootings and stuff. So it’s a very difficult topic. But I do know, especially early on, I think 2010, I would go to 4Chan for fun and they would post crazy offensive stuff. And this was just to scare off people. So we’d show to other people, say, “Hey, do you know this internet website 4Chan? Just check it out.” And they’d be, “Dude, what the fuck is that?” I’m like, “No, no, you don’t understand. That’s to scare you away. But actually when you go through scroll, there’s deep conversations.” And they would already be… This was like a normie filter to stop. So kind of cool. But yeah.

Lex Fridman2:08:03

它终究会变黑暗。

英文原文

It goes dark.

Pieter Levels2:08:00

他们就像喊停一样。所以,挺酷,但话说回来……

英文原文

They’re like stop. So, cool, but yeah.

Lex Fridman2:08:03

它终究会变黑暗。

英文原文

It goes dark.

Pieter Levels2:08:04

它终究会变黑暗,没错。

英文原文

It goes dark, yeah.

Lex Fridman2:08:05

一旦那些人混进来,他们纯粹为了取乐,就会干一堆种族主义的事儿,就像你刚才说的那些。

英文原文

And if you have those people show up, they’ll for the fun of it, do a bunch of racist things and all that kind of stuff you were saying.

Pieter Levels2:08:11

对,我觉得它从来就……哥们儿,我不是算命的,但它始终围绕着‘挑衅’展开——它就是一群挑衅者(provocateurs)。

英文原文

Yeah. I think it was never… Man, I’m not a fortune, but it was always about provoking. It’s just provocateurs.

Lex Fridman2:08:17

但在头罩地图(hood maps)之类的情况下,这种挑衅行为可能会损害一件好东西。一座城镇里掺入一点‘毒’总是有益的——就像汤姆·威茨(Tom Waits)那种风格,但你又不希望掺得太多,否则就会毁掉整座城镇,毁掉这件东西。

英文原文

But the provoking in the case of hood maps or something like this can damage a good thing. A little poison in a town is always good. It’s like the Tom Waits thing, but you don’t want too much, otherwise it destroys the town. It destroys the thing.

Pieter Levels2:08:35

是啊。但他们就像渗透测试员(pen testers)、渗透测试工程师、黑客一样,只是帮你测试你的应用,然后你再加些功能进去。我有一份NSFW(不适合工作场合)词汇表。当他们说出不当词汇时,系统就会把他们自动转接到YouTube上——那是一段视频,一段非常令人放松的ASMR视频:发光的果冻缓缓流淌,或者奶酪在吐司上慢慢融化的画面,用来帮他们冷静下来。

英文原文

Yeah. But they’re like pen testers, penetration testers, hackers. They just test your app for you and then you add some stuff. I had a NSFW word list. They would say bad words, so when they would write bad words, they would get forwarded to YouTube, which was a video. It was a very relaxing video that ASMR with glowing jelly, streaming like this to relax them or cheese melting on the toast to chill them out.

Lex Fridman2:09:05

是啊,我喜欢这个。但事实上,很多东西我之前都没意识到,原来大量网络迷因(memes)都起源于福昌(Forchand)。比如‘瑞克摇’(Rick Roll),我以前完全没搞懂……我根本不知道‘瑞克摇’起源于福昌。还有太多太多迷因,你自以为是……

英文原文

Yeah, I like it. But actually, a lot of stuff, I didn’t realize how much originated in Forchand in terms of memes. Rick Roll, I didn’t understand… I didn’t know that Rick Roll originated in Forchand. There’s so many memes, most of the memes that you think it takes-

Pieter Levels2:09:17

‘Roll’这个词,我觉得源自福昌——倒不是说‘roll’这个词本身源自福昌,而是就这个迷因用法而言,你会得到‘roll doubles’(双倍滚动),因为……当时福昌上的帖子ID是随机生成的。所以如果我抽中了重复数字,比如‘22’之类的,就会发生某些事。于是人们就在这些重复数字的帖子ID上搞起了类似博彩市场的玩法。里面有趣的东西太多了。

英文原文

The word roll I think comes from Forchand, not the word roll, but in this case, in the meme use, you would get roll doubles because every… It was post IDs on Forchand. So, they were random. So, if I get doubles, this happens or something. So, you’d get two-two… Anyway, it’s like a betting market on these doubles on these post IDs. There’s so much funny stuff.

Lex Fridman2:09:38

是啊,那是纯粹的互联网。但话说回来,阴暗面的东西总会悄悄渗进来,而把阴暗面控制在较低程度,是件好事。在黑暗中保留一点‘噪音’挺好,但也不能太多。不过,你又必须时刻留意这类问题……我想,总体而言,对抗垃圾信息(spam)得靠‘游牧者名单’(Nomad list)。你们是怎么对抗垃圾信息的?

英文原文

Yeah. That’s the internet that’s purist. But yeah, again, the dark stuff seeps in and it’s nice to keep the dark stuff to some low amount. It’s nice to have a bit of noise in the darkness, but not too much. But again, you have to pay attention to that with… I guess spam in general, you have to fight that with Nomad list. How do you fight spam?

Pieter Levels2:10:01

老兄,我用的是GPT-4o,简直太棒了。我有用户输入,还有用户点评——人们可以点评城市,而且根本不需要注册,全是匿名点评。他们甚至会为一座城市写成整本书,详述那里有什么好、什么不好。我把这些内容全部送进GPT-4o,问它:这是个好点评吗?是否具有冒犯性?是否带有种族主义色彩,或诸如此类的问题?接着,系统会通过Telegram发消息,自动拒绝某些点评,我再人工复核一下——天哪,它判断得实在太准了,太……

英文原文

Man, I use GPT-4o. It’s amazing. So, I have user input, I have reviews, people can review cities and I don’t need to actually sign up. It’s anonymous reviews and they write whole books about cities and what’s good and bad. So, I run it through GPT-4o and I ask, is this a good review? Is it offensive? Is this racist or some stuff? And then, it sends message in Telegram, it rejects reviews, and I check it and man, it’s so on point. It’s so-

Lex Fridman2:10:31

自动化。

英文原文

Automated.

Pieter Levels2:10:32

对,而且准确度极高。它能理解双关语。我在聊天社群里也运行着GPT-4o——这是一个拥有1万人的聊天社群,大家在里面聊天,有时彼此争吵起来。过去我雇了真人版主,效果其实不错;但后来版主自己反而跟用户吵起来了,有人嚷嚷‘这家伙有偏见’之类的。现在我换上了GPT-4o,效果真的、真的、真的、真的非常好。它能理解幽默——你可能说了句难听的话,但其实是开玩笑,不算冒犯,因此不该删除。它能识别出这一点。

英文原文

Yes, and it’s so accurate. It understands double meanings. I have GPT-4o running on the chat community. It’s a chat community of 10,000 people, and they’re chatting, and they start fighting with each other and I used to have human moderators was very good, but they would start fighting the human moderator. This guy is biased or something. I have GPT-4o and it’s really, really, really, really good. It understands humor. You could say something bad, but it’s like a joke and it’s not offensive so much so it shouldn’t be deleted. It understands that.

Lex Fridman2:11:05

我真希望能为X平台(推特)开发一套基于GPT-4o的、多种类型的过滤器。

英文原文

I would love to have a GPT-4o based filter of different kinds for X.

Pieter Levels2:11:15

是啊。这周我还发了一条推文做事实核查:你可以点击‘事实核查’按钮,然后由GPT-4o来执行……听着,GPT-4o对某些事情并非永远正确,但它确实能对一条推文给出大致的事实核查结果。通常,我现在写一些关于经济学或人工智能等较难主题的内容时,都会先输入GPT-4o,问它:‘你能帮我核查下事实吗?’因为我可能无意中说了什么蠢话。

英文原文

Yeah. I thought this week, I tweeted a fact check. You can click fact check and then GPT-4o… Look, GPT-4o is not always right about stuff, but it can give you a general fact check on a tweet. Usually, what I do now when I write something difficult about economics or something about AI, I put in GPT-4o, I say, “Can you fact check it?” Because I might’ve said something stupid.

Pieter Levels2:11:35

而那些蠢话往往会被回复迅速揪出来,比如‘哦,你这句话说错了’——结果整条推文就彻底讲不通了。所以我经常让GPT-4o帮我核查大量内容。

英文原文

And the stupid stuff always gets taken out by the replies like, “Oh, you said this wrong.” And then, the whole tweet doesn’t make sense anymore. So, I ask GPT-4o to fact check a lot of stuff.

Lex Fridman2:11:44

所以,事实核查确实是个难题;但若换成评估某条内容的思考深度与论证质量,那就有趣多了,也更可行。这似乎更可行——看起来更像是GPT能胜任的任务,因为它较少关乎‘真相’本身,而更多关乎内容的严谨性。

英文原文

So, fact check is a tough one, but it would be interesting to rate a thing based on how well thought out it is and how well argued it is. That seems more doable. That seems like more doable. It seems like a GPT thing because that’s less about the truth and it’s more about the rigor of the thing.

Pieter Levels2:12:04

完全正确。而且你可以直接在提示词(prompt)里提出这类要求。比如,我不知道……举个例子:请为X平台的推文回复创建一个评分体系——如果按‘诚信度’‘真实性’‘根本性深度’或‘趣味性’等维度排序,这条回复该排在什么位置?它大概率会给你一个相当不错的评分。埃隆可以用Grok实现这个功能,他完全可以开始用它来审核回复,毕竟他们的回复区简直就是一团混乱。

英文原文

Exactly. And you can ask that. You can ask in the prompt, I don’t know, for example, do you think… Create a ranking score of X Twitter replies where should this post be if we rank on, I don’t know, integrity, reality, fundamental deepness or something, interestness, and it would give you that a pretty good score probably. Elon can do this with Grok. He can start using that to check replies because their reply section is chaos.

Lex Fridman2:12:32

是啊,而且目前的排序或回复机制效果并不好。

英文原文

Yeah. And actually the ranking or the reply is not great.

Pieter Levels2:12:35

完全讲不通。

英文原文

Doesn’t make any sense.

Lex Fridman2:12:35

讲不通。

英文原文

It doesn’t make sense.

Pieter Levels2:12:36

不。

英文原文

No.

Lex Fridman2:12:36

我还想按不同方式来排序。

英文原文

And I would like to sort in different kinds of ways.

Pieter Levels2:12:39

是啊,现在回复实在太多了。如果你粉丝很多,我收到的回复就多到看不过来,很多内容我直接就错过了,而我只想看到优质内容。

英文原文

Yeah. And you get too many replies now. If you have a lot of followers, I get too many replies, I don’t see everything, and a lot of stuff I just miss and I want to see the good stuff.

Lex Fridman2:12:49

还有通知之类的东西,也完全是混乱一片。要是能以有趣的方式过滤、以有趣的方式排序,那就太好了。因为我觉得自己错过了太多东西。而最终浮现在我眼前的,却往往只是一个毫无粉丝的普通人的随机评论——无论正面还是负面,都只是‘哦,就这样吧’。

英文原文

And also the notifications or whatever, it’s just complete chaos. It’d be nice to be able to filter that in interesting ways, sort it in interesting ways. Because I feel like I miss a lot. And what surfaced for me is just a random comment by a person with no followers. That’s positive or negative. It’s like okay.

Pieter Levels2:13:09

如果是一条极好的评论,它当然应该被顶上来;但或许还应稍作调整,比如看看这些评论者是否有粉丝——因为他们很可能更深度参与这个平台,对吧?

英文原文

If it’s a very good comment, it should happen, but it should probably look a little bit more like, do these people have followers because they’re probably more engaged in a platform, right?

Lex Fridman2:13:17

哦不,我根本不在乎对方有多少粉丝。如果你是按评论质量来排序,那很好;但绝不能只是简单地按时间顺序堆砌,变成一片杂乱无章的评论海洋。

英文原文

Oh no, I don’t even care about how many followers. If you’re ranking by the quality of the comment, great, but not just randomly chronological just a sea of comments.

Pieter Levels2:13:28

是啊,这根本讲不通。

英文原文

Yeah. It doesn’t make sense.

Lex Fridman2:13:29

是啊。

英文原文

Yeah.

Pieter Levels2:13:31

X平台(推特)恰恰就是这一问题的绝佳例证,我觉得。

英文原文

X could be very proof of that, I think.

Lex Fridman2:13:33

你经常强调的一点,也是我特别喜欢的,就是‘自动化步骤’。也就是说,当你有了某个产品,有了某个想法,并把它建成了,它开始赚钱了,开始让人开心了,也形成了一个使用它的用户社群——这时,你就该迈出‘自动化步骤’:把你必须亲自做的事尽可能自动化,从而让它以最少的人工干预持续无限期运行下去。你能解释下你在这方面的理念吗?你所说的‘自动化’具体指什么?

英文原文

One thing you espouse a lot, which I love is the automation step. So, once you have a thing, once you have an idea, and you build it, and it actually starts making money, and it’s making people happy, there’s a community of people using it. You want to take the automation step of automating the things you have to do as little work as possible for it to keep running indefinitely. Can you explain your philosophy there? What you mean by automate?

Pieter Levels2:14:01

是啊。初创者的一般理论是:一旦项目启动并开始盈利,你就开始雇人做事——比如做营销这类你自己起初亲力亲为的工作;再比如社群管理,或者为‘游牧者列表’(Nomad List)组织线下聚会,这也可能成为一个专职岗位。

英文原文

Yeah. So, the general theory of starters would be that when it starts, you start making money, you start hiring people to do stuff, do stuff that you like marketing, for example, do stuff that you would do in the beginning yourself. And whatever, community management, and organizing meetups for Nomad List, for example, that would be a job, for example.

Pieter Levels2:14:18

而我觉得,我既没那么多钱去雇人,也不想经营一家员工众多的大公司——因为管理大量人员本身就很费劲。所以我一直努力尽可能将这些事务自动化。这实际上可以非常具体:比如‘游牧者列表’就不是一个与其他初创项目不同的特殊平台,它就是一个网页,用户可以在上面自行组织线下聚会,设定日程、日期等等。

英文原文

And I felt like I don’t have the money for that and I don’t really want to run a big company with a lot of people because there’s a lot of work managing these people. So, I’ve always tried to automate these things as much as possible. And this can literally be like for Nomad List, it’s not a different other starters, it’s like a webpage where you can organize your own meetup, set a schedule, a date, whatever.

Pieter Levels2:14:42

你还能看到届时会有多少‘游牧者’到场,确保实际到场人数足够举办一场聚会。聚会结束后,系统会自动在‘游牧者列表’官方账号发布一条推文:‘这里有一场聚会!’同时向该城市所有已登记、即将到场的用户发送私信。然后大家就来到酒吧,聚会自然就办起来了——整个流程完全自动化。对我来说,这显然该自动化:为什么还要找个人来组织呢?自动化才更合理。我几乎所有项目都是这样做的:想办法用代码实现自动化;尤其是现在有了AI,你能自动化的事务比以往任何时候都多得多,因为AI的理解能力实在太强了。过去我只能用if语句,现在你只需向GPT提问,把内容传给GPT-4o的API,它就能返回‘这个好’‘这个坏’之类的判断。

英文原文

You could see how many Nomads will be there at that date. So, there will be actually enough Nomads to meet up. And then, when it’s done, it sends a tweet out on the Nomad List account, there’s a meetup here, it sends a direct message to everybody in the city who are there, who are going to be there. And then, people show up on a bar, and there’s a meetup, and that’s fully automated. And for me, it’s so obvious to make this automatic, why would you have somebody organize this? It makes more sense to automate it, and this with most of my things, I figure out how to do it with codes and I think especially now with AI, you can automate so much more stuff than before because AI understands things so well. Before I would use if statements. Now, you ask GPT, you put something in GPT-4o in the API and it sends back, this is good, this is bad.

Lex Fridman2:15:29

是啊,所以你现在甚至能自动化处理主观类事务。

英文原文

Yeah. So, you basically can now even automate subjective type of things.

Pieter Levels2:15:35

这就是现在的区别所在,而且是最近才出现的。

英文原文

This is the difference now and that’s very recent.

Lex Fridman2:15:38

但要真正实现这一步自动化,依然很难——因为你本质上是在把一切工作都委托给代码。对很多人来说,迈出这一步并非易事。那么,当你提到‘自动化’时,你指的是定时任务(cron jobs)吗?

英文原文

But it’s still difficult to… That step of automation is difficult to figure out how to, because you’re basically delegating everything to code. It’s not trivial to take that step for a lot of people. So, when you say automate, are you talking about cron jobs?

Pieter Levels2:15:56

是的。老兄,大量定时任务。

英文原文

Yes. Man, a lot of cron jobs.

Lex Fridman2:15:57

大量定时任务。

英文原文

A lot of cron jobs.

Pieter Levels2:16:00

真的,我登录服务器后,就敲‘crontab -e’进入编辑模式,然后写上‘hourly’(每小时一次),再写一行‘php do-this-thing.php’——这就是一个脚本,它每小时执行一次指定操作。就这么简单。我所有网站都是这么运作的。

英文原文

Literally, I log into the server and I do pseudo cron tab dash E, and then I go into edit and I write hourly. And then, I write PHP, do this thing dot PHP, and that’s a script, and that script does a thing and it does it then hourly. That’s it. And that’s how all my websites work.

Lex Fridman2:16:19

你有没有设置过某种机制,比如当出问题时自动发邮件通知你,或通知负责管理的人?

英文原文

Do you have a thing where it emails you, or something like this, or emails somebody managing the thing if something goes wrong?

Pieter Levels2:16:25

我做了些叫‘健康检查’(health checks)的网页,比如‘healthcheck.php’。网页上会显示emoji表情:状态正常就显示绿色对勾,异常则显示红色叉号;它还会执行数据库查询。例如,查询阿姆斯特丹的网速是多少?好,结果是27兆比特每秒——是个精确数值,没问题,通过。接着它继续检查下一个数据点,逐一验证所有指标。

英文原文

I have these webpages I make, they’re called health checks, so it’s like healthcheck.php. And then, it has emojis, it has a green check mark if it’s good, and a red one if it’s bad, and then it does database queries. For example, what’s the internet speed in, for example, Amsterdam? Okay, it’s a number. It’s 27 point megabits, so it’s accurate number. Okay, check, good. And then, it goes to the next and it goes on all the data points.

Pieter Levels2:16:49

过去24小时内有人注册吗?这很重要,因为注册功能可能出问题了。好的,检查一下,看是否有人注册成功。然后我用uptimerobot.com来监控服务可用性,但它也能检测关键词——它会检测一个表情符号,即红色的叉号(❌),代表出了问题。因此,它每分钟都会打开健康检查页面,查看是否有异常;一旦发现问题,就会通过Telegram给我发一条告警消息:“嘿,出什么事了?”——当然,它不会真的说“嘿,出什么事了?”,而是直接向我发送告警。

英文原文

Did people sign up in the last 24 hours? It’s important because maybe the sign-up broke. Okay, check, somebody sign up. Then I have uptimerobot.com, which is for uptime, but it can also check keywords. It checks for an emoji, which is the red X, which is if something is bad. And so, it opens that health check page every minute to check if something is bad. Then if it’s bad, it sends a message to me on Telegram saying, “Hey, what’s up?” It doesn’t say, “Hey, what’s up?” It sends me alert.

Lex Fridman2:17:15

嗨。嗨,亲爱的。

英文原文

Hey. Hey, sweetie.

Pieter Levels2:17:16

这个系统一宕机我就立刻知道,然后马上去检查。所以,只要一出故障,一分钟内我就能察觉,接着就可以打开笔记本电脑着手修复。但好处是,最近几年系统几乎不再出问题了。而十年前我刚起步时,所有东西动不动就崩溃。现在呢,上周的正常运行时间甚至达到了100.000%,而这些健康检查本身也计入整体可用率统计——也就是说,一切运转良好。

英文原文

This thing is down and then I check. So, within a minute of something breaking, I know it, and then I can open my laptop and fix it. But the good thing is the last few years, things don’t break anymore. And definitely 10 years ago when I started, everything was breaking all the time. And now it’s almost last week it was like 100.000% uptime and these health checks are part of the uptime percentage. So, it’s like everything works.

Lex Fridman2:17:41

你这么一说,我突然意识到:我也该给自己建一个专属页面,把所有健康检查都集中展示在一页上,这样我只要打开这个页面,就能一眼看到所有绿色对勾标记。

英文原文

You’re actually making me realize I should have a page for myself, one page that has all the health checks just so I can go to it and see all the green check marks.

Pieter Levels2:17:53

看着真舒服。

英文原文

It feels good to look at.

Lex Fridman2:17:54

就只是这样,行了。

英文原文

It’d just be like, okay.

Pieter Levels2:17:54

是啊。

英文原文

Yeah.

Lex Fridman2:17:55

好了,没问题,一切都没问题。你还能看到上次出问题是什么时候——它会显示‘从未’,或者意思是:自你上次关心并检查以来,一直都很正常。

英文原文

All right. We’re okay, everything’s okay. And you can see when was the last time something wasn’t okay and it’ll say never or meaning you’ve checked since last cared to check, it’s all been okay.

Pieter Levels2:18:11

没错。以前它还会把健康的检查结果也发给我,‘一切正常,一切正常,一切正常。’

英文原文

For sure. It used to send me the good health checks. It all works. It all works. It all works.

Lex Fridman2:18:16

但这种情况太频繁了。

英文原文

But it’s been so often.

Pieter Levels2:18:18

然后我就觉得:‘这感觉真好。’可转念又想:‘好吧,显然它不可能……你得把正常的告警隐藏起来,只显示异常告警。’现在正是这样做的。

英文原文

And I’m like, this feels so good. But then I’m like, okay, obviously it’s not going to… You need to hide the good ones and show only the bad ones and now that’s the case.

Lex Fridman2:18:24

我需要把所有东西整合到一个地方,全部自动化。另外,目前还有一大堆定时任务(cron jobs)。这档播客的发布流程完全是自动化的——所有环节都已自动完成,包括剪辑等各类操作。不过,要是能进一步自动化就更好了,比如翻译之类的工作,也都值得自动化。

英文原文

I need integrate everything into one place. Automate everything. They have also just a large set of cron jobs. A lot of the publication of this podcast is done all… Everything is just on automatically, it’s all clipped up, all those kind of stuff. But it would be nice to automate even more. Translation, all those kind of stuff would be nice to automate.

Pieter Levels2:18:46

是啊。每个JavaScript错误、每个PHP错误也会被发送到我的Telegram里。所以,不管哪个用户——不一定是访问网页的用户——只要遇到错误,JavaScript就会把错误信息发给服务器,再由服务器转发到我的Telegram,覆盖我所有的网站。

英文原文

Yeah. Every JavaScript, every PHP error gets sent to my telegram as well. So, every user, whatever user it is, doesn’t have to be page user. If they run into an error, the JavaScript sends the JavaScript error to the server and then it sends to my Telegram from all my websites.

Lex Fridman2:19:04

所以你会收到一条消息。

英文原文

So, you get a message.

Pieter Levels2:19:05

于是我就收到一条‘未声明变量’之类的错误提示,诸如此类。然后我想:‘哦,有意思。’接着我就去排查,这种方式能帮你逐步实现零错误——刚开始时错误信息铺天盖地,现在几乎已经没有了。

英文原文

So, I get a uncalled variable error, whatever, blah-blah-blah. And then, I’m like, okay, interesting. And then, I go check it out, and that’s a way to get to zero errors because you get flooded with errors in the beginning and now it’s like nothing almost.

Lex Fridman2:19:19

这真的很酷。这真的很酷。

英文原文

That’s really cool. That’s really cool.

Pieter Levels2:19:22

但这类事情,其他人往往要花大价钱请New Relic这类大型SaaS公司来管理。其实你自己也能做到,而且可以用现成的工具。但我更喜欢自己动手搭建,反而更简单。

英文原文

But this is the same stuff people, they pay very big SaaS companies like New Relic for, to manage the stuff. So, you can do that too. You can use off the shelf. I like to build myself. It’s easier.

Lex Fridman2:19:34

是啊,这样搞自动化确实很棒。我开始思考:生活中有哪些事是我自己在做、却本可以自动化的?

英文原文

Yeah, it’s nice. It’s nice to do that automation. I’m starting to think about what are the things in my life I’m doing myself that could be automated.

Pieter Levels2:19:43

问问ChatGPT,把你一天的安排告诉它,再问它哪些部分适合自动化。

英文原文

Ask ChatGPT, give your day, and then ask it what parts should automate.

Lex Fridman2:19:48

嗯,我特别想进一步自动化的,就是我对社交媒体的使用——既包括输入(浏览),也包括输出(发布)。

英文原文

Well, one of the things I would love to automate more is my consumption of social media, both the output and the input.

Pieter Levels2:19:55

哇,这非常有意思。我觉得已经有了一些入门级工具在做这事,比如用AI总结Twitter上发生的有趣动态。我记得有个叫swyx的人,他办了一份完全由AI生成的新闻简报,里面全是AI领域最新的酷炫玩意儿。

英文原文

Man, that’s very interesting. I think there’s some starters that do that. They summarize the cool shit happening on Twitter with AI. I think the guy called swyx or something, he does a newsletter. It’s completely AI generated. We have the cool new stuff in AI.

Lex Fridman2:20:11

是啊,我很想这么做。而且不只是Twitter,Instagram、Facebook、LinkedIn等等所有平台都涵盖进去,就相当于问一句:‘今天互联网上发生了什么?能帮我总结一下吗?’

英文原文

Yeah, I would love to do that. But also across Instagram, Facebook, LinkedIn, all this kind of stuff, just like, “Okay, can you summarize the internet for me for today?”

Pieter Levels2:20:22

summarizeinternet.com。

英文原文

summarizeinternet.com.

Lex Fridman2:20:23

是啊,.com域名。因为我觉得刷社交媒体实在太耗时间了,而且有些日子它对我的心理状态影响也不好。

英文原文

Yeah, dot com. Because I feel like it pulls in way too much time, but also I don’t like the effect it has some days on my psyche.

Pieter Levels2:20:33

是因为喷子,还是因为内容本身,比如政治类话题?

英文原文

Because of haters or just general content, like politics?

Lex Fridman2:20:37

就是泛泛的内容。不不不,就是泛泛的内容。比如TikTok对我来说就是个典型例子。有时候我刷完TikTok,就感觉自己变傻了,就是那种——

英文原文

Just general. No, no, just general. For example, TikTok is a good example of that for me. I sometimes just feel dumber after I use TikTok. I just feel like-

Pieter Levels2:20:45

是啊,我都不用了。

英文原文

Yeah. I don’t use it anymore.

Lex Fridman2:20:47

整个人空落落的,毫无灵感。有趣的是,当时刷着还挺乐呵:‘哈哈,看那只猫干了件搞笑的事。’然后又看到:‘哦,看那个人跟着音乐滑稽地跳舞。’可十分钟后你就发现:‘我怎么感觉智商直线下降,接下来一整天都不想干任何事了。’

英文原文

Empty somehow and I’m uninspired. It’s funny in the moment I’m like, “Haha, look at that cat doing a funny thing.” And then, you’re like, “Oh, look at that person dancing in a funny way to that music.” And then, you’re like 10 minutes later you’re like, I feel way dumber and I don’t really want to do much for the rest of the day.

Pieter Levels2:21:06

是啊。有次我女朋友坐旁边,看见我在看某个蠢视频,就说:‘哥们,你那张脸看起来也蠢透了。’你整张脸都开始不由自主地露出那种‘哦,有意思’的表情。

英文原文

Yeah. My girlfriend sat, she saw me watching some dumb video and she’s like, “Dude, your face looks so dumb as well.” Your whole face starts going like, “Oh, interesting.”

Lex Fridman2:21:19

X平台有时对我也是这样,我觉得我可能天生就容易被戏剧性内容吸引。

英文原文

With X sometimes for me too, I think I’m probably naturally gravitating towards the drama.

Pieter Levels2:21:26

难道不是所有人都这样吗?

英文原文

Aren’t we all?

Lex Fridman2:21:27

是啊。所以,我现在主要关注AI领域的从业者,尤其是那些只发技术内容的人,效果特别好——我一看他们的动态,就很容易顺着他们分享的内容钻进学习新论文、优质转载或各种酷炫演示的‘兔子洞’里;他们转发的东西,也常常把我带进这种‘兔子洞’。我在里面学习、受到启发,收获满满。但控制这种吸引力确实很难。

英文原文

Yeah. And so, following AI people, especially AI people that only post technical content has been really good because then I just look at them, and then I go down rabbit holes of learning new papers that have been published, or good repost, or just any kind of cool demonstration of stuff, and the kind of things that they retweet, and that’s the rabbit hole. I go, and I’m learning and I’m inspired, all that kind of stuff. It’s been tough. It’s been tough to control that.

Pieter Levels2:21:52

确实很难。你得主动管理自己的社交平台。我自己也建了一个静音列表,把政治类内容全静音了,因为我不想让这类信息出现在我的信息流里。我想我已经静音了太多东西,以至于现在我的信息流反而很健康,能看到真正有趣的内容。但问题是,你居然得靠手动修改、定制你的社交App,才能让它不毒害你的心理健康——这本身就是个问题。平台本该替你做好这件事。

英文原文

It’s difficult. You need to manage your platforms. I have a mute board list as well, so I mute politics stuff because I don’t really want it on my feed, and I think I’ve muted so much that now my feed is good. I see interesting stuff. But the fact that you need to modify, you need to mod your app, your social media platform just to function and not be toxic for you for your mental health. That’s a problem. It should be doing that for you.

Lex Fridman2:22:18

这某种程度上也算一种自动化。挺有意思的。我希望自己能更方便地通过API接入X和Instagram。

英文原文

It’s some level of automation. That would be interesting. I wish I could access X and Instagram through API easier.

Pieter Levels2:22:27

你得每月花4.2万美元,我朋友就这么干。是的,你可以这么做。

英文原文

You need to spend $42,000 a month, which my friends do. Yeah, you can do that.

Lex Fridman2:22:32

不,但就算你真花了这笔钱,也还是拿不到……存在诸多限制,导致自动化难以实现。因为他们想限制滥用行为,或者防止你把App里的所有数据都扒走,拿去训练大语言模型(LLM)之类的东西。但如果我只是想找到办法,自动化地与X平台或Instagram互动,他们偏偏就不让你轻松做到。

英文原文

No. But still, even if you do that, that you’re not getting… There’s limitations that don’t make it easy to do automate because the thing that they’re trying to limit abuse or for you to steal all the data from the app to then train in LLM or something like this. But if I just want to figure out ways to automate my interaction with X system or with Instagram, they don’t make that easy.

Lex Fridman2:22:55

但我真的很想实现这种自动化,并探索各种利用大语言模型(LLM)来管控我所消费内容的方式,也许还能把这套方案公开出来,甚至让平台方自己看看,如何借鉴它来改进自家系统。但问题是,目前根本缺乏足够的接入权限……

英文原文

But I would love to automate that and explore different ways how to leverage LLMs to control the content I consume, and maybe publish that, and maybe they themselves can see how that could be used to improve their system. But there’s not enough access to get-

Pieter Levels2:23:11

是啊,你可以截取手机屏幕。做个App,实时监控你的屏幕画面。

英文原文

Yes, you could screen cap your phone. It can be an app that watches your screen with you.

Lex Fridman2:23:16

确实可以。

英文原文

You could, yeah.

Pieter Levels2:23:17

但我真不确定它具体能做什么。也许能在你看到之前就把某些内容先屏蔽掉?

英文原文

But I don’t really know what it would do. Maybe it can hide stuff before you see it.

Lex Fridman2:23:22

我有这个功能。我写了很多Chrome扩展程序,用来隐藏不同网页上的特定区域。比如,在我主力电脑上,我会隐藏YouTube上我自己创作内容的所有播放量、点赞数等数据,这样我就不会……

英文原文

I have that. I have Chrome extensions… I write a lot of Chrome extensions that hide parts of different pages and so on. For example, on my main computer, I hide all views, and likes, and all that on YouTube content that I create. So that I don’t-

Pieter Levels2:23:37

这很聪明,对你没影响。

英文原文

That’s smart, doesn’t affect you.

Lex Fridman2:23:38

确实没影响,是的。这样你就不会分心去看那些数字了。我还会隐藏其他内容……我还为X平台专门设置了一种模式,把大部分内容都隐藏掉,YouTube也一样。

英文原文

It doesn’t, yeah. So, you don’t pay attention to it. I also hide parts… I have a mode for X where I hide most of everything. It’s the same with YouTube.

Pieter Levels2:23:38

我也有同样的扩展程序。

英文原文

I have the same, I have this extension.

Lex Fridman2:23:50

嗯,我自己写的,因为这样更方便——毕竟这些平台界面老在变,要持续动态适配并不容易。但他们确实很擅长让你分心,然后……

英文原文

Well, I wrote my own because it’s easier because it keeps changing. It’s not easy to keep it dynamically changing, but they’re really good at getting you to be distracted and starting to-

Pieter Levels2:24:03

‘相关账号’‘相关帖子’——我就想:‘我才不想要相关推荐呢。’

英文原文

Related account, related post. I’m like, I don’t want related.

Lex Fridman2:24:04

结果十分钟后,你发现自己正盯着某个热门话题发呆。

英文原文

And 10 minutes later you’re like or something that’s trending.

Pieter Levels2:24:07

我身边有奇怪多的朋友沉迷YouTube,而我却不沉迷。我想大概是因为我的注意力持续时间太短,撑不住YouTube的节奏。但我装了一个叫‘YouTube Unhook’的扩展程序,它会隐藏所有相关推荐内容。我就能只看到视频本身,效果简直惊艳。但有时我需要搜索某个教学视频,比如‘怎么操作某件事’,于是打开YouTube,结果一上来就是一堆YouTube Shorts。这些Shorts完全是算法设计出来的,目的就是引诱你点开。我一点开,五分钟后就变成这副呆滞脸,彻底陷进去了。到底发生了什么?我本来只想放一段早晨喝咖啡时听的爵士乐混音,压根不想点进Shorts!这真的太难了。

英文原文

I have a weird amount of friends addicted to YouTube and I’m not addicted. I think because my attention span is too short for YouTube. But I have this extension, YouTube Unhook, which hides all the related stuff. I can just see the video and it’s amazing, but sometimes I need to search a video how to do something, and then I go to YouTube and then I had these YouTube shorts. These YouTube shorts, they’re algorithmically designed to just make you tap them. And then, I tap, and then I’m like five minutes later with this face and you’re just stuck. And what happened? I was going to play the coffee mix, the music mix for drinking coffee together in the morning, like jazz. I didn’t want to go to shorts. So, it’s very difficult.

Lex Fridman2:24:54

我喜欢我们此刻正在实际梳理出一大堆有趣的问题,而这些问题全都可以通过创业来解决。那么,关于退出呢?什么时候退出?怎么退出?

英文原文

I love how we’re actually highlighting all kinds of interesting problems that all could be solved with a startup. Okay. So, what about the exit? When and how to exit?

Pieter Levels2:25:03

老兄,你可别问我,因为我从来没卖过自己的公司。

英文原文

Man, you shouldn’t ask me because I never sold my company.

Lex Fridman2:25:07

你所有做成功的项目,一次都没卖过?

英文原文

All the successful stuff you’ve done, you never sold it?

Pieter Levels2:25:10

是啊,挺令人难过的。所以,我参与过很多并购类交易之类的事情,也在这个过程中学到了很多关于财务人员的知识——比如操纵手段、尽职调查,还有估值调整。人们往往在之后才更改估值。所以,很多人先吊着你,说要收购你,结果一拖就是六个月。这是经典套路,通常要耗时六到十二个月,他们想把什么都看个遍。

英文原文

Yeah, it’s sad. So, I’ve been in a lot of acquisition like deals and stuff, and I learn a lot about finance people as well there, manipulation, and due diligence, and then changing the valuation. People change the valuation after. So, a lot of people string you on to acquire you and then it takes six months. It’s a classic. It takes six to 12 months. They want to see everything.

Pieter Levels2:25:33

他们要看你的Stripe账户、你的代码,以及所有其他东西。到最后,他们却会把报价压低,因为你已经投入太多、深陷其中了。这其实是一种谈判策略。我就直接说:‘不,我不想卖。’而我的公司有个问题:它们的利润率高达90%。公司出售时通常按倍数定价,即按利润或营收的若干倍来估值。

英文原文

They want to see your stripe, and your code, and whatever. And then, in the end, they’ll change the price to lower because you’re already so invested. So, it’s like a negotiation tactic. I’m like, “No, I don’t want to sell.” And the problem with my companies is they make 90% profit margin. Companies get sold with multiples, multiples of profit or revenue.

Pieter Levels2:25:57

而这个倍数常常是三倍、四倍甚至五倍的营收或利润。就我而言,所有业务都是自动化的,所以我完全可以等上三年,届时拿到的钱和现在卖掉一样多,而且我还能继续出售同一家公司。你明白我的意思吗?我依然能以三至五倍的估值把它卖出去。因此,除非出价足够高,否则从财务角度看,出售其实并不划算。如果对方出价六倍、七倍或八倍,那我可不想为这笔钱再等六年;但如果只给三倍,我完全等得起。

英文原文

And often the multiple is three times, three times or four times or five times revenue or profit. So, in my case, they’re all automated, so I might as well wait three years and I get the same money as when I sell and then I can still sell the same company. You know what I mean? I can still sell it for three to five times. So, financially, it doesn’t really make sense to sell unless the price is high enough. If the price gets to six or seven or eight, I don’t want to wait six years for the money, but if you give me three years, nothing, I can wait.

Lex Fridman2:26:27

所以,这意味着你所创建的公司真正有价值的东西,远不止界面和众包内容,更在于人本身——也就是用户群体。

英文原文

So, that means there are really valuable stuff about the companies you create is not just the interface and the crowdsource content, but the people themselves, the user base.

Pieter Levels2:26:39

是啊。Nomad List就是一个社区。没错。

英文原文

Yeah. For Nomad List, it’s a community. Yeah,

Lex Fridman2:26:41

所以,我能预见到它会极具价值。我挺惊讶的——

英文原文

So, I could see that being extremely valuable. I’m surprised that-

Pieter Levels2:26:44

是啊。Nomad List是我的‘孩子’,是我第一个真正做起来的产品,我其实不太确定自己是否想把它卖掉。等你老了以后,拥有这样一个仍在运转的项目会很美好。它承载着一项使命:人们应该能去世界任何地方旅行,能在任何地方工作,能接触不同的文化。这是一种让世界变得更好的好方式。

英文原文

Yeah. Nomad List is it’s my baby. It’s my first product I took off and I don’t really know if I want to sell it. It’s something would be nice when you are old because you’re still working in this. It has a mission, which is like people should travel anywhere, and they can work from anywhere, and they can meet different cultures. And that’s a good way to make the world get better.

Pieter Levels2:27:03

如果你去中国生活一段时间,你就会发现那里的人其实很友善。而许多关于中国的说法,虽有不少是宣传,但其中也有很多属实;不过更重要的是,你通过旅行能学到很多东西。我想,正因如此,这个产品才值得保留而不出售。至于AI类产品,比如Photo AI,我对它们的情感依恋就少得多,倒是可以考虑卖掉。是的。

英文原文

If you go to China and live in China, you’ll learn that they’re nice people. And a lot of stuff you hear about China’s propaganda, a lot of stuff is true as well, but it’s more you learn a lot from traveling. And I think that’s why it’s a cool product to not sell. AI products, I have less emotional feeling with AI products like Photo AI, which I could sell. Yeah.

Lex Fridman2:27:23

是啊。你刚才还提到一点:你得把‘卖掉自己亲手创建的公司后会产生的失落感’也计入价格考量之中。

英文原文

Yeah. The thing you also mentioned is you have to price in the fact that you’re going to miss the company you created.

Pieter Levels2:27:31

还有它赋予你的意义。这种现象非常著名——初创公司创始人在完成融资或被收购后陷入抑郁:‘这曾是我全部的人生,那现在的我又是谁?’于是他们立刻开始打造下一个项目,永不停歇。所以,我认为最好一直工作到生命终结,持续投身于酷炫的项目,而不该退休。我觉得退休大概率是件坏事。

英文原文

And the meaning it gives you. This is very famous like depression after startup finance sold their company. They’re like, this was me. Who am I? And they immediately start building another one. They never can stop. So, I think it’s good to keep working until you die. Just keep working on cool stuff and you shouldn’t retire. I think retirement is bad probably.

Lex Fridman2:27:52

所以,你通常都是独自开发产品,也基本是单打独斗地工作。这样做的思路是什么?

英文原文

So, you usually build the stuff solo and mostly work solo. What’s the thinking behind that?

Pieter Levels2:27:58

我觉得自己不太擅长与他人合作。倒不是说我疯了,而是我不信任别人。

英文原文

I think I’m not so good working with other people. Not like I’m crazy, but I don’t trust other people.

Lex Fridman2:28:03

澄清一下,你是不相信别人能把事情做到极致?

英文原文

To clarify, you don’t trust other people to do a great job?

Pieter Levels2:28:07

是的。而且我也不想开那种所谓‘共识会议’——大家聚在一起,最后只能得出折中方案,特别欧洲风格。我不知道这是否叫‘圩田模式’(polder model):把人关进一个房间,直到他们在政治议题上达成妥协才放出来。我认为这种模式只会催生平庸。

英文原文

Yeah. And I don’t want to have this consensus meeting where we all… You have a meeting with three people and then you get these compromise results, which is very European. I don’t know if they call it polder model where you put people in the room and you only let them out when they agree on the compromise in politics. And I think it breeds averageness.

Pieter Levels2:28:28

你得到的只会是平庸的想法、平庸的公司、平庸的文化。你需要一位领导者,或者干脆单干、亲力亲为。我认为,就得自己动手干。当然,我也信任某些人,比如我最好的朋友安德烈(Andre),我们正在共同创办一家新的AI初创公司——但这恰恰因为我们彼此相识已久,而他也是我极少数愿意一起创业的人之一,几乎绝无仅有。

英文原文

You get an average idea, average company, average culture, you need to have a leader or you need to be solo and just do it. Do it yourself, I think. And I trust some people, like with my best friend Andre, I’m making a new AI startup, but it’s because we know each other very long and he’s one of the few people I would build something with, but almost never.

Lex Fridman2:28:52

那么,当团队不止一人时,怎样才算成功?你和安德烈如何协作?你又如何与其他人为共同目标而协作?

英文原文

So, what does it take to be successful when you have more than one? How do you build together with Andre? How do you build together with other people?

Pieter Levels2:28:59

他负责写代码,我则负责在Twitter上发布内容。严格来说,我就是在Twitter上推广它。我们共同制定产品策略,就像我说的:‘这部分应该更好些,那部分也应该更好些。’但我认为,必须由一个人来实际编写代码。他用Ruby编码,而我则说:‘我不会Ruby。’我用的是PHP。

英文原文

So, he codes, I should post on Twitter. Literally, I promote it on Twitter. We set product strategy. Like I said, this should be better, this should be better. But I think you need to have one person coding it. He codes in Ruby, so I was like I cannot do Ruby. I’m in PHP.

Lex Fridman2:29:14

那你有没有和另一位开发者长期并肩编码的经历?

英文原文

So, have you ever coded with another person for prolonged periods of time?

Pieter Levels2:29:19

这辈子从来没有过。

英文原文

Never in my life.

Lex Fridman2:29:24

你觉得背后的原因是什么?

英文原文

What do you think is behind that?

Pieter Levels2:29:26

我不知道。一直以来,都只是我独自坐在笔记本电脑前写代码。

英文原文

I don’t know. It was always just me sitting on my laptop coding.

Lex Fridman2:29:30

不,你从未有过另一位开发者加入进来——

英文原文

No, you’ve never had another developer who rolls in and-

Pieter Levels2:29:33

我唯一一次是在Photo AI项目中,聘请了一位AI开发者菲利普(Philip)。因为我不会写Python,而AI相关工作基本都用Python,我需要让模型跑起来、复现结果等等,还得改进Photo AI。他帮了我大忙,整整工作了十个月。

英文原文

I’ve had once where with Photo AI, there’s a AI developer, Philip. I hired him to do the… Because I can’t write Python and AI stuff is Python. And I needed to get models to work, and replicate, and stuff and I needed to improve Photo AI. And he helped me a lot for 10 months he worked.

Pieter Levels2:29:48

天哪,我当时试着用Python配合NumPy和包管理器,结果发现这玩意儿太难搞懂了,我根本没时间钻研。十年前,我或许还有时间通宵达旦地啃Python,但现在这真不是我的菜。

英文原文

And man, I was trying Python working with NumPy, and package manager, and it was too difficult for me to figure this shit out. And I didn’t have time. I think 10 years ago, I would’ve time to sit, go do all-nighters to figure this stuff out with Python. It’s not my thing.

Lex Fridman2:30:04

这不是你的领域,只是另一种编程语言而已。我明白。AI是新事物,我懂。但你从未有过一位开发者加入进来,审视你的PHP+jQuery代码,然后说‘好啊’——就像即兴表演或即兴创作里常说的‘Yes, and…’(是的,而且……),表示接纳并在此基础上推进。

英文原文

It’s not your thing. It’s another programming language. I get it. AI, new thing, got it. But you’ve never had a developer roll in, look at your PHP jQuery code, and yes. Like in conversation or improv, they talk about yes and basically, all right.

Pieter Levels2:30:20

我曾经有过一次,为期一周——

英文原文

I had for one week-

Lex Fridman2:30:21

明白了——

英文原文

Understand-

Pieter Levels2:30:22

然后就结束了。

英文原文

And then, it ended.

Lex Fridman2:30:22

发生了什么?

英文原文

What happened?

Pieter Levels2:30:23

因为他想用另一种技术栈彻底重写所有代码——

英文原文

Because he wanted to rewrite everything in-

Lex Fridman2:30:26

不,那是找错人了。

英文原文

No, that’s the wrong guy.

Pieter Levels2:30:27

我知道。

英文原文

I know.

Lex Fridman2:30:27

他想用什么重写?

英文原文

He wanted to rewrite in what?

Pieter Levels2:30:29

他说jQuery不行,得全部重写为Vue.js。我说:‘好吧。’他又说:‘我们必须全部改用Vue.js。’我问:‘你确定吗?不能就继续用jQuery吗?’他说:‘不,伙计。’他还说需要改动大量东西。我说:‘行吧。’当时我觉得,我们是要清理一堆烂摊子,但几周下来,才发现这会耗费太多时间。

英文原文

He wanted to rewrite, he said is jQuery, we can’t do this. I’m like, okay. He’s like, “We need to rewrite everything in Vue.js.” I’m like, “Are you sure? Can’t we just like keep jQuery?” He’s like, “No, man.” And we need to change a lot of stuff. And I’m like, okay. And I was feeling we’re going to clean up shit, but then after weeks, it’s going to take way too much time.

Lex Fridman2:30:50

我觉得,我喜欢和这样的人共事:当我接触他们时,我会在心里假定他们是人类历史上最聪明的人。因此,我会认真审视他们的代码,或他们创造的东西,努力发现其方法背后的天才之处。你真的得理解他人,真正留意他们。然后,基于这种理解,再展开关于‘哪种方法更好’的对话。

英文原文

I think I like working with people where when I approach them, I pretend in my head that they’re the smartest person who has ever existed. So, I look at their code or I look at the stuff they’ve created and try to see the genius of their way. You really have to understand people, really notice them. And then, from that place, have a conversation about what is the better approach.

Pieter Levels2:31:15

是啊。但这类人属于顶尖开发者,而且是技术上毫无偏见的开发者——他们能快速掌握任何技术栈。这样的人极少,大概只占开发者的前5%。因为如果你去找更高阶的开发者——并非有意冒犯各位开发者——但大多数开发者其实并不……唉,说实话,大多数人在本职工作中表现都不算出色,医生之类的职业也不例外。

英文原文

Yeah. But those are the top tier developers and those are the ones that are tech ambiguous. So, they can learn any tech stack. And that’s really few, it’s top 5%. Because if you try higher devs, no offense to devs, but most devs are not… Man, most people in general jobs are not so good at their job, even doctors and stuff.

Lex Fridman2:31:15

这太令人难过了。

英文原文

That’s too sad.

Pieter Levels2:31:35

当你意识到这一点——人们在工作中普遍平庸,尤其在开发和编程领域,我觉得更是如此——抱歉如果……

英文原文

When you realize this, people are very average at the job, especially with dev and with coding, I think. So sorry if-

Lex Fridman2:31:41

我认为,对一名开发者而言,能够加入进来并理解代码的‘韵律感’、‘风格’,是一项极其重要的能力——

英文原文

I think that’s a really important skill for a developer to roll in and understand the musicality, the style-

Pieter Levels2:31:48

没错,兄弟!这就是‘代码共情力’(code empathy)。

英文原文

That’s it, man. Empathy, it’s code empathy.

Lex Fridman2:31:51

就是‘代码共情力’。

英文原文

It’s code empathy.

Pieter Levels2:31:51

是啊,这是个新词,但确实如此。你得先理解代码,通览全局,然后当然可以提出修改建议。但话说回来,jQuery确实很疯狂——我居然还在用jQuery,简直疯狂。我们可以改掉它。

英文原文

Yeah, it’s a new word, but that’s it. You need to understand, go over the code, get a holistic view of it and man, you can suggest we change stuff for sure. But look, jQuery is crazy. It’s crazy I’m using jQuery. We can change that.

Lex Fridman2:32:05

这根本不算疯狂。jQuery同样优美而强大,PHP也同样优美而强大。尤其是正如你最近提到的,随着版本演进,PHP如今已是一门相当严肃的编程语言了,速度极快。现在的PHP真的很快。JavaScript——

英文原文

It’s not crazy at all. jQuery is also beautiful and powerful and PHP is beautiful and powerful. And especially as you said recently, as the versions evolved, it’s much more serious programming language now. It’s super-fast. PHP is really fast now. It’s crazy. JavaScript-

Pieter Levels2:32:24

比Ruby快多了,没错。

英文原文

Much faster than Ruby, yeah.

Lex Fridman2:32:25

——现在也快得惊人。所以,如果你在意运行速度,它确实快得惊人。而且使用这些编程语言的开发者群体极为庞大,也有各种框架可供选择——只要你喜欢某个框架。所以,用什么其实并不重要。另外,如果我是一名开发者,来跟你合作,而你本人极其成功,已交付了大量产品。

英文原文

… really fast now. So, if speed is something you care about, it’s super-fast. And there’s gigantic communities of people using those programming languages. And there’s frameworks if you like the framework. So, whatever, it doesn’t really matter what you use. But also, if I was a developer working with you, you are extremely successful. You’ve shipped a lot.

Lex Fridman2:32:46

那么,当我加入时,我绝不会假设你一无所知,而是会默认皮特(Pieter)是史上最聪明的开发者,并向你学习。是的,我会留意代码中的某些部分,心想:‘哦,明白了,原来他是这么思考的。’接着,如果我要添加一个小功能,那就一定要在前面加个emoji,然后严格遵循同样的风格添加进去。

英文原文

So, if I roll in, I’m going to be like, I don’t assume you know nothing. Assume Pieter is a genius, the smartest developer ever. And learn from it. And yes, and notice parts in the code where, “Okay, okay, I got it, here’s how he’s thinking.” And now if I want to add another little feature, definitely needs to have emoji in front of it, and then just follow the same style and add it.

Lex Fridman2:33:17

我的目标是让你开心、让你微笑、让你脱口而出:‘哈哈,靠,我懂了!’这时,你就会开始尊重我、信任我,我们就能以这种方式协同工作了。我不知道……我不知道找到这样的开发者到底有多难。

英文原文

And my goal is to make you happy, to make you smile, to make you like, “Haha, fuck, I get it.” And now you’re going to start respecting me, and trusting me, and you start working together in this way. I don’t know. I don’t know how hard it is to find developers.

Pieter Levels2:33:32

不,我觉得这样的人是存在的。我觉得我需要雇佣更多人,需要多尝试不同的人。

英文原文

No, I think they exist. I think I need to hire more people, I need to try more people.

Lex Fridman2:33:33

多试试不同的人,没错。

英文原文

Try people, yeah.

Pieter Levels2:33:36

但这会耗费我大量精力和时间。不过,这100%是可行的。但我想要吗?我不知道。目前一切运转良好。好吧,你可能会说:‘行吧,Nomad List看起来很笨重。’人们都说它的设计很笨重。好吧,我会改进设计。比如,这就排在我待办事项清单的旁边。我最终会做到的。

英文原文

But that costs a lot of my energy and time. But it’s 100% possible. But do I want it? I don’t know. Things run fine for now. Okay, you could say, okay, Nomad List looks clunky. People say the design is clunky. Okay, I’ll improve the design. It’s like next to my to-do list, for example. I’ll get there eventually.

Lex Fridman2:33:54

但这是事实。你在自己擅长的领域也极其出色。我刚看了Photo AI的界面——你用jQuery?jQuery多么厉害啊!但你看这些‘牛仔’们正越来越……这儿全是‘牛仔’。太多了,实在太多了。不过我很高兴他们全都穿着衬衫。总之,这里的界面真的、真的非常棒。我能看出你清楚自己在做什么。而Nomad List的界面也极其出色。

英文原文

But it’s true. You’re also extremely good at what you do. I’m just looking at the interfaces of Photo AI, you would jQuery, how amazing is jQuery? But you can see these cowboys are getting… There’s these cowboys. This is a lot. This is a lot. But I’m glad they’re all wearing shirts. Anyway, the interface here is just really, really nice. I could tell you know what you’re doing. And with Nomad List, extremely nice, the interface.

Pieter Levels2:33:54

谢谢兄弟。

英文原文

Thank you, man.

Lex Fridman2:34:25

而这全都是你一个人。

英文原文

And that’s all you.

Pieter Levels2:34:27

对,所有东西全是我做的。

英文原文

Yeah, everything is me.

Lex Fridman2:34:29

所以,这一切,还有每个小功能,所有这一切——

英文原文

So, all of this and every little feature, all of this-

Pieter Levels2:34:32

有人说它看起来像有多动症(ADHD)或注意力缺陷障碍(ADD),因为它塞了太多内容。而如今的设计潮流是极简主义,对吧?

英文原文

People say it looks ADHD or ADD. It’s so much because it has so many things. And design these days is minimalist, right?

Lex Fridman2:34:40

没错,我明白你的意思。但这里呈现的是大量信息,而且是有用的信息;这些信息以干净的方式传递出来,同时仍保持时尚感与观赏趣味性。所以,极简主义设计,其实是当你想完全不传达任何信息、只图酷炫时才用的。

英文原文

Right, I hear you. But this is a lot of information, and its useful information, and it’s delivered in a clean way while still stylish and fun to look at. So, minimalist design is about when you want to convey no information whatsoever and look cool.

Pieter Levels2:34:56

对,确实很酷,但也显得有点自命不凡,对吧?

英文原文

Yeah, it’s very cool. It’s pretentious, right?

Lex Fridman2:34:58

不管是不是自命不凡,如果功能本身没用,那也没意义。而这里的关键在于:将大量信息以干净的方式呈现给你;而一旦追求干净,你就没法太‘性感’。所以,它已经够‘性感’了。

英文原文

Pretentious or not, the function is useless. This is about a lot of information delivered to you in a clean and when it’s clean, you can’t be too sexy. So, it’s sexy enough.

Pieter Levels2:35:09

对。我觉得这大概就是我大脑的样子:一大堆事情在同时发生,就像在演奏贝斯音乐,节奏感特别强——‘嗒-嗒-嗒-嗒’。

英文原文

Yeah. This is I think how my brain looks. There’s a lot of shit going on. It’s like drawing bass music. It’s very tk-tk-tk-tk.

Lex Fridman2:35:15

对。但整体依然非常美观,各元素间距恰到好处,字体也特别漂亮,可读性很强,字号虽小——

英文原文

Yeah. But this is still pretty, the spacing of everything is nice. The fonts are really nice, very readable, very small-

Pieter Levels2:35:23

对,我自己挺喜欢的,你也知道,但因为我亲手做的,所以我并不信任自己的判断。

英文原文

Yeah, I like it as you know, but I made it so I don’t trust my own judgment.

Lex Fridman2:35:26

不,这真的非常棒。

英文原文

No, this is really nice.

Pieter Levels2:35:27

谢谢,Lex。

英文原文

Thank you, Lex.

Lex Fridman2:35:28

这些表情符号 somehow……这是一种风格,一种特色。

英文原文

The emojis are somehow… It’s a style. It’s a thing.

Pieter Levels2:35:32

我得一个个挑选表情符号,挑起来还挺费时间的。

英文原文

I need to pick the emoji. It takes a while to pick them.

Lex Fridman2:35:35

这些表情符号确实起到了很棒的、令人难忘的概念占位符作用。如果全用纯文字,反而会让人不堪重负;而有了表情符号,就真的帮了大忙。这是个绝妙的添加。有些人可能会盯着看:‘你为什么到处都用表情符号?’其实它真的……对我而言,真的——

英文原文

There’s something about the emojis is a really nice memorable placeholder for the idea. If it was just text, it would actually be overwhelming if it was just text. The emoji really helps. It’s a brilliant addition. Some people might look at it. Why do you have emojis everywhere? It’s actually really… For me, it’s really-

Pieter Levels2:35:53

有人让我把表情符号删掉。

英文原文

People tell me to remove the emoji.

Lex Fridman2:35:54

对。嗯,这些人根本不知道自己在说什么。

英文原文

Yeah. Well, people don’t know what they’re talking about.

Pieter Levels2:35:56

把它放在图片旁边。

英文原文

Take it next to the picture.

Lex Fridman2:35:58

我敢肯定,别人会给你提很多建议。这真的非常棒。然后,用色也很棒。字体小,但又不至于太小。而且显然,你还得展示地图,这其实特别棘手。

英文原文

I’m sure people will tell you a lot of things. This is really nice. And then, using color is nice. Small font, but not too small. And obviously, you have to show maps, which is really tricky.

Pieter Levels2:36:11

对,很棒。

英文原文

Yeah. Nice.

Lex Fridman2:36:12

不,这真的、真的、真的非常棒。好,你看鼠标悬停上去时的效果——

英文原文

No. This is really, really, really nice. Okay, how this looks when you hover over it, it’s-

Pieter Levels2:36:20

就像那些CSS过渡动画效果。

英文原文

Like the CSS transitions.

Lex Fridman2:36:21

不,我明白这个,但我敢肯定……你琢磨出自己想要的效果要花多长时间?你有没有钻过牛角尖,一钻就是两周?

英文原文

No, I understand that, but I’m sure there’s… How long does it take you to figure out how you want it to look? Do you ever go down a rabbit hole where you spent two weeks?

Pieter Levels2:36:30

没有,这是迭代式的。就像过去十年里,这儿加个CSS过渡效果,那儿做点别的调整——

英文原文

No, it’s iterative. It’s like 10 years of add a CSS transition here or do this or-

Lex Fridman2:36:35

喏,你看这些现在都是圆角的了?

英文原文

Well, see these are rounded now?

Pieter Levels2:36:35

对。

英文原文

Yeah.

Lex Fridman2:36:38

如果你愿意的话,圆角可能是更好的选择;但如果你想改成矩形、直角,你会怎么做?你直接就——

英文原文

If you wanted to, round is probably the better way, but if you want it to be rectangular, sharp corners, what would you do? You just go-

Pieter Levels2:36:45

我就打开CSS文件的索引页,按Command+F搜索‘border-radius: 12px’,然后全部替换成‘border-radius: 0’。接着按Command+Enter,Git就会自动部署……推送到GitHub,再触发Webhook,最后部署到我的服务器上,五秒内就上线了。

英文原文

So, I go through the index at CSS, and I do command F and I search border radius 12px. And then, I replace with border radius zero. And then, I do command enter and it’s Git deploys… It pushes it to the GitHub, and then sends a web book, and then deploys to my server and it’s live in five seconds.

Lex Fridman2:37:04

你经常直接部署到生产环境?你没有测试环境吗?

英文原文

You often deploy it to production? You don’t have a testing ground?

Pieter Levels2:37:08

没有。我因此出了名,因为我懒得每次都在自己笔记本上搭一套预发布(staging)服务器。所以现在,我直接部署到生产环境——天呐,我这么干肯定会被骂死。但对我个人来说,这方法效果极佳。因为我用了大量PHP、Lint和JSON校验工具,它们能及时告诉我哪里出错了。所以我不会贸然部署;事实上,过去12个月里,我大概提交了37,000次Git提交之类的。我改一个小地方,敲回车,就推送到GitHub;GitHub发Webhook给服务器,服务器拉取代码,部署到生产环境,立刻生效。

英文原文

No. So, I’m famous for this because I’m too lazy to set up a staging server on my laptop every time. So, nowadays, I just deploy to production and man, I’m going to be canceled for this. But it works very well for me. Because I have a lot have PHP, Lint and JSON, so it tells me when there’s errors. So, I don’t deploy, but literally, I have like 37,000 Git commits in the last 12 months or something. So, I make small fix, and then come out, enter and sends to GitHub. GitHub sends a web to server, web server pulls it, deploys the production and is there.

Lex Fridman2:37:45

从你按下Command键开始,整个流程延迟多久?

英文原文

What’s the latency of that from you pressing command?

Pieter Levels2:37:47

一秒,可能是一到两秒。

英文原文

One second, can be one to two seconds.

Lex Fridman2:37:50

所以,你只要一做修改,就等于在逼自己练就‘几乎不出错’的本事?

英文原文

So, you just make a change and then you’re getting really good at not making mistakes basically?

Pieter Levels2:37:53

老兄,你说得太对了!人们总问:‘你怎么能做到这点?怎么练就这种本事,让服务器不宕机?’因为你必须更谨慎地写代码。但说实话,在任何大公司里,这做法都蠢透了。可对我而言,它之所以管用,是因为让我快得飞起。比如有人在Twitter上报一个Bug,我还会掐表计时。

英文原文

Man, 100% you’re right. People are like, “How can you do this, where you get good at not taking the server down?” Because you need to code more carefully. But look, it’s idiotic in any big company. But for me it works because it makes me so fast. Somebody will report a bug on Twitter and I do a stopwatch.

Pieter Levels2:38:11

我最快多久能修好这个Bug?结果两分钟后,比如,问题就解决了。这过程很有意思,因为跟那些公司合作时,你报个Bug,结果等六个月才解决——太可怕了。而你能快速解决问题,真的会让用户特别开心。但这也确实挺疯狂的。

英文原文

How fast can I fix this bug? And then, two minutes later, for example, it’s fixed. And it’s fun because it’s annoying for me to work with companies where you report a bug and it takes six months. It’s horrible. And it makes people really happy when you can really quickly solve their problems. But it’s crazy.

Lex Fridman2:38:29

我不觉得这疯狂。我确信中间有折中方案,但我认为那种先测试、再预发布、再开发,还要用多个表、多个数据库来维护状态的整套流程——

英文原文

I don’t think it’s crazy. I’m sure there’s a middle ground, but I think that whole thing where there’s a phase of testing, and there’s the staging, and there’s the development, and then there’s multiple tables and databases that you use for the state, it’s-

Pieter Levels2:38:29

就是填表。

英文原文

Filing.

Lex Fridman2:38:46

一团乱麻。还牵扯不同团队,根本不行。

英文原文

It’s a mess. And there’s different teams involved. It’s no good.

Pieter Levels2:38:49

我就像是站在另一端、既靠谱又带点幽默感的极端例子。

英文原文

I’m like a good funny extreme on the other side.

Lex Fridman2:38:51

但稍微安全一点就好,也不用太保守。那就太棒了。

英文原文

But just a little bit safer, but not too much. It would be great.

Pieter Levels2:38:55

对,对。

英文原文

Yeah. Yeah.

Lex Fridman2:38:56

而且我敢肯定,X(原Twitter)现在搞快速迭代升级,用的就是这套方法。正是如此——

英文原文

And I’m sure that’s actually how X now, how they’re doing rapid improvement. That’s exactly-

Pieter Levels2:39:01

他们确实这么干,因为Bug变多了,大家就开始抱怨:‘哦,他买了Twitter,现在满屏都是Bug。’哥们儿,东西正在飞速上线呢,事情正在发生。现在它已是个动态应用了。

英文原文

They do because there’s more bugs and people complain about like, “Oh look, he bought this Twitter and now it’s full of bugs.” Dude, the shipping stuff, things are happening now. And it’s a dynamic app now.

Lex Fridman2:39:10

对。Bug其实恰恰说明好事正在发生。Bug本身就是一种特性,因为它表明团队真正在造东西。

英文原文

Yeah. The bugs is actually a sign of a good thing happening. The bugs are the feature because it shows that the team is actually building shit.

Pieter Levels2:39:16

完全正确。

英文原文

A hundred percent.

Lex Fridman2:39:17

嗯,其中一个问题是,我看YouTube潜力巨大,能开发的功能多得很,但我就是看它拖得太久。所以我有机会接触过不少其他团队。其中一支是MLA团队,即多语言音频(Multi-Language Audio)团队。你可能不知道,YouTube支持为视频添加不同语言的配音音轨。

英文原文

Well, one of the problems is like I see with YouTube, there’s so much potential to build features, but I just see how long it takes. So, I’ve gotten a chance to interact with many other teams. But one of the teams is MLA, multi-language audio. I don’t know if you know this, but in YouTube you can have audio tracks in different languages for overdubbing.

Lex Fridman2:39:40

这支团队人不多,用的人也不多,但每新增一个功能,他们都得开会、达成共识,还得分配资源。工程师得投入工作。但我敢肯定,工程师申请审批时肯定特别痛苦,因为任何改动都不能影响网站其余部分的正常运行。但如果缺乏足够专断、自上而下的决策力——

英文原文

And there’s a team and not many people are using it, but every single feature, they have to meet and agree. And there’s allocate resources. Engineers have to work on it. But I’m sure it’s a pain in the ass for the engineers to get approval because it has to not break the rest of the site, whatever they do. But if you don’t have enough dictatorial top down, when-

Lex Fridman2:40:00

……缺乏足够专断、自上而下的指令,比如‘我们现在就必须搞定多语言音频’,那这事永远都做不完。而多语言音频恰恰是个绝佳例子:眼下看似小众,但它极有可能彻底改变整个世界。比如我现在上传这段对话,如果能瞬间自动配音成40种语言,让所有人观看收听,那么每一段视频都能以这些不同语言被消费……这将彻底改变一切。而YouTube在这一领域拥有得天独厚的优势,足以成为领导者:它拥有算力、用户基数,也积累了丰富的相关经验。所以,多语言音频本该——

英文原文

… have enough dictatorial top-down like we need this now. It’s going to take forever to do anything multi-language audio, but multi-language audio is a good example of a thing that seems niche right now, but it quite possibly could change the entire world. When I upload this conversation right here, if instantaneously it dubs it into 40 languages and everybody consume, every single video can be watched and listened to in those different … It changes everything. And YouTube is extremely well positioned to be the leader in this. They got the compute. They got the user base. They have the experience of how to do this. So, multi-language audio should be-

Pieter Levels2:40:46

列为最高优先级功能,对吧?

英文原文

High priority feature, right?

Lex Fridman2:40:47

对。这确实是高优先级功能,也是一种……谷歌如今痴迷于AI,想向世人证明自己能在AI领域称霸。这正是谷歌亮出‘我们用上了AI’的绝佳方式,也是打破语言壁垒、终结语言狂热的一条路径。

英文原文

Yeah. That’s high priority and it’s a way … Google’s obsessed with AI right now, they want to show off that they could be dominant in AI. That’s a way for Google to say, “We used AI.” This is a way to break down the walls, that language craze.

Pieter Levels2:41:01

对他们而言,最理想的结果恐怕是保住自己的职位,而非打造出真正酷炫的产品。

英文原文

The preferred outcome for them is probably their career, not the overall result of the cool product.

Lex Fridman2:41:07

我觉得他们并非自私自利之类。而是机器——

英文原文

I think they’re not selfish or whatever. There’s something about the machine-

Pieter Levels2:41:12

组织本身。

英文原文

The organization.

Lex Fridman2:41:12

组织层面的问题,就是[听不清 02:41:14]——

英文原文

The organizational stuff that just [inaudible 02:41:14]-

Pieter Levels2:41:14

我跟合作的大公司打交道时,常遇到这类情况。我在私信里跟很多人聊过,他们每个人都真的在拼命做事,都很友善;而我反倒像个混蛋,总说:‘伙计们,这事我跟你们20个人聊了六个月,却毫无进展。’他们就说:‘老兄,我知道,但我真的尽力了。’所以,这是系统性问题。

英文原文

I have this when I report box on big companies I work with. I talk to a lot of different people in DM and they’re all really trying hard to do something. They’re all really nice and I’m the one being kind of asshole because I’m like, “Guys, I’m talking to 20 people about this for six months, nothing’s happening.” They say, ” Man, I know, but I’m trying my best.” And yeah, so it’s systemic.

Lex Fridman2:41:34

对。这再次要求——我也不知道有没有更委婉的说法——一种专断型的自上而下管理:CEO亲自介入,对YouTube直接下令:‘MLA项目,立刻给我搞定。这是最高优先级。’

英文原文

Yeah. It requires, again, I don’t know if there must be a nicer word, but a dictatorial type of top-down the CEO rolls in and just says for YouTube, it’s like MLA, get this done now. This is the highest priority.

Pieter Levels2:41:48

我觉得大公司,尤其是美国的大公司,很多事都是法律问题。你得把所有东西都交给法务部门过一遍。而像我这样做事,根本不可能在大公司里这么干,因为所有东西部署之前,大概率都得先过法务这一关。

英文原文

I think big companies, especially in America, a lot of it is legal. You need to pass everything through legal. And you can’t like, man, the things I do, I could never do that in a big corporation because everything has to be probably get deployed, has to go through legal.

Lex Fridman2:42:01

嗯,再说一次,这属于独裁式管理。基本上,史蒂夫·乔布斯就经常这么干。我见过不少领导者都这么做:无视律师,无视薪酬委员会(comps)。

英文原文

Well, again, dictatorial. You basically say Steve Jobs did this quite a lot. I’ve seen a lot of leaders do this. Ignore the lawyers. Ignore comps.

Pieter Levels2:42:10

没错,是的。

英文原文

Exactly. Yeah.

Lex Fridman2:42:11

无视公关部门,无视所有人,把权力交给工程师,倾听一线员工的声音,赶紧把这事搞定,而且必须在周五前搞定。就这些。

英文原文

Ignore PR. Ignore everybody. Give power to the engineers. Listen to the people on the ground, get this shit done and get it done by Friday. That’s it.

Pieter Levels2:42:20

而且法律本身也会变。举个例子,假设你上线了这个AI配音功能,结果引发了一些法律纠纷和诉讼,于是法律随之调整,案子会上诉,甚至可能打到最高法院,最终法律条文被修改。所以,只要你把它发布出去,你就改变了社会,也改变了法律框架;而如果你总是因害怕现有法律框架而不敢发布,那你什么都不会改变。

英文原文

And the law can change. For example, let’s say you launch this AI dubbing and there’s some legal problems with lawsuits, so the law changes, there will be appeals, there will be some Supreme Court thing, whatever, and the law changes. So, just by shipping it, you change society, you change the legal framework. By not shipping, being scared of the legal framework all the time, you’re not changing things.

Lex Fridman2:42:39

纯粹出于好奇,你用的是什么集成开发环境(ID)?咱们聊聊你的整套开发环境配置吧。鉴于你效率超高——常常穿着内裤瘫在沙发上写代码——那对你来说,用什么ID重要吗?你用的是VS Code吗?

英文原文

Just out of curiosity, what ID do you use? Let’s talk about your whole setup. Given how ultra productive you are that you often program in your underwear slouching on the couch, does it matter to you in general? Is there a specific ID you use? VS Code?

Pieter Levels2:42:57

对,用VS Code。以前我用Sublime Text。我觉得这其实没那么重要。我对那些总强调‘工具特别重要’的说法持高度怀疑态度,真的不觉得它有多关键。我认为,只要你对自己手头的工具非常熟悉,就能跑得飞快。比如IDE里的快捷键——我超爱Sublime Text,因为它支持多光标操作:你搜索某个内容后,就能用光标批量替换整个文件里的匹配项;而VS Code在这方面做得并不好。

英文原文

Yeah, VS Code. Before, I used Sublime text. I don’t think it matters a lot. I think I’m very skeptical of tools when people think they say it matters, right? I don’t think it matters. I think whatever tool you know very well, you can go very fast. And the shortcuts, for example, IDE. I love Sublime text because I could use multi-cursor. You search something and then I could make mass replaces in a file with the cursor thing and the VS Code doesn’t really have that as well.

Lex Fridman2:43:27

Sublime是我最早学会这个功能的编辑器,他们把这功能做得特别简单易用。那这功能叫什么来着?多编辑?

英文原文

Sublime is the first editor where I’ve learned that. And I think they just make that super easy. So, what would that be called? Multi-edit.

Pieter Levels2:43:35

多光标(multi-cursor)。

英文原文

Multi-cursor.

Lex Fridman2:43:35

就是多光标编辑功能,随便怎么叫都行。

英文原文

Multi-cursor edit thing, whatever.

Pieter Levels2:43:38

太棒了。

英文原文

So good.

Lex Fridman2:43:39

我敢说几乎所有编辑器都能实现这个功能,只是设置起来可能比较麻烦。

英文原文

I’m sure almost every editor can do that. It’s just probably hard to set up.

Pieter Levels2:43:44

是啊,我觉得VS Code在这点上确实不太行,至少我试过之后是这么觉得的。不过我常用它来处理数据,比如世界银行的数据集——我就靠多光标批量修改所有内容。但话说回来,我现在用的就是VS Code。老天,我是被逼着换的:推特上老有人看到我截图里用的是Sublime Text,就嚷嚷‘你怎么还在用Sublime Text啊,老古董!快换VS Code!’我就说‘行吧行吧,我试试’。后来我换了新MacBook,重装系统时压根没从旧电脑复制任何东西,而是彻底清空、全新安装,就像Windows里格式化C盘那样,一切从零开始。我就想:‘好吧,这次试试VS Code。’结果一用就黏上了,不过说实话,我也不太在意——这玩意儿对我真没那么重要。

英文原文

Yeah, VS Code’s not so good at it, I think, or at least I tried it. But I would use that to process data, like data sets. For example, from World Bank. I would just multi-cursor mass change everything. But yeah, VS Code. Man, I was bullied into using VS Code because Twitter would always see my screenshots of Sublime text and say, “Why are you still using Sublime text, Boomer. You need to use VS Code.” I’m like, “Yeah, I’ll try it.” I got a new MacBook and then I never install. I never copy the old MacBook. I just make it fresh, like a clean format C Windows, clean starts. And I’m like, “Okay, I’ll try VS Code.” And it’s stuck, but I don’t really care. It’s not so important for me.

Lex Fridman2:44:23

哇哦,提到‘格式化C盘’这个梗啊?

英文原文

Wow. The format C reference, huh?

Pieter Levels2:44:25

老兄,那可真是黄金年代!你装完Windows,三到六个月后系统就开始出毛病、越来越卡,然后你就重启进DOS,执行format C,把整个硬盘清空,再重新装一遍Windows 95——那感觉简直太爽了!你还能重新规划一切:‘这次我要好好装系统’,‘这次我要把桌面布置得漂漂亮亮’。

英文原文

Dude, it was so good. You would install windows and then after three or six months, it would start breaking and everything gets slow. Then you would restart, go to DOS, format C, you would delete your hard drive and then install the Windows 95 again. It was so good times. And you would design everything. Now, I’m going to install it properly. Now, I’m going to design my desktop properly.

Lex Fridman2:44:47

是啊,我不知道算不算同辈压力,但我用了好多年Emacs,而且我很喜欢Lisp,所以大量自定义功能都是用Lisp写的——这本身就是一门编程语言。部分原因确实是同辈压力,但另一部分也是意识到:人得持续学习新东西。jQuery也是类似情况。我觉得自己现在还是得学Node.js,哪怕这根本不是我的主业,甚至离主业差得十万八千里。但我觉得,你得一直学下去;哪怕最后不长期使用,也得先给它一个机会——这样,你对世界的理解才会不断拓展。

英文原文

Yeah, I don’t know if it’s peer pressure, but I used Emacs for many, many years and I love Lisp, so a lot of the customization is done in Lisp. It’s a programming language. Partially, it was peer pressure, but part of it is realizing you need to keep learning stuff. The same issue with jQuery. I still think I need to learn NodeJS for example, even though that’s not my main thing or even close to the main thing. But I feel like you need to keep learning this stuff. And even if you don’t choose to use it long term, you need to give it a chance. So, your understanding of the world expands.

Pieter Levels2:45:23

是啊,你想搞懂新的技术概念,看看它们能不能帮到你。连试都不试一下,那才傻呢。

英文原文

Yeah, you want to understand the new technological concepts and see if they can benefit you. It would be stupid not to even try it.

Lex Fridman2:45:30

我觉得更重要的其实是概念层面的拓展,而非工具本身的扩展。而这恰恰是个挑战。比如真正沉下心去学VS Code:掌握所有快捷键、所有插件,实际安装各种组件、动手折腾——这本身就是个有趣的挑战,一开始确实挺别扭的。

英文原文

It’s more about the concepts I would say, than the actual tools expanding. And that can be a challenging thing. So, going to VS Code and really learning it, all the shortcuts, all the extensions, and actually installing different stuff and playing with it, that was an interesting challenge. It was uncomfortable at first.

Pieter Levels2:45:46

是啊,我也是这样。

英文原文

Yeah, for me too. Yeah.

Lex Fridman2:45:47

是啊,但你就是一头扎进去。

英文原文

Yeah. But you just dive in.

Pieter Levels2:45:48

这就像是神经可塑性训练(NeuroFlex),让你的大脑保持新鲜活跃,诸如此类。

英文原文

It’s like NeuroFlex, like you keep your brain fresh, this kind of stuff.

Lex Fridman2:45:52

我得多练练这个。你给React机会了吗?

英文原文

I got to do that more. Have you given React a chance?

Pieter Levels2:45:56

还没,但我确实想学。基础概念我都懂,就是不知道该从哪儿下手。

英文原文

No, but I want to learn. I understand the basics. I don’t really know where to start.

Lex Fridman2:46:03

不过我想,你得用它来构建真实项目,这才是你自己的学习模型。

英文原文

But I guess you got to use your own model, which is build the thing using it.

Pieter Levels2:46:09

不,老兄,我其实已经这么干过了。我用jQuery做的那些东西,本质上很多都是在无意中重复造轮子——不是刻意模仿现有技术,而是写着写着,不知不觉就重建了已有的技术方案。我坚持写得足够久,结果碰到了所有人共通的问题,于是也开始搭建类似的框架。所以本质上,我用的是我自己的一套框架……

英文原文

No, man, so I kind of did that. The stuff I do in jQuery is essentially a lot of it is like I start rebuilding whatever tech is already out there, not based on that, but just on accident. I keep going long enough that I built the same. I start getting the same problems everybody else has and you start building the same frameworks kind. So, essentially I use my own framework of-

Lex Fridman2:46:29

所以你是从零开始,亲手打造了一套完全属于自己的框架,并且对它了如指掌。

英文原文

So, you basically build a framework from scratch that’s your own, that you understand it.

Pieter Levels2:46:32

差不多吧,比如Ajax调用之类的功能,本质上也是一样的。听着,我没那么多时间。而且说‘没时间’往往只是借口,归根结底是你没把它放到足够高的优先级上。我现在的首要任务仍是经营公司、持续优化业务,以及推进AI相关工作。我觉得,现阶段学AI比学前端框架有价值得多,影响力也大得多。

英文原文

Kind of, yeah, with Ajax calls, but that’s essentially the same thing. Look, I don’t have the time. And I think saying you don’t have the time is always a lie because you just don’t prioritize it enough. My priority is still running the businesses and improving that and AI. I think learning AI is much more valuable now than learning front end framework. It’s just more impact.

Lex Fridman2:46:53

我想,你每天确实该学点新东西。

英文原文

I guess you should be just learning every single day a thing.

Pieter Levels2:46:58

对,你可以每天学一点点React,或者现在Next.js风头正劲,那就每天学一点Next.js。不过我管这些叫‘军工复合体’,但不管怎样,你还是得了解它、掌握它。

英文原文

Yeah, you can learn a little bit every day, a little bit of React or I think now Next is very big, so learn a little bit of Next. But I call them the military industrial complex. But you need to know, know it anyway.

Lex Fridman2:47:11

你得先学会如何使用战争武器,然后才能当和平缔造者。

英文原文

You got to learn how to use the weapons of war and then you can be a peacemaker.

Pieter Levels2:47:11

是啊。

英文原文

Yeah.

Lex Fridman2:47:16

是啊,我的意思是,你得用我们刚才聊的那种方式去学——也就是边学边用它做项目,还要真刀真枪地部署上线。

英文原文

Yeah, I mean, but you got to learn it in the same exact way as we were talking about, which is learn it by trying to build something with it and actually deploy it.

Pieter Levels2:47:25

这些框架太复杂了,而且更新太快。所以问题来了:我到底该从哪儿开始?我想,这跟当年初学建网站时的迷茫是一样的——面对GPT-4,我该从哪儿起步?但现实就是这么动态,变化太快,所以我甚至不确定现在花时间学它是否明智。也许可以组合着学:比如Next.js搭配PHP的Laravel框架(Laravel是PHP的一个框架),这或许对我有帮助;再比如Tailwind CSS这种CSS样式引擎,这类工具说不定能帮我节省不少时间。

英文原文

The frameworks are so complicated and it changes so fast. So, it’s like where do I start? And I guess it’s the same thing when you’re starting out making websites, where do you start as GPT-4, I guess. But yeah, it’s just so dynamic. It changes so fast that I don’t know if it would be a good idea for me to learn it. Maybe some combination of few Next with PHP Laravel. Laravel is like a framework for PHP. I think that it could benefit me. Maybe Tailwind for CSS, like a styling engine. That stuff could probably save me time.

Lex Fridman2:47:58

但话说回来,你不真动手试一试,永远没法知道效果如何。感觉上,你得亲自构建点什么——也许我是在自言自语,但我真该用Laravel重写我那个个人单页网站了。哪怕它几乎没有任何动态元素,也可以加一个动态功能,但必须用这个框架端到端走完整流程;或者用Node.js从头到尾完整构建并部署一次。其中一部分难点,就在于搞清楚到底该怎么部署。

英文原文

But yeah, you won’t know until you really give it a try. And it feels like you have to build, if maybe I’m talking to myself, but I should probably recode my personal one page in Laravel. Or even though it might not have almost any dynamic elements, maybe have one dynamic element, but it has to go end to end in that framework or end-to-end build in NodeJS. Some of it is figuring out how to you even deploy the thing.

Pieter Levels2:48:29

我完全没概念。我只知道现在会把代码推送到GitHub,然后自动同步到我的服务器。至于JavaScript怎么运行,我一无所知。所以我想,我需要Vercel或Heroku这类平台帮忙。

英文原文

I have no idea. All I know is right now, I would send it to GitHub and it sends it to my server. I don’t know how to get JavaScript running. I have no clue. So, I guess I need a pass like Vercel or Heroku, those kind of platform.

Lex Fridman2:48:44

我刚刚突然冒出个想法:我就想做一个单页网站,只含一个动态功能,然后用一大堆不同框架分别实现它。

英文原文

I actually just gave myself the idea of I just want to build a single webpage, one webpage that has one dynamic element and just do it in every single, in a lot of frameworks.

Pieter Levels2:48:59

啊,在同一个页面上?

英文原文

Ah, on the same page?

Lex Fridman2:49:01

完全相同的页面。

英文原文

Same exact page.

Pieter Levels2:49:03

全都一样?

英文原文

All the same?

Lex Fridman2:49:03

差不多一样的页面。

英文原文

Kind of page.

Pieter Levels2:49:04

这主意很聪明啊,是个很棒的项目。你能借此学遍所有框架,还能直观看出它们之间的差异,挺有意思的。

英文原文

That’s smart page. That’s a cool project. You can learn all these frameworks. And you can see the differences. That’s interesting.

Lex Fridman2:49:08

还能测测各自耗时多久。

英文原文

How long it takes to do it.

Pieter Levels2:49:09

对,拿秒表计时。

英文原文

Yeah, stopwatch.

Lex Fridman2:49:11

我还得琢磨出一个足够复杂的任务。因为它最好能实现某种数据库访问功能,并能动态变更内容。

英文原文

I have to figure out actually something sufficiently complicated. Because it should probably do some kind of thing where it accesses the database and dynamically is changing stuff.

Pieter Levels2:49:23

加点AI功能,或者大语言模型(LLM)相关的东西。

英文原文

Some AI stuff, some LLM stuff.

Lex Fridman2:49:25

对,倒不一定非得是AI或LLM,API调用也行。

英文原文

Yeah. It doesn’t have to be AI LLM, but maybe API call.

Pieter Levels2:49:29

那就做成API调用。

英文原文

But then you do it API.

Lex Fridman2:49:29

调用某个外部API。

英文原文

API call to something.

Pieter Levels2:49:30

对,比如做个复刻版。这部分会特别酷。

英文原文

Yeah. To replicate, for example. And then that would be a very cool part.

Lex Fridman2:49:33

对对对。还要计时,同时记录我的心情指数——我真要干这个了!

英文原文

Yeah, yeah, yeah. And time it. And also report on my happiness. I’m going to totally do this.

Pieter Levels2:49:41

因为没人做过这种基准测试。没人拿开发者幸福感去对比不同框架,也没人测过各框架的实际交付耗时。

英文原文

Because nobody benchmarks this. Nobody’s benchmark developer happiness with frameworks. Nobody’s benchmark the shipping time.

Lex Fridman2:49:47

干脆花一个月来做这件事。主流框架有多少种?大概五种主要实现路径吧,涵盖前后端。

英文原文

Just take a month and do this. How many frameworks are there? There’s five main ways of doing it. So, there’s backend and frontend.

Pieter Levels2:49:58

这些东西也把我搞糊涂了。比如React,现在好像都变成后端框架了——它本来明明只是前端框架,结果现在你被迫也得用它写后端。我真搞不懂。然后……

英文原文

This stuff confused me, too. Like React now apparently has become backend or something that used to be only frontend and you’re forced to do now backend also. I don’t know. And then.

Lex Fridman2:50:07

但据互联网所说,你其实并不真的被迫做任何事。找到做事的‘标准方式’实际上并非易事。比如标准场景:你去冰淇淋店,店里有一百万种口味。我想要香草味。如果我这辈子从未吃过冰淇淋,我们能不能先学学什么是冰淇淋?我想要香草味。有时他们真就直接标着‘香草’。但我真正想了解的是:最基本的方式是什么?但又不是那种傻乎乎的、而是标准的、公认的、普遍采用的方式。

英文原文

But you’re not really forced to do anything, according to the internet. It’s actually not trivial to find the canonical way of doing things. So, the standard, you go to the ice cream shop, there’s a million flavors. I want vanilla. If I’ve never had ice cream in my life, can we just learn about ice cream? I want vanilla. Sometimes they’ll literally name it vanilla. But I want to know what’s the basic way, but not dumb, but the standard canonical common.

Pieter Levels2:50:42

对,我想知道占主导地位的做法。

英文原文

Yeah. I want to know the dominant way.

Lex Fridman2:50:43

对,占主导地位的做法。

英文原文

Yeah, the dominant way.

Pieter Levels2:50:44

比如只有6%的开发者是这么做的。要搞清楚这一点很难。这就是问题所在。

英文原文

Like the 6% of developers do it like this. It’s hard to figure that out. That’s the problem.

Lex Fridman2:50:50

对,也许大语言模型(LLM)能帮上忙。也许你应该明确地问:‘占主导地位的做法是什么?’

英文原文

Yeah, maybe LLMs can help. Maybe you should explicitly ask what is the dominant-

Pieter Levels2:50:54

因为它们通常知道哪种做法占主导地位——它们给出的答案往往是概率最高的那一类,所以向它们提问确实很有道理。而且说实话,我觉得,如果你真想学某个框架,或者我想学某个框架,最有效的办法或许是雇一位已经熟练使用它的人,然后坐在一起,一起动手做一个项目。我自己从没这么做过,但一直想过。这样就能非常快速地把他的知识‘装进’我的脑子里。

英文原文

Because they usually know the dominant. They give answers that are the most probable kind of, so that makes sense to ask them. And I think honestly, maybe what would help is if you want to learn or I would want to learn a framework, hire somebody that already does it and just sit with them and make something together. I’ve never done that, but I’ve thought about it. So, that would be a very fast way to take their knowledge in my brain.

Lex Fridman2:51:19

我试过这类方法。结果取决于对方是谁:如果对方是世界级的开发者,那当然好;但很多时候,他们自己早已习惯那种方式,从未主动探索过其他选项。于是他们就会带着教条主义的态度居高临下地告诉你:‘这才是正确的做法。’而你得说:‘不不不,咱们只是共同探索而已。好吧,给我看看你试过的那些酷炫的东西。’这就要求双方都保持开放心态——要知道,Node.js 并非 Web 开发的唯一正解,它只是一种方式而已;传统的 LAMP(Linux + Apache + MySQL + PHP)、PHP、jQuery 和原生 JavaScript 方式也完全没问题,只是各有优劣,关键是你得清楚这些优劣分别是什么。

英文原文

I’ve tried these kinds of things. What happens is it depends, if they’re a world-class developer, yes. Oftentimes, they themselves are used to that thing and they have not themselves explored in other options. So, they have this dogmatic talking down to you, “This is the right way to do it.” It’s like, “No, no, no, we’re just exploring together. Okay, show me the cool thing you’ve tried,” which is it has to have open mindedness to NodeJS is not the right way to do web development. It’s like one way. And there’s nothing wrong with the old LAMP, PHP, jQuery, vanilla JavaScript way. It just has its pros and cons and you need to know what the pros and cons are.

Pieter Levels2:52:06

对,但这类人确实存在,你大概率能找到他们。

英文原文

Yeah, but those people exist. You could find those people probably.

Lex Fridman2:52:08

对。

英文原文

Yeah.

Pieter Levels2:52:09

如果你想学人工智能,想象一下,让卡帕西(Karpathy)就坐在你旁边。他做那些 YouTube 视频,简直太棒了。他甚至能用五岁小孩都能听懂的方式,教你如何构建大语言模型(LLM)。太神奇了!再想象一下,这个人就坐在你身边,手把手教你:‘咱们一起来做个 LLM 吧。’天啊,那简直太棒了!

英文原文

If you want to learn AI, imagine you have Karpathy sitting next to you. He does these YouTube videos. It’s amazing. He can teach it to a five-year-old about how to make LLM. It’s amazing. Imagine this guy sitting next to you and just teaching you, “Let’s make LLM together.” Holy shit. It would be amazing.

Lex Fridman2:52:26

对,我是说,卡帕西有他自己的风格,我不确定他是否适合所有人。比如那个‘五岁小孩’——这还得看是哪个五岁小孩。

英文原文

Yeah. I mean, Karpathy has its own style and I’m not sure he’s for everybody. For example, a five-year-old. It depends on the five-year-old.

Pieter Levels2:52:35

对。

英文原文

Yeah.

Lex Fridman2:52:36

他技术性极强。

英文原文

He’s super technical.

Pieter Levels2:52:37

但他之所以厉害,恰恰是因为他技术性极强,同时又是唯一能用如此简单方式解释这些复杂概念的人——这正体现了他彻头彻尾的天才之处。如果你能不用术语就把事情讲清楚,大家只会惊叹:‘哇!’

英文原文

But he’s amazing because he’s super technical and he’s the only one who can explain this stuff in a simple way, which shows his complete genius. If you can explain without jargon, you’re like, “Wow.”

Lex Fridman2:52:48

而且是从零开始亲手构建。

英文原文

And build it from scratch.

Pieter Levels2:52:50

对,绝对是顶级水准,这家伙真了不起。

英文原文

Yeah, it’s like top tier, like, what a guy.

Lex Fridman2:52:53

但他可能反框架,因为他习惯从零开始构建。

英文原文

But he might be anti-framework because he builds from scratch.

Pieter Levels2:52:57

没错,正是如此。实际上他很可能就是。对。

英文原文

Exactly. Yeah. Actually he probably is. Yeah.

Lex Fridman2:53:00

他就像你,不过是专攻人工智能领域的你。

英文原文

He’s like you, but for AI.

Pieter Levels2:53:02

对。所以,也许对我们来说,学习框架本身就是一个很糟糕的主意。也许我们应该继续待在 PHP 和脚本小子(script kiddie)的世界里,以及……

英文原文

Yeah. So, maybe learning framework is a very bad idea for us. Maybe we should stay in PHP and script kiddie and the…

Lex Fridman2:53:08

但也许,通过学习框架,你反而能弄清自己真正想从零开始构建什么。

英文原文

But you have to maybe by learning the framework, you learn what you want to yourself build from scratch.

Pieter Levels2:53:14

对,也许该学的是概念,但你其实不必马上把它用到自己的实际工作中,对吧?对,对。

英文原文

Yeah. Maybe learn concepts, but you don’t actually have to start using it for your life, right? Yeah, yeah.

Lex Fridman2:53:19

你至今还是个 Mac 用户,或者说曾经是个 Mac 用户?

英文原文

And you’re still a Mac guy, or was a Mac guy.

Pieter Levels2:53:21

对,对。我是在 2014 年转用 Mac 的。当时我想开始旅行,我哥哥就对我说:‘伙计,买台 MacBook 吧,现在这已经是标配了。’我当时就想:‘哇,我得从 Windows 切换过去了。’那时我用着三块屏幕,全是 Windows 系统,整套音乐制作环境都搭好了,结果全得卖掉。之后我就买了台 MacBook,记得打开包装盒那一刻,它美得令人窒息——铝合金机身,闪闪发亮。我掀开盖子,撕掉屏幕保护膜,真是美极了。我整整三天都没碰它,就光盯着它看。那会儿我还一直用着 Windows 电脑呢。后来我就带着它去旅行了。

英文原文

Yeah, yeah. I switched to Mac in 2014. It was because when I wanted to start traveling and my brother was like, “Dude, get a MacBook. It’s the standard now.” I’m like, “Wow, I need to switch from Windows.” And I had three screens, like windows. I had this whole setup for music production. I had to sell everything. And then I had a MacBook and I remember opening up this MacBook box and it was so beautiful. It was this aluminum. And then I opened it. I removed the screen protector thing. It’s so beautiful. And I didn’t touch it for three days. I was just looking at it really. And I was still on the Windows computer. And then I went traveling with that.

Pieter Levels2:53:56

而且,所有好事都是在我转用 Mac 之后才开始发生的——这话听起来是不是特别教条?

英文原文

And all my great things started when I switched to Mac, which sounds very dogmatic, right?

Lex Fridman2:54:01

你说的好事具体指哪些?

英文原文

What great things are you talking about?

Pieter Levels2:54:03

所有生意都开始走上正轨,我开始旅行,开始创办初创公司,开始赚钱——这一切,全都是在我转用 Mac 之后才开始的。

英文原文

All the businesses started working out. I started traveling. I started building startups. I started making money. It all started when I switched to Mac.

Lex Fridman2:54:10

听着,你快把我劝得想换 Mac 了。我现在要么在 Windows 里用 WSL 运行 Linux,要么直接用 Ubuntu Linux。但像编辑或 Adobe 系列软件这类工作,我还是得靠 Windows。

英文原文

Listen, you’re making me want to switch to Mac. So, I either use Linux inside Windows with WSL or just Ubuntu Linux. But Windows for most stuff like editing or any Adobe products.

Pieter Levels2:54:27

对,比如 Adobe 系列软件,对吧?

英文原文

Yeah, like Adobe stuff, right?

Lex Fridman2:54:28

对,对,对。嗯,我想 Mac 上也能做这些事。我在想,我是不是该换 Mac?你怀念 Windows 的哪些地方?它的优缺点分别是什么?

英文原文

Yeah, yeah, yeah. Well, I guess you could do Mac stuff there. I wonder if I should switch. What do you miss about Windows? What was the pros and cons?

Pieter Levels2:54:35

我觉得 Mac 的‘访达’(Finder)简直糟糕透顶。

英文原文

I think the Finder is horrible. Mac.

Lex Fridman2:54:38

什么糟糕透顶?

英文原文

The what is horrible?

Pieter Levels2:54:38

‘访达’(Finder)。哦,你不知道‘访达’?那就是 Mac 上的文件管理器,相当于 Windows 的资源管理器(Windows Explorer)。

英文原文

The Finder. Oh, you don’t know the Finder? So, there’s the Windows Explorer.

Lex Fridman2:54:41

对。

英文原文

Yeah.

Pieter Levels2:54:42

Windows 资源管理器简直太棒了。

英文原文

Windows Explorer is amazing.

Lex Fridman2:54:42

谢谢你居高临下地贬低我。

英文原文

Thank you for talking down on me.

Pieter Levels2:54:44

‘访达’真的很奇怪,老兄。它有些怪异的地方。比如有个 Bug:你在 WhatsApp 或 Telegram 上发送或添加照片时,它会自动选中整个文件夹,你一不小心按了回车键,就会把整个文件夹里的所有照片、所有文件一股脑儿发到聊天群里——这事就发生在我女朋友身上。她开始一张接一张地往我这儿发照片。所以‘访达’真的很古怪,不过 Mac 整体是基于 Unix 的,因此自带 Linux 特性。

英文原文

The Finder is strange, man. There’s strange things. There’s this bug where if you send, attach a photo on WhatsApp or Telegram, it just selects the whole folder and you almost accidentally can click Enter and you send all your photos, all your files to this chat group, happened to my girlfriend. She starts sending me photo, photo, photo. So, Finder is very unusual, but it has Linux. The whole thing is it’s Unix-based.

Lex Fridman2:55:06

所以你常用命令行?

英文原文

So, you use the command?

Pieter Levels2:55:08

对,一直用,一直用。有意思的是,Mac 上可以运行各种 Unix 系统,比如 Debian 之类的,绝大多数 Linux 工具都能在 macOS 上跑,这让它成为开发的绝佳平台。我本地就跑着 Nginx 服务器。只要我不懒,懒得在笔记本上搭建测试环境,那就直接用 Nginx 服务器,和我云服务器上的配置一模一样,网站运行方式也完全一致。我几乎能复用全部配置文件,一切都能正常工作。这让 Mac 成为运行 Linux 相关任务的极佳平台,我觉得。

英文原文

Yeah, all the time. All the time. And the cool thing is you can run, I think it’s like Unix, like Debian or whatever. You can run most Linux stuff on MacOS, which makes it very good for development. I have my Nginx server. If I’m not lazy in set up my staging on my laptop, it’s just the Nginx server, the same as I have on my cloud server, the same way the websites run. And I can use almost everything, the same config files, configuration files, and it just works. And that makes Mac a very good platform for Linux stuff, I think.

Lex Fridman2:55:41

对,对。

英文原文

Yeah. Yeah.

Pieter Levels2:55:43

当然,真正的 Ubuntu 还是要更好一些,不过……

英文原文

Real Ubuntu is better, of course, but.

Lex Fridman2:55:45

我目前处于一种很奇怪的境地:我在 Windows 和 Android 上算是个高级用户,而我那些更聪明的朋友全都用 Mac 和 iPhone。这就有点……

英文原文

Yeah, I’m in this weird situation, where I’m somewhat of a power user in Windows and let’s say Android and all the much smarter friends I have all using Mac and iPhone. And it’s like-

Pieter Levels2:56:03

但你不想屈服于同辈压力。

英文原文

But you don’t want to go through the peer pressure.

Lex Fridman2:56:06

这不是同辈压力。我之所以想生孩子,其中一个原因是我打心底里喜欢孩子,但也有顾虑:也许会有取舍,或者诸如此类的问题。不过,我看到身边那些极其成功、极其聪明的朋友,他们有了孩子后真的非常幸福。所以这不是同辈压力,而是一个强烈的信号。

英文原文

It’s not peer pressure. It’s one of the reasons I want to have kids is that I would love to have kids as a baseline, but there’s a concern. Maybe there’s going to be a tradeoff or all this kind of stuff. But you see these extremely successful smart people who are friends of mine, who have kids and are really happy they have kids. So, that’s not peer pressure, that’s just a strong signal.

Pieter Levels2:56:28

对,这事儿对很多人管用。

英文原文

Yeah. It works for people.

Lex Fridman2:56:29

这事儿对很多人管用。Mac 也是同理:从根本上讲,我不喜欢封闭系统,所以我本质上更喜欢 Windows,因为它自由度更高;Android 也是一样,自由度更高,可定制性更强。但所有‘酷 kids’、所有聪明人都在用 Mac 和 iPhone。这就让我觉得:‘好吧,我得认真试试看了。’尤其是开发方面,毕竟越来越多的工作都在云端完成。总之,听你说‘所有好事都是转用 Mac 后才开始的’,还挺有意思的。也许我也能变成那样——等我转用 Mac 后,所有好事就开始发生了。

英文原文

It works for people. And the same thing with Mac. It’s like I don’t see, fundamentally, I don’t like closed systems. So, fundamentally, I like Windows more because there’s much more freedom. Same with Android. There’s much more freedom. It’s much more customizable. But all the cool kids, the smart kids are using Mac and iPhone. It’s like, “All right, I need to give it a real chance,” especially for development, since more and more stuff is done in the cloud anyway. Anyway. But it’s funny to hear you say all the good stuff started happening. Maybe I’ll be like that guy too. When I switched to Mac, all the good stuff started happening.

Pieter Levels2:57:10

我觉得这主要跟硬件有关,倒不是软件的问题。Mac 的硬件做工实在太精良了,比如键盘。

英文原文

I think it’s just about the hardware. It’s not so much about the software. The hardware is so well-built, right? The keyboard.

Lex Fridman2:57:15

对,但你看我用的这个键盘。

英文原文

Yeah. But look at the keyboard I use.

Pieter Levels2:57:16

确实挺酷的。

英文原文

It is pretty cool.

Lex Fridman2:57:19

‘酷’这个词还算贴切。你最喜欢在哪儿工作?

英文原文

That’s one word for it. What’s your favorite place to work?

Pieter Levels2:57:23

在沙发上。

英文原文

On the couch.

Lex Fridman2:57:24

沙发重要吗?是指家里的沙发,还是随便哪张沙发都行?

英文原文

Does the couch matter? Is the couch at home or is it any couch?

Pieter Levels2:57:28

不,比如酒店房间里的沙发。

英文原文

No, like hotel couch. In the room.

Lex Fridman2:57:31

房间里的沙发。

英文原文

In the room.

Pieter Levels2:57:31

但我以前工作时特别讲究人体工学:站着办公桌、一切配置都完美——屏幕高度与视线齐平,等等等等。后来我发现,这跟抬举动作也有关系。我开始出现重复性劳损(RSI),比如手指发麻之类的感觉,这种不适感甚至会蔓延到整个背部。有一次,我在联合办公空间里早上六点就开始工作,太阳刚升起,我正埋头写代码,突然听到一个声音或别的什么动静,就往左一扭头,结果脖子一下子僵住了,心想:‘哇,完蛋了。’我当时就想:‘我是不是要死了?我大概真的要死了。’

英文原文

But I used to work very ergonomically with a standing desk and everything, perfect, eye height, screen, blah, blah, blah. And I felt like, man, this has to do with lifting too. I started getting RSI, like a repetitive strain injury, like tingling stuff. And it would go all the way on my back. And I was sitting in a coworking space like 6:00 AM, sun comes up and I’m working and I’m coding and I hear a sound or something. So, I look left and my neck gets stuck and I’m like, “Wow. Fuck.” And I’m like, “Am I dying? And I’m probably dying.”

Lex Fridman2:58:05

对,大概真的要死了。

英文原文

Yeah, probably dying.

Pieter Levels2:58:06

我才不想死在联合办公空间里呢。我要回家,在平静与尊严中死去。于是我合上笔记本,塞进背包,走到街上,骑上我的摩托车,回家躺到枕头上,把腿抬高,好缓解背部的不适——因为整个背部都出问题了。而这全是因为我长期那样工作。所以我后来开始用笔记本支架,一切都重新调整到符合人体工学的标准。

英文原文

I don’t want to die in a coworking space. I’m going to go home and die in peace and honor. So, I closed my laptop and I put it in my backpack. And I walked to the street and got on my motorbike, went home and I lied down on a pillow with my legs up and stuff to get rid of this … Because it was my whole back. And it was because I was working like this all the time. So, I started getting a laptop stand everything ergonomically correct.

Pieter Levels2:58:34

但后来我开始举重。从那以后,似乎一切都变得顺畅了:体态更挺直了,再也不会得重复性劳损(RSI),手也不再发麻,完全没疼痛之类的问题了。于是,我就开始在沙发上工作,感觉特别棒——你离……很近。我这样坐着:双腿并拢,腿上放个枕头,再把笔记本电脑放在上面,然后就开始工作。

英文原文

But then I started lifting. And since then, it seems like everything gets straightened out. Your posture, you’re more straight. And I’d never have RSI anymore, representative strain injury. Never tingling anymore. No pains and stuff. So then, I started working on the sofa and it’s great. It feels you’re close to the … I sit like this legs together and then a pillow and then a laptop, and then I work.

Lex Fridman2:59:02

你是向后靠吗?

英文原文

Are you leaning back?

Pieter Levels2:59:06

双腿并拢,然后——

英文原文

Together like legs and then-

Lex Fridman2:59:07

鼠标放在哪儿?用的是——

英文原文

Where’s the mouse? Using the-

Pieter Levels2:59:09

不用鼠标。MacOS系统、MacBook上所有操作都靠触控板。我以前用过罗技MX鼠标,那款堪称完美的人体工学鼠标——

英文原文

No. So, everything’s trackpad on the MacOS, on the MacBook. I used to have the Logitech MX mouse, the perfect ergonomic mouse-

Lex Fridman2:59:17

你就只用这个小东西做这些操作。

英文原文

You’re just doing this little thing with the thing.

Pieter Levels2:59:19

对。

英文原文

Yes.

Lex Fridman2:59:19

就一个屏幕?

英文原文

One screen?

Pieter Levels2:59:20

就一个屏幕。我以前用三个屏幕。所以,我清楚人们是从哪儿来的——我以前也堆了满屋子设备,但后来意识到,把所有东西都浓缩到一台笔记本里,反而更棒。这台是16英寸的MacBook,屏幕其实挺大的。但只用这一台,感觉太棒了,因为你离工具特别近,离正在发生的事特别近,就像修车一样。老兄,要是用三块屏幕,你得这儿看看、那儿看看,结果反而容易伤到脖子。

英文原文

One screen. And I used to have three screens. So, I come from the, I know where people come from. I had all this stuff, but then I realized that having it all condensed in one laptop. It’s a 16-inch MacBook, so it’s quite big. But having it one there is amazing because you’re so close to the tools. You’re so close to what’s happening. It’s like working on a car or something. Man, if you have three screens, you can look here, look there, you get also neck injury actually.

Lex Fridman2:59:45

嗯,我不知道……听上去你好像加入了某个邪教,正拼命想说服我。不过,听说你单屏也能超高效工作,这倒挺好——我是说,这简直不可思议。

英文原文

Well, I don’t know. This sounds like you’re part of a cult and you’re just trying to convince me. I mean, but it’s good to hear that you can be ultra-productive on a single screen. I mean, that’s crazy.

Pieter Levels2:59:57

Command+Tab切换应用。Windows是Alt+Tab,MacOS则是Command+Tab,切换起来特别快。

英文原文

Command Tab. You Alt Tab. When it’s Alt Tab. MacOS is Command Tab, you can switch very fast.

Lex Fridman3:00:02

比如整个屏幕都开着VS Code,你在看代码;接着你要部署一个网站,怎么办?切换屏幕?

英文原文

So, you have the entire screen is taken out by VS Code, say you look at the code. And then if you deploy a website, you what? Switch screen.

Pieter Levels3:00:10

Command+Tab切到Chrome浏览器。我以前用过滑动切换屏幕空间的功能,可以设置多个桌面空间。但我当时就想:‘啊,太复杂了,干脆全塞进MacBook这一个屏幕上得了。’

英文原文

Command Tab to Chrome. I used to have this swipe screen. You could do different screen spaces. I was like, “Ah, it’s too difficult. Let’s just put it all on one screen on the MacBook.”

Lex Fridman3:00:21

这样你也能保持高产。

英文原文

And you can be productive that way.

Pieter Levels3:00:23

对,效率非常高,真的比以前还高。

英文原文

Yeah, very productive, yeah. More productive than before.

Lex Fridman3:00:27

有意思。我用三块屏幕,其中两块是竖着放的,摆在侧面。

英文原文

Interesting. Because I have three screens and two of them are vertical. On the side.

Pieter Levels3:00:31

对,写代码嘛,没错。

英文原文

Yeah, the codes, right, yeah.

Lex Fridman3:00:32

写代码时,能看得更多。

英文原文

For the code, you can see a lot.

Pieter Levels3:00:34

不,老兄,我超爱看朋友们的装备——他们那些酷炫的‘战斗站’,对吧?太震撼了!我既想要,又不想真要。

英文原文

No, man, I love it. I love seeing it with friends. They have amazing battle stations, right, it’s called. It’s amazing. I want it, but I don’t want it.

Lex Fridman3:00:42

你喜欢这种限制条件。

英文原文

You like the constraints.

Pieter Levels3:00:44

就是这个意思。

英文原文

That’s it.

Lex Fridman3:00:44

限制条件确实有某种特质:一旦你适应了它,就能更专注,更能集中精神。

英文原文

There’s some aspect of the constraints, which once you get good at it, you can focus your mind and you can.

Pieter Levels3:00:50

老兄,我对‘更多’这事特别存疑——你真的需要那么多东西吗?说不定反而会拖慢我的节奏。

英文原文

Man, I’m suspicious of more. Do you really need all the stuff? It might slow me down actually.

Lex Fridman3:00:55

这么表达真到位。我也怀疑‘更多’——我方方面面都怀疑‘更多’,各行各业都……

英文原文

That’s a good way to put it. I’m suspicious of more. Me too. I’m suspicious of more in all ways, in all walks-

Pieter Levels3:01:01

因为你能为‘更多’找一堆理由来辩护啊。比如我的开发同事就说:‘我得赚钱,所以我得多买几块屏幕,得提高效率。’可你读过《人月神话》就知道,招更多人反而会拖慢软件项目进度——这可是出了名的。我觉得这个比喻或许也适用于工具:我看到不少朋友陷入‘装备收集综合征’,买了一大堆东西,但实际产出并不高。他们拥有最顶尖、最漂亮的‘战斗站’、台式机,样样俱全,可效率却不见得高。而且这也挺有趣——我所有东西都装在背包里,全靠这台笔记本,过着游牧式、极简主义的生活。

英文原文

Because you can defend more. You can defend. Yeah. My developer, I make money. I need to get more screens. I need to be more efficient. And then you read stuff about Mythical Man-Month, where hiring more people slows down a software product project that’s famous. I think you can use that metaphor maybe for tools as well. Then I see friends just with gear acquisition syndrome that buying so much stuff, but they’re not that productive. They have the best, most beautiful battle stations, desktops, everything. They’re not that productive. And it’s also fun. It’s all from my laptop in a backpack. It’s nomad, minimalist.

Lex Fridman3:01:35

给我讲讲你生活中那种‘极致高效’的一天吧——就是那种干成一大堆事、全程高度聚焦于完成任务的日子。你几点起床?是固定时间吗?特别早?还是特别晚?

英文原文

Take me through the perfect ultra productive day in your life. Say where you get a lot of shit done and it’s all focused on getting shit done. When are you waking up? Is it a regular time? Super early, super late?

Pieter Levels3:01:52

对。我通常凌晨2点睡觉,有时甚至拖到凌晨4点前。但我女朋友是午夜就睡,所以我们折中定在凌晨2点。我一般上午10点或11点左右起床,不过更常是10点。洗个澡,煮咖啡——我煮手冲咖啡,用V60滤杯那种。烧水,放咖啡粉,慢慢萃取。我和女朋友一起住,然后打开笔记本,开始写代码,检查一下有什么状况,比如Bug之类的。

英文原文

Yes. So, I go to sleep at 2:00 AM usually, something like that and before 4:00 AM. But my girlfriend would go sleep midnight. So, we did a compromise like 2:00 AM. So, I wake up around 10:00, 11:00, no, more like 10:00. Shower, make coffee. I make coffee, like drip coffee, like the V60, the filter. And I boil water and then put the coffee in and chill, live with my girlfriend, and then open laptops, start coding, check what’s going on, bugs or whatever.

Lex Fridman3:02:23

你能连续坐在电脑前写多久代码?

英文原文

How stretches of time are you able to just sit behind the computer coding?

Pieter Levels3:02:28

以前我需要特别长的整块时间,经常通宵赶工才能把事情做完。但现在我已经训练出一种能力:即使频繁被打断,也能……

英文原文

So, I used to need really long stretches where I would do all-nighters and stuff to get shit done. But I’ve gotten trained to have more interruptions where I can-

Lex Fridman3:02:37

因为不得不这样。

英文原文

Because you have to.

Pieter Levels3:02:39

生活就是这样啊——干扰实在太多了:女朋友问东问西,朋友上门拜访,各种事儿。所以我现在反应特别快,能迅速进入专注状态,也能迅速抽身出来。我听说有些带娃的开发者或创业者也是这样:一开始还抱怨‘哎呀,没法工作’,但慢慢就习惯了,反而能在短时间内极度高效——毕竟只有20分钟可用,之后又是一团乱。所以,这又是一种限制,对吧?

英文原文

This is life. There’s a lot of distractions. Your girlfriend asks stuff, people come over, whatever. So, I’m very fast now. I can lock in and lock out quite fast. And I heard people, developers or entrepreneurs with kids have the same thing. Before, they’re like, “Ah, I cannot work.” But they get used to it and they get really productive in short time because they only have 20 minutes. And then shit goes crazy again. So, another constraint, right?

Lex Fridman3:03:02

对,挺有意思的。

英文原文

Yeah. It’s funny.

Pieter Levels3:03:03

所以我觉得这套模式挺适合我。然后做饭、吃饭,午饭吃牛排、鸡肉什么的。

英文原文

So, I think that works for me. And then cook food and stuff. Have lunch, steak and chicken and whatever.

Lex Fridman3:03:11

你一天吃好几顿啊?刚才说喝咖啡,接下来呢?

英文原文

You eat a bunch of times a day. So, you said coffee, what are you doing?

Pieter Levels3:03:14

对,几个小时后开始做饭。我们买本地供应的肉类、蔬菜,自己烹饪。再喝第二杯咖啡,继续干活。有时午饭还出门吃,顺便掺点乐子。

英文原文

Yeah, so a few hours later, cook foods. We get locally sourced meat and stuff and vegetables and cook that. And then second coffee and then go some more. Maybe go outside for lunch. You can mix fun stuff.

Lex Fridman3:03:27

按你所说,一个‘完美高效日’里,你大概有多少小时在编程?如果全力以赴,是不是几乎全天都在写代码?

英文原文

How many hours are you saying a perfectly productive day you’re doing programming? If you were to kill it, are you doing all day basically?

Pieter Levels3:03:35

你是说那种特殊日子……

英文原文

You mean the special days where …

Lex Fridman3:03:36

特殊日子。

英文原文

Special days.

Pieter Levels3:03:37

……比如女朋友去巴黎了,你独自在家待一周,那简直太爽了——可以专心写代码,通宵达旦,边写边吃巧克力。

英文原文

… girlfriend leaves to Paris or something and you’re alone for a week at home, which is amazing. You can just code. It’s like you stay up all night and eat chocolates.

Lex Fridman3:03:45

对,巧克力。

英文原文

Yeah, chocolate.

Pieter Levels3:03:47

对。

英文原文

Yeah.

Lex Fridman3:03:47

对对对,好,好。咱们先把女朋友从画面里去掉,再把社交生活也去掉,就剩你自己。

英文原文

Yeah, yeah, yeah. Okay, okay. Let’s remove girlfriend from picture. Social life from picture. It’s just you.

Pieter Levels3:03:53

老兄,那日子简直疯了。

英文原文

Man, that shit goes crazy.

Lex Fridman3:03:55

因为一疯起来……

英文原文

Because when shit goes crazy.

Pieter Levels3:03:56

现在就疯起来了。

英文原文

And now shit goes crazy.

Lex Fridman3:03:57

好,咱们倒回去:你还在按时起床吗?还有咖啡喝。没有女朋友聊天,也没有……

英文原文

Okay. Let’s rewind. Are you still waking up? There’s coffee. There’s no girlfriend to talk to. There’s no-

Pieter Levels3:04:04

现在我们下午1点、2点才醒。

英文原文

Now we wake up like 1:00 PM, 2:00 PM.

Lex Fridman3:04:11

因为你下午6点就睡了?

英文原文

Because you went to bed at 6:00 PM.

Pieter Levels3:04:13

对,因为我一直在写代码,研究一些新出的AI玩意儿,特别着迷,根本睡不着——太重要了,必须保持清醒,必须把这些全看完,必须立刻动手做出点东西来。而恰恰是这种时候,我才更容易产出新东西。我有个朋友,他真会订一家酒店住上一周,离开家……他也有孩子,老婆和孩子都留在家里,他自己跑去酒店住。听起来有点可疑,对吧?跑去住酒店。

英文原文

Yeah, because I was coding. I was finding some new AI shit. And I was studying it and it was amazing. And I cannot sleep because it’s too important. We need to stay awake. We need to see all of this. We need to make something now. But that’s the times I do make new stuff more. So, I think I have a friend, he actually books a hotel for a week to leave his … And he has a kid too. And his girlfriend and his kid stay in the house and he goes to another hotel. Sounds a little suspicious, right? Going to a hotel.

Pieter Levels3:04:39

但他去酒店就干一件事:写作或写代码。他是作家,需要这种独处时光、这种安静。我觉得进入心流状态确实如此:面对大量干扰时,我维护现有项目更拿手;但创造新东西,就必须靠这种状态——一段不受打扰的连续时间。这是很常见的。所以,我下午1点、2点才醒,照样喝咖啡、洗澡——我们还是会洗澡。然后就不停写代码。也许朋友会过来,反正也会过来。

英文原文

But all he does is writing or coding. He’s a writer and he needs this alone time, this silence. And I think for this flow state, it’s true. I’m better maintaining stuff when there’s a lot of disruptions than creating new stuff. I need this. It’s common, this flow state, this uninterrupted period of time. So, yeah, I wake up 1:00, 2: 00 PM, still coffee, shower, we still shower. And then just code non-stop. Maybe my friend comes over, comes over anyway.

Lex Fridman3:05:10

就是一点小干扰。

英文原文

Just some distraction.

Pieter Levels3:05:11

对。还有安德烈,他也写代码,所以会过来。我们一起写,一起听音乐,又回到[听不清 03:05:17]那种日子了——对,就是一起办公的日子。

英文原文

Yeah. Also, Andre, he codes too, so he comes over. We code together. We listen. It starts going back to the [inaudible 03:05:17] days. Yeah, coworking days.

Lex Fridman3:05:19

所以你们并不是真正协作,只是各自工作而已。

英文原文

So, you’re not really working with him, but you’re just both working.

Pieter Levels3:05:22

因为两个人一起坐在沙发上写代码,氛围很好——大部分时间都很安静,或者放点音乐,偶尔问个问题,但总体上大家都是高度专注的。

英文原文

Because it’s nice to have the vibe where you both sit together on the couch and coding on something and actually, it’s mostly silent or there’s music and sometimes you ask something, but generally, you are really locked in.

Lex Fridman3:05:34

你听什么音乐?

英文原文

What music are you listening to?

Pieter Levels3:05:37

我觉得是Techno(科技舞曲),比如YouTube上的Techno频道。有个叫HOR的频道,名字里带分音符(H-O加两点)。那是柏林风格的Techno,随便啦。他们拍摄场地是在贴白瓷砖的厕所里,特别酷。而且他们的音乐总带着很强的工业感——

英文原文

I think techno, like YouTube techno. There’s a channel called HOR with a umlaut, like H-O like double dot. It’s Berlin techno, whatever. They film it in a toilet with white tiles and stuff. And very cool. And they always have very good industrial-

Lex Fridman3:05:57

工业风,节奏快、力度强。

英文原文

Industrial, so fast-paced heavy.

Pieter Levels3:05:59

有点攻击性。

英文原文

Kind of aggressive.

Lex Fridman3:05:59

对。这种音乐不会干扰你的大脑吗?

英文原文

Yeah. That’s not distracting to your brain?

Pieter Levels3:06:03

不会,简直绝了。我觉得真正干扰人的反而是爵士乐——我早上醒来陪女朋友喝咖啡时听爵士,那种钢琴声慢慢就让人烦了,音调太多,信息量太大。而这种工业Techno,就像非洲的雨舞,是一种超然的迷幻 trance(恍惚)状态。

英文原文

No, it’s amazing. I think distracting, man, jazz. I listen, coffee jazz with my girlfriend when I wake up and it’s kind like this piano starts getting annoying. It’s like it’s too many tones. It’s like too many things going on. This industrial techno is like these African rain dances. It’s this transcendental trance.

Lex Fridman3:06:23

这很有意思,因为我现在主要听的是棕色噪音(brown noise)。

英文原文

That’s interesting because I actually mostly now listen to brown noise. Noise.

Pieter Levels3:06:30

对,哇哦。

英文原文

Yeah. Wow.

Lex Fridman3:06:31

声音还挺响的。

英文原文

Pretty loud.

Pieter Levels3:06:31

哇哦。

英文原文

Wow.

Lex Fridman3:06:33

你学到的事情之一就是,你的大脑会习惯任何东西。所以,我确信,如果我真的给电子音乐一个真正尝试的机会,我的大脑也会适应它。但噪音不同,它会对你的大脑产生某种影响。我觉得这方面是有科学依据的,但我其实并不关心。你只需做自己的科学家,研究你自己、研究你自己的大脑。对我而言,它确实会产生某种效果。我第一次尝试时就立刻发现了:大概过了几分钟后,所有干扰——一切干扰——全都消失了,只剩下‘嘘’的一声。这时你能非常专注地聚焦于某件事上,很奇妙。你真的能高度专注于某件事,至于那件事具体是什么,其实并不重要。我觉得这正是人们通过冥想所达到的状态,比如专注于自己的呼吸。

英文原文

And one of the things you learn is your brain gets used to whatever. So, I’m sure to techno, if I actually give it a real chance, my brain would get used to it. But with noise, what happens is is something happens to your brain. I think there’s a science to it, but I don’t really care. You just have to be a scientist of one, study yourself, your own brain. For me, it does something. I discovered it right away when I tried it for the first time. After about a couple of minutes, everything, every distraction just disappears. And it goes like, shh. You can hold focus on things really well. It’s weird. You can really focus on a thing. It doesn’t really matter what that is. I think that’s what people achieve with meditation. You can focus on your breath, for example.

Pieter Levels3:07:24

这只是普通的布朗噪声,并不是双耳节拍(binaural)那种。

英文原文

It’s just normal brown noise. It’s not like binaural.

Lex Fridman3:07:26

不。

英文原文

No.

Pieter Levels3:07:27

只是普通的布朗噪声。

英文原文

Just normal brown noise.

Lex Fridman3:07:28

就像‘嘘’那样。

英文原文

It’s like, “Shh.”

Pieter Levels3:07:28

对。

英文原文

Yeah.

Lex Fridman3:07:30

白噪声,我觉得也差不多,就是那种‘轰隆’响的、高频率的噪声。而布朗噪声,我觉得低频成分更重一些。

英文原文

White noise, I think it’s the same. It’s like big noise, white noise. Brown noise, I think it’s like bassier.

Pieter Levels3:07:36

对,它更弥散,更柔和。

英文原文

Yeah. It’s more diffused. More dampened.

Lex Fridman3:07:39

更柔和。

英文原文

Dampened.

Pieter Levels3:07:40

对,我能理解这一点。

英文原文

Yeah, I can see that.

Lex Fridman3:07:40

没有尖锐感。

英文原文

No sharpness.

Pieter Levels3:07:41

对,没有刺眼的亮度。

英文原文

Yeah, sharp brightness.

Lex Fridman3:07:43

对,就是那种亮度。

英文原文

Yeah, brightness.

Pieter Levels3:07:43

对,对,我能理解。你用的是耳机,对吧?

英文原文

Yeah, yeah. I can see that. And you use a headphone, right?

Lex Fridman3:07:45

对,耳机。

英文原文

Yeah, headphones.

Pieter Levels3:07:46

对。

英文原文

Yeah.

Lex Fridman3:07:47

实际上,我在日常生活中经常戴着布朗噪声四处走动。

英文原文

I actually walk around in life often with brown noise.

Pieter Levels3:07:51

老兄,这听起来简直像精神病患者干的事,但还挺酷的。

英文原文

Dude, that’s like psychopath shit, but it’s cool.

Lex Fridman3:07:53

对,对,对。当我杀人的时候,它特别管用——能盖住他们的尖叫声。

英文原文

Yeah, yeah, yeah. When I murder people, it helps. It drowns out their screams.

Pieter Levels3:08:00

天啊。

英文原文

Jesus Christ.

Lex Fridman3:08:02

我说得太多了。

英文原文

I said too much.

Pieter Levels3:08:03

哥们儿,我要去试试布朗噪声了。

英文原文

Man, I’m going to try brown noise.

Lex Fridman3:08:05

是为杀人试,还是为写代码试?对吧?

英文原文

With the murder or for the coding? Yeah.

Pieter Levels3:08:06

为写代码试,对。

英文原文

For the coding, yeah.

Lex Fridman3:08:07

好,不错。试试看,试试看。但你对任何事情都得真正给它一个机会。

英文原文

Okay, good. Try it. Try it. But you have to with everything else, give it a real chance.

Pieter Levels3:08:12

对。

英文原文

Yeah.

Lex Fridman3:08:13

另外,正如我之前说的,我有时还会在布朗噪声之上叠加类似科技舞曲(techno)风格的电子音乐。但我会控制节奏速度,因为节奏越快,焦虑感就越强。所以,当我真需要高效完成任务——尤其是编程时——我会配上节拍,效果极佳,很酷。我觉得,这种用小技巧探索自己大脑的方式挺酷的。通常我不喜欢身边有人,因为哪怕他们也在工作,我也说不清为什么——我太喜欢人了,人真的很有趣。

英文原文

I also, like I said, do techno-y type stuff, electronic music on top of the brown noise. But then control the speed, because the faster it goes, the more anxiety. So, if I really need to get shit done, especially with programming, I’ll have a beat. And it’s great. It’s cool. I say it’s cool to play those little tricks with your mind to study yourself. I usually don’t like to have people around because when people, even if they’re working, I don’t know, I like people too much. They’re interesting.

Pieter Levels3:08:45

对,在联合办公空间里,我总会忍不住聊太多。

英文原文

Yeah, In coworking space, I would just start talking too much.

Lex Fridman3:08:48

对,这就成了干扰源。

英文原文

Yeah. So, there’s a source of distraction.

Pieter Levels3:08:50

对,在联合办公空间里,我们搞了个‘罚款罐’,就是一个马克杯。如果你连续专注工作45分钟,期间只要说出任意两个词,就得交一美元罚款。比如你说‘嘿,最近咋样?’就得往罐子里放一美元;要是说了三句话,就得放三美元。然后有15分钟自由活动时间,随便聚会玩闹。接着再继续45分钟专注工作——这套方法还真管用。但你必须让人闭嘴,否则……

英文原文

Yeah, in the coworking space, we would do a money pot, like a mug. So, if you would work for 45 minutes and then if you would say a pair of words, you would get a fine, which is like $1. So, you’d put $1 to say, “Hey, what’s up?” So, $3 you put in the mug. And then 15 minutes free time, we can party whatever. And then 45 minutes again working and that worked. But you need to shut people up or they…

Lex Fridman3:09:16

我觉得,共同保持沉默本身蕴含一种亲密感,或许我对此不太适应,但你得让自己变得脆弱一点,和亲近的朋友一起,真正长时间静坐、沉默,同时做一件事。

英文原文

I think there’s an intimacy in being silent together that maybe I’m uncomfortable with, but you need to make yourself vulnerable and actually do it with close friends to just sit there in silence for long periods of time and doing a thing.

Pieter Levels3:09:36

老兄,我看过一期播客视频,是关于佛教的,里面的人一边打坐冥想,一边互相采访,形式就像普通播客。结果突然在某个问题之后,其中一人只说了句‘嗯,嗯’,接着整整沉默了三分钟,然后才说:‘太棒了,真的太棒了。’我当时就想:‘哇,真酷。’

英文原文

Dude, I watched this video of this podcast. It was like this Buddhism podcast with people meditating and they were interviewing each other or whatever like a podcast. And suddenly after a question, it’s like, “Yeah, yeah.” And they were just silent for three minutes and then they said, “That was amazing. Yeah, that was amazing.” I was like, “Wow, pretty cool.”

Lex Fridman3:09:58

埃隆就是这样。我特别喜欢这点。比如你问他一个问题:‘对你来说,完美的一天是什么样的?’我就这么问了,然后他就坐在那儿,足足想了30秒。

英文原文

Elon’s like that. And I really liked that. You’ll ask a question, I don’t know, what’s a perfectly productive day for you? I just asked. And you just sit there for 30 seconds thinking.

Pieter Levels3:10:12

对,他在思考。

英文原文

Yeah. He thinks.

Lex Fridman3:10:15

对。

英文原文

Yeah.

Pieter Levels3:10:16

这太酷了。我真希望自己也能多思考一会儿……但我总想直接袒露真心,让心里的话直通嘴巴、脱口而出。可我思考得越多,自我审查就越严重,反而只想立刻把想法一股脑儿抛出来。

英文原文

That’s so cool. I wish I could think more about … But I want to show you my heart. I want to go straight from my heart to my mouth to saying the real thing. And the more I think, the more I start filtering myself and I want to just throw it out there immediately.

Lex Fridman3:10:34

我在团队中更常这么做。我觉得他在这方面练习得很多,我自己也是。在团队环境中,当你思考或头脑风暴时,允许自己在沉默中静静思考。因为在会议中,大家总急着说话,其实应该先想清楚再开口。共同沉默完全没问题。只要你给自己留出这个空间,往往真能想出特别棒的点子。

英文原文

I do that more with team. I think he has a lot of practice in that. I do that as well. And in team setting, when you’re thinking, brainstorming and you allow yourself to just think in silence. Because even in meetings, people want to talk. It’s like no, you think before you speak. And it’s okay to be silent together. If you allow yourself the room to do that, you can actually come up with really good ideas.

Pieter Levels3:10:57

对。

英文原文

Yeah.

Lex Fridman3:10:58

那么,好,就谈这个完美的一天——这一天你摄入多少咖啡因?

英文原文

So, okay, this perfect day, how much caffeine are you consuming in this day?

Pieter Levels3:11:03

老兄,太多了。平时我喝两杯咖啡,但在这完美的一天里,可能要喝到四杯。这样就开始逼近焦虑阈值了。

英文原文

Man, too much. Because normally two cups of coffee. But on this perfect day, we go to four maybe. So, we’re starting to hit the anxiety levels.

Lex Fridman3:11:12

所以,四杯对你来说算很多?

英文原文

So, four cups is a lot for you?

Pieter Levels3:11:15

嗯,我觉得我冲的咖啡浓度相当高。比如用V60手冲时,我一次放20克咖啡粉。朋友们都管它叫‘核弹级咖啡’,因为劲儿实在太大。

英文原文

Well, I think my coffees are quite strong when I make them. It’s like 20 grams of coffee powder in the V60. So, my friends call them nuclear coffee because it’s quite heavy.

Lex Fridman3:11:24

超级浓。

英文原文

Super strong.

Pieter Levels3:11:25

确实很浓。但那种状态很妙——刚好卡在即将引发惊恐发作的边缘,却又还没到那一步。这时候整个人极度专注,简直神了!不过,这种状态在我生活中确实有其位置,我觉得它特别适合创造新东西,效果惊人。

英文原文

It’s quite strong. But it’s nice to hit that anxiety level where you’re almost panic attack, but you’re not there yet. But that’s like, man, it’s super locked in. Just like, it’s amazing. But I mean, there’s a space for that in my life. But I think it’s great for making new stuff. It’s amazing.

Lex Fridman3:11:47

从零开始,创造一个全新的东西。

英文原文

Starting from scratch, creating a new thing.

Pieter Levels3:11:48

对。我觉得女朋友们该让男友每年至少离开两周——不,等等,应该是每年至少一次,也许每季度一次,我也不确定。就让他们独自待着,专心创作。虽然他们很棒,但……

英文原文

Yes. I think girlfriends should let their guys go away for two weeks. Every few, no, every year. At least. Maybe every quarter, I don’t know. And just sit and make some without, they’re amazing. But no-

Pieter Levels3:12:00

独自创作些东西……他们很棒,但不能有任何打扰。就一个人待着,这样人们才能创造出真正惊人的成果。

英文原文

Make some shits without… They’re amazing, but no disturbances. Just be alone, and then people can make something very amazing.

Lex Fridman3:12:09

就像我们之前展示的那样,戴着牛仔帽,在山里待着。

英文原文

Just wearing cowboy hats in the mountains like we showed before.

Pieter Levels3:12:11

没错,我们可以这么做。

英文原文

Exactly, we can do that.

Lex Fridman3:12:12

有部电影讲的就是这个。

英文原文

There’s a movie about that.

Pieter Levels3:12:13

还带着笔记本电脑。

英文原文

With the laptops.

Lex Fridman3:12:14

不过他们其实没怎么写代码。

英文原文

They didn’t do much programming though.

Pieter Levels3:12:16

对,你可以稍微写一点。

英文原文

Yeah, you can do a little bit of that.

Lex Fridman3:12:17

好。

英文原文

Okay.

Pieter Levels3:12:18

然后再稍微发个版,两者都能兼顾。

英文原文

And then a little bit of shipping. Can do both.

Lex Fridman3:12:21

那是《断背山》。

英文原文

It’s different, Broke Back Mountain.

Pieter Levels3:12:23

但他们得允许我们离开。你需要一个‘男人洞穴’,对吧?

英文原文

But they need to allow us to go. You need like a man cave, right?

Lex Fridman3:12:25

对,用来发版。

英文原文

Yeah, to ship.

Pieter Levels3:12:26

对,用来发版。

英文原文

Yeah, to ship.

Lex Fridman3:12:27

搞定正事。对,这是个平衡问题。好,挺酷的。那睡眠、午睡这些呢?你好像睡得不多?

英文原文

Get shit done. Yeah. It’s a balance. Okay, cool. What about sleep, naps and all that? You’re not sleeping much?

Pieter Levels3:12:34

我白天不午睡。我觉得能量小憩(power nap)挺好,但我现在白天根本不会觉得累。老兄,这也跟健身有关——我根本不累。只有到了晚上想睡觉的时候,我才觉得累。

英文原文

I don’t do naps in a day. I think power naps are good, but I’m never tired anymore in the day. Man, it’s also because of gym, I’m not tired. I’m tired when I want to… When it’s night, I need to sleep.

Lex Fridman3:12:45

对,我超爱午睡。

英文原文

Yeah. Me, I love naps.

Pieter Levels3:12:47

我睡眠质量很好。

英文原文

I sleep very well.

Lex Fridman3:12:47

我超爱午睡。

英文原文

I love naps.

Pieter Levels3:12:47

是吗?

英文原文

Yeah?

Lex Fridman3:12:49

我不在乎,也不知道为什么。脑子就这样关掉又打开。我不知道这是否健康,反正对我管用。

英文原文

I don’t care. I don’t know. I don’t know why. Brain shuts off, turns on. I don’t know if it’s healthy or not. It just works.

Pieter Levels3:12:53

对。

英文原文

Yeah.

Lex Fridman3:12:55

我觉得,无论心理还是生理方面,你都得成为自己身体的学生,了解自己的极限在哪里。总体而言,你得对互联网上的建议保持怀疑态度,因为很多建议只是针对普通人群设定的良好基准线。

英文原文

I think with anything, mental, physical, you have to be a student of your own body and know what the limits are. You have to be skeptical taking advice from the internet in general, because a lot of the advice is just a good baseline for the general population.

Pieter Levels3:13:09

确实不够个性化。

英文原文

It’s not personalized, yeah.

Lex Fridman3:13:10

但你必须成为自己身体、自己本人、自己运作方式的学生。对,我做过很多尝试。对我而言,间歇性禁食就很有趣——过去我一天吃好多顿饭,尤其在大重量训练时期,因为大家都说你得多餐进食,但后来我发现,一天只吃一两顿,我反而能变得更强壮,感觉也更好。

英文原文

But then you have to become a student of your own body, of your own self, of how you work. Yeah. I’ve done a lot. For me, fasting was an interesting one because I used to eat a bunch of meals a day, especially when I was lifting heavy, because everybody says that you have to eat a lot, multiple meals a day, but I realized I can get much stronger, feel much better if I eat once or twice a day.

Pieter Levels3:13:38

对,我也是。对。

英文原文

Yeah, me too. Yeah.

Lex Fridman3:13:39

太疯狂了。

英文原文

It’s crazy.

Pieter Levels3:13:39

我从来就不理解少食多餐这套理论。对,这招对我根本不管用。

英文原文

I never understood the small meal thing. Yeah, it didn’t work for me.

Lex Fridman3:13:42

让我问你一下,如果你能谈谈你创建的其他产品,那就很有意思了。我们聊过NomadList、Interior AI、Photo AI、Therapist AI。那Remote OK是什么呢?

英文原文

Let me just ask you, it’d be interesting if you can comment on some of the other products you’ve created. We talked about NomadList, Interior AI, Photo AI, Therapist AI. What’s Remote OK?

Pieter Levels3:13:52

它是一个专门发布远程工作的招聘平台。因为十年前,虽然已有各类招聘网站,但并没有真正专精于远程岗位的招聘平台。所以我做了这样一个平台。最初是在NomadList上建了一个叫‘Nomad Jobs’的页面,结果很多公司开始在上面招聘,靠发布职位收费。后来我把它独立拆分出来,成立了Remote OK。如今它已是全球第一或第二大远程工作招聘平台。而且整个平台完全自动化:用户只需发布职位,求职者即可申请;平台还提供个人资料功能,相当于远程工作的LinkedIn。

英文原文

It’s a job board for remote jobs. Because back then, 10 years ago, there was job boards, but it was not really specifically remote job, job boards. So I made one. First on NomadList, I made Nomad Jobs, like a page. And a lot of companies started hiring and it paid for job posts. So I spin it off to Remote OK, and now it’s the number one or number two biggest remote job boards. And it’s also fully automated. People just post a job and people apply. It has profiles as well. It’s like LinkedIn for remote work.

Lex Fridman3:14:23

只专注远程岗位?

英文原文

Just focus on remote only?

Pieter Levels3:14:25

对。本质上就是一个简单的招聘平台。我发现招聘平台远比你想象中复杂得多,但没错,它就是一个专为远程工作设计的招聘平台。不过好处在于,职位发布收费可以定得很高。老兄,这可是笔不错的B2B生意。起步价是2.99美元,但巅峰期——也就是2021年美联储开始疯狂印钞那会儿——我单靠Remote OK的职位发布收入就高达每月14万美元。后来我还加了不少疯狂的增值选项,比如彩虹色职位广告、自定义背景图等,全是增值项。一个增值项就能收一千美元,简直疯狂。所有公司都拼命加购增值项,‘我们要全部都要!’职位广告价格涨到三千、四千美元。我当时就想:‘这生意真不错。’后来美联储停止印钞,收入就暴跌了,从14万跌到只剩一万左右。现在已回升,我想大概是每月四万美元。那真是好时光。

英文原文

Yeah. It’s essentially like a simple job board. I discovered job boards are way more complicated than you think, but yeah, it’s a job board for remote jobs. But the nice thing is you can charge a lot of money for job posts. Man, it’s good money, B2B. You start with 2.99, but at the peak, when the feds started printing money like 2021, I was making 140K a month with Remote OK with just job posts. And I started adding crazy upsells, like rainbow-colored job posts. You can add your background image. It’s just upsells, man. And you charge a thousand dollars for an upsell. It was crazy. All these companies just upsell, upsell. Yeah, we want everything. Job posts would cost $3,000, $4,000. And I was like, “This is good business.” And then the feds stopped printing money and it all went down, and it went down to like 10K a month from 140. Now it’s back, I think it’s 40. It was good times.

Lex Fridman3:15:22

我得问问你关于数字游民生活的事——回到这个话题,你写过一篇关于‘重启’的博客文章,总体上讲的是把所有东西都送人,过一种极简主义生活。

英文原文

I got to ask you about, back to the digital nomad life, you wrote a blog post on the reset and in general, just giving away everything, living a minimalist life.

Pieter Levels3:15:33

是啊。

英文原文

Yeah.

Lex Fridman3:15:33

做到这一点、扔掉所有东西,到底需要什么?

英文原文

What did it take to do that, to get rid of everything?

Pieter Levels3:15:37

十年前,这种风潮在博客圈里很流行。那时候博客特别火,整个网络就像一个‘博客圈’,当时还兴起了‘百物挑战’。

英文原文

10 years ago was this trend in the blog. Back then, blogs were so popular, it was like a blogosphere and it was like the 100 Things Challenge.

Lex Fridman3:15:43

‘百物挑战’是什么?

英文原文

What is that, the 100 Things Challenge?

Pieter Levels3:15:44

我的意思是,这听起来挺荒唐的,但你要把你家里拥有的每一样物品都列出来并计数。你做个电子表格,然后说:‘好吧,我有500样东西。’你得把它减到100样。为什么?就因为这是当时的流行趋势。所以我照做了。我开始卖东西,也开始扔东西。2012年我还服用了摇头丸(MDMA)和迷魂药(ecstasy)。那次体验之后,我感觉整个人都变了,觉得非得把东西全扔掉不可。真的。

英文原文

I mean, it’s ridiculous, but you write down every object you have in your house and you count it. You make a spreadsheet and you’re like, “Okay, I have 500 things.” You need to get it down to 100. Why? It was just the trend. So I did it. I started selling stuff, started throwing away stuff. And I did MDMA and ecstasy 2012. And after that trip, I felt so different and I felt like I had to start throwing shit away. I swear.

Lex Fridman3:16:11

是啊。

英文原文

Yeah.

Pieter Levels3:16:12

然后我就开始扔东西,感觉简直就像那种药物把我引向了一条路:‘你得把所有东西都扔掉。你得踏上一段旅程。你得离开这里。’我想,这就是摇头丸带给我的影响。是的。

英文原文

And I started throwing shit away and I felt that it was almost like the drug sending me to a path of, you need to throw all your shit away. You need to go on a journey. You need to get out of here. And that’s what the MDMA did, I think. Yeah.

Lex Fridman3:16:26

降到100件物品,难度有多大?

英文原文

How hard is it to get down to 100 items?

Pieter Levels3:16:29

嗯,你得卖掉你的电脑之类的东西。你得上eBay去卖,然后……天哪,上eBay卖光自己所有东西,过程特别有意思,因为你由此发现了社会百态。你会遇到各种最离谱的人——从富人到穷人,所有人都会来你家买东西。太有趣了,太好玩了。我强烈推荐每个人都试试。

英文原文

Well, you need to sell your PC and stuff. You need to go on eBay, and then… Man, going eBay selling all your stuff is very interesting because you discover society. You meet the craziest people. You meet every range from rich to poor, everybody comes to your house to buy stuff. It’s so funny. It’s so interesting. I recommend everybody do this.

Lex Fridman3:16:46

就为了见见那些想要你破烂的人。

英文原文

Just to meet people that want your shit.

Pieter Levels3:16:48

是啊。我以前不知道。我当时住在阿姆斯特丹,根本不知道自己其实属于某个亚文化群体之类的;而通过eBay,我才真正认识了荷兰人本来的样子。所以我把所有东西都卖掉了。

英文原文

Yeah. I didn’t know. I was living in Amsterdam and I didn’t know I have my own subculture or whatever, and I discovered the Dutch people as they are from eBay. So I sold everything.

Lex Fridman3:16:59

你卖过的最奇怪的东西是什么?不是最奇怪的,而是让你印象最深的?

英文原文

What’s the weirdest thing you had to sell and you had to find a buyer for? Not the weirdest, but what’s memorable?

Pieter Levels3:17:05

那时候我在做音乐,我们用佳能5D相机拍音乐视频。当时人人都在用这种相机拍电影和音乐视频。这台相机是我跟朋友们一起买的,所以我也得把它卖掉——因为它太贵了,大概六千欧元左右。但卖掉它,就意味着我们不会再拍音乐视频了;我要离开荷兰;我们正在做的这些项目也会就此终结。我当时想:‘这些音乐视频,我们根本成不了气候,也红不了,更不会成功。我们得停手了。’连音乐制作本身,也实在没什么起色。我对朋友们感到特别愧疚,因为我们一直合作,而如今却要卖掉这台我们一起创作的相机——

英文原文

So back then, I was making music and we would make music videos with a Canon 5D camera. Back then, everybody’s making films and music videos of that. And we bought it with my friends and stuff, and it was kind of like I had to sell this thing too, because it was very expensive, like 6K or something. But it meant that selling this, meant that we wouldn’t make music videos anymore. I would leave Holland. This stuff we were working on would end. And I was saying, “This music video stuff, we’re not getting big, we’re not getting famous in this or successful. We need to stop doing this.” This music production also, it’s not really working. And I felt very bad for my friends because we would work together on this and to sell this camera that we’d make stuff with and-

Lex Fridman3:17:49

这是一次艰难的告别。

英文原文

It was a hard goodbye.

Pieter Levels3:17:50

它只是一台相机,但感觉就像在说:‘抱歉,伙计们,这条路走不通了,我得走了。’

英文原文

It was just a camera, but it felt like, “Sorry guys, it doesn’t work and I need to go.”

Lex Fridman3:17:56

谁买了它?你还记得吗?应该是个完全无法理解你这段心路历程的人吧。

英文原文

Who bought it? Do you remember? It was some guy who couldn’t possibly understand the journey.

Pieter Levels3:18:03

它的运动轨迹。

英文原文

The motion of it.

Lex Fridman3:18:03

是啊。

英文原文

Yeah.

Pieter Levels3:18:03

是啊。

英文原文

Yeah.

Lex Fridman3:18:05

他就直接来了,‘钱在这儿,谢谢。’

英文原文

He just showed up here, “Here’s the money. Thanks.”

Pieter Levels3:18:07

是啊。但这就像是亲手斩断自己的生活:‘这些东西,到此为止;接下来我们要干新的事情了。’

英文原文

Yeah. But it was cutting your life like, “This shit ends now and now we’re going to do new stuff.”

Lex Fridman3:18:12

我觉得这很美。我这辈子做过两次:把所有东西、所有东西、所有东西全都送人,最后只剩一条裤子、几件内衣、一个背包。我觉得这么做很重要,它能让你看清什么才是真正重要的。

英文原文

I think it’s beautiful. I did that twice in my life. I gave away everything, everything, everything, like down to just pants, underwear, backpack. I think it’s important to do. It shows you what’s important.

Pieter Levels3:18:26

是啊。我想,这正是我从中领悟到的:你发现原来自己只需极少的物品、极少的身外之物就能活下去;但与此同时,也有其反面——你会更依赖这些物品之外的服务。对吧?比如,你不需要买车,而是用优步(Uber);或者你不需要厨房用具,因为旅行时你总在外面餐馆吃饭。因此,你更依赖别人提供的服务,但同样也要为此花钱。这样也不错。

英文原文

Yeah. I think that’s what I learned from it. You learn that you can live with very little objects, very little stuff, but there’s a counter to it. You lean more on the stuff, on the services. Right? For example, you don’t need a car, you use Uber, right? Or you don’t need kitchen stuff because you go to restaurants when you’re traveling. So you lean more on other people’s services, but you spend money on that as well. So that’s good.

Lex Fridman3:18:49

是啊,但仅仅是放手物质财产,就赋予了你在世界上自由移动的一种自由感。它让你拥有彻底的自由,可以随时前往另一座城市,可以……

英文原文

Yeah, but just letting go of material possessions, which gives a kind of freedom to how you move about the world. It gives you complete freedom to go into another city, to…

Pieter Levels3:18:58

背着你的背包。

英文原文

With your backpack.

Lex Fridman3:18:58

背着背包。这种自由感是实实在在的。物质财产、固定居所等等这些东西,在精神层面多少会把你束缚住。年轻时勇敢地跃入世界,尤其值得——

英文原文

With a backpack. There’s a freedom to it. There’s something about material possessions and having a place and all that, that ties you down a little bit spiritually. It’s good to take a leap out into the world, especially when you’re younger, to like-

Pieter Levels3:19:12

老兄,我强烈建议:如果你18岁,刚高中毕业,就立刻出发旅行,同时搞点互联网相关的事情,随便什么都行。带上你的笔记本电脑,这将是一段超棒的经历。五年前,我可能还会选择上大学;但现在我却在想:‘不,也许该跳过大学。’先出去走走,四处旅行一阵子,弄清楚一些事情。等你25岁时再回大学也不迟。你可以想:‘好,现在我已学会如何在商业上取得成功。’你手里有钱了。至少此时,你能真正选择自己真心想学的专业。因为18岁的年轻人,往往只会选那些就业市场看起来比较吃香的专业,对吧?所以,如果真想那样,不如先去旅行、创业,之后再决定要不要上大学。

英文原文

Man, I recommend if you’re 18, you get out of high school, do this, go travel and build some internet stuff, whatever. Bring your laptop and it’s an amazing experience. Five years ago, I’d still go to university, but now I’m thinking like, “No, maybe skip university.” Just go first, travel around a little bit, figure some stuff out. You can go back to university when you’re 25. You can like, “Okay, now I learned to be successful in business.” You have money. At least now, you can choose what you really want to study. Because people at 18, they go study what’s probably good for the job market. Right? So it probably makes more sense. If you want that, go travel, build some businesses and go back to university if you want.

Lex Fridman3:19:49

所以,上大学最大的价值之一就是拓展人脉:结交朋友,认识各种人。它是一种强制性的社交机制。但如果你能通过旅行,在外面的世界里结识他人——

英文原文

So one of the biggest uses of a university is the networking. You gain friends, you meet people. It’s a forcing function to meet people. But if you can meet people out into the world by travel-

Pieter Levels3:20:00

老兄,而且你能接触到如此多不同的文化。

英文原文

Man, and you meet so many different cultures.

Lex Fridman3:20:02

对我而言,问题在于:如果我在那么年轻的时候就去旅行,我容易被世界边缘地带的人吸引。对我来说——

英文原文

I mean, the problem for me is if I traveled at that young age, I’m attracted to people at the outskirts of the world. For me-

Pieter Levels3:20:10

哪儿?

英文原文

Where?

Lex Fridman3:20:11

不,不是地理意义上的边缘。

英文原文

No, not geographically.

Pieter Levels3:20:12

哦,是指亚文化群体。

英文原文

Oh, the subcultures.

Lex Fridman3:20:14

对,就是那些怪人,那些阴暗面。

英文原文

Yeah, the weirdos, the darkness.

Pieter Levels3:20:17

对,我也是。

英文原文

Yeah, me too.

Lex Fridman3:20:18

但那可能并不是18岁时最好的人脉拓展方式。

英文原文

But that might not be the best networking at 18 years old.

Pieter Levels3:20:22

不,但老兄,只要你足够聪明,就能保证自身安全。我旅行时遇到了太多怪人——这本就是旅行的本质。如果你真正放开了,就会遇到最疯狂的人,而他们往往也是最有趣的人。我真的没法再强烈推荐了。

英文原文

No, but, man, if you’re smart about it, you can stay safe. And I met so many weirdos from traveling. That’s how travel works. If you really let loose, you meet the craziest people and it’s the most interesting people. It’s just I cannot recommend it enough.

Lex Fridman3:20:39

你看,问题是:当你18岁时,依个人性格不同,你既得学会当个怪人,也得学会做个普通人。你终究还得学会如何融入社会。比如像我这样,天生就是个局外人,就始终存在彻底变成局外人的危险。而那是一种更艰难的生活。如果你彻底投身艺术、彻底拥抱黑暗,生活只会更加艰难。

英文原文

Well see, the thing is that when you’re 18, I feel like depending on your personality, you have to learn both how to be a weirdo and how to be normie. You still have to learn how to fit into society. For a person like me, for example, who’s always an outcast, there’s always a danger for going full outcast. And that’s a harder life. If you go full artists and full darkness, it’s just a harder life.

Pieter Levels3:21:07

你可以回来,可以重新回归普通人的生活。

英文原文

You can come back, you can come back to normie.

Lex Fridman3:21:09

这是一种技能。我觉得你必须学会如何融入体面的社会。

英文原文

That’s a skill. I think you have to learn how to fit into polite society.

Pieter Levels3:21:16

但我自己也曾是个非常古怪的局外人。而如今,我反而更能适应普通人的生活了。

英文原文

But I was a very strange outcast as well. And I’m more adaptable to normie now.

Lex Fridman3:21:21

你是学来的。是啊。

英文原文

You learned it. Yeah.

Pieter Levels3:21:23

过了三十岁,你就……是啊。

英文原文

After 30s, you’re like… Yeah.

Lex Fridman3:21:25

但我的意思是,这确实是一种必须学习的技能。

英文原文

But I mean, it’s a skill you have to learn.

Pieter Levels3:21:27

是啊。老兄,我也觉得:你起步时是个局外人,但随着你不断自我修炼,你身上的‘破事’就越少;你渐渐变得越来越像个普通人,因为你对自己越来越放松、越来越开心,结果反倒变得没那么有趣了,对吧?

英文原文

Yeah. Man, I feel also that you start as an outcast, but the more you work on yourself, the less shit you have. You start becoming more normie because you become more chill with yourself and more happy and it makes you uninteresting, right?

Lex Fridman3:21:43

对,对,对。

英文原文

Yes, yes, yes.

Pieter Levels3:21:45

那些疯狂的人,永远是最有趣的。一旦你解决了内心的挣扎,完成了心理治疗之类的事,你变得……可能就没那么有趣了。

英文原文

The crazy people are always the most interesting. If you’ve solved your internal struggles and your therapy and stuff and you become… It’s not so interesting any more maybe.

Lex Fridman3:21:56

我想说的是,人不必非得破碎才能有趣。

英文原文

You don’t have to be broken to be interesting, I guess is what I’m saying.

Pieter Levels3:21:59

是啊。

英文原文

Yeah.

Lex Fridman3:22:00

你极简化之后,最后剩下些什么东西?

英文原文

What kind of things were left when you minimalized?

Pieter Levels3:22:03

一个背包、一台MacBook、一把牙刷、几件衣服、内衣、袜子。在亚洲你不需要太多衣服,因为天气热,所以就穿泳裤、短裤,脚踩人字拖到处走。就是些最基本的衣服,T恤而已。我去自助洗衣店洗衣服。我记得最后大概就剩50样东西左右吧。是的。

英文原文

So the backpack, Macbook, toothbrush, some clothes, underwear, socks. You don’t need a lot of clothes in Asia because it’s hot. So you just wear swim pants, swim shorts, you walk around flip-flops. So very basic, T-shit. And I go to the laundromat and wash my stuff. And I think it was like 50 things or something. Yeah.

Lex Fridman3:22:27

是啊,挺好的。我之前跟你提过那个《荒野求生》节目,它真的特别考验人——你只能带10样东西,还要在野外生存,其中一样必须是斧头。每个人都会带斧头,有些人还会带锯子,但通常斧头就够用了。你基本上得靠它砍倒树木、削整木料,才能搭建庇护所——

英文原文

Yeah, it’s nice. As I mentioned to you, there’s the show alone. They really test you because you only get 10 items and you have to survive out in the wilderness, and an ax. Everybody brings an ax. Some people also have a saw, but usually, Axe does the job. You basically have to, in order to build a shelter, you have to cut down and cut the trees and make-

Pieter Levels3:22:52

在《我的世界》(Minecraft)里学的。

英文原文

Learned in Minecraft.

Lex Fridman3:22:55

我人生中所有东西,都是在《我的世界》里学到的,老兄。是啊,是啊。主动给自己设定这些限制,有助于你理解什么对你真正重要,也帮你理解如何在这个世界上立足。而践行极简生活,就是实现这一目标的方式之一。不过我也遇到过一些人,他们真心热爱物质财产,这确实能给他们带来快乐。这也很美好。对我而言不是这样,但人各有异。

英文原文

Everything I learned about life, I learned in Minecraft, bro. Yeah, yeah. It’s nice to create those constraints for yourself, to understand what matters to you, and also, how to be in this world. And one of the ways to do that is just to live a minimalist life. But some people, I’ve met people that really enjoy material possessions and that brings them happiness. And that’s a beautiful thing. For me, it doesn’t, but people are different.

Pieter Levels3:23:23

它只给我带来两周的快乐。

英文原文

It gives me happiness for two weeks.

Lex Fridman3:23:24

是啊。

英文原文

Yeah.

Pieter Levels3:23:25

我很快就会适应到一种基础享乐水平,速度非常快。

英文原文

I’m very quickly adapting to a baseline hedonistic adaptation very fast.

Lex Fridman3:23:31

是啊。

英文原文

Yeah.

Pieter Levels3:23:31

但老兄,如果你看看相关研究,大多数人买辆新车,六个月后就没了新鲜感;买套新房子,六个月后也一样。你还是老样子。你会想:‘哇,我是不是该买一堆东西?’研究享乐适应现象,让我对极简主义思考了很多。

英文原文

But man, if you look at the studies, most people get a new car, six months, get a new house, six months. You just feel the same. You’re like, “Wow, should I buy all the stuff?” Studying hedonistic adaptation made me think a lot about minimalism.

Lex Fridman3:23:46

所以,你甚至不必经历获取物品的整个过程,只需专注于那些更持久的东西。

英文原文

And so, you don’t even need to go through the whole journey of getting it. Just focus on the thing that’s more permanent.

Pieter Levels3:23:54

是啊。

英文原文

Yeah.

Lex Fridman3:23:54

比如建造东西。

英文原文

Like building shit.

Pieter Levels3:23:56

是啊。你身边的人、你所爱的人、美味的食物、美好的体验、有意义的工作、锻炼身体——这些事情让我感到快乐,我想也会让你感到快乐。它们确实让我感到快乐。

英文原文

Yeah. People around you, people you love, nice food, nice experiences, meaningful work, exercise, those things make you happy, I think. Make me happy for sure.

Lex Fridman3:24:07

你写过一篇博客文章,标题是《为什么我失联了,也许你也该如此》。你在与人沟通方面有什么策略?

英文原文

You wrote a blog post, “Why I’m unreachable and maybe you should be too.” What’s your strategy in communicating with people?

Pieter Levels3:24:14

是啊。我写那篇文章时,收到的私信多得数不清——你可能比我还要多上一百万条。人们因为我没回复而生气。我当时就想:‘好吧,那我就干脆彻底关闭私信功能。’结果呢,大家又因为我关了私信而生气,说我根本不是什么‘人民之友’。

英文原文

Yeah. So when I wrote that, I was getting so many DMs as you probably have a million times more. And people were getting angry that I wasn’t responding. And I was like, “Okay, I’ll just close down these DMs completely.” Then people got angry that I closed my DMs down, that I’m not like, man of the people.

Lex Fridman3:24:31

你变了,老兄。

英文原文

You’ve changed, man.

Pieter Levels3:24:32

是啊,你变了,就是这种……我来解释一下原因:我每天根本没有时间回答每一个问题。而且,人们发给我的东西真是五花八门,比如跟踪狂,还有人把整个人生故事都写给你看,再向你讨教建议。老兄,我真的一无所知。我又不是心理治疗师,我真不懂这些事。

英文原文

Yeah, you’ve changed, like this… And I’ll explain why. I just don’t have the time in a day to answer every question. And also, people send you crazy shit, man, like stalkers and people write their whole life story for you, and then ask you for advice. Man, I have no idea. I’m not a therapist. I don’t know. I don’t know this stuff.

Lex Fridman3:24:52

但同时,也有非常美好的内容。

英文原文

But also, beautiful stuff.

Pieter Levels3:24:54

不,我绝对确定。

英文原文

No, absolutely sure.

Lex Fridman3:24:55

比如人生故事。我曾发过一个咖啡论坛帖子,说如果有人想跟我喝杯咖啡,欢迎报名。结果收到了数量极其庞大的申请。我翻看这些申请时,发现里面全是可爱的人、真正美好的人类,以及特别动人的故事。想到自己无法一一见到这些人,我的心都碎了。所以,这其中一部分原因就是:人能真正看见他人、帮助他人、理解他人、倾听他人或注视他人的带宽,终究是有限的。

英文原文

Like life story. I’ve posted a coffee forum if you wanted to have a coffee with me, and I’ve gotten an extremely large number of submissions. And when I look at them, there’s just beautiful people in there, beautiful human beings and really powerful stories. And it breaks my heart that I won’t get to meet those people. So there’s part of it is just like, there’s only so much bandwidth to truly see other humans and help them or understand them, or hear them, or see them.

Pieter Levels3:25:24

是啊。我也有这个问题:我总想试着帮别人,也想着‘哦,咱们一起搞创业公司吧’之类的。但这些年我渐渐明白,对我而言……听起来可能有点不好,但我确实帮过我的朋友安德烈,举个例子。他是在联合办公空间里主动找到我的,我们就是这样认识的。他对我说:‘我想学编程,想搞创业公司,咱们该怎么开始?’我说:‘好,走,先装Nginx,然后就开始写代码。’

英文原文

Yeah. I have this problem that I try, I want to try help people and also like, “Oh, let’s make startups,” and whatever. And I’ve learned over the years that generally for me… And it sounds maybe bad, but I helped my friend Andre, for example. He came up to me in the coworking space. That’s how I met him. And he said, “I want to learn to code. I want to do startups. How do we do it?” I said, “Okay, let’s go, install Nginx. Let’s start coding.”

Pieter Levels3:25:47

而他身上有一种自我驱动的能量——他其实根本不需要别人推,自己就行动起来了;他会提问,但不会问太多;他就这么一路干下去、学下去。如今,他已创办了自己的公司,赚了很多钱,还运营着自己的创业项目。可那些向我求助、我给了建议之后却反过来跟我争辩的人呢?你有没有遇到过这种情况?别人向你寻求建议,结果你刚一开口,他们就反驳说:‘不,你错了,因为……’我只能回一句:‘好吧,兄弟,我不想跟你辩论。你不是来向我请教的吗?’而那些需要别人不断推动的人,往往根本推不动。你必须自己拥有这种能量。

英文原文

And he has this self energy that he actually, he doesn’t need to be pushed, he just goes and he just goes, and he asks questions and he doesn’t ask too many questions. He just goes, goes and learns it. And now, he has a company and makes a lot of money, has his own startups. And the people that ask me for help, but then I gave help, and then they started debating it. Do you have that? People ask you for advice and they go against you to say, “No, you’re wrong because…” I’m like, “Okay, bro, I don’t want to debate. You asked me for advice, right?” And the people who need to push generally, it doesn’t happen. You need to have this energy for yourself.

Lex Fridman3:26:25

嗯,他们在寻找,在摸索,在努力弄清楚答案。但很多时候,一旦他们真的找到了自己想要的东西,答案其实就在自己内心。这话听起来很玄乎、很灵性,但事实就是:你得靠自己把这事儿想明白。他们向外伸手,试图向周围的世界发问:‘我该怎么过这一生?我该怎么弄明白这一切?’但最终,答案一定来自他们自身的成长和修炼。说起来可能有点傻,但其实就是上网搜索、主动查找……

英文原文

Well, they’re searching. They’re searching. They’re trying to figure it out. But oftentimes, their search, if they successfully find what they’re looking for, it’ll be within. Sounds very like spiritual sounding, but it’s really figuring that shit out on your own. But they’re reaching, they’re trying to ask the world around them like, “How do I live this life? How do I figure this out?” But ultimately, the answer is going to be from them working on themselves. And literally, it’s the stupid thing, but Googling and doing like searching-

Pieter Levels3:26:54

是啊。所以我觉得,这其实是种拖延症。我觉得给人发消息,很大程度上就是一种拖延。怎么才能成为成功的播客主?老兄,直接开干就完了,马上动手!

英文原文

Yeah. So I think it’s procrastination. I think sending messages to people is a lot of procrastination. How do you become successful podcasters? Bro, just start. Just go.

Lex Fridman3:27:06

直接开干!

英文原文

Just go.

Pieter Levels3:27:07

我也绝不会去问你‘怎样才能成为成功的播客主’。我会直接开干,然后照搬你的方法。我会想:‘啊,这家伙用的是黑色背景,咱们大概也得用这个。’

英文原文

And I would never ask you how to be a successful podcaster. I would just start it, and then I would copy your methods. I would say, “Ah, this guy has a black background. We probably need this as well.”

Lex Fridman3:27:16

是啊,试试看,试试看。然后你就会意识到,关键根本不在黑色背景,而在别的地方。于是你慢慢找到属于自己的声音,不断尝试各种东西。

英文原文

Yeah, try it. Yeah, try it. And then you realize it’s not about the black background, it’s about something else. So you find your own voice, keep trying stuff.

Pieter Levels3:27:22

完全正确。

英文原文

Exactly.

Lex Fridman3:27:23

模仿是一件很难的事。很多人只会照抄,却始终无法超越它。

英文原文

Imitation is a difficult thing. A lot of people copy and they don’t move past it.

Pieter Levels3:27:28

是啊。

英文原文

Yeah.

Lex Fridman3:27:28

你应该先理解他们的方法,然后再超越它。找到你自己,找到你自己的声音,找到你自己的……

英文原文

You should understand their methods, and then move past it. Find yourself, find your own voice, find your own-

Pieter Levels3:27:34

是啊,你先模仿,再加入自己的风格。这就是创作过程,本质上就是……所有人永远都是在前人工作的基础上继续构建。你不该卡在那里。

英文原文

Yeah, you imitate, and then you put your own spin to it. And that’s like creative process. That’s literally the whole… Everybody always builds on the previous work. You shouldn’t get stuck.

Lex Fridman3:27:41

一天24小时,睡眠8小时。你把它拆解成一道数学题:洗澡、整理、喝咖啡共耗时90分钟,时间就这么一点点被削薄,最后归零。

英文原文

24 hours in a day, eight hours of sleep. You break it down into a math equation. 90 minutes of showering, cleaning up, coffee, it just keeps whittling down to zero.

Pieter Levels3:27:52

老兄,其实没那么精确,但我当时不得不估算个平均值之类的东西。

英文原文

Man, it’s not this specific, but I had to make an average or something.

Lex Fridman3:27:55

是啊。救火式事务处理。哦,我喜欢这个词。买菜和跑腿一小时。我试过把一天中每分钟做的事都列出来,尤其在我生活更简单的时候。这样梳理一遍,真的让人神清气爽——你能清楚地看到自己浪费了多少时间,又喜欢做什么事;做让自己开心的事需要多少分钟,做高效产出的事又需要多少分钟。你最终会发现:只要安排得当,一天的时间其实相当充裕。

英文原文

Yeah. Firefighting. Oh, I like that. One hours of groceries and errands. I’ve tried breaking down minute by minute what I do in a day, especially when my life was simpler. It’s really refreshing to understand where you waste a lot of time and what you enjoy doing. How many minutes it takes to be happy, doing the thing that makes you happy, and how many minutes it takes to be productive? And you realize, there’s a lot of hours in the day if you spend it right.

Pieter Levels3:28:23

是啊,其中大部分都被浪费掉了。是啊。

英文原文

Yeah. A lot of it is wasted. Yeah.

Lex Fridman3:28:24

对我来说,长期以来最大的挑战,就是找到一段段不受打扰的时间,让我能真正沉浸于深度工作之中——就像镜头拉近一样全神贯注,彻底屏蔽所有干扰。

英文原文

For me, the biggest battle for the longest time is finding stretches of time where I can deeply focus into really deep work. Just like zoom in and completely focused, cutting away all the distractions.

Pieter Levels3:28:41

是啊,我也是。

英文原文

Yeah, me too.

Lex Fridman3:28:41

这才是真正的挑战,而且令人极度不适。

英文原文

That’s the battle. It’s unpleasant. It’s extremely unpleasant.

Pieter Levels3:28:43

咱们得飞到一座岛上,建个‘男人洞穴岛’,让所有人都能专心编码一周,把事情搞定,做出新项目。

英文原文

We need to fly to an island, make a man cave island where everybody can just code for a week and just get shit done, make new projects.

Lex Fridman3:28:53

是啊,是啊。

英文原文

Yeah, yeah.

Pieter Levels3:28:54

但老兄,就因为我在计划里写了‘一小时用于性生活、拥抱、爱情’,他们居然叫我‘精神病’。老兄,我真得写点什么进去啊。他们就说:‘哦,这家伙是个精神病,连做爱都要精确规划到某个小时。’老兄,我才没这么干呢,但是……

英文原文

But man, they called me psychopath for this because it says one hours of sex, hugs, love. Man, I had to write something. They were like, “Oh, this guy’s psychopath. He plans his sex in specific hour.” Bro, I don’t, but-

Lex Fridman3:29:06

他们还专门设了个拥抱计数器。

英文原文

They have a counter for hugs.

Pieter Levels3:29:08

是啊,没错。咔嚓,咔嚓,咔嚓。

英文原文

Yeah, exactly. Yeah. Click, click, click.

Lex Fridman3:29:12

这不过是用数字来呈现生活本身罢了。

英文原文

It’s just a numerical representation of what life is.

Pieter Levels3:29:15

是啊。

英文原文

Yeah.

Lex Fridman3:29:16

就像那种图表,画出你一生中有多少个星期。

英文原文

It’s like one of those, when you draw out how many weeks you have in a life.

Pieter Levels3:29:21

哦,老天,这太黑暗了。是啊,老兄,真不想多看。

英文原文

Oh dude, this is dark. Yeah, man. Don’t want to look at that too much.

Lex Fridman3:29:21

天哪。

英文原文

Holy shit.

Pieter Levels3:29:24

是啊,老兄。你还能见父母几次?天啊,老兄,这真吓人。

英文原文

Yeah, man. How many times you see your parents? Jesus, man. It’s scary, man.

Lex Fridman3:29:29

没错。可能也就只剩寥寥数次了。

英文原文

That’s right. It might be only a handful more times.

Pieter Levels3:29:30

是啊,老兄。

英文原文

Yeah, man.

Lex Fridman3:29:33

你只要算一算数学账就知道了:如果你一年见他们一次或两次……

英文原文

You just look at the math of it. If you see them once a year or twice a year-

Pieter Levels3:29:36

是啊。今天还视频通话了呢。

英文原文

Yeah. FaceTime today.

Lex Fridman3:29:38

是啊。我的意思是,当你看到某个你喜欢见面的朋友——比如你朋友圈边缘的朋友——突然意识到:‘哎呀,我已经有三年没真正见过他了。’那我们彼此还能再见几次?是啊。

英文原文

Yeah. I mean, that’s dark when you see somebody you like seeing, like a friend that’s on the outskirts of your friend group. And then you realize, “Well, I haven’t really seen him for three years.” So how many more times do we have that we see each other? Yeah.

Pieter Levels3:30:00

你觉得朋友是不是会不知不觉地从你生活中慢慢消失?你的朋友圈本就会自然演变,对吧?

英文原文

Do you believe that friends just slowly disappear from your life? Your friend group evolves, right?

Lex Fridman3:30:07

的确如此。的确如此。

英文原文

It does. It does.

Pieter Levels3:30:08

Facebook有个问题:它把你十年前刚上线时的同学、旧友全都翻了出来。你加了他们为好友,然后心里却嘀咕:‘我们干嘛又要重新联系?就让那些回忆留在那儿好了,现在的生活已经完全不同了。’

英文原文

There’s a problem with Facebook. You get all these old friends from school when you were 10 years old back when Facebook started. You would add friend them, and then you’re like, “Why are we in touch again? Just keep the memories there. It’s a different life now.”

Lex Fridman3:30:21

是啊。我不知道这是不是男生特有的现象,或者我也不确定。我有些朋友,虽然平时几乎不互动,但我们依然是朋友。每次见到他们……我想是因为我们有大量共同经历和共同记忆作为基础。大概就像什么都没变过一样,甚至感觉我们好像天天都在聊天,哪怕实际上已经一年没说过话了。所以嘛……

英文原文

Yeah. I don’t know. That might be a guy thing or I don’t know. There’s certain friends I have that we don’t interact often, but we’re still friends. Every time I see him… I think it’s because we have a foundation of many shared experiences and many memories. I guess it’s like nothing has changed. Almost like we’ve been talking every day, even if we haven’t talked for a year. So that’s…

Pieter Levels3:30:46

是啊,这是些深层问题。

英文原文

Yeah, this deep issues.

Lex Fridman3:30:47

是啊。所以我不必非得跟他们保持日常互动,他们照样属于我的朋友圈。而另一些人,我则经常互动。这因人而异,但总之,我身边有一张由真正善良的人构成的关系网,我对他们怀有真切的爱意,也永远可以信赖他们。如果其中任何一人半夜给我打电话,哪怕让我去毁尸灭迹,我也会立刻赶到。我喜欢把这当作友谊的定义,但它确实是真实的,千真万确。

英文原文

Yeah. So I don’t have to be interacting with them for them to be in a friend group. And then there’s some people I interact with a lot. It depends, but there’s just this network of good human beings that I have a real love for them and I can always count on them. If any of them called me in the middle of the night, I’ll get rid of a body, I’m there. I like how that’s a definition of friendship, but it’s true. It’s true.

Pieter Levels3:31:18

真正的朋友。

英文原文

True friend.

Lex Fridman3:31:20

你最近越来越出名了,这对你有什么影响?

英文原文

You become more and more famous recently. How’s that affect you?

Pieter Levels3:31:24

其实不算‘最近’,因为这是一个渐进的过程,对吧?它一直在持续,而且我自己也不知道为什么会一直这样下去。

英文原文

It’s not recently, because it’s this gradual thing, right? It keeps going. And I also don’t know why it keeps going.

Lex Fridman3:31:32

这会不会给你带来压力?毕竟你在推特上非常坦率,基本上是全程公开地造东西,完全不在乎内容是否过于技术化,或者是否涉及其他方面,就是毫无保留地展现自己。随着你人气越来越高,这种状态会不会让你觉得需要稍微收敛一点、稳重一点……

英文原文

Does that put pressure on you to… Because you’re pretty open on Twitter and you’re just basically building shit in the open and just not really caring if it’s too technical, if it’s any of this, just being out there. Does it put pressure on you as you become more popular to be a little bit more collected and…

Pieter Levels3:31:53

老兄,我觉得恰恰相反,对吧?因为我自己关注的人之所以有趣,正因为他们想到什么说什么,随心所欲地表达。反倒是那些只发某一类话题推文的人,才让人觉得无聊透顶。我对他们的私人生活一无所知,而我恰恰想了解他们的私人生活。你做播客时,不也总问些关于人生、性格的问题吗?这才是商业或体育领域最有趣的部分——体育背后的故事、运动员背后的真实人生,或是创业者背后的真人真事。这些才是真正有意思的内容。

英文原文

Man, I think the opposite, right? Because the people I follow are interesting, because they say whatever they think and they shape or whatever. It’s so boring that people start tweeting only about one topic. I don’t know anything about their personal life. I want to know about their personal life. You do podcasts, you ask about life stuff of personality. That’s the most interesting part of business or sports. What’s behind the sport, the athlete right behind the entrepreneur? That’s interesting stuff.

Lex Fridman3:32:18

做回一个真实的人。

英文原文

To be human.

Pieter Levels3:32:19

是啊。就像我转发过一条推文,那条推文有点过了。我们当时在清理马桶,因为马桶堵了,但这确实是真实发生的事。因为英伟达的黄仁勋说过,他当初就是从清理马桶开始创业的。

英文原文

Yeah. Like I shared a tweet, it went too far. We were cleaning the toilet because the toilet was clogged, but it’s just real stuff. Because Jensen Huang, the Nvidia guy, he says he started cleaning toilets.

Lex Fridman3:32:32

那还挺酷的。你发过一条关于‘丹尼餐厅’(Denny’s)的推文,我记不太清了。

英文原文

That was cool. You tweeted something about the Denny’s thing. I forget.

Pieter Levels3:32:36

是啊,那是最近的事。英伟达是在一家丹尼餐厅的餐桌上创立的。

英文原文

Yeah. It was recent. Nvidia was started in a Denny diner table.

Lex Fridman3:32:41

你还把它升华得挺有深度。

英文原文

And you made it somehow profound.

Pieter Levels3:32:43

是啊,就是这条,就是这条。

英文原文

Yeah. This one, this one.

Lex Fridman3:32:45

一家市值三千亿美元的公司——英伟达,竟是在一家美国连锁餐厅‘丹尼餐厅’里起步的。人们需要一个‘第三空间’,一个能带着笔记本电脑工作、从而打造出下一个十亿甚至万亿美元公司的场所。那么第一空间和第二空间又是什么呢?

英文原文

Nvidia, a $3 trillion company was started in a Denny’s, an American diner. People need a third space to work on their laptops to build the next billion or trillion dollar company. What’s the first and second space?

Pieter Levels3:32:56

家庭办公室,没错。

英文原文

The home office. Yeah.

Lex Fridman3:32:59

然后是介于两者之间的‘岛屿’。

英文原文

And then the in-between, the island.

Pieter Levels3:32:59

我想,是的。

英文原文

I guess, yeah.

Lex Fridman3:33:00

‘岛屿’。

英文原文

The island.

Pieter Levels3:33:01

是啊,你需要一个可以聚集的地方,伙计。我还专门查过这方面的历史:四百年前,欧洲的咖啡馆里爆发了科学革命与启蒙运动。人们会去咖啡馆,坐在那里喝咖啡、工作、写作、辩论,甚至规划海上航线——所有这些事,都是在法国、奥地利、英国、荷兰等地的咖啡馆里完成的。所以,我们一直以来就习惯去咖啡馆工作,与他人偶然邂逅、交谈,并由此创办企业等等。之前你邀请我来这儿,我们飞到美国后,我意识到的第一件事就是:我以前来过美国,但这次我们在一家咖啡馆里,到处都是笔记本电脑,每个人都在忙自己的事,我还拍了张照片。而在欧洲,如今大片地区已不允许使用笔记本电脑了——这点我倒能理解。

英文原文

Yeah. You need a space to congregate, man. And I found history on this. So 400 years ago in the coffee houses of Europe, the scientific revolution, the enlightenment happened. Because they would go to coffee houses, they would sit there, they would drink coffee and they would work. They would work, they would write, and they would do debates, and they would organize marine routes. Right? They would do all the stuff in coffee houses in Europe, in France, in Austria, in UK, in Holland. So we were always going to cafes to work and to have serendipitous conversations with other people and start businesses and stuff. And when you asked me to come on here and we flew to America, and the first thing I realized was that I’ve been to America before, but we were in this cafe and there’s a lot of laptops. Everybody’s working on something and I took this photo. And then when you’re in Europe, large parts of Europe now, you cannot use a laptop anymore. No laptop, which I understand.

Lex Fridman3:34:01

但对你而言,这种自然、有机的联合办公空间——也就是咖啡馆——恰恰是创造事物的根本场所。

英文原文

But that is to you, a fundamental place to create shit, is in that natural, organic co-working space of a coffee shop.

Pieter Levels3:34:10

对很多人来说确实如此。很多人住处非常狭小,而联合办公空间又很无趣:它们是私密的、缺乏偶然性、枯燥乏味。咖啡馆却棒极了,因为随机进来的人可以问你:‘你在忙什么?’而且不只是用笔记本电脑的人,人们也在像四百年前那样交谈、辩论等等,各种事情正在发生。伙计,我能理解其中的美学意味,就像有人说:‘初创男(startup bro),出货就是个扯淡的初创项目。’

英文原文

Well, for a lot of people. A lot of people have very small homes and co-working spaces are boring. They’re private, they’re not serendipitous, they’re boring. Cafes are amazing because random people can come in and ask you, “What are you working on?” And not just laptops. People are also having conversations like they did 400 years ago, debates or whatever. Things are happening. And man, I understand the aesthetics of it. It’s like, “Start up bro. Shipping is a bullshit startup.”

Pieter Levels3:34:40

但背后还有更深层的东西:人们确实在实实在在地创造东西,创办新公司,而社会正从中受益。我认为,我们正受益于英伟达;美国GDP无疑正受益于英伟达;如果欧洲能多创办些公司,欧洲GDP也能受益。而我在欧洲感受到一种氛围,一种……你得把各种要素连接起来,但禁止在咖啡馆使用笔记本电脑,正是这种氛围的一部分。它传递的意思是:‘对,我们真不是来工作的,我们是来享受生活的。’我认同这一点。安东尼·波登(Anthony Bourdain)那条推文就配了一张他在法国抽着烟、喝着咖啡的照片,他说:‘这才是咖啡馆该有的样子。’我完全赞同。

英文原文

But there’s something more there. There’s people actually making stuff, making new companies that the society benefits from. We’re benefiting from Nvidia, I think. The US GDP for sure is benefiting from Nvidia. European GDP could benefit if we build more companies. And I feel in Europe, there’s this vibe and this… You have to connect things, but not allowing laptops in cafes is part of the vibe. It’s like, “Yeah, we’re not really here to work. We’re here to enjoy life.” I agree with this. Anthony Bourdain, this tweet was quoted with Anthony Bourdain photo of him with cigarettes and a coffee in France, and he said, “This is what cafes are for.” I agree.

Lex Fridman3:35:15

但其中也包含某种创业精神:你必须允许人们敢于梦想远大,并为实现梦想拼尽全力,同时在彼此互动中感受对方的能量。这正是我当年在硅谷工作时喜欢那里的原因之一——那里的咖啡馆。那里聚集着一群追梦者,你可以拿他们开玩笑,因为每个人都觉得自己要打造一家万亿美元级别的公司,但——

英文原文

But there is some element of entrepreneurship. You have to allow people to dream big and work their ass off towards that dream, and then feel each other’s energy as they interact with. That’s one of the things I liked in Silicon Valley when I was working there, is the cafes. There’s a bunch of dreamers that you can make fun of them for like, everybody thinks they’re going to build a trillion-dollar company, but-

Pieter Levels3:35:38

是啊,而且现实很骨感,不是人人都能成功。99%的人最终都只是空谈[听不清 03:35:41]。

英文原文

Yeah. And it’s off, so not everybody wins. 99% of the people will be bullshit [inaudible 03:35:41].

Lex Fridman3:35:41

但他们确实在拼尽全力。

英文原文

But they’re working their ass off.

Pieter Levels3:35:42

是啊,他们确实在做事。你不能只把这类‘初创男’当成笑柄,说:‘哦,这玩意儿才刚起步呢。’不,根本不是这样。这是人们在真正做出酷炫的东西。而这终将惠及你,因为它会为你所在的国家和地区创造就业机会。我认为,在欧洲,这是一大难题:我们有着非常反创业的心态。

英文原文

Yeah. And they’re doing something. And you need to pass this startup bro like, “Oh, it’s started one level.” No, it’s not. It’s people making cool shit. And this will benefit you because this will create jobs for your country and your region. And I think in Europe, that’s a big problem. We have a very anti- entrepreneurial mindset.

Lex Fridman3:36:03

敢想敢干,放手去造。你这条置顶推文真的特别鼓舞人心,里面列出了你尝试过的所有项目,以及其中成功的那些。

英文原文

Dream big and build shit. This is really inspiring, this pin tweet of yours. All the projects that you’ve tried and the ones that succeeded.

Pieter Levels3:36:13

成功的极少。

英文原文

There’s very few.

Lex Fridman3:36:13

‘静音人生’(Mute life)。

英文原文

Mute life.

Pieter Levels3:36:14

这是为了在推特上设置静音,分享静音列表用的。

英文原文

This was for Twitter to mute, to share the mute list.

Lex Fridman3:36:20

是啊,‘火计算器’(Fire calculator)、不再用谷歌(No more Google)、‘制作者排名’(Maker rank)、‘我的副业值多少钱’(How much is my side project worth)、‘气候查找器’(Climate finder)、‘创意AI’(Ideasai)、‘航空公司列表’(Airlinelist)——

英文原文

Yeah. Fire calculator, no more Google, maker rank, how much is my side project worth, climate finder, ideasai, airlinelist-

Pieter Levels3:36:30

‘航空公司列表’至今仍在运行,但它不赚钱。‘航空公司列表’用于对比各航空公司的安全水平。因为我坐飞机时很紧张,所以就想:‘不如把所有飞机事故的数据都收集起来吧。’

英文原文

Airlinelist still runs, but it doesn’t make money. Airlinelist compares the safety of airlines. Because I was nervous to fly, so I was like, “Let’s collect all the data on the crashes for all the airplanes.”

Lex Fridman3:36:40

‘巴厘岛海底电缆’(Bali sea cable)?不错,太棒了。‘建造村庄’(Make village)、‘游牧者装备’(Nomad gear)、‘3D与虚拟现实开发’(3D and virtual reality dev)、‘播放我的收件箱’(Play my inbox)——就像你刚才提到的,还有很多其他项目。

英文原文

Bali sea cable. Nice. That’s awesome. Make village, nomad gear, 3D and virtual reality dev, play my inbox, like you mentioned. There’s a lot of stuff.

Pieter Levels3:36:54

是啊,伙计。

英文原文

Yeah, man.

Lex Fridman3:36:54

我正试着找几条你比较尴尬的推文。

英文原文

I’m trying to find some embarrassing tweets of yours.

Pieter Levels3:36:56

你可以点开‘精选’(highlights)标签页,里面全是精华内容。

英文原文

You can go to the highlights tab. It has all the good shit.

Lex Fridman3:37:00

找到了。

英文原文

There you go.

Pieter Levels3:37:01

这是迪拜。

英文原文

This was Dubai.

Lex Fridman3:37:02

第一视角:创办一家人工智能初创公司。哇哦,你真是个实打实的网红。

英文原文

POV, building an AI startup. Wow. You’re a real influencer.

Pieter Levels3:37:09

而且如果现在有人复制这张照片,再换掉截图,它自然就变成一张梗图了。

英文原文

And if people copy this photo now and they change the screenshots, it becomes like a meme, of course.

Lex Fridman3:37:16

这张不错。

英文原文

This is good.

Pieter Levels3:37:16

这就是迪拜的样子,简直令人难以置信。

英文原文

That’s how Dubai looks. It’s insane.

Lex Fridman3:37:19

那些建筑真美,城市背后的故事也疯狂极了。

英文原文

That’s beautiful architecture. It’s crazy, the story behind the cities.

Pieter Levels3:37:22

是啊,背后的故事,肯定没错。所以这讲的是欧洲经济,即……

英文原文

Yeah, the story behind, for sure. So this is about the European economy, where…

Lex Fridman3:37:27

欧洲经济格局由‘恐龙’企业主导。今天我专门研究过,可以拿出证据给你看:欧盟前百强企业中,80%成立于1950年之前;而美国前百强企业中,仅36%成立于1950年之前。

英文原文

European economy landscape is ran by dinosaurs. And today, I studied it so I can produce you with my evidence. 80% of top EU companies were founded before 1950. Only 36% of top US companies were founded before 1950.

Pieter Levels3:37:42

是啊。因此,美国顶级企业的中位成立年份大约是1960年,而欧洲顶级企业的中位成立年份则是1900年左右。也就是说,这里分别是1913年和1963年,相差整整五十年。

英文原文

Yeah. So the median founding of companies in US is something like 1960, and the median… The top companies, right? And the median in Europe is 1900 or something. So it’s here, 1913 and 1963. So there’s a 50-year difference.

Lex Fridman3:37:58

这很好地印证了你刚才所谈的内容——两种文化、两种民族创业精神之间的差异。

英文原文

It’s a good representation of the very thing you were talking about, the difference in the cultures, entrepreneurial spirit of the peoples.

Pieter Levels3:38:06

但欧洲曾经也是充满创业精神的。1800年、1850年、1900年都有公司创立。大约在1950年前后,风向转变,美国开始领先。我想表达的观点是:我希望欧洲能重回创业文化,重新打造出大型企业。因为目前,所有老牌‘恐龙’企业掌控着经济命脉,它们游说政府,而欧洲政府本身也被这些企业渗透,制定了大量监管政策。我认为这叫‘监管俘获’(regulatory capture),导致新入行者极难进入某个行业——监管太多太严。实际上,监管对大公司非常有利,因为它们有能力遵守;而我做不到,对吧?比如我现在想在欧洲创办一家人工智能初创公司,几乎不可能——因为有相关人工智能法规,让我举步维艰。我可能还得找公证人,还得办各种证书、许可证。而在美国,我只需打开笔记本电脑,基本就能立刻启动一家人工智能初创公司。

英文原文

But Europe used to be entrepreneurial. There was companies founded in 1800, 1850, 1900. It flipped around 1950 where America took the lead. And I guess my point is, I hope that Europe gets back to… Because I’m European, I hope that Europe gets back to being an entrepreneurial culture where they build big companies again. Because right now, all the old dinosaur companies control the economies. They’re lobbying with the government. Europe is also, they’re infiltrated with the government where they create so much regulation. I think it’s called regulatory capture, where it’s very hard for a newcomer to enter an industry because there’s too much regulation. So actually, regulation is very good for big companies because they can follow it. I can’t follow it, right? If I want to start an AI startup in Europe now, I cannot because there’s an AI regulation that makes it very complicated for me. I probably need to get notaries involved. I need to get certificates, licenses. Whereas in America, I can just open my laptop. I can start an AI startup right now mostly.

Lex Fridman3:39:06

你对‘有效加速主义运动’(EAC,Effective Accelerationist movement)怎么看?

英文原文

What do you think about EAC, Effective Accelerationist movement?

Pieter Levels3:39:09

伙计,你请过贝夫·杰索斯(Beff Jezos)来做客,我超爱贝夫·杰索斯,他太棒了。如果EAC同样能营造一种更积极的未来观,那就非常必要了——因为人们对社会、对社会的未来、对气候变化等等,一直抱持着非常悲观的态度。EAC则提供了一种积极的未来观:技术能让我们……消耗更多能源。我们当然要设法获取清洁能源,但我们也需要消耗更多能源,以制造更酷炫的东西、进军太空、开发能改善社会的技术。我们不该回避技术,技术可以成为许多问题的答案。

英文原文

Man, you had Beff Jezos on. I love Beff Jezos and he’s amazing. And if EAC is very needed to similarly create a more positive outlook on the future, because people have been very pessimistic about society, about the future of society, climate change, all this stuff. EAC is a positive outlook on the future. Technology can make us… We spend more energy. We should find ways to of course, get clean energy, but we need to spend more energy to make cooler stuff and go into space and build more technology that can improve society. And we shouldn’t shy away from technology. Technology can be the answer for many things.

Lex Fridman3:39:53

是啊,多去建造,少花时间搞恐吓式宣传、过度谨慎之类的事。有些谨慎是合理的,有些也不错,但大多数时间,我们应该毫无愧疚地投入建造、创造与实干之中。这提醒我们,是什么让美国变得伟大——正是那些建设者,正如你所说,是那些创业者。我们在讨论技术可能出什么问题、诸如此类话题时,绝不能忘记这一点。

英文原文

Yeah, build more. Don’t spend so much time on fear-mongering and cautiousness and all this kind of stuff. Some was okay, some was good, but most of the time should be spent on building and creating and doing so unapologetically. It’s a refreshing reminder of what made United States great, is all the builders. Like you said, the entrepreneurs. We can’t forget that in all the discussions of how things could go wrong with technology and all this kind of stuff.

Pieter Levels3:40:20

是啊,看看中国。中国如今正处于美国当年所处的阶段——大概是1900年前后吧?它正以惊人的速度飞速建设。当然,中国存在巨大问题,但这是发展过程中的必然现象。美国起步时同样面临巨大问题,对吧?但我认为,对欧洲这样的国家或地区而言,情况非常危险:一旦陷入自满与安逸,你就只能朝两个方向走——要么这样,要么那样。你来自这里,于是你选择这样,接着你又能选这样或那样。我认为你应该选择这样——

英文原文

Yeah. Look at China. China is now at the stage of America. What? Like 1900 or something. They’re building rapidly insane. And obviously, China has massive problems, but that comes with the whole thing. America is beginning also with massive problems. Right? But I think it’s very dangerous for a country or a region like Europe to… You get to this point where you’re complacent, you’re comfortable, and then you can either go this or you can go this way. You’re from here, you go like this, and then you can go this or this. I think you should go this way and…

Lex Fridman3:40:56

向上。

英文原文

Go up.

Pieter Levels3:40:56

对,向上。我认为问题在于思维文化。所以我创造了‘EUAC’——即‘欧洲版有效加速主义’(European version of Effective Accelerationism)。

英文原文

Yeah, go up. And I think the problem is the mind culture. So EUAC, I made EUAC, which is the European version.

Lex Fridman3:40:56

我明白了。

英文原文

I get it.

Pieter Levels3:41:06

我做过连帽衫之类的东西。所以很多人戴这种‘让欧洲再次伟大’的帽子。我最初把它做成红色,但结果太像特朗普风格了。所以现在改成了更偏向欧洲蓝的色调,即‘让欧洲再次伟大’。

英文原文

I made hoodies and stuff. So a lot of people wear this, make Europe great again hat. I made it red first, but it became too like Trump. So now, it’s more like European blue, make Europe great again.

Lex Fridman3:41:19

好的,明白了。那么,你的人生极其精彩,非常成功,建造了许多酷炫的东西。那么,对于年轻人,你会给出什么建议,告诉他们如何做到同样的事?

英文原文

All right. Okay. So you had an incredible life. Very successful, built a lot of cool stuff. So what advice would you give to young people about how to do the same?

Pieter Levels3:41:32

老兄,我谁的话都不会听,就做你自己认为对的事,跟着自己的内心走,对吧?所有人都会施加同辈压力,逼你去做自己根本不想做的事;父母、家人或整个社会都会这样告诉你。但你要尝试走自己的路,因为这条路或许真能走通。你可以掌控航向。当然,它很可能不会立刻见效——你大概率会经历非常艰难的时期,就像我当年也经历过那样,相对而言,对吧?但最终,只要你足够明智,就能让事情运转起来,就能像你一样、也像我一样,打造出属于自己的那一方小天地。我认为这一点应当被更多地倡导:去做你自己的事。经济与社会中,本就留有空间,容得下你做自己的事。这就像是一个个小村庄,每个人各司其职、各卖各的:我卖面包,你卖肉,人人都能经营自己那点小事业。你不必非得当个‘普通人’(normie),正如你所说的那样;你可以活成你真正想成为的样子。

英文原文

Man, I would listen to nobody. Just do what you think is good and follow your heart. Right? Everybody peer presses you into doing stuff you don’t want to do. And they tell you like parents, or family, or society and tell you. But try your own thing because it might work out. You can steer the ship. It probably doesn’t work out immediately. You probably go into very bad times like I did as well, relatively, right? But in the end, if you’re smart about it, you can make things work and you can create your own little life of things as you did, as I did. And I think that should be more promoted. Do your own thing. There’s space in economy and in society for, do your own thing. It’s like little villages, everybody would sell. I would sell bread. You would sell meat. Everybody can do their own little thing. You don’t need to be a normie, as you say. You can be what you really want to be.

Lex Fridman3:42:25

并且要全力以赴地去做那件事。

英文原文

And go all out doing that thing.

Pieter Levels3:42:28

没错,你必须全力以赴。因为如果你敷衍了事,就绝不可能成功。你得全身心投入那些被视为异类的事物之中,拥抱与众不同,只管去做你真正想做的任何事,对吧?

英文原文

Yeah, you got to go all out. Because if you half ass it, you cannot succeed. You need to go lean into the outcast stuff. Lean into the being different and just doing whatever it is that you want to do. Right?

Lex Fridman3:42:42

你得拿出全部心力来干这事。

英文原文

You got a whole ass it.

Pieter Levels3:42:44

对,拿出全部心力来干这事,没错。

英文原文

Yeah. Whole ass it. Yeah.

Lex Fridman3:42:46

这真是一场令人难以置信的对话,终于见到你,真是我的荣幸。

英文原文

This was an incredible conversation. It was an honor to finally meet you.

Pieter Levels3:42:49

能来到这里,也是我的荣幸,Lex。

英文原文

It was an honor to be here, Lex.

Lex Fridman3:42:50

和你交谈非常愉快,也请继续坚持你自己的道路,继续用你所打造的所有酷炫事物激励我、激励全世界。

英文原文

To talk to you and keep doing your thing. Keep inspiring me and the world with all the cool stuff you’re building.

Pieter Levels3:42:57

谢谢你,老兄。

英文原文

Thank you, Man.

Lex Fridman3:42:59

感谢收听本期与皮特·莱维尔斯(Pieter Levels)的对话。如欲支持本播客,请查看简介中的赞助商信息。接下来,让我以Dropbox联合创始人德鲁·休斯顿(Drew Houston)的一段话作为结尾——顺便说一句,我超爱Dropbox。不管怎样,德鲁曾说过:‘别担心失败,你只需成功一次就够了。’感谢收听,期待下次再见。

英文原文

Thanks for listening to this conversation with Pieter Levels. To support this podcast, please check out our sponsors in the description. And now, let me leave you with some words from Drew Houston, Dropbox co-founder. By the way, I love Dropbox. Anyway, Drew said, “Don’t worry about failure. You only have to be right once.” Thank you for listening and hope to see you next time.

出版方介绍

Pieter Levels (aka levelsio on X) is a self-taught developer and entrepreneur who has designed, programmed, launched over 40 startups, many of which are highly successful.

编辑摘要和译文均基于该出版方提供的资料生成。

发布者音频 (在新标签页中打开)

来源与研究方法

这些观点关联至发布方提供的带时间戳的访谈文字稿。其中的转述内容已标注,不作为逐字引语呈现。

阅读发布者的文字稿 (在新标签页中打开)报告问题